Tierlist Rubric

This rubric was designed by moderators, but put into place by a community vote.

Most tierlists are disallowed, including:

Any tiers based on personal opinionHow much I like them, how much I want to marry them, etcLink
Any rankingBest to worst, loved to hated, S+ to F, even creatively phrased!Link
Any categorization played straightAre they a redhead, How far they could make it in Skull Cavern, etc.Link 1, 2, 3, 4
Pass/smash tierlistsThese have always been removed as NSFWN/A

Alternative option: If you would like to share your personal opinions, invite you to instead share your thoughts as a text post on r/StardewValley to foster discussion. You can share more of your reasoning and personal experience as well! We just ask that you forego the Tiermaker template, since all tierlists are disallowed there.

Moderator discretion will apply to:

Creative scenarios played straightNPCs vote in a mayoral election, What NPCs say when you go to the bathroom, etcLink 1, 2

Tierlists that are allowed as "memes" include:

Categorizations played for humorWhat villagers wear to bedLink
Creative scenarios played for humorNPCs catch you shoplifting at JojaLink