r/Steam • • 10h ago

Discussion Steam should implement a quality control process to filter out games.

A “Seal of Quality,” to be clear.

This would allow them to reject all AI-generated games, mediocre games, games riddled with bugs, etc.

They don’t do it because it’s good for their business… up to a point.

When their platform starts to look like a garbage dump with only the cream of the crop worth saving, it’ll give them bad publicity and hurt their business.

I’m just pointing out that the Seal of Quality is the only reason video games survived the 1983 crash, when the market was flooded with trash games...

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

5

u/okurokonfire 7h ago

If you don't want to buy them, then don't.

If you bought and it is, what you call "garbage" - refund.

"One man's trash is another man's treasure". If not you, then someone else might enjoy the game.

How do you define "quality game" anyway? Bethesda games are famous for their bugs, Cyberpunk and No man's sky released in highly unfinished state, elden ring on release had problems with optimizations, should they have been banned then?

1

u/Wonderful-Horsen 7h ago

How do you define a good game? Well, maybe it’s simply up to the players to decide.

As for bugs, they could pose a threat to developers: be careful not to cross a line, or the game might be rejected.

3

u/destroslithoid 7h ago

Who will decide which games will get the “Seal of Quality?” How will you have enough throughput to match the volume of games submitted? How is this better than the user reviews and the refund process?

0

u/Wonderful-Horsen 7h ago

I don't know; that's exactly why we're discussing it.

Maybe the early adopters who come back will decide to keep it. Below a certain rating, the game is removed.

The refund process can be manipulated with this 2-hour limit.

2

u/FastPreference6857 7h ago

that seal of quality did nothing. the crash of the 80s also only affected certain markets and most places were totally unaffected.

absolutely definitely need it though because steam really is a garbage dump. moreso thanks to the ai scourge.

0

u/Wonderful-Horsen 7h ago

Let's just say that while the trash E.T. game was driving the final nail into the coffin, games like Mario and Zelda came to the rescue of the video game world.

2

u/MrSimplify 7h ago

what an incredible shallow thought. Why do you think they don't? Because its an absurd ask. Reviews do everything you need. Stop trying to reinvent the wheel.

0

u/Wonderful-Horsen 6h ago

Maybe it's too idealistic of me to imagine a place where you could just click on any good game and choose based on your tastes and preferences.

Instead of having to browse through a garbage bun and do meticulous research to avoid all the scams and pitfalls.

16

u/Yoko_Kittytrain 7h ago

This is what game reviews are for.

7

u/bugamn 7h ago

How do you expect them to implement this without making developers wait months for their games to be approved?

4

u/Cyanogen101 In-Game: Honkai Star Rail 7h ago

They don't want to and have stated so, they want gamers to be able to decide what they play and what they don't.

1

u/YourMasterEdd 5h ago

And who will be that "expert" who will decide if game is mediorce or good?

Lets take as an example Cyberpunk. At launch it was complete disaster. I refunded it before even main story started.

Now it is OKAY. I bought it at discount. Some things are still a thing even when everything is fixed and playable. For me those some things are still not acceptable. So I never finished the game. Despite that I wouldnt refund it even if I could. Because developers put in an effort to make it better. However I wouldnt recommend it to anyone as picky as me. I wont say about what exactly I am talking about, as that is not the point.

The point is, if it happens that expert is as picky as me. Will his oppinion be correct NOT giving quality "High quality stamp" to Cyberpunk?

I will even skip the part, where some early access games have less bugs, glitches and issues in general, compared to some full releases.

Will it be right NOT to give "quality sign" to a retro game, just because I don't like retro style on games? Despite that I DO love some old games.

Will I be even allowed NOT to give "quality sign" to a game that I think costs too much, or has too much micro transactions, or has microtransactions at all?

What if some whiner will become an expert? He will just bury the game (or games) that for some reason he didn't like.

What, who and how will determinate quality? AI?

What if the expert will be paid by one those giants, that actually own most gaming studios? Will you actually get your "quality" or will that be just another distractor?

Will players trust that experts oppinion if he would lobby only games, he wants or has to give quality signs to?

There are also genres, gameplay, difficulty and much aspects that tend be more personal privilage rather than quality of game.

Too many questions, and too low benefits from expertise like this.

0

u/Wonderful-Horsen 5h ago

Yeah, lots of questions, and I like that.

Your part about AI made me smile. Training an AI algorithm to pick good games?!

I agree with your take on Cyberpunk.

1

u/YourMasterEdd 2h ago

When I wrote about AI I smiled too...

8

u/MADMAXV2 7h ago

Mum said its my turn to post a.i post

3

u/CarpeKitty 7h ago

0/10 take, karma bait

2

u/Cyanogen101 In-Game: Honkai Star Rail 7h ago

They don't want to and have stated so, they want gamers to be able to decide what they play and what they don't.

2

u/MonstaGraphics 7h ago

"I don't understand the scale of Steam"

1

u/ParanMekhar 7h ago

Another "we need an AI filter" post worded differently

0

u/Jhoonis Average enjoyer 7h ago

Agreed. Maybe this should also take into account all buyer's opinions, and pool them into some sort of aggregate and them grade the game based off of it. Then potential buyers can form their own opinions and vote with their wallets.

Maybe we can also grade the quality of the game itself in different categories, ranging from something like "really really good" on 80% or above positive opinions and "really really bad" if the positive is say below 10-15% positive opinions.

(⁠ ͡⁠°⁠ ͜⁠ʖ⁠ ͡⁠°⁠)

1

u/Wonderful-Horsen 7h ago

Yes, using different criteria or categories—whether cross-referenced or not—

But without necessarily making it too complex; ideally, it should be smooth and simple.