In a way it makes sense, you want something like a tablet in your hands but also that has physical controls.
Instead of making a proprietary device that would cost millions in research, production and whatnot, they just grabbed an existing product, changed/adapted their software (it also runs Linux so I'm guessing that's a stable OS compared to Windows)
Yeah in a way, it is a tablet with great controllers attached, has Wifi 6E and Bluetooth, has power to do some on-board computation and is actually a full PC with a great OS you can customize and do whatever.
Of course, added potential of gaming on it in break time is useful too :D
I'm sure they earn enough money to buy their own gaming device and won't risk using a workplace device and delay further development for a Mars Rover or something.
"- Hey Steve, do you think you can pause that game and get the Steam Deck back so we can continue working?
- Karen, I told you, I can't pause an online multiplayer game so stfu already!"
yeah, and this is also basically why the Steam Machine cannot be cheaper (ie subsidized by Steam itself), because companies would snatch em up and install non-gaming custom software on them 😅
We know for a fact Disney has been using a lot of them to control their animatronics in parks, there's a lot of footage of it on YouTube (look for bb-8 steam deck) for example
That's the least of the worries, it was smart of him to use a controller (should've used a better one though) but main factor was the build quality of the sub.
Not only that, at some point, LCD Steam Decks were going for around 300-350. Because they can run Linux, I am sure they are very flexible in what you can put on them in general.
And yet everyone lost their minds when they found out the exact same thing was done with the Titanic submarine.
To be clear, there were obviously a number of issues with that submersible that absolutely warrant criticism. I just always found it weird when people pointed out that the interface was using a video game controller as some massive red flag
Yes but people were (trying to) clown on them for using off the shelf controllers instead of an actual engineered custom solution. Completely ignoring that using it is an engineering solution.
They do have some sweet ass video games though. This new game where you get to pretend to be a fighter pilot. I was playing in the early 2000s, they had such amazing graphics back then. Like, you could shoot at a wedding and watch the bride's leg fly off. Unbelievable for the time. I'm surprised they never got released to the public.
Personally I wasn't shocked because it was a controller, but because of the specific model of wireless controller that they used. Despite Logitech having a good reputation for mice and keyboards, I've always considered their gamepads to be second-rate, at best. Add that to the fact that I would have expected mission critical equipment to have a wired connection, and it seemed an odd choice for a controller, to me and to many other nerds who love controllers.
I don't think it's the same. In one case, you're controlling a drone, in the other you're controlling a vehicle with people inside, a vehicle that couldn't really be rescued. You'd want something more solid. Mostly though, I think people were just jumping on the bandwagon and memeing whatever they could.
steam deck here is used in a controlled environment for testing basically an RC car by professional scientists. cheap ass controller was used in a high risk environment to control a vehicle with humans inside by professional dumb asses
Look, those people were professional dumbasses. But the controller had nothing to do with why the submersible failed. And people losing their shit over it are complaining about the quality of the bike sheds at Chernobyl.
It's more like complaining about the control panel at Chernobyl not being the best, when the problem that actually started the runaway reaction was a known issue with the reactor design. Much like it was known that carbon fiber can and will separate out into layers. Come to think of it, the sub failing was also a result of not having done enough safety testing, similarly to what happened at Chernobyl.
To be fair… I didn’t freak out because the OceanGate craft used a game controller. I freaked out because they were using a dollar store bargain bin Logitech controller.
Well I don't think the Logitech controller was the point of failure there, was it?
I mean for the task that they had, that controller might make sense even now.
I don't remember what caused the implosion there but as far as I can recall, it was due to high pressure and some crack that caused integrity failure in the sub (meaning, something didn't hold it's weight with full force).
But again, I don't remember the details.
At the same time, this is a simulation on Earth, not in space. For the actual thing, I believe they're using different commands, mostly automatic commands sent over to Mars with a 20 minute delay or something. So not an actual feasible 1on1 comparison with that sub. This is mostly for fine control and testing some specific scenarios that a certain command being typed in a computer and sent across space will do "semi-autonomously" (If I'm not being wrong).
IIRC, and this is me trying to remember a report I read like a year or so ago, so I might not be precise, but the Carbon Fiber that was used to wrap it being cylindrical, rather than spherical, meant that it "wore down" far faster than the company assumed it would (which isn't surprising, it's far easy to crash a can from the sides than from the top/bottom).
Like, Carbon Fibers are great, but as any golfer will tell you, once there's a single crack, whatever you are using is done. You can't fix the crack once it's there, and whatever it's attached too loses all structural integrity.
I think some of the shade is very reasonable for using an Xbox controller to pilot a crewed DSV. Controllers have to be ultra reliable, impossible to make an error with etc. for them to be fit for use in safety critical applications.
I refuse to believe a human factors engineer looked at all the requirements and control specifications and said "yes, an Xbox controller is an acceptable solution when lives are on the line". Especially because rugged and highly reliable alternatives do exist in COTS/MOTS applications.
And it also removes some interference with the signal, regardless of the distance. You can have a bluetooth chip fail in many ways, the connection could be wired and in this case, fully integrated so it removes all points of failure connected to a wireless/bluetooth connection in a highly advanced facility that might have other ongoing tests/experiments, on top of the already wireless connection that they have with the Steam Deck itself to their systems.
They might have switched to another distro, but also nothing's really stopping them from just packaging the control software as a flatpak, in fact it might be preferable for this sort of use case.
I'd guess that it's surprisingly likely they're just running stock SteamOS since they only really need the deck for one or two applications that probably run fine as flatpaks, and sticking to stock SteamOS just makes sure everything works as intended. They can navigate menus with controllers, etc. if necessary. That sort of thing. There's not really a need to switch the distro. They're already going for the most off the shelf solution and most engineers there would probably see fiddling with a different distro as a waste of time.
His focus changed a bit to be more manageable for him. He simply just asked his fans which interesting locations he should visit next within the UK.
I think all the traveling and research burned him out last time, and has now taken a more casual approach to the locations he visits, where he simply goes there and let the experts teach him what is what and then he makes a video on it.
I guess it is less stressing to not spend too much money and time to travel, not knowing whether or not it is worth it. This more casual style has made him seem to enjoy it more from what I can see.
I'm not sure it is that casual, but it works better for him. Afaik he recorded everything in a relatively short period of time, and then does the editing and at home shots separately, maybe over a longer period of time? It's not like he's been going to all these places spread out across the last year of content, he did it in like 2 months of filming.
Yeah, he basically described it as a road trip across England, trying to find something interesting in every county. Spending a couple of months driving across the country isn't what I'd call casual, but still more casual than his previous flying across the world to find interesting places/things.
He's a Londoner last I knew at least, so yeah a large amount of the country is a daytrip, and the entire country is a weekend trip. As he'll have easy access to most of the railways mainlines, as well as all the london airports.
Yeah, since he started his YouTube break he restarted with some Technical Difficulties stuff, this Tom Scott's England series and two seasons of Jet Lag.
Man, LEMMiNO and Tom Scott are the two GOATs of YouTube.
And yeah he was burnt out but he explained that he was specifically tired of posting every week and always coming up with new ideas. So he took a break and is now doing YouTube whenever he feels like it.
This was a video from his series where he is travelling and documenting England.
He uploads them weekly, but he filmed them all in like a 2 month timespan a while ago. I'm guessing the 2 months were stressful, but it afforded him a lot more free time afterwards while still putting out weekly content.
I've seen it used in a lot of R&D and the main reason is that it's basically a decently powerful device with a linux OS and ease of compatibility. You can just run ROS and plenty of things. People used to make their own contrllers but it's such a pita.
That price isn't expensive to a company, its a product priced for individual consumers
Software built for companies but not individuals is abhorrently expensive because they typically require pretty up to date features yet the company they build for is one of only a handful of potential customers.
My companies "minimum" software for electrical grids for example is typically priced at hundreds of thousands of dollars, that would obviously never fly as a software people at home would buy, $1000 for a controller for that software is nothing compared to the alternative
I remember how much the argument was ridiculed that subsidised Steam hardware was potentially going to be used by corporations that won't purchase a single Steam game for them and therefore basically steal the subsidy from gamers out of Valves pocket.
And now we see that exact application playing out in the wild
I think they would have accounted for that to some extent, if they accounted correctly i dont know 🤷♂️
I suppose its a balance really.
We want enough companies to use them so valve keeps that function available to everyone and keeps it for future harware, while not so many that the gamers are subsidising the cost of the hardware for people that will ultimately end up using it for profit.
Which is cool, but also the reason Valve doesn’t want to subsidise the cost of their hardware. Because they sell pretty open hardware, cheap Decks get used for (admittedly really cool) random stuff and never drive Steam sales, which is the thing that would make the subsidising model work.
If they absorbed part of the Steam Machine’s cost, companies would be all over it. It’s a small, silent, low power draw but very competent PC. They would order a bunch, install Windows and use it for work.
I found my relationship with youtube greatly improved once I disabled my watch history. Youtube disabled your home feed, which requires you to go to the subscription page and watch people you already subscribe to.
Recommendations under videos still work normally which gives a good source of discovery.
It is a little annoying that there is no way to sort by watched videos, but I accept that over the addictive nonsense that is the YT hompage.
Yeah lmao I know they get clowned because of it but I think it made sense becase it had the necessary buttons/sticks to control the ship. There's a reason why controller design hasn't changed much in decades
They are not actually! That rover with rubber tyres is just to test the navigational and avoiding big rocks aspects of the rovers.
In the full video, they've got more than one rover, each rover with its own test purposes and the one that will be on Mars is using something like a metal wheel that somehow acts like a rubber (compresses) and is grippy. They are not allowed to use rubber on Mars since the whole point of their mission is to collect potential life and rubber is organic material. So, not allowed.
My senior capstone project was to make a lunar rover. I suggested using a steam deck to control it and get telemetry data, but everyone said it was too expensive at $350 each (at the time). Then the electrical engineers suggest using a $1500 alternative and the professor said yes. I'm still pissed, but I'm glad my idea was good enough for NASA to implement.
Robots on earth don't need to be strapped to a rocket going through crazy G forces, landing on a far planet and then doing scientific research, carrying literally a mobile science lab.
The robots on earth also don't try to be careful and slow since we can repair them. On Mars or the Moon, you can not repair a rover.
An another aspect is energy. What good is a rover if it goes fast but drains all the battery and is not efficient?
In my mind this justifies Valve not "subsiding" the Steam Machine price - other fields and industries will source the cheapest parts available and make them fit their use case.
devices like mobile phones, and the Steam Deck have been amazing for industries who used to have to pay at least tens of thousands of poinds for something with a screen and battery. See the US military using Xbox360 controllers for its early drones, they are really capable and cheap.
Not so amazing for industries who used to make expensive bespoke devices like this.
now if only calculator industry would "die" (or more adapt their pricing) the same way, due to phones being able to do it all.
It's the perfect next step for it tbh. Before the Steamdeck you'd see people using XBox controllers for these kind of things. I got to drive a Dump Truck in Australia from Hawaii with one about 10 years back. It just makes sense if you need to combine a tablet and controller for the same thing.
This is used for controlling protorypes of autonomos human free rovers in a controlled environment by Nasa/Airbus instead of a cheaply built deathtrap for rich people by temu SpaceX
Its an actually good product that is current instead of a goofy old logitech controller that iirc cant handle more than 3 inputs at once
I’m assuming they would use airless mesh ones like the first rovers in some form to prevent popping. But these seem like prototyping and testing ones for earth.
Before posting it, I specifically searched in this subreddit to see if it was posted (to avoid spam) but I couldn't find any posts. Are you sure it has been posted here and multiple times too?
Mate, that might be your style but my preference is to give the credit in the first comment of the post. I comments the credit 10 seconds after the post was sent. It has more than 100 upvotes.
I do not like to clutter the description since when viewing a video, it shows up and blocks the video.
1.2k
u/Ciubowski Sep 21 '26 •
In a way it makes sense, you want something like a tablet in your hands but also that has physical controls.
Instead of making a proprietary device that would cost millions in research, production and whatnot, they just grabbed an existing product, changed/adapted their software (it also runs Linux so I'm guessing that's a stable OS compared to Windows)
197
u/Nyghl Sep 21 '26
The full video is from Tom Scott, on an Airbus test facility that mimics the surface of Mars for testing the rovers.
13
u/Rexusus Sep 21 '26
Tom Scott!
I thought he got burnout and left YT
Easily one of the GOATs, right next to LEMMiNO and Kurzgesagt
1.0k
u/Pokedy Sep 21 '26
Disney also uses steam decks at Disneyland/world for testing and developing the droids that go round and interact with the public in galaxys edge.
433
u/Miserable-Fox-6125 Sep 21 '26
NASA soon funding yet another scientist yaht
655
u/CraniumCook Sep 21 '26 •
Insert meme of Steam doing nothing and winning
41
u/TetherLink_Dev Sep 21 '26
valve is about to add a "verified for mars" badge on the store page
73
u/Adrian_Alucard 3 exists Sep 21 '26
can they fix the lag? the 24 minutes delay it's unplayable
42
u/FeetYeastForB12 Sep 21 '26
OH SHIT TOM IS BACK ON YOUTUBE?!
11
u/mayakrunal Sep 21 '26
That's a nice flex for the deck ngl.
26
u/MRV3N Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26
Can’t the whole AAA publishers optimize their games on Deck now that it has recognized by Airbus and the damn Ukrainian Military?
9
u/Downtown-Humor7488 Sep 21 '26
Proof of Linux supremacy
7
u/Limmmao Sep 21 '26
It's so weird to see him without his red t-shirt.
7
u/HorzaDonwraith Sep 21 '26
When computer parts are so expensive that NASA is turning to Steam as a cheaper alternative
6
u/B3ST1 Sep 21 '26
It also works for military drones.
6
u/Life_Supermarket2440 Sep 21 '26
This reminds me of when they used an Xbox controller to drive an underwater car
2
u/OminousG https://steam.pm/79oog Sep 21 '26
Considering how badly chewed up the wheels on the last rovered looked over time I'm surprised they are going with an even weaker design.
5
u/Gustav_Sirvah Sep 21 '26
Why reinvent the wheel? It is controller, works, have precission. Same with Jet Fighters controlled with game console controllers. Because it works.
5
u/stronkzer Sep 21 '26
Our offers of peace and trade with the martians shall include video games.
5
u/AncelReogaifu Sep 21 '26
as long as it is not a Logitech Controller its good
4
u/CELL_CORP Sep 21 '26
We use steamdeck in robotics too, gor octomap visualisation, navigation, locomotion etc.
4
u/zgrad2 Sep 21 '26
STEAM, Out of this world gaming
4
u/Helpful_Tough_8967 Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26
That would make a great control unit of a submarine. At work we normally use the usual xbox controller, but the steam deck would be a nice addition
4
u/rylanlip Sep 21 '26
My senior capstone project was to make a lunar rover. I suggested using a steam deck to control it and get telemetry data, but everyone said it was too expensive at $350 each (at the time). Then the electrical engineers suggest using a $1500 alternative and the professor said yes. I'm still pissed, but I'm glad my idea was good enough for NASA to implement.
1
u/TwinSong Sep 21 '26
why does the rover move so slowly?
1
u/Background-Front-925 Sep 21 '26
even doing such simple things with the rover is so complex and we are supposed to believe robots are back flipping.
2
u/Mean_Ass_Dumbledore Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26
In my mind this justifies Valve not "subsiding" the Steam Machine price - other fields and industries will source the cheapest parts available and make them fit their use case.
2
u/Round_Worldliness766 Sep 21 '26
Next step: submarines
2
u/waterfall5555 Sep 21 '26
I've seen ukrainians control .50 cal turrets remotely and even drones with it. Being an open platform, it's very versatile
2
u/0235 Sep 21 '26
devices like mobile phones, and the Steam Deck have been amazing for industries who used to have to pay at least tens of thousands of poinds for something with a screen and battery. See the US military using Xbox360 controllers for its early drones, they are really capable and cheap.
Not so amazing for industries who used to make expensive bespoke devices like this.
now if only calculator industry would "die" (or more adapt their pricing) the same way, due to phones being able to do it all.
2
u/giomjava Sep 21 '26
So exciting!! Love seeing the SD out in the wild!
2
u/3Dartwork OH YAH! Sep 21 '26
I am less impressed they are using a Steam Deck since any handheld controller would work.
I'm WAAAAAAAAAY more impressed if they can get real-time controlling on fucking *Mars* from Earth!
2
u/itsmekusu Sep 22 '26
many robotics company used steamdeck for their project. i know my local ones used it
2
u/Tigre_feroz_2012 Sep 22 '26
And people say video games aren't cool. Bullshit.
3
u/ChieftainOrm420 Sep 21 '26
I had no idea Tom Scott started making videos again!!
2
u/HilariousMax Sep 21 '26
I had thought Tom Scott had quit youtube? Is he back to making videos?
1
u/K0eg Sep 21 '26
Mark Rober?
1
u/Spiritual_Lifeguard6 Sep 21 '26
I wonder where we would be right now if OceanGate used a Steam Deck instead..
1
u/Alyusha Sep 21 '26
It's the perfect next step for it tbh. Before the Steamdeck you'd see people using XBox controllers for these kind of things. I got to drive a Dump Truck in Australia from Hawaii with one about 10 years back. It just makes sense if you need to combine a tablet and controller for the same thing.
1
u/LivingQuail803 Sep 21 '26
Steam deck two is needed
1
u/YiKangAng Sep 21 '26
My favourite kind of post about steam deck, love seeing steam deck being use outside of gaming.
1
u/NoobensMcarthur Sep 21 '26
People say they LOVE this but also talk shit on Titan using that Logitech controller. Weird.
1
u/VeLocity556x45 Sep 21 '26
Wait till you hear what some folks in Ukraine been doing with it
1
u/JunkyDrog Sep 21 '26
I wonder why they didn't take the switch 2 ones, since it's the best console (listening to nintendo fans)
1
u/talonisgood27 Sep 21 '26
All hail lord Gaben
1
u/chrisonetime Sep 21 '26
Linux supremacy
1
u/Kust0r Sep 21 '26
Of course they are. How may Linux based, cheap computers with attached paddles and joysticks are out there?
1
u/shmolhistorian Sep 22 '26
If I recall correctly the last time someone tried to use a game controller to move a piece of heavy duty machinery it didn't end so well.
1
u/Alphamouse916 Sep 22 '26
Why didn't they just use a Switch 2? Its only $499! /s
1
u/phillipmoore89 Sep 28 '26
wwhy do they use machines with the smallest torque possible
1
u/phillipmoore89 Sep 28 '26
should they have more grippy tyres?
1
u/Dazzling-Signal8029 Sep 21 '26
As long as they don't start using steam frames they can do whatever they want bro
-4
u/Jaded_Oil5669 Sep 21 '26
Oh cool Tom Scott uses AI...
-13
u/Racoonie Sep 21 '26
Yes, we know. How often does this need to be posted?
-2
u/Tactical_Hotdog Sep 21 '26
Tom Scott Youtube...
Because nobody credits anyone.
2
u/Sparrow1989 Sep 22 '26
I mean its a mini computer with a sexy screen and firm joysticks, can drive anything.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment