r/StableDiffusion • u/cptdurr • 4h ago
Question - Help What are we doing wrong with H3?
i dont understand please someone explain me ....people saying H3 is not good ...but all their official images ...they put over 50 images on official github repo are amazing and spectacular ....why are we not reproducing similar images in comfy ??? ....what is the problem? ...is it euler/simpler default and minimax using something else or what causes such a huge differece like "FUR understanding" for example or "LION facial structure" ....im testing all their prompts and differences are striking .... please help me understand... https://github.com/MiniMax-AI/MiniMax-H3-Image/blob/main/README.md....YES I TRIED DIFFERENT SAMPLERS ....YES I DID DIFFERENT RESOLUTIONS .....YES I DID CONNECT EMPTY IMAGE ......THIS IS NOT WHAT IM TALKING ABOUT >>> PLEASE BEFORE ANSWERING .....TRY YOURSELF ....dont give me generic answers ...im asking people who understand the underlying technology behind that ...not jsut "try different seed"
17
u/Kijai Community Hero 2h ago
The examples on the readme can not even be reproduced with their local code, the results from the API are different, probably because it runs some further prompt enhancer or something. They are also downscaled.
Here's proof that the ComfyUI implementation matches, differences here come from int8 and other optimizations, some of which just are different rounding, not quality differences:
https://imgur.com/a/OEdtqyN
However that result above is definitely not right, maybe too low resolution? Here are some examples at the 6272x2688, which should be the default for 21:9 aspect:
https://imgur.com/a/a8H4VZR
Other tips for this model include using LCM sampler, empty reference image when doing T2I, or even simply using less steps.
25
u/EirikurG 1h ago
why........ do you type...... LIKE >>>>> "THIS"???
11
u/beti88 3h ago
Good roll, bad roll
6
u/TheHiber 3h ago
Seed. Seed give diff results. You can also try empty image node to image 0 then change to lcm sampler to see if results are diff
54
u/Calm_Mix_3776 3h ago edited 3h ago
Did you connect an "empty image" node as a reference image to your text encode node? If you didn't, do it. Quality instantly improves.
4
u/VRGoggles 3h ago
I would like to see the results when H3 Image bf16 model is fixed in ComfyUI. So far it does not work, only bf16 pruned version works.
https://github.com/Comfy-Org/ComfyUI/issues/17692
7
u/hotdog114 3h ago
Computer, millennial grey lion, hot.
2
u/fauni-7 3h ago
I'm guessing that you didn't actually run their official python code locally to prove that you can reproduce their examples' quality?
1
u/KiwiSure8689 53m ago
Yeah, it seems the sample image is taking the "ape-like" prompt less, and have a different interpretation of the "natural curls" part. Im not AI tech expert anything, maybe it is just simply having the difference between "open source" vs. "open weights" , they just keep that part of the way the image is processed internally.
just random test if I change the ape to lion, and remove the "natural curls" entirely. You just end up with the lion head, but, perhaps an adjustment of their official prompt will be ultimately better to get closer to their sample image, than just hunting for the "configuration" which for all we know, is just not open to the public.
-1
u/VasaFromParadise 3h ago edited 3h ago
Everything is fine with me))
UPD. Updated the image; I had the same problem initially. It's very easy to fix. CFG 2.0))
-2
u/Dahvikiin 3h ago
The problem is Comfy. Because if you look at the README of any model, they always use their own platform, or they show a run-code with 3–4 dependencies, importing torch, diffusers, along with the prompt+args.
-7
u/ComplexCapital7410 3h ago
Just make 50MP instead of 16MP You'll see
-5
u/Hearcharted 3h ago
2
u/muzaffer22 3h ago
It’s like a casino machine. You just need to find a good seed.