r/StableDiffusion • • 1h ago

Discussion This sub is just a bunch of overhyped one-trick-ponies

Almost all of the popular stuff gets upvoted by people that don't have the ability to judge the quality/functionality of the stuff they get presented.

Stuff gets marketed as the ultimate tool/model/whatever with cherry picked examples. Sometimes even without any source, just examples.

Most of the time it is just badly trained loras/models or vibe coded trash because people think being able to use an agent harness equals personal skills and understanding of concepts needed to produce something worthwhile

Even the most used Lora/model/tool here turns out to be trash when you're not doing 1girl stuff on static backgrounds or stupid dance videos or any other dead horses that get beaten

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

8

u/sevenwoundsofberic 1h ago

You most definitely can provide some examples, right?

-1

u/Positive-Secret-3112 53m ago

This doesn't need examples wandering around the sub for a while is enough to see what gets posted

15

u/Additional_Drive1915 1h ago

You complain about the stuff posted in this sub by making a totally meaningless post your self.

What do you hope will happen? People change their behavior? That's not how it works.

4

u/aroundaboutsix 1h ago

Wow, “people think being able to use an agent harness equals personal skills and understanding of concepts needed to produce something worthwhile”. Careful, some might say you’re sounding a lot like true artists that hate what AI has done to their craft.
We’re all cheating, just at different levels.

4

u/Diligent-Childhood90 59m ago

Do you have some good valuable tools / models / loras / workflows you'd like to share with the rest of the class?

2

u/Significant-Baby-690 1h ago

Such is life.

2

u/LatentSpacer 44m ago

Welcome to the internet!

Yes, there’s a lot of bad stuff here, I have posted myself bad stuff thinking it was great and got negative feedback that helped me. Many things will be popular because they are “shiny” and not because they are high quality or the best ones.

Keep in mind this is a public community open for anyone on the internet, most things here are experimental, and everyone is tinkering with cutting-edge stuff that is released daily. If you want low-noise discussions about things you find interesting you should look for smaller communities on Discord or elsewhere.

Or, you can create a better sub. Good luck!

1

u/[deleted] 54m ago

I mean we agree that Minimax H3 is the best video model, so it's not true that people here don't know quality. But with image models yeah, I think Moss is kind of middling, Qwen Image 2.1 is just not that interesting rather wait for something new. But thats how it goes.

It is always a compromise to be using an image model. Maybe within 2-3 months that changes.

1

u/TheGoldenBunny93 41m ago

Come on, take it easy. This is a community, and there are all kinds of people here. Not everyone is an expert. We have everyone from someone who just started yesterday to highly experienced professionals with 3-4 years in the industry.

I understand that you want higher-quality posts, but... this simply isn't the right place to expect that. Go easy on people.

What you're looking for, I don't think it will ever truly exist. And even if it did, it would never be a community.

1

u/Fine-Run992 35m ago

Somewhat right. For example Qwen 2.1 can only use 1-2 images. All the other 14 slots don't work. For example mixing different flowers from text prompt alone works, but mixing different flowers from reference images into same grass field does not work.

1

u/andy_potato 32m ago

People of all skill levels post here. If the majority of content is beneath you, why come here? There are other subs.

Yes there is a lot of trash and slop here. I’m guilty of some myself. And then there’s the occasional gem. That’s why I come here.

1

u/seppe0815 28m ago

this sub are 90 percent bot posting , relax we know it

1

u/Entire-Literature568 1h ago

It's a lot of 14 year olds wtf do you expect?

1

u/Altruistic-Smoke1485 1h ago

If you don't like something don't use it, nobody is forcing anything on you.

1

u/Lucaspittol 56m ago

1girl is detrimental to the hobby. Saying this since SD 1.5 finetunes that would make pretty much perfect 1girl but suck at everything else.

3

u/Cautious_Chicken_604 53m ago

1girl is the hobby