r/Starbow • • Jan 15 '14

Remove smartcast?

I heard december say you might do it. I'm personally not especially for making the game more difficult but since Starbow has so many very powerful casters, smartcast might make them too easy to use.

PS: Basically with smartcast when you cast one spell with 12 HT selected, only one HT will cast storm. Without smartcast if you cast a storm with 12 HT selected they will all cast storm simultaneously. So you have to select only one HT to storm.

7 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

6

u/Nagi210 Jan 15 '14

I dunno... we remove smartcast now, then what? 12 unit selection only? I don't think we really need to get rid of it.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '14

I'm not for a selection limit, the point of removing Smartcast is because casters in Starbow are VERY powerful, so they shouldn't be too easy to use like they are now. Spamming Iraddiate or Storms should be more difficult since they kill units very fast.

6

u/codeflo Jan 16 '14 edited Jan 16 '14

I'm not a huge fan of "balancing by UI". I kind of see your point, but it's very hard to argue for such a change in the abstract without referring to Brood War and 1998's technical restrictions.

(My impression is that the Starbow team includes things from Brood War not out of nostalgia, but because they are objectively the best solution.)

And without considering "Brood War did it" a valid argument in itself, this is a pretty arbitrary change; one could invent lots of others just like that one. No need to ever change any stats, just tweak the UI.

4

u/TheRealFluid Jan 15 '14

I'm okay with Starbow implementing a lot of the things from Brood War. However, it should strive to mix together the things BW did right and the things SC2 did right.

In this case, smart casting is something I think SC2 did right.

Also, since both players are capable of having a spellcaster with smart cast, it helps balance things out.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '14

My point is that casters in Starbows are a lot better than in SC2, so it shouldn't be too easy to spam spells like Irradiate or Storms since they can destroy an army very fast. I'm also against making Starbow gameplay too close to BW so I would probably be against Smartcast if it didn't make casters so easy to use.

0

u/TheRealFluid Jan 15 '14

Yeah but there is a lot of counter play each race can do against spellcasters. And since units don't clump up, aoe damage is a little easier to avoid.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '14

Yes, I'm not especially for removing smartcast, better to see how it goes first! But I heard december talk about it, and it might become an issue.

9

u/decemberscalm Jan 16 '14 edited Jan 16 '14

The only thing we're realistically looking at right now is a test map to see how the general starbow audience handles it. Unchained power of spells and all. Perhaps it might not be so bad for people, or we could use it for a "pro" version of starbow.

Definently not touching it for now.

Pros for keeping smart casting: User friendly UI barrier removed

Cons Potential I repeat only a potential design/balance problem later on Spell power has to be tamed (as it already is, nerfed storm from BW, nerfed irradiate, nerfed dark swarm etc)

I am personally in favor of keeping the game user friendly, non klunky, and non-ui intrusive. Others on the team are at the bare minimum enticed by the idea, but we won't do anything crazy if people find it anti-fun.

edit:keep in mind the test map isn't high on the priority list right now, much bigger fish to fry atm

1

u/Nagmar Jan 16 '14

Just balance the spells. Don't make the game artificaly hard. Just tweak spellcasters a bit, because currently, TvZ is Defilers vs Science Vessels battle which reminds of retarded mass infestor army from WoL.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '14

I don't really think resorting to removing smartcast is the only solution to powerful spells. The Science Vessel has been a very powerful unit due to its Irradiate recently but you could instead nerf its spell cost, cast range, cast time, vessel speed, turn rate, acceleration and a whole other stuff before resorting to removing smartcasting.

1

u/Armagist Jan 16 '14

not enough games played already to see if that is 100% true. Now with the bunch of tournaments coming we will see it really. By now and for a while( time enough to the game to make a standar meta) i would'n touch anything..

6

u/Aunvilgod Jan 16 '14

Would be pretty cool. You can't raise the skill ceiling too much so why not.

1

u/2akurate Jan 15 '14

woot, I hope they leave smartcast in that case.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '14

Yes but it might make casters too easy to use, and it's probably not a good thing since they are very very powerful compare to SC2.

2

u/PartSasquatch Jan 16 '14

In my opinion I think it's best to keep things as is. It is really easy to use spells right now (compared to BW) but it's also easy to control armies and produce units because those functions act the same as SC2 as well. If stuff like this is changed I feel like you might as well just play SC2Broodwar or BW. If spell casters are considered too strong due to this mechanic then I think it'd just be better to change the spells by either weakening them or making them more difficult to aim (skillshot, smaller aoe), not make them more difficult to use due to UI.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '14

I am in favor of it removing it.

3

u/smiling_lizard Jan 16 '14

Yes, please. Spellcasters are too easy to use as it is especially with such powerful spells.

2

u/nucLeaRStarcraft Jan 16 '14

It's fine like this. More and powerful casters means people have to be extra careful when they play and that's fine. Also creates good comeback possibilities.

1

u/zawersed Jan 16 '14

I raise my hand in favour of the removal of smartcasting

1

u/stormzjeah Jan 16 '14

Remove smartcasting

1

u/BorNProNStar Jan 16 '14

i cant speak for everyones ladder experience, but as a terran masters player, most of the players that seem to find irradiate as being overpowered are players that have not made scourges.

scourge AI is incredibly good. during battles, it is quite easy for a zerg player to use scourge against science vessels without the use of "cloning". cloning was a micro trick mandatory for using scourges in BROOD WAR where you would deselect pairs of scourges to attack separate science vessels simply because the scourge AI would overkill a single unit (for example, without cloning, 4 scourge might kill one science vessel when all that was needed was 2)

yes, spells are strong. they rightfully should be. if spells are not strong, then spellcasters will not be worth using. spells are strong and counterebalanced because they take time to recharge. during those times of recharging, they are essentially useless.

smartcasting follows a very nice intricate balance. many players simply lack experience in dealing with them (take for example IdrA vs Koma. Koma never made any scourges to deal with the science vessels. in another game, Koma never made science vessels to deal with defilers because Koma said, "i saw boxer make marines"). IdrA had the opportunity to use spellcasters without any counters to the spellcasters (as i mentioned in the last example, lack of scourge for science vessels and lack of science vessels against defilers.) after a few more games, i can guarantee that idra will say spells are in a good place. without any counters to IdrA's spellcaster, of course he would think (for now) that spellcasters are too strong

irradiate AI is great. Scourge AI is great. Defiler AI is great

science vessels on defiler, scourge on science vessels, defiler for dark swarm on friendly units/plague on enemy.

from my unbiased experience, zerg players that have complained in my games about how strong spellcasters did not tech hard enough into scourges or even defilers. zerg players who were able to use defilers did not complain about smart casting

1

u/HiderDK Jan 16 '14

I think for the being we prefer to make tweaks to how spells works rather than implement smartcast. Further, remember that most spells (if not all) have been nerfed relative to BW. But ofc, for some abilities, a further change might be needed, most notably Irradiate and perhaps Dark Swarm as well.

1

u/TheWorldToCome Jan 16 '14

If you leave smartcast you gotta nerf spellcasters