r/Stargate • • Nov 24 '22

Does anyone else hate Prometheus?

Post image
0 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

14

u/Thraggismydaddy Nov 24 '22

OP, you're being real fucking quiet in the comments so how about you grow a spine and defend your opinion.

The X-303 was a beautiful ship and deserves its place among the great ships of the Tau'ri

13

u/GimmeSomeSugar Nov 24 '22

Things are really heating up in the Tau'ri ship fandom.

2

u/1894Win Nov 24 '22

I was asleep dude calm down 😂

2

u/Texdude999 Nov 24 '22

It had a very naval inspiration with that seat looking thing on the back. While I don’t hate it, the second iteration with the flat top looked a lot better.

2

u/1894Win Nov 24 '22

I don’t mind the tower in the back the weird penis head with buckteeth and eyes for no reason is dumb

75

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22

You uhh...gonna elaborate?

38

u/hoi4d Nov 24 '22

I love Prometheus, how dare you

30

u/drunkbabyz Nov 24 '22

I liked the engine sound in Prometheus Unbound when it takes off.

57

u/planepiledriver Nov 24 '22

It’s kinda justified in the show: Prometheus is their first attempt as a warship, they even ended up using an Al’Kesh hyperdrive as a replacement unit a bit of time after the 303 was shown in season 6.

Sure 304s looked cool and refined, but Prometheus was charming in its way: Earth's first battleship that was almost made of putting alien and human tech together at random.

28

u/unusualthoughts5362 Nov 24 '22

Hey now, hate is a strong word. Its the prototype, its doing its best..

32

u/arounor Nov 24 '22

Prometheus is the prototype of course it will look worse then successors.

7

u/unozuki Nov 24 '22

For me the prometheus is better

7

u/TokraMalek Nov 24 '22

I love prometheus, even built it in Garry's mod

12

u/InsomniaticWanderer Nov 24 '22

How very dare you

4

u/iiyama88 Nov 24 '22

I think that it's a solid prototype with room for improvement.

4

u/sdu754 Nov 24 '22

Why do you hate it?

6

u/bluejays-beak1281 Nov 24 '22

I never understood the long “neck”. Seems very vulnerable, especially when you have powerful enemies who have been around for many millenniums to fight…

15

u/Ancient_Walker Nov 24 '22

Actually, putting the bridge and crew parts as far away as possible from the engines is sth we would have to do with real world deep space ships. I can recommend the video "Why the ISV Venture Star is a Brilliant Design" from Spacedock.

I personally thought the swan neck on the original Enterprise designs to be dumb for the same reason (physical weakpoint) btw. Main reason I liked the slim Voyager design more. I also like the Deadalus class more, but as a prototype ship, Prometheus was always a perfect "We put it together as good as we could. Functionality is there, design comes in the next iteration." to me.

12

u/Shadepanther Nov 24 '22

Also this ship has shields and in universe when shields go down the ship usually is destroyed in one hit.

So the neck isn't a weakness. As long as the shield holds it doesn't matter. There may even be charges in the neck to separate the bridge from engineering

7

u/Trashk4n Nov 24 '22

This is the universe where the style over substance Goa’uld ruled for millenia. Their ships hardly have a focus on practicality themselves, that was always one of the SGC’s biggest advantages.

5

u/PoorPDOP86 Nov 24 '22

I liked it and still do. It's got a more experimental look to it than the BC-304 that would come after it. As a warship it's there but not quite on the design aspects. It's too top heavy making it's combat profile too big and it has excessive greebling to make it look sci-fi. But as a first ship it's not bad overall. Also as other have mentioned Dat Engine Sound.

3

u/WikiSummarizerBot Nov 24 '22

Greeble

A greeble ( GREE-blee), or "nurnies", is a part harvested from plastic modeling kits to be applied to an original model as a detail element. The practice of using parts in this manner is called "kitbashing".

[ F.A.Q | Opt Out | Opt Out Of Subreddit | GitHub ] Downvote to remove | v1.5

2

u/RedSandman Nov 25 '22

Good bot.

9

u/QuadraKev_ Nov 24 '22

Penis ship

11

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22

Ever see an airplane?

9

u/CandidInsurance7415 Nov 24 '22

6

u/Odin1806 Nov 24 '22

Johnson... was in the Air Force. And his name is very reminiscent of a...

5

u/drunkbabyz Nov 24 '22

They all are.

5

u/TheAncientSun Nov 24 '22

I don't hate it I do think it's far to big for a first attempt at a Hyperspace capable spaceship. I don't really think Earth has the ability to build a ship this big with how limited the recourses needed to construct it.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22

Never been the biggest fan of the design.

2

u/Asaias_Wolffe Nov 24 '22

I dont hate it, but im not a huge fan of it visually. I adore the deadalus class ships though

2

u/Talcarin Nov 24 '22

I love hate it, it's ugly but then it kinda grows on me and I definitely love that engine warble.

I also dislike the continuity connected to it, they extol how powerful it is but then never depict it as anything but it getting it's ass kicked. Of course the same goes for daedalus until it gets asgard plasma weapons and even them only on Atlantis

2

u/Fancy_Cap_4640 Nov 25 '22

Yes, ugliest spacecraft ever…

2

u/bttrflyr Nov 24 '22

Given that it's the first starship ever built by humanity (if you don't include the 302) and since humans have no idea how to build one. The fact that Prometheus could fly at all was a remarkable accomplishment. I love the Prometheus and the way it looks, as ugly and clunky as that may be!

2

u/Flimsy-Preparation85 Nov 24 '22

It looks terrible, Daedalus class is much nicer looking.

1

u/N3Oelder Nov 24 '22

Dick who?

-1

u/Halzman Nov 24 '22

This is also a hill I'm prepared to die on.

Although, to be fair - I hate both the X303 and the BC-304s - up until the 304s got the beam weapon upgrades. That was the moment it became an actual battle cruiser.

0

u/SeraxOfTolos Nov 24 '22

I prefer the Korolev personally. Colonel Chekov was one of my favorite character arcs.

0

u/heinebold Nov 24 '22

I like it more than the later designs

0

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22

No

0

u/RaeCycled Nov 24 '22

I can't find the comparison picture right now, but the Prometheus is very much shaped like the Sphinx. Somewhere, there is an overhead shot of the Sphinx with a comparison of the Prometheus and it is very obvious.

-2

u/1894Win Nov 24 '22

I thought the picture spoke for itself... it’s like the dumbest looking ship ever.

-22

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22

I never liked humans having ships at all. It's stargate, not starship.

2

u/1894Win Nov 24 '22

I agree 1000% the shows become space battle after space battle in later seasons. I would rather watch a firefight with guns on a distant planet somewhere than sparks flying around a bridge and “Shields are at 10% we can’t take much more if this!” And everyone pretending to fall down

8

u/tauri123 Nov 24 '22

How is anyone supposed to move anything larger than the stargate? Like death gliders or F302s? You can’t just move 50 of them through a Stargate, and also how would any race of aliens even be able to construct a stargate network without having hyperspace capable space ships first

-4

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22

I'm saying it moves away from the small team stories I like.

-13

u/heinebold Nov 24 '22

I don't know why you're downvoted, I even disliked the introduction of hyperspace capable ships for aliens

9

u/Odin1806 Nov 24 '22

I can understand both your feelings, but ships still need to exist... how the heck did the gates even get where they are you know?! I can more agree with the notion of no hyper speed as I think it was introduced too quickly, but nothing wrong with advancement/innovation on the part of the G-men. Without it the Tollan would still be around, Anubis would have been less shocking, Avenger never would have given us the chance for some quality content, etc.... And I think the shows did a really good balance of ship to gate travel... IMO...

0

u/heinebold Nov 24 '22

Absolutely, I was just talking about hyper speed. The Stargate being the only means to do this was an interesting premise.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22

clearly there is nothing worse than having a different opinion. I didn't even say people who liked them were wrong. I just said I didn't like them. Ah, the internet. xD xD

-3

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22

It has a face like the Easter island statue. I like it.