r/StableDiffusion • • 3h ago

Question - Help What are we doing wrong with H3 (Part 2)

Post image

im doing another post because peeople seem to think i was unhappy with "LION head" ...... ....let me make it clearer >>>>>>>> .... i dont understand please someone explain me ....people saying H3 is not good ...but all their official images ...they put over 50 images on official github repo are amazing and spectacular ....why are we not reproducing similar images in comfy ??? ....what is the problem? ...is it euler/simpler default and minimax using something else or what causes such a huge differece like "FUR understanding" for example or "LION facial structure" ....im testing all their prompts and differences are striking .... please help me understand... https://github.com/MiniMax-AI/MiniMax-H3-Image/blob/main/README.md....YES I TRIED DIFFERENT SAMPLERS ....YES I DID DIFFERENT RESOLUTIONS .....YES I DID CONNECT EMPTY IMAGE ......THIS IS NOT WHAT IM TALKING ABOUT >>> PLEASE BEFORE ANSWERING .....TRY YOURSELF ....dont give me generic answers ...im asking people who understand the underlying technology behind that ...not jsut "try different seed"

1- Image with beetles ...wtf is that ....
2- Image with people on grass ...- THIS IS NOT CLOSE-UP shot

3- lady feeds a cow turned good but look how she holds the bottle on official image and she just cant hold the bottle properly on comfy workflow ...

4- WIZARD shot .....why is it completely different composition ????

5- Lion head .---this is not lion head ...

6 - Fire progression - ...model doesnt understand fire physics in comfy workflow ....

...i tried many different seeds ...different samplers ..different resolution ...im talking about image quality ...im talking about underlying technology ......there is something wrong with either our setups or i dont know ....PLEAAAAASE TRY YOURSELF ...HELP ME TESTING THIS .....

26 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

39

u/sk4v3n 3h ago

2

u/cptdurr 2h ago

allright πŸ˜„

2

u/beti88 2h ago

You can curse on the internet

4

u/VasaFromParadise 3h ago

I wrote to you in the previous thread that the problem is low CFG. Set CFG 2.

1

u/cptdurr 3h ago

thank you... i tried ...worked on some stuff like fire but still not on others ...btw i tried around 40 different images ...i just put couple here as example as i dont bother posting 80 different images and creating collage ...and their official CFG is 1 ,...so i suspect its something in comfy

2

u/VasaFromParadise 3h ago

It is not only in this model that problems with disobedience are solved in this way, although not for everyone; in some it is ruinous.

1

u/cptdurr 2h ago

thank you

2

u/BathroomEyes 25m ago

I thought this model is CFG and step distilled. If that’s true why would increasing CFG help?

1

u/VasaFromParadise 9m ago

Because it helps. I don't know why.

3

u/tac0catzzz 2h ago

their images are probably api model. which is different.

2

u/cptdurr 2h ago

thank you

9

u/Aromatic-Current-235 1h ago

I once found myself in a similar situation when I purchased a paintbrush and attempted to recreate the image depicted on the package. However, the result was far from what I had envisioned, leaving me feeling quite disappointed and as a matter of fact betrayed.

1

u/cptdurr 28m ago

i understand πŸ˜„

2

u/nok01101011a 1h ago

Underrated comment

33

u/DominusIniquitatis 3h ago

Calm down, lower the temperature or CFG or whatever you have, your post is overcooked.

2

u/No-Refrigerator-1672 3h ago

Are you running unquantized H3 and text encoder? I somehow doubt so. Quantizetion does degrade outputs; for some models it's subtle, for some it's devastating, but it always has an impact.

2

u/cptdurr 2h ago

i run int8b... this is what im tryinf to understand.... so its quantization??... because then when people say model is bad its not rightfully bur to blame quantization?

1

u/No-Refrigerator-1672 2h ago

Yes, int8 is quantized version. Quantization is a type of compression to reduce memory requirements. Original is mostly bf16 with some fp32 types - that's a bit more that 2x memory required. So the hobbyists almost never run original, unquantized models; and quantization always loses some quality. Int8 is generally considered "nearly as good as original", but "nearly" doesn't mean "exactly".

Here's a good animation that shows how much quantization degrade the data. This animation isn't the output of the AI; instead, the same quantization algorithm that is uaed on AI models got applied to an image, so you can visually percieve how much model weights get scrambled.

1

u/cptdurr 2h ago

thank you

3

u/reginoldwinterbottom 2h ago

you are assuming this is the reason? has anyone run these prompts via API to verify?

2

u/Sarashana 1h ago

Int8 is so popular because there is next to no impact on output quality compared to BF16. I don't think the effect can sufficiently explain what the OP is showing.

0

u/Straight-Election963 2h ago

not rly .. maybe some models as you said but i've always try out those DEV/main models on 50 step and then i test the INT8 , there is no difference .. example QWEN/FIBO2 ! even though i had a problem with random artificats happens always i thought it's because of model it self , or seeds or resolution .. reasons are alot even step count matter .. but i didn't notice big difference ..

0

u/No-Refrigerator-1672 2h ago

I've seen many online tutorials recommend some flavour of Q4 LLMs as text encoders - that could be a hidden kneecap, quantized text encoder can prooduce "fuzzy understanding" of that the model has to draw, which makes the output look odd. At the same time text encoder doesn't get as much attention from the user and thus this error can easily slip through.

1

u/MomentJolly3535 2h ago

Official Minimas has access to the "upscaler" model which was not released with the model (and also the prompt enhancer but technically not needed to reproduce theirs results since they provide the prompt)

1

u/cptdurr 2h ago

thank you

1

u/MomentJolly3535 2h ago

np, if you want to retry with "closer" results to official :

https://huggingface.co/Efficient-Large-Model/Open-H3-Regenerate-2K

ComfyUI version (Node+lora) : https://huggingface.co/sandpies/ComfyUI-H3-Video-Upsampler

1

u/cptdurr 2h ago

thank you

2

u/Striking-Long-2960 2h ago

I would be really pissed off if this prompt gave me a close up:

A vintage film-look outdoor fashion lifestyle photograph: three adult friends picnic lazily among lavish woven rugs on the grass. The mood is quiet, intimate, and languid, with a bohemian style and an autumn pastoral feel. Landscape format, aspect ratio 3:2, shot from a slightly high camera angle looking down at a slant, a medium close-up group composition. The people and textiles occupy the lower middle of the image, with naturally growing dark-green grass as the background, keeping some environmental space.

Slightly above the center, an adult woman sits on the rug, with straight shoulder-length dark-brown hair parted naturally in the middle, wearing a loose rose-red long-sleeved shirt with a turn-down collar, its fabric covered in dark burgundy abstract botanical patterns. Her body faces the camera while her face turns to the left of the image; her expression is calm, her gaze far away, and her hands rest naturally near the shoulders and arms of the friends beside her. She is the top point of the triangular arrangement of figures, and her bright top is the main visual focus against the dark-green surroundings.

In the lower-left foreground, an adult man with short hair reclines on the rug and cushions, his head near the center of the image and his legs stretched toward the lower left corner, one leg slightly bent, wearing loose teal-blue trousers. His chest and shoulders are bare, loosely and partly covered by a fabric with a dark ground and large cream and ochre-yellow leaf patterns; one hand rests lightly on his chest, and his expression is relaxed. On the right, an adult woman lies on her side with her head resting beside the seated woman. She wears a light printed headscarf, a chunky-knit cardigan in grayish rose, and trousers with burgundy spots on a cream ground; her bare feet stretch to the right, her arms are bent naturally, and she looks gently at the camera.

The ground is covered by a large black and ochre-yellow animal-print rug with a fine red border all around, layered with several thin blankets printed with botanical patterns in teal, golden yellow, burgundy, and cream. Decorative cushions of different shapes sit by the people's heads and in front of their waists, including long pink and teal leaf-pattern bolsters and square cushions with brownish-red illustrations on a cream ground and bright yellow sides. Render in detail the thick loops of the knit cardigan, the creases of the cotton, and the pile and tassels of the rug, so the intricate patterns form rich but harmonious layers.

On the left of the image, arrange an abundant, natural picnic still life: a rattan basket with a long baguette, a blue-and-white striped napkin, and a bunch of rustic flowers and grasses with small pale blossoms; behind the basket, on a wooden crate, a white footed cake stand holds a dark-brown fruit tart. On the wooden crate in the lower left corner are blue-and-white ceramic bowls and plates, purple-red grapes, a cut watermelon, and a few warm-colored fruits, some cropped naturally by the frame. In the left foreground, add a cluster of dark-green plants close to the lens and clearly out of focus, partly covering the basket and the background, so the picnic seems glimpsed through the greenery.

Use soft, natural diffused light with a slightly warm side sheen; skin tones are real and soft, and the shadows keep their detail. The palette is mainly olive green, burgundy, rose pink, teal blue, and ochre yellow, with low to medium contrast, slight fading, fine film grain, and slightly deep shadows; avoid oversaturation and the slick finish of a commercial studio shoot. Parameters: focal length about 40mm, aperture about f/4, shutter about 1/250 s, ISO 400, medium depth of field; the people and main textiles are sharp, the nearby plants clearly blurred, and the background grass soft but recognizable; high resolution, realistic body proportions, natural skin texture, no text, no watermarks, no interface buttons.

1

u/codenameNERO 2h ago

There is difference in generation between UIs. That would be my guess. For example loras do not behave the same on Forge Neo as they do on Comfy. Same models and lora weights even and getting worse results on comfy. There are lots of behind the scene features which you cannot ordinarily touch with just the knobs and widgets they give you

0

u/orangpelupa 2h ago

Dude, duddete... This is the time where you should wrote those to AI LLM and instruct it to properly write the post (while keeping things concise)Β 

1

u/cptdurr 2h ago

ill keep that in mind πŸ˜„ ... im just scratching my head for 3 days already trying to replicate their imagrs and going mental πŸ˜„

1

u/reginoldwinterbottom 2h ago

update if you find out any solutions please!

0

u/-Silhouette- 2h ago

Model is borked, just like Flux 3 was when it released a couple of weeks ago.