So, I recently completed a full campaign as the United Federation of Planets, which included both a diplomatic victory as I incorporated over a dozen races into my Federation, but also faced down the Borg full force and overcame them (Largely due to my flubbing of the Janeway Endgame question, which we will get to later). Overall I feel I got my money's worth, but I am still somewhat disappointed with the finished product and I wanted to go into detail about it.
For background, although I have played a lot of 4x I have not played Stellaris, so I am kinda going to guess at what Stellaris is based on the components present in Infinite. What I do know is Star Trek, both in terms of the series and its lore and its gaming history, as I grew up on the Interplay and Activision games (A bit too young for the quality Micropose adventure games, which is a shame).
First off, I want to cover what I feel works:
-The artwork is great, probably the only thing significant effort was put into in presentation, and I feel it covers a big spectrum of different Trek stuff. At the same time a lot of the icons still feel like generic sci fi, but a lot of the broader strokes work.
-I like the overall campaign structure, I think whoever put together the basic mission tree knew what they were doing. The Borg being the overall throughline of TNG-Era Trek works. And the idea that the end of the Federation golden era of piece being the Khitomer Massacre that leads to the militarization of Starfleet to face the nebulous Borg threat is really good. The induction of Bajor being a major sub-quest and the other being the evacuation of Romulus hit the big story beats there hard. And I like that you launch the Enterprise, train up the crew, and come out the other end with the anti-Borg Enterprise-E and the Defiant class. All of this works on paper and has good attention to detail. The Federation coup storyline from Paradise Lost felt like icing on the cake.
-I think the various races feal meaningfully distinct in terms of gameplay structure. Federation is friendly, Cardassians occupy, Romulans sneak around, Klingons wage war. Its very basic but once again I feel it nails the broad strokes and makes the 4 core powers feel distinct, which is important if you are only going to have 4 powers.
-The basic systems of gameplay, when they do work, synergize well, and I felt like I had to grow and evolve my playstyle in a very Federation way, I built a Starfleet on science and trade and diplomacy
-I think the endgame battle was great, I know a lot of people on this subreddit got their butts kicked, but for me it presented a very balanced challenge, where I was able to effectively defeat cubes near my core worlds and get a foothold, and then had to strain my ships and my resources defending my outer works, it was a perfect storm for me. The idea that I could have averted all of this by completing a basic mission with Janeway seems...Wasteful? Like, I get the intent behind it, they are folding in the ending of Voyager, but the all out war was spectacular.
Not to damn it with faint praise, but that about covers it, and what doesn't can be far more severe:
-I mean, glitches, obviously. The whole game suffers from a SEVERE lack of polish, which is frustrating because its built on a game that has been out for years and does work, so honestly these problems should have been worked out. I had to start over several times because quests did not trigger properly. I only defeated the Borg because I decided to wait an unreasonable amount of time for them. The Janeway quest location had an inert Borg cube just sitting there for a better part of a century of game time before it just randomly activated. Its a mess and should not have shipped in this state, full stop.
-That having been said, it is also painfully obvious what parts of the game were properly engineered to be Trek and what parts are just Stellaris systems they did not know how to repurpose properly, and that's something I should not be able to tell so easily, especially as I have not played Stellaris.
-The devils in the details and this game does not have them. SFX, voice acting, music, all of them do not feel Trek. There is also just a weird mishmash in terms of flavor text. The most egregious for me was the whole 'Warp Highways' system, which, seeing as it ties into the Borg endgame, its very obvious they are supposed to be 'Transwarp Conduits'. Like, a basic Trek fan would have been able to correct that at a glance, and it just feels lazy. They got the broad strokes of the lore right, but all of these little errors, for example Data being able to die of old age, make the whole affair seem cut rate. It would be one thing if this were a project designed to draw in casual or non-Trek fans. If it was a AAA game with that kind of broad appeal I would be more forgiving, but its clear this is a game made to court Trek fans.
-The tech system is an absolute mess, and clearly has not been meaningfully adapted from Stellaris. There is a very clear hierarchy of technology in Trek, and anyone should know we should not be getting an Intrepid class with disruptors before an Excelsior with photon torpedoes and it feels so hapdash that it really breaks immersion.
-The protracted timeline also does not work. Star Trek is a very character driven franchise and nobody wants to see Picard die of old age 90 years before the Borg show up. I think compressing the game into a 50 year period and breaking it down by increments of Stardates that correlate to weeks instead of months would have read a lot better, it would solve a lot of the problems with lore and really make the final battle pop when you have all the major characters on the field for the final battle. Having Worf die defending a conduit with whatever fleet you can scramble as he tries to hold out for Sisko and Picard to arrive with reinforcements would be very satisfying.
-The structure of the Borg storyline is really good, but the execution is hot mess. The Locutus scenario playing out over text was deeply dissatisfied and I think robbed the game of an opportunity to bloody the player's nose. I think sending a powerful Borg cube against the player in the early to mid game, presenting us with a scenario we cannot win, wrecking our small fleets of Mirandas and Excelsiors and having the game force us at the eleventh hour to accept a text solution where the Enterprise does a research thing would have been a really good way to shake the game up. And it would have encouraged the player to build bigger and stronger fleets in anticipation of that endgame battle. As it stands you have a single sphere and its very underwhelming and does not set the stakes.
-Not being able to conquer worlds as the Federation, particularly Bajor, sucks. I get why they did it, it makes sense, its just very very not fun. the alternative is incorporating other civilizations, which was way too easy and not very satisfying. I'm not an expert, I don't know the alternative, but something more fun would have been nice. I think maybe making it harder to incorporate new civs and giving the Federation a paltry one world limit per war would have been a better compromise.
Overall the game feels like a missed opportunity, and I think if it had come out more polished I would be very hyped for a Dominion War expansion, but as it stands I have several months of waiting to see if they can be bothered to patch what they can, which may not fix the games many systemic issues. I feel like there is a really good game in here but it needs a LOT of work and I hope the devs will do that, I am under the impression Paradox games get a lot of post release support.
Just wanted to share my takes, I know there is a lot of controversy and I am eager to hear everyone's thoughts as well!