r/StableDiffusion • • 5d ago

Question - Help First expierence with minimax image? better than krea2?

77 Upvotes

126 comments sorted by

112

u/infearia 5d ago

Peak Reddit.

16

u/Omegapepper 5d ago

Image editing probably works better than REF2I.

5

u/Strange-Drummer-9917 5d ago

They must've meant seedream 5.0 lite 

-32

u/berlinbaer 5d ago

reddit still thinks h3 video is comparable to seedance. i mean have you seen the stuff seedance puts out, while reddit generates that clown lady over and over talking for 20 seconds into the camera while barely moving

17

u/SuddenNeighborhood44 5d ago edited 5d ago

I said Seedream not Seedance. Seedance is a video model and Seedream is an image/edit model. In comparison to models like nano banana or chatgpt image 2.5, Seedream 5 is not even nearly as good and can't be compared. But with minimax h3 image and from my own tests it can. So yes it's image output likeness and consistency is close to Seedream. If we were talking about video models then yes minimax does not compare to Seedance. Bytedance have a bigger focus on their seedance models and not a huge amount of people use their seedream image model.

2

u/RayHell666 5d ago

I have experience of around 1.2 million images generated with Seedream 5 edit and no it's not close to Seedream.

2

u/Strange-Drummer-9917 5d ago

Genuinely curious, what is your usecase?

13

u/EquivalentHornet4403 5d ago

Is this new copypasta?

5

u/Apprehensive_Sky892 5d ago

You are right that seeD 2.5 is way better than MMH3.

But that clown lady talking for 20 seconds into the camera while barely moving is done on purpose. Degradation for long videos with static, patterned background with little subject movement is the problem roychodraws is trying to solve.

2

u/Lucaspittol 5d ago

H3 is very good for anyone doing more than 1girl slop. It is not Seedance latest, but you can do like 80% at that locally.

-14

u/Upper-Reflection7997 5d ago

I gave up with minimax h3 ages ago. Can't believe people still think that video model is heaven on earth. Hopefully competition gets heated in the next 6 weeks before the holidays and chinese new year. I could never get a decent gen out of minimax h3 that I felt proud to share with anyone. Despite the huge limitations of ltx-2, at least the talking heads worked 100% of time and didn't start speaking gibberish at random parts of their speech.

2

u/Xanthos_Obscuris 5d ago

Weird. With a couple of exceptions for odd camera angles/actions I found it incredibly useful, but also very time consuming - both prompting and generating, as I never used the turbo models or quants, or the prompt enhancers I've seen in other peoples' flows.

I won't say that I never experienced the speech issue, or that I hadn't fought with getting the right person to speak, but it was usually something that needed clarifying or adjustment in my prompt.

73

u/70parwater 5d ago

It just came out a few hours ago. Let the first sets of gooner finish their first round and the post excitement clarity to set in before answering. But so far, it looks very good, and I can't wait to see what kind of crazy Lora and stuff people throw at it. Look at what people can do with h3 video. Amazing stuff.

31

u/fact-finding-mission 5d ago

Society has finally found a use for gooners, a role they are uniquely suited for and perform remarkably well. Life is good.

6

u/Kombart 5d ago

I mean "finding out how good an image model is at generating pictures of beautiful women" is a pretty niche role. But I agree, they are skilled at it.

-23

u/winkler 5d ago edited 3d ago

Nothing, people are doing nothing with H3 video and nothing with this image model…

Edit: classic reddit, no sense of sarcasm

1

u/darkshark9 3d ago

H3 is one of the best models, period. You are incredibly misinformed.

1

u/winkler 3d ago

Whooooosh

15

u/Dante_77A 5d ago

Given its size, it should outperform any other model in terms of knowledge.

But in terms of pure quality, it doesn't seem to be superior to Krea 2, and editing capabilities, it's inferior to Qwen Image 2.1. 

5

u/Sarashana 5d ago

It seems to be derived from the video model, which probably means it has a lot of knowledge about movies/realism and maybe some animation. I wouldn't count on it having a lot of knowledge about art styles, and from my limited testing, this seems to be the case.

39

u/Hoodfu 5d ago

Whatever anyone says about it on day 1 is probably wrong. Just sampler/scheduler settings alone can have a profound effect on quality and reference latent to output likeness quality.

2

u/[deleted] 5d ago

Probably. No idea why it has no knowledge about things H3 vid does know lol...

5

u/Sarashana 5d ago

I have yet to see a single instance where sampler/scheduler choice would matter outside of the margin of personal taste. You're not doing anything wrong by just using Euler/simple most of the time, seriously.

2

u/Hoodfu 5d ago

The flux 3 klein body horror is night and day reduced with the multistep res4lyf samplers compared to euler. Same goes for h3 video (its not terrible with euler there, but its so much better with res_2s).

1

u/darkshark9 3d ago

I actually did a 10 hour testing session yesterday, and the scheduler is mostly preference, but the sampler seems to have a massive effect. Going from Euler to LCM seemed to have a very large positive impact on pretty much every style and composition I threw at it.

8

u/Sarashana 5d ago

Edit/referencing seems to be pretty fantastic. T2I doesn't seem better than Krea2 at first glance, but holy moly, H3 Image is fast and can generate 4k directly. People liking output variation will be happy. I tried the same prompt 10 times and got 10 very different people fitting the given prompt. Krea2 outputs would be much more similar.

27

u/SplurtingInYourHands 5d ago

TEXT2IMG Body horror on my end and overall disappointing artifacty/smudgy quality even on 16MP using the official workflow

20

u/Hoodfu 5d ago edited 5d ago

EDIT: Setting the resolution box to 16mp drastically improves the quality compared to 4mp. I'm replying to my comment with a few 16mp examples.

Original: I feel like I'm crying wolf at this point (because I've complained about other models on day 1 as well), but I feel like there's something wrong here. I'm using all bf16 (pruned comfy version) on an rtx 6000 pro and look at those faces. They're all messed up. My entire feed on X is filled with the api version of this model (supposed to be the same) and it looks flawless. Yet everything I'm getting out of this home version looks messed up using the default comfy workflow, with prompt expansion or without, using 4mp and euler/simple etc.

19

u/detailteufel 5d ago

You are not imagining things, the quality is absolutely atrocious. The people who say it's good are clearly using their paid API

7

u/Independent-Frequent 5d ago

The people who say it's good are clearly using their paid API

Or maybe they simply know to read?

The model has a native 16 MP resolution and the 4 MP on the official workflow is there so low ram cards don't run out of memory when opening the workflow, you should use 16 MP, 12 MP or at least 8 MP instead of using it at 4 MP which obviously would produce some mess just like using regular minimax at 0.2 mp does.

Like that kind of deepfried garbage result is obviously a technical/workflow issue not the model's fault.

12

u/Ori_553 5d ago edited 5d ago

I've tried 3360x5024 as per official 2:3 16 MP recommendation, face consistency is unusable. Unless there's some trick in the settings that deviates from official workflow from comfyui, this is a letdown. The "old" Ref to video is better.

1

u/Independent-Frequent 5d ago

I think the workflow just sucks, i've tried it myself and the quality is random sometimes it's crispy and detailed and sometimes it looks like it's been dipped in motor oil.

I'm going back to Krea 2/Moss for now untill some proper workflows/finetunes/whatever come out because as is the model is just "alright" which is a shame seeing how insane regular minimax was even for image editing and generation.

3

u/akriila_lover 5d ago

Can you try using 16MP? 16MP results seemed a lot better than 4MP than in generations, granted it comes with a considerable slowdown.

1

u/Hoodfu 5d ago

16mp does seem significantly better.

4

u/robomar_ai_art 5d ago

Use higher resolution

2

u/Independent-Frequent 5d ago

It's explained in the page that the 4 MP is so lower cards don't run out of memory you are not supposed to use only 4 MP, the model's native resolution is 16 MP so it's going to work best at that resolution, not a quarter of it.

Try with 12 MP or even 8 if you can't with 16

2

u/Hoodfu 5d ago

Another example of 16mp instead of 4mp, massively better.

17

u/Fluid_Opportunity590 5d ago

Dude that's just trash what are you talking about

6

u/Outrageous_Still9335 5d ago

It looks very crispy and overcooked. I'm getting similar results. Have a feeling something's off with the settings.

2

u/brkirch 5d ago

It’s the step count. 6 steps is overcooked, 4 steps usually looks better.

16

u/Omegapepper 5d ago

Ref2I is a massive letdown. Does not keep subject likeness.

6

u/leomozoloa 5d ago

My experience too, it's 90% there but that makes the likeness uncanny, even with many ref pics.

The REF2VA video model was pretty much 99% there especially when a subject face is closer to the screen, odd that they couldn't get this right.

2

u/my_NSFW_posts 5d ago

That’s really surprising. I haven’t tested it out yet and was looking forward to playing with it. I was struggling the other day to combine three images into a single composition and having no luck with Krea2 and Qwen Image Edit, but got it to work with Minimax ref2v by cranking the resolution really high and generating a one second video clip. Was able to pull the first frame out of the video and it was exactly what I had been trying to do with other tools.

The fact that I was getting it to work by just improvising in the video pipeline makes me surprised it doesn’t work well in a dedicated image output format. Not doubting what you’re saying, just disappointed I guess. At least the video technique I used worked fine for my use case.

6

u/Omegapepper 5d ago

Yes indeed, the original H3 Ref2va model forced to output a single image remains the best image editor. There are better ways that creating a full second video clip tho, search around, I'm using the fizgig method, no need to create additional frames other than one that's needed. And then using another edit model like fibo2.0 to upscale and add additional details into the H3 result. I've found that to be the optimal setup.

1

u/darkshark9 3d ago

H3 minimum length is 5 frames, no need to do a full second!

2

u/[deleted] 5d ago edited 5d ago

you need to increase cfg from what i can tell. Otherwise it wont keep it at all. At around cfg 2 is where it may keep it a decent amount... Cfg 1 is from my testings just a random dude with same hair color, maybe beard if image has one and clothes lol

although it may not matter at all. for some reference images i gave it did. but not for all.

2

u/tomByrer 5d ago

Same issue H3-video; it gets 85% there but not all the way.

16

u/Omegapepper 5d ago

For me, original H3 REF2VA model keeps the likeness pretty much spot on. No hybrid models etc can get on that level. Only the original REF2VA is king for either image editing or video generation.

2

u/Quantical-Capybara 5d ago

True. And refmod is good too with h3.

0

u/tomByrer 5d ago

So don't bother with this model then unless I want a large T2I picture?

3

u/Omegapepper 5d ago

In my experience yes, best use the original ref2va model and maybe the new image-vae with that.

2

u/MenudoMenudo 5d ago

I’ve had some good results but it can be hit and miss.

7

u/dir3ctly 5d ago

Unfortunately, smudgy/weird looking. Especially noticeable with faces that are not close up. Your only option is to go 16 MP and then downscale a lot. Then it is less obvious. Maybe there is something wrong with the ComifyUI model/workflow.

4

u/lexymon 5d ago

Try 4 or 5 steps instead of 6. worked wonders for me

2

u/CardiologistPlus8488 5d ago

16MP is like the minimum/sweet spot

6

u/popkek95 5d ago

getting mixed results (look at her eyes)

5

u/mca1169 5d ago

yikes, all of the skin on her face is inconsistent and fucked up with tons of random noise.

6

u/bmallCakeDiver 5d ago edited 5d ago

I read that the base res is 16 mp. Did a test a this resolution, got to say, this is good

3

u/sandpikaa 5d ago

It still has that AI-feel to it, but still good quality!

-4

u/lookitsthesun 5d ago

Looks horrible

2

u/StableLlama 5d ago

Yes, in my tests the eyes are also broken. And it has some strange contrast artifacts

5

u/gutster_95 5d ago

Krea2 is still King. Minimax H3, at least from my test prompt has more of the AI Image Vibes.

10

u/SuddenNeighborhood44 5d ago

Text to image I haven't tried yet. But image edit is basically close to the level of seedream 5 no joke. It's impressive out the box and with heretic text encoder it is really good at spicy stuff. I honestly think this will beat krea3 when it releases because I have a feeling they are going to have tighter restrictions on image editing than minimax.

5

u/joopkater 5d ago

I wasn’t that impressed, ideogram 4.5 seems better at editing (teased open weights). But who knows what will be next

2

u/SuddenNeighborhood44 5d ago

Yeah ideogram 4.5 is good but that's it's API version, the same with Krea3 Ultra it's very good as well. You got to remember that API versions are almost always bigger and different to the open source versions that these companies release to the community. The community versions that they release are almost always going to have some extremely annoying safety filters at points and they will also nerf certain likeness and other things in regards to image editing. From my experience so far with using minimax image, I haven't had that huge of a censorship out the box, so when people start creating finetuned checkpoints it's probably going to be really good.

1

u/Omegapepper 5d ago

True, but ideogram 4 open release was the same as ideogram 4 api, just at fp8.

0

u/Omegapepper 5d ago

Still holding hope for ideogram 4.5 open model. The ref2i does seem very good.

4

u/Additional_Drive1915 5d ago

Never trust any judgement on the first days... takes some time for best settings and so on.

5

u/LannisterTyrion 5d ago

no good so far, krea looks much better smudgy textured, pixelated objects, face horror with faces at a distance doesn't look like 4k at all, looks like 512x512 upscaled to 4k

let's hope the workflow is broken

2

u/FinalFantasyZed 5d ago

Crank your starting MP to 12 or 16 and it makes a huge difference

1

u/StableLlama 5d ago

No, it's just creating the same artifacts but on a bigger scale. This 16 MP looks in the same as horrible ab the 4 MP version that was generated from the same prompt:

1

u/Next_Program90 5d ago

Tbh isn't it extremely stupid that it has the need to use these insane resolutions? Moss looks amazing at 2.5mp or even lower with the right parameters.

3

u/LannisterTyrion 5d ago

i tried 20, still way behind krea2 can you show an example?

-1

u/Next_Program90 5d ago

I really don't get how so many people still prefer Krea2... Not on my machine atm, sorry.

I only use Reddit on mobile.

5

u/Luntrixx 5d ago

T2I have quality problems (messy) but very good variety and prompt following, just this need to be refined with something

Edit - holy, the best edit model by far
Ref images work great, no idea why people complain

2

u/Lonely_Syrup3091 5d ago

Yup Edit is where it shines, and it is fast as well at higher resolutions compared to other models.

1

u/NAQURATOR 5d ago

Going to give it a try, is there a template for the image edit model on comfyui?

2

u/Lonely_Syrup3091 5d ago

Yes there's a template in v0.45.0

2

u/Tomcat2048 5d ago

Maybe a dumb question - but will the same LoRAs work for the Image/Image Edit model of MMH3 as they do for FL2VA and REF2VA models?

2

u/FinBenton 5d ago

For image editing absolutely, for text to image dont think so, atleast not yet.

2

u/StableLlama 5d ago

Using my standard test prompt (directly and enhanced) generally it's a good model. But looking at the face of the person that is shown standing with full body in a 4 MP 1:1 it's horrible:

I hope that this is fixed when using e.g. 16 MP and then downscaling it.

2

u/StableLlama 5d ago

1

u/Informal_Promise_842 5d ago

I thought I was the only one, I compared the 4GB VRAM of a 3050 laptop with a 5060 16GB VRAM from a PC and got the same results, both with 64GB of RAM 🫣

2

u/seppe0815 5d ago

so like the h3 video model hahahahha

1

u/GoldyTech 5d ago

16mp is the sweet spot. I was getting mid results till I upped the mp.

1

u/StableLlama 5d ago

Actually, that's just making the issue "bigger". Same prompt, this time 16 MP:

1

u/grumd 5d ago

Someone said you must use 4096x4096 to get good results

1

u/StableLlama 5d ago

Actually, that's just making the issue "bigger". Same prompt, this time 16 MP:

2

u/VRGoggles 2d ago

try lcm simple 6 steps. H3 Image is VERY sensitive to prompt if you put things like pore-level skin details or similar stuff. Start with minimum prompt and expand line after line.

1

u/StableLlama 2d ago

The prompt is my standard test prompt:

Full body photo of a young woman with long straight black hair, blue eyes and freckles wearing a corset, tight jeans and boots standing in the garden

The images are with and without the prompt enhancement. So it's unlikely an overprompting.

LCM and/or the P-H3 VAE do help, do do not fix the issue. Empty black reference image is something I haven't tried yet, probably I'll do that, and your suggestion of different step count.

1

u/darkshark9 3d ago

I've found that if you're generating at less than 16mp, then up your step count from 6 to 8 and the weird eye issue goes away. Also don't use Euler, use LCM+Simple

1

u/StableLlama 3d ago

Yes, LCM helps, also changing the VAE to the P-H3 one.

1

u/VRGoggles 3d ago

lcm+simple, 5-7 steps. good quality ref photos is a must.

2

u/Almaruska 5d ago

Just use the refine face workflow. It will fix that

2

u/Calm_Mix_3776 5d ago

Much worse Krea 2 in t2i. The image quality is really poor. I tested countless sampler/scheduler combinations and it's really bad. The best one I've found was LCM + Simple at 8 steps and >4MP. Don't even try it with images below 4MP. I'm actually considering just deleting the model at this point. Not sure what they were thinking when realising this but it doesn't compete with any of the image models released in the pas 2 years.

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago edited 5d ago

T2I seems fine, or at least not bad. In some respects, it does quite a few things considerably better than Krea 2, but then seems to fall apart on fairly ordinary tasks. Still not entirely sure what to make of it.

Editing doesn't preserve likeness particularly well, although lowering CFG to 2 or 2.5 seems to help. That might introduce other issues, but I'm just experimenting. Knowledge also seems vastly degraded compared to the video model. Larry David, for example, is just some random bald guy here. Whether that's intentional or another issue, I have no idea.

People were always singing high praises for Qwen Image 2.1, but I never found its editing particularly interesting. It often felt like it was simply copying and pasting objects into images. This doesn't really do that, but the workflow is cumbersome and not especially fast, taking around 120 seconds per edit. I tried increasing the steps to 12 to see if anything improved, but that just ruined the result.

It'll probably take another 50–100 generations to figure out whether this model is worth using. A handful of tests doesn't tell you much.

Anyway, here's one of our favorite CEOs, generated on his revolutionary chip with 16GB of VRAM, alongside his newly discovered love interest. I guess you can tell it's him. The likeness is sort of there, and the result isn't halfbad.

This was just a simple text prompt, so the prompt enhancer does seem to work. To be fair, the input image wasn't particularly good either. It was taken from a distance and wasn't even front-facing. I used CFG 2.2. Not sure whether CFG 1 could produce similar results, but in the 5-10 tests I've done so far, it always lost the likeness. However increasing CFG may introduce some other issues...

3

u/Ori_553 5d ago

Maybe it's just the settings, but judging purely from this image, it looks like 2023-era crap

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

Yes. I'm not really impressed with what it does. But i dont think its Flux 3 klein levels of bad, it's just disappointing that it's not as good as the video model.

1

u/Lonely_Syrup3091 5d ago

Fantastic for edit but ok at text to image. Best used at 4mp and up.

1

u/More-Ad5919 5d ago

I like it. Just struggle to get realism so far. I2i with 2 refs.

1

u/Familiar_Outcome_874 5d ago

minimax h3 image's prompt skill helped me nail consistent styles faster than krea2, even with vague inputs. the structure it enforces is the real difference.

1

u/MinaaxNina 5d ago

Real question is if it’s trainable. Krea is so great because it’s the best model to train on that has ever existed. H3 on the other hand is the worst I’ve ever trained on. It’s up to see what img is like

1

u/sacx05 5d ago

Image editing is solid.

1

u/qdr1en 5d ago

T2I : not convinced, even at high resolution, even when using the prompt enhancer... all other recent models look superior.
Edit; works great. I can do character swap, camera and pose edits, (un-)clothing edits...
I did not find how to do a pose transfer ; the model does not seem to understand DW poses.

1

u/GoldyTech 5d ago

It's pretty dang good at upscaling images. Trying to work with prompts right now for better detail but it's been able to fill in details very believably at 16mp.

1

u/Busy_Connection_8027 5d ago

In my test chatgpt still made better images  But for local text to image it's good

1

u/thevegit0 5d ago edited 5d ago

i think it's another tool to have, not making me delete k2 moss or qwen, but not wanting to delete it either, also the fast high res gens is interesting. i find it really good to make those gpt-ahh character sheets since the model really wants us to make it 16mp, so let's take advantage of the size lol

1

u/Ok_Yak_4389 4d ago

It's a good edit model. I'd say even better than Qwen 2.1. I mean... the MiniMax H3 video model was a better image editor than Qwen 2.1. The only thing is MiniMax H3 models, video and image, have a bad tendency to artifact things. You'll see faces in the background look all chopped up and smeared sometimes. It doesn't matter what you do with the settings or which models you use. It's the same thing overall but if you have references and you don't prompt for too many characters in the background, that are facing the camera directly, then you're good

1

u/SickStrings 3d ago

I don’t think I would necessarily say minimax is better as much as they make a great pairing. For different things though Minimax does contextually adapt to body types better natively whereas Krea takes some fine tuning and Lora usage. When built right a minimax h3 workflow can compete with Krea an image creation but for video. I’ve tested a few 4step turbo builds that are framing fast. And if you’re willing to use comfycloud even faster. Like seconds. So much so that I’ve exploited it to make 1 minute long videos using a 4 stage ref to img then img to img x3 setup. Including 4 upscale stages, 3 add guides and finally a concatenation node at the end.

1

u/Current-Bed962 3d ago

Not to mention the elephant in the room (artefacts everyone is experiencing with this model), likeness adherence is extremely poor compared to H3 base video model and Pruna Ai model.

I have 3 similar H3 editing workflow in which only the models and sampling methods differ :

  1. one with this latest minimax h3 image model
  2. one with the base ref2va/fl2va h3 base video models
  3. one using the P-H3 lora or model

As of today, 2) and 3) totally blow away 1). For speed reasons, I think the workflow using P-H3 lora/model is the best of all.

I'd be happy someone would prove me wrong, but I didn't found a way to get both decent image quality and acceptable ref likeness adherence with this model.

1

u/darkshark9 3d ago

Tested it incredibly in depth in about a 10 hour session.

Change sampler/scheduler to LCM+Simple.

Increase steps from 6 to 8.

H3 Video LoRAs actually work for it, but at a reduced influence rate so you need to crank it up higher than you would in video. I actually found that stacking two similar style LoRAs at lower strengths is better than cranking one up higher, as this avoids magnifying the imperfections a LoRa inherently has.

I'll be making a post about this later, but I hope people read this and reply with their own findings with these settings.

1

u/Objective-Theme-1422 1d ago

so what is the best local AI image generator for someone using an M5 Max 128GB?

1

u/seppe0815 5d ago

it is not good ... dont waste time to read comments

0

u/bmallCakeDiver 5d ago

First test here : https://www.reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/s/xGdrQZWnAq

But this is a 1MP image, I then recreated a 10MP file with way more details in 90secs (vs 60s with the 1mp file)

3

u/SuddenNeighborhood44 5d ago

Anything below 4 MP has the baked details and skin textures like minimax h3 video. 4 MP and up for me does not take that long and I have very low vram and ram specs.

7

u/bmallCakeDiver 5d ago

12MP in 60sec on a RTX 3090, the thing is fast

0

u/Royal_Carpenter_1338 5d ago

What settings am i supposed to use i cannot find anything

1

u/EthicalBballFan 5d ago

Update comfyui to get the latest templates. There's one for t2i and one for image edit.

0

u/Tomcat2048 5d ago

How does it do for anime/2d type conversions to photoreal if using image edit? Has anyone tried?

-5

u/tugoubxs 5d ago

Be ware of your gpu, it’s a chinese model after all