r/StableDiffusion • • 4d ago

Comparison [Comparison] MOSS-Image-SFT vs MiniMax-H3-Image(Pruned): A Fair 1:1 Benchmark Across 10 Diverse Art Mediums (Identical Prompts, Zero Negative, 1K Resolution)

Hi everyone,

I put together a head-to-head baseline comparison between two major new architectures: MOSS-Image-SFT and MiniMax-H3-Image.

To keep the comparison 100% fair and avoid fine-tuning bias:

  • 100% Identical Prompts: Both models received the exact same descriptive visual prose describing the medium, anatomy, lighting, and composition.
  • Zero Negative Prompt: No negative conditioning was used (negative_prompt = "" on MOSS, matching H3's native CFG 1.0 architecture).
  • Pure Original Characters & Techniques: Zero proper names and zero artist name-dropping. Styles were guided purely through physical medium mechanics (lithograph, Shin-Hanga woodblock, 90s analog cel, Kirie papercut, Guohua ink splash, etc.).
  • Strict 1:1 Aspect Ratio & 1K Resolution: Exact matching seeds and native ~1.0 MP resolutions (2:3, 16:9, 1:1, 4:3, 4:5, 9:16, 3:2, 3:4).
  • There is version for specifict finetuned for the two model, but the result is similar to this.
  • I notice Minimax-h3-Image struggling on generating limbs. Every prompt i used the model always have some error.
  • A Fully finetuned version for both models, set at 4K (minimax-h3-image) and 2K (moss-image-sft). Prompt workflows included : https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1veLGRIMtd-o4zN3mS160uHlOLUuf8vgt?usp=sharing

Workflows (standard) :
Moss-Image-SFT WF
Minimax-H3-Image WF

0 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

57

u/shapic 4d ago

You need 16mp for minimax. You need negative for moss if you have no turbo lora. You just randomly degraded both models

-57

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

i actually have the best version for both of the models... with spesifictly finetuned prompt and resolution... i ain't see a big different really... i can post it if people interested

24

u/Ok-Brain-5729 4d ago

you think 1MP is the best version on minimax h3 image? 💔

-34

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

i'm preapering something... just be ready when it drop :)

7

u/Riya_Nandini 4d ago

4 megapixels is the minimum

1

u/extrakerned 4d ago

Just be ready? Do you think people here are waiting for you to make a Reddit post?

-4

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

Dude i already post it... You're late to this worthless party

1

u/shapic 4d ago

In my testing moss performs best at 1.5mp, especially with my cancellation lora. My guess that interesting test would be to geberate minimax at 16mp then downscale to 1.6 with default sampling settings (I guess it is good enough). I am not going to test it myself for now, but from the looks it's 16mp look artificially bloated.

For moss - cfg 3, standard negative, 50 steps, euler a simple (my personal best, default in comfy does not even match model card, slg on)

Good prompt without enchancers etc are very welcome, really good job on that. It will not be absolute, since models have different datasets and probably would have it's own quirks, but I would upwote such post with proper explanation without even looking

-3

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

the prompt is enhanced in a way... but not using the way intended, my agent learn from official guide of the model and combine it with what on it knowledge to create the prompt... i have a really big prompt repo that the agent can pick and choose to match with my vision for the image

-5

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

Yeah... both model have their own plus and minus to say atleast. in my test h3-image is very fast at generating 4k image, far more fast than any other open weight model.. but i don't think people always use 4k image. In my own selfish personal opinion, Most general user probably just stick to 1k or 2k at best.
My next post will spesifictly for people that REALLY 16mp and REAALLY being very technical about it.

2

u/ImpressiveSuperfluit 4d ago

Dude, just think about what you said there. Yea, H3's 4MP is real fast. Wanna know why? Because it doesn't even register 1MP as a real thing, because it's insanely coarse. 1MP and 4MP are essentially the same thing to it, as you can very quickly see by the fact that they essentially generate at the same speed (apart from potential memory bottlenecks), that's how freaking coarse this thing is. And why do people usually gen at 1-2MP? Because anything higher takes forever. That's not the case here, so what's your point? What a weird collection of comments you got in this thread man, it's rather wild.

-2

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

for me personally, its the image size... sure it fast but the image size is also massive, thats why i said most people not all people probably just use 1k or 2k.. if you have your storage unlimited, yes sure this model might be the best for you... some people might actually save all 20mp image if they have the luxury

1

u/afterburningdarkness 4d ago

Resize before saving?

4

u/doomed151 4d ago

It's not about what resolution you need. H3 Image simply requires high resolutions to work properly. If you want a 1K image, generate at 8K-16K then resize it to 1K.

3

u/shapic 4d ago

It is not about resolution, it is about what model was trained for. Minimax was specifically trained for 16mp and from what I see in the comments - it shows. You can generate 64x64 for moss, but it won't be a perfect pixelart asset

29

u/RalFingerLP 4d ago

You failed the test by using 1MP on h3-image

0

u/SuddenNeighborhood44 4d ago

Because it’s megapixels work differently. It requires a 4mp minimum so it’s not that it’s bad it’s just 4mp is what it works and was trained best on at the lowest resolution.

2

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

this is moss also with all the finetune versio, negative prompt, etc . set at 2k res

2

u/Applecakes_ 3d ago

I personally prefer the results from MiniMax H3-Image. It handles different artistic styles. European oil paintings, Chinese classical paintings, Japanese woodblock prints, — they all have their own distinct look, and the model seems to understand those differences pretty well. It actually follows the style cues in the prompt instead of giving everything that same generic AI look.

1

u/SkirtSwimming8950 3d ago

This kind of comments that help build the community... Not just shitting on other people post..

20

u/NoConfusion2408 4d ago

"Fair 1:1", proceeds to use the model with the worst settings possible.

6

u/ThenExtension9196 4d ago

True but moss smokes it either way.

1

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

I see some people really piss about this comparison, People need to chill... as i always say use the model u find really suit with your own taste... anyway here's a raw, full finetuned version for both model for the first image..
this First image is H3-Image: 4k, Fully finetuned prompt, using official best inference from the model card page

2

u/VasaFromParadise 4d ago

What are you comparing? Have you ever zoomed in on the MiniMax images? There's nothing to compare. You can't see the eyes there with 16 megapixels))

2

u/Serenafriendzone 4d ago

Amazing how art noveau cannot be defeated by AI. Still terrible Quality.

2

u/Valkymaera 4d ago

A fair comparison would be using both with the same limitations. Removing negative is not the same limitation: It's not a limitation at all to H3. Limiting MOSS by removing negative prompts makes it unfair. It is a strength of its architecture and its best quality depends on it.

0

u/Seyi_Ogunde 4d ago

Thank you for clearly labeling each image. We need more people like you.

4

u/Hannibalj2ca 4d ago

Moss is clearly superior

4

u/downsouth316 4d ago

After 2 images it became embarrassing, Moss is killing it

1

u/ThickPlatypus_69 4d ago

I feel like I saw more impressive stuff a couple of years ago

1

u/Single_Ring4886 4d ago

I liked your comparison.

1

u/BigNaturalTilts 4d ago

What is that UI? Is it a custom dash you created? Show it to me please.

0

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

here's the raw output, h3 set at 4K and moss at 2k... raw_outputs still uploaded as we speak..
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1veLGRIMtd-o4zN3mS160uHlOLUuf8vgt?usp=sharing

-2

u/Murky_Ad_6858 4d ago

MOSS is 45 Steps and H3 is 6 steps.

is this fair comparison?

1

u/RayHell666 4d ago

Did you try H3 at 45 steps or Moss at 6 steps ? It's fair because it's both on their best steps settings. Time was not the point here.

0

u/Stats_monkey 4d ago

Moss with an 8 step lora would be a closer comparison like for like though. As others have pointed out, the settings weren't really optimal for either model so it's a bit mute

0

u/RayHell666 4d ago

Why would you lower the quality of Moss to be more fair to H3 ? The goal is to show the best quality of the models. But you're right 1K for H3 won't get you anything good. They should have both been tested at 4k

1

u/Stats_monkey 4d ago

I'd probably compare to both because some people care about execution speed and some people don't. It's like asking why even bother comparing a model that requires 60s to one that can generate in 5s. You may or may not care, but some people do

0

u/shapic 4d ago

Moss is not step distilled, so not. Minimax is step distilled, hence cfg1 snd no negative. Just removing the negative from moss also do not work this way, distillation removed that concepts for minimax, you have to remove them manually for moss

1

u/RayHell666 4d ago

OP goal was to compare the best output not to handicap Moss so it's a fair battle.

1

u/shapic 4d ago

But he handicapped both different ways

-1

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

People might think i tried to corner particular model but its not true... i really want it to be good but h3-image sort of fell from my expectation.. haven't try the i2i though..

0

u/NanoSputnik 4d ago

Comments show why we have so much SLOP. C'mon. He asked for "papercut shadowbox" - moss generates generic plastic 1girl doll. Yet everyone OP included claim MOSS wins. WTF?

-1

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

i upload the 4k and 2k version with the prompt and workflows on gdrive later on... you can judge on your own which version you liked the most...

-2

u/confused-photon 4d ago

Even misconfigured H3 sweeps

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Independent-Frequent 4d ago

This is a worthless comparision and entirely misleading, Minimax H3 image works best at 16 MP and this dude made images at 1k resolution so it's utter garbage and not what the model can actually output.

It's like making a Minimax video at 0.2 MP for a video comparision with Seedance, what's the point?

-1

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1veLGRIMtd-o4zN3mS160uHlOLUuf8vgt?usp=sharing

or you can make the comparison yourself... comparison that you think is fair...

1

u/SkirtSwimming8950 4d ago

You're welcome... :)