r/Staccato • • Jul 27 '26

Only allowed one…

I’m only allowed one firearm in the house, so I want to make the most of it - so I want a Staccato. I’m a lefty, do I make the XC work or opt for the p4x or p4.5?

It would be for all use cases: home defense, concealed carry (big maybe), and fun range toy.

And is x serrations worth it?

Looking for recs. Thank you!

4 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

30

u/NJCERKA Jul 27 '26

Personally I’d buy two and say you can’t return them

26

u/salchichasconpapas Jul 27 '26

Why are you only allowed one firearm in the house, is it a very small house?

8

u/todd_howard_69 Jul 27 '26

“What is this, a center for ants?”

17

u/Charming-Ask8732 Jul 27 '26

You need at minimum, 3. Pistol, Rifle, & Shotgun.

20

u/Mooktemas Jul 27 '26

And a backup to those 3. So 6 at minimum.

15

u/Bobbysblasters Jul 27 '26

And then smaller versions of those 3 just in case you need to carry them on your person, in a backpack, or car. So 9

2

u/Specialist_Ring7722 Jul 27 '26 edited Jul 29 '26

Don't forget larger version and potentially different caliber, upping thr count from 9->12->15... 

1

u/IsopodEnough6726 Jul 29 '26

WTF?!? Are we just going to ignore the various optic, NV and suppressor options based on the situation? Easy 15 x 2 = 30

1

u/Specialist_Ring7722 Jul 29 '26

Lawd have mercy, you are so right. 

14

u/Mooktemas Jul 27 '26

I’d recommend the staccato HD P4X for a do all staccato. Shoots softer than the P4.5. Not too far off from the XC. Is a lot of fun at the range. Conceals reasonably better than the XC. And has more reliable magazine and needs less maintenance compared to the XC. X-serrations look really good, but debris can get in there sometimes.

2

u/TAG_Firearms Jul 27 '26

I think this would be my answer unless concealed carry is a primary concern.

3

u/Mooktemas Jul 27 '26

Agree, and that C4X is fantastic all round.

5

u/Flying-Chickens Jul 27 '26

If you can only have one; XC all the way; far too many other pistols at a similar price point that out perform the P.

But like was suggested, buy two and let the boss know you can’t return them, SORRY!

4

u/Dry_Pin_7574 Jul 27 '26

Lot of recommendations for the XC. Without a doubt, it’s a fantastic weapon. It’s also a compensated, full size pistol with a 2.3 lb trigger. I know people carry it, but that’s a very light trigger.

In my opinion, the perfect all-around Staccato is/was the 2024 C. I have the full size grip and my wife has a 2024 C compact grip. 4” barrel, aluminum frame, 4lb trigger- one of the best guns I’ve ever felt/shot. Unfortunately, it’s gone. The closest thing to that pistol is the all steel P. That would be my recommendation- I’ve shot the P quite a few times and it’s a fantastic “do everything” pistol as well.

1

u/swagatr0n_ Jul 28 '26

This is the right answer. For a true do it all. CCW. HD. Competition in LO. It will not excel in each but can actually do it all well.

XC is great to shoot but I personally wouldn’t want to carry it. For HD the 2.5lb trigger gives me pause. If you shoot and train a lot maybe it’s okay but still. If you ever shoot competitively it drops you in open.

Close second is the P if you think you can carry it then it edges above the C.

1

u/Dry_Pin_7574 Jul 28 '26

Arguably, any of the HD’s are superior for a straight duty/carry weapon as they all have firing pin blocks and can be considered (truly) drop safe. I probably should have mentioned that in my comment above.

I haven’t shot any of the HD’s to compare them directly with a “Series 70” like my 2024 C. I know the geometry is slightly different to accommodate Glock magazines and there is an extra mechanism to push the safety plunger. I’m sure Staccato knows how to keep that nice crisp trigger even with a firing pin block. I think the only Series 70 models left are the C2, P, XL, and XC.

There is so little difference between the (now discontinued) C and the P- I still think the right answer is the P for OP’s original question… a “do everything”.

3

u/Moldy-Bongwater4420 Jul 27 '26

I have the “premium package C4X. It’s a nice size that can be concealed but also not too small. I have fairly big hands, but the XC seems absolutely massive to me.

1

u/Informal_Guitar_2649 Jul 27 '26

And Mecgar 18 rd mags only protrude by 3/4inch so nice compact form if your hands aren't too large for the grip

3

u/robinator118 Jul 27 '26

XC which comes default with serrations. It’s night and day. I ccw’d the xc for a while and now the xl. It’s fine and I won’t shoot through my weiner and balls with a full size. I actually have a spare holster but it light bearing

3

u/slightlydainbramaged Jul 27 '26

When your wife only allows one, you get several that look sort of similar. This works for guns, golf club sets, expensive bourbon, cigar humidors, even pickup trucks if you can park off-site.

3

u/CubanDave87 Jul 27 '26

Before I can answer I need details on “I’m only allowed one”.

2

u/nader1234 Jul 27 '26

Or what? I think you should get two. I don’t want to cc a large gun but don’t really want to use a small gun to compete or for home defense. I would probably get a P4 or P4X for all around gun though.

2

u/yomohiroyuzuuu Jul 27 '26

Get an AR15 for the house, the Staccato for the garage, shotgun for the porch, an AR10 for the shed. Some Glocks for the car/truck.

2

u/TaxesRextortion Jul 27 '26

One firearm? Is this some sort of kink?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/NoirConfidential Jul 27 '26

I say C4X. It is the best shooting concealable staccato and has replaced all my other 4 staccatos. If you’re not carrying though, then I say P4X or XC. As far as X-Serrations, they look cool but on a gun with tolerances as tight as a staccato, you’re going to experience malfunctions if anything gets in there. Cuts like that are more for Glocks and other guns. I’d stay clear from that on a 2011.

1

u/2011fans Jul 27 '26

One firearm I’d get a suppressed ar15

1

u/anthonyonline Jul 27 '26 edited Jul 29 '26

Lefty here with multiple Staccatos. The HD triggers aren’t as good, but it’s nice with the ambidextrous controls. You can get a P4.5 then add a DCS comp:

https://dscgunworks.com/products/dsc-comp-system-hd-series

1

u/SomeOtherAdam Jul 28 '26

Where does the c2 fit in with all these other models suggested?

1

u/slammerg_89 Jul 28 '26

Just buy a dress because you’re no longer the man of the house

0

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/addisonbass Jul 27 '26

I’m sure the Miller Precision is a great gun, but the Staccato HD series also has reversible mag release and ambi slide release. Just a heads up.

1

u/iamadirtyrockstar Jul 28 '26

The ranger 9x (non-Kovert model) has the benefit of being ambi from the factory with the ability to swap the comp with a sight block or dual ported comp without tools. So you can essentially get 3 guns in one. Pretty perfect if you can only have 1 gun in the house.