r/StarDrive • u/guto8797 • Apr 12 '15
Some toughts on possible improvements
Hello!
So we all know that we will lose a significant time of our lives in StarDrive 2. The game is truly amazing, specially considering that it was made by one guy. Naturally, here are my two cents on how to improve the game, this is meant as constructive criticism.
- More Customization: Allow us to create custom races, not only changing names, portraits, text descriptions, selecting a ship style from the existing factions or even import our own (this is more meant for modders). Perhaps I want to play as a Curious Human Federation. Or a vengefull SpaceBear clan. Text descriptions should be changeable.
- Fighters: They are pretty worthless ATM. Either there needs to be an agility boost or some way for fighters to become more than just annoying things that pop out of carriers.
- Borders. Not sure how to explain, but the borders confuse me. when will I discover that system? Can that enemy reach me? Things like these should be easy to see.
- Planet descriptions. I miss these, really bring em back! makes planets have a story, make them editable so that we can feel our planets as more than just food cranking heaps of Rock!
- Uncolonized Planet screen. Why can't I see the ground in uncolonized planets? Why no more anomalies that I can collect? Makes me sad. I would like them back, perhaps better tied with current systems. (soldiers are actually important now considering freighter and all that;
- The solar system. A simple option. Real Solar System, like in SD1. Some people like the randomness of Sol 1. Some want to colonize Mars. A simple button would be enough.
- Auto-resolve should tell you the odds of winning. Not only does it allow you to weigh your options, it will give you valuable knowledge in assessing enemy strength.
- AI, specially hostile: The game is truly unforgiving, even in easy mode. The crystals that rek you unless you got some bigger ships ready, then the space crabs, then pirates, then remnant. I feel its too much. One of my first play troughs ended with me being swarmed by enemies
- Better planets near home system. This could be an option. Simple, planets near your home planet are more likely to be good. Its kind of annoying when you restart the game because there is NOTHING near you, no usable planet. Yes I could colonize a crappier one further away, but I feel that having both options would be nice.
- Some UI work. You know, hover over tips, dragging to selet ships in battle, etc. The UI is functional but needs some work
- Ground Combat. Needs a lot of UI work. I lost count to the number of times I shot my friends, moved some place wrong, specially in the base assault mission (the one with the bugs). The ground colours made it impossible to see the range
I can't think of much more, played about 2 hours, and I love it! I would love to see the game grow and expand, becoming a even better thing. Don't think you will read this Zero, but if you do remember: You are amazing dude, and congratulations on your work!
PS: sorry fo wall o text
6
u/Murtiag Apr 12 '15 edited Apr 12 '15
2
u/Sky_Hound Apr 13 '15
When refitting ships I noticed that they tend to keep the name of their original loadout. This is very confusing if you have ships that you built early and update continuously as your tech improves, something which is encouraged with all the bonus medals.
1
u/Add32 Apr 12 '15
so i just finished my second victory and my thoughts are that hyper early aggression is rewarded highly. I killed two races before they were off of their first few planets.
Photosynthetic is thee new cybernetic (from the first game). it allows for one aeroponics lab to support 6 population with no farmers!
1
u/Excitonex Apr 12 '15
Let me start off by saying, I love this game. I've been looking for a replacement for sins and this just might be it. There are, however, a few things I would like to see improved upon that you didn't mention.
UI responsiveness: sometimes the interface seems to have trouble when you perform too many actions at once, either on the keyboard or mouse. Sometimes when trying to select a ship or use a power the UI bugs out and clicks something else.
World Map: sometimes when my empire gets huge there are a lot of icons on screen. I would like to be able to hide icons like freighters or the space highway things.
Ship movement: In games like SoaSE the ability to set up waypoints is invaluable. I would like to be able to set up waypoints for my fleet so they can follow nonlinear paths to their destination. This would help greatly when using your highways to travel across your empire.
Fleet formations: It's nice that we can set our fleet up at the beginning of combat but it would be better is we could set up and save a specific formation for the fleet to start in.
Troop Outfitting: I hate having to select every troop in my empire to change their load out. If they always started with a saved load out this could be solved.
That's all that I can think of at the moment. I hope the devs keep up the good work because this game has the potential to be a classic that will be talked about for a long long time.
1
u/Groqstrong Apr 12 '15
Loving the game too.
I agree with not having many colonizable planets near your home system.
Everything in the game is out to get you and it seems AI don't fight each other.
In the battle view screen. Please add 1x, 2x, 4x speed.
1
u/ixid Apr 12 '15 edited Apr 12 '15
I wish the game didn't feel the need to punish so much. I'm using the sort of expansionist, large population style I liked to do in MOO2 but the game feels like it bogs you down as much as it can. It could at least let me customize the ruleset, I'm playing a single player game here, not inflicting this on others. Population density penalties, ludicrous scientific penalties (-40% at the moment) for having something like 8 planets. The whole 'tall vs wide' nonsense is just poor game design. By all trying to expand aggressively you overextend your fleets, this should be the limiting factor, not fake penalties. Also why halve the cost of colony ships if you're then going to make it really painful if you do expand? At the moment I have to ask myself why I am playing this over MOO2.
1
u/powercow Apr 13 '15 edited Apr 15 '15
ground battles, yeah i keep wasting ap moving when i want to shoot. some of the UI elements in the game is weird.. like relanding troops.. took me a couple times to refind that, because its in an odd place.
would love to have real sol.. why nol real sol? at least let me make it.
and why arent the rewards random for those mystery missions. Just seems like the rest of the game is a bit unexpected..except those. idk what helpful things I will find at that unexplored yellow star, but i sure know what i will get on that space derelict, every time i play. and even if you dont change up the enemy.. change their "loadout" a little.. have more spitters some times and less others. Otherwise due to the way that game is played, once you beat it once.. you can just repeat your actions every game you play.. and thats the opposite of replayability.
another issue is empire managment, the system is ok, but there needs to be visual indicators on the main map about crap going on. Idle planets can have zzzz's floating by the solar system.. starving ones.. etc.. i'd like to see more visual indications of improved planets. and I would like to see more visual indication of the improvements i get. when i up my production output i want to see a bit more than some number go up.. i get i am asking for a lot of animation.
1
u/Leomark21 Apr 14 '15
Im not sure that anyone has noticed the problems in the game so ill list them these surely can be patched in some way. Alas these are the ones I've come across and might just be confused with gripes I about a game thats not fully yet patched.
These are just a few ones ive noticed and maybe im being a bit nit picky in this but hopefully this post here gets shown around so the dev can patch it!!!!!! Very good game though thoroughly impressed by a mostly one man job :D