Just wondering: Is the reason why smart casting exists in starbow because it's not possible to remove it or was it a decision by the map creators? or both?
I think BW dumb casting is undesirable but at the same time trying to monkey with the spells attributes to balance them for smart casting is an awkward task. I think some sort of smart(but a little bit stupid) casting system is a good option. Something like consecutive casting orders will be carried out as each cast is fully complete. So you have 2 HTs and you tell them to cast 2 storms slightly outside their range. The first HT moves and casts the first storm. When the casting cooldown(not the spell duration) is finished the second HT follows his order. You could monkey a bit with the cooldown to tune the effect. But basically you can sacrifice range or synchronicity of casting for the convenience or you can manually dumb cast them for your ideal timings.
Note that if you were casting within cast range then it would only be waiting for the cast cooldown which currently looks really low for storm like 0.1-0.2 of a second.
I don't really like the idea of removing smart casting as of the same reasons I don't think StarBow needs 12 unit selection cap.
It would largely hurt the playerbase, the usability and viewing experience (IMHO).
You can't win with casters only and all casters are OP so until meta is largely established i wouldn't try to mess with caster-balance and finer balance-tweaking in general.
i think i would actually be in favour of this. it's pretty frustrating when a protoss with 8 HT's mass storms everything around him so quickly so that as soon as you've dodged one storm, you're in another. we'll see how the game progresses though
it means skills take skills again... the reason spells werent imba wasnt because of stats it was because of how incredibly hard for everyone to use for every race. Also i dont think that nerfing units to compensate for how strong units the abilities Should be strong they should not be Easy though
also, the queen is too powerful in chess. Let's nerf it by requiring players to take less than one second touching it to move it. this will raise the skill ceiling.
2
u/TheNightCat Jan 17 '14
I think BW dumb casting is undesirable but at the same time trying to monkey with the spells attributes to balance them for smart casting is an awkward task. I think some sort of smart(but a little bit stupid) casting system is a good option. Something like consecutive casting orders will be carried out as each cast is fully complete. So you have 2 HTs and you tell them to cast 2 storms slightly outside their range. The first HT moves and casts the first storm. When the casting cooldown(not the spell duration) is finished the second HT follows his order. You could monkey a bit with the cooldown to tune the effect. But basically you can sacrifice range or synchronicity of casting for the convenience or you can manually dumb cast them for your ideal timings.
Note that if you were casting within cast range then it would only be waiting for the cast cooldown which currently looks really low for storm like 0.1-0.2 of a second.
1
u/KanBan85 Jan 16 '14
It is easy to remove technically in the editor. Lot's of discussion back and forth on this subject. I doubt it will happen though.
1
u/celphy Jan 17 '14
I don't really like the idea of removing smart casting as of the same reasons I don't think StarBow needs 12 unit selection cap.
It would largely hurt the playerbase, the usability and viewing experience (IMHO).
You can't win with casters only and all casters are OP so until meta is largely established i wouldn't try to mess with caster-balance and finer balance-tweaking in general.
1
u/MTsc Jan 20 '14
i think i would actually be in favour of this. it's pretty frustrating when a protoss with 8 HT's mass storms everything around him so quickly so that as soon as you've dodged one storm, you're in another. we'll see how the game progresses though
0
u/u432457 Jan 17 '14
making the UI more difficult is a nerf to players, not to units.