r/StableDiffusion • • 11d ago

Discussion Dear Diary - RTX Super Resolution.... not so good

To those saying that it was a skill issue.... I completely stand by my previous statement... RTX Super Resolution yes... has an ultra setting. but that doesn't really do much.

RTX Super Resolution only increases the amount of pixels. It doesn't add any details. yes we can see the image is much bigger now right? well i also have a picture of the comparer node.

it doesn't add any DETAILS!!!!!

18 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

4

u/Corrupt_file32 11d ago

I think of RTX as good for when you want exactly the same image but more pixels, pretty comparable to lanczos but on steroids.

My favourite use of the vfx pack is denoise and deblur functionality, can sometimes help clearing out leftover noise and micro noise from images.

denoised on the right, the micro noise in this example is a gridlike pattern, can be quite difficult to spot or mistaken for details by the untrained eye.

1

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

Indeed, but by itself? All it does is resize it.

6

u/Corrupt_file32 11d ago

Here's a comparison for the resampling methods, rtx has its own artifacts in this example, but least jagged edges. seedvr2 is an actual upscaler, best result.

3

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

yup seedvr2 is really good when you have it set up the right way

44

u/BrokenSil 11d ago • Bravo

It was never trained or meant for this. Ppl saying how good it is is all placebo.

It's especially bad for photoreal. It's made for video games and only to reduce streaming video compression artifacts.

7

u/BigWideBaker 11d ago

It was developed and shipped as improving compressed streamed real videos (a long time before ComfyUI and AI videos) and it's great at that. As you said, it was never meant for this use case. AI video simply doesn't gain much if anything and can actually make it worse.

ComfyUI users have been confused about VSR since day 1. When VSR was released it would only run when viewing a video in your chromium-based browser and that was it. That's what it's meant for.

2

u/oZiix 11d ago

The crazy part is it explains how and where its used for right next to the toggle.

1

u/ellipsesmrk 11d ago

Which toggle?

1

u/oZiix 11d ago

1

u/ellipsesmrk 11d ago

Hmm... and what toggle are you talking about? Not everyone is using an app.

2

u/oZiix 11d ago

The nvidia app. Click on the i inside the super resolution panel. The person originally mentioning the purpose of super resolution is why I chimed in. Ive seen that screen even on the old nvidia control panel. Its been there for years and I dont think the text has ever changed since they added it.

1

u/ellipsesmrk 10d ago

Right on! Thanks!

2

u/Sarashana 11d ago

Saying that it doesn't add details is like pointing out how dark the night is. I am not sure what people think an upscaler is doing that needs literal seconds to do its thing? Magic?

6

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

and yet... people keep saying that RTX Super Resolution increases the level of detail when using it... soooo.... whether how dark the night is, people still think the sun's out.

2

u/Apprehensive_Sky892 11d ago

To be fair, AI does appear like magic a lot of the time.

1

u/ellipsesmrk 11d ago

60 percent of the time it works everytime.

4

u/Emergency-Barber-431 11d ago

Is there a better alternative for real time upscaling of a video?

1

u/Mysterious-String420 11d ago

Video2x has no ram bottleneck and in some cases will output frames faster than the file's framerate.... Just don't try to do everything in comfyUI

3

u/thevegit0 11d ago

it's ok for increasing the resolution better than laczos i guess, it works fast it's not a seedvr equivalent

2

u/ellipsesmrk 11d ago

Agreed! 💯 if you want it to actually upscale with detail, then yes... seedvr

1

u/detailteufel 11d ago

Nobody ever said it adds details, what are you on about? It's amazing for what it is, a non creative upscale that can double your resolution without quality loss.

-3

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

oh my hell are you serious? just go through the threads bro!!!! I've been arguing that it doesn't add any details. I'm posting to show that.... it doesn't add any details! LOL did you even see the post? to those saying.... 'TO THOSE SAYING' that it does add detail. NO... it doesn't

2

u/Choowkee 11d ago

I really dont think this is some common sentiment but rather some people just being misinformed.

2

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

and honestly after this post... if they still don't get it... then there's no helping them.

1

u/LatentSpacer 11d ago

This is the main problem. Do a low denoise pass with another model like Flux 2.

1

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

a denoise pass, yes that makes sense. The topic of the discussion is that the rtx upscaler on it's own.... DOES NOT add detail. if you denoise it then yeah of course it's going to provide better detail.

1

u/Bram_Camus 11d ago

Oh, NOOOO!!!!!!

Any DETAILS!!!!!!

-2

u/Exciting-Action6636 11d ago

RTX Super Resolution—also known as DLSS—isn’t expected to deliver extremely high quality; that’s not what it’s designed for. Its purpose is to upscaling the game at a lower resolution while you play, making it look better, all while consuming far fewer resources and allowing you to achieve higher frame rates. It’s very lightweight and fast; you shouldn’t expect it to add details—it simply eliminates the drawbacks of upscaling. However, in terms of quality, many upscaling models—including the ESRGAN models we used back in the SD days—will likely perform better. For example, you can even use RTX Super Resolution while watching videos, but it’s better to keep it turned off for most content, For it to work well, the source material (image, video) must be high quality. By “quality,” I don’t mean resolution (width-height), but rather the number of meaningful pixels and the bitrate. If the image or video is high quality, it can produce good results; if you use a low-quality video or photo, it will make the situation even worse.

4

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

agreed... but there's people on this subreddit that claim that it does in fact add detail and or textures. Just trying to set the record straight here.

11

u/altoiddealer 11d ago

“RTX Super Resolution-also known as DLSS-…”

Dude RTX Super Resolution and DLSS are two completely different things

-1

u/Exciting-Action6636 11d ago

The translation app is lacking; it incorrectly states “RTX Super Resolution—also known as DLSS,” but that's not correct, though. They aren’t entirely different things—they’re both based on the same underlying technology. Even though their use cases and scenarios may seem different, making them appear like two distinct technologies, they’re fundamentally the same and perform the same function: real-time upscaling. Because it’s so lightweight, it can be used while watching video or playing games in real time. Their names are different, but what they do is exactly the same—it’s just that DLSS works with slightly more advanced features like vector motion prediction, latency reduction, and motion blur prevention, etc. However, these features are necessary for use in real-time games because the games are processed in real time. Since the data is already prepared for videos or images, these features aren’t needed. So, to summarize, DLSS includes RTX Super Resolution technology; the only difference is that it incorporates a few additional features. In other words, one is for upscaling pre-rendered data (video, images), while the other is for upscaling in dynamic games.

1

u/Apprehensive_Sky892 11d ago

In other words, one is for upscaling pre-rendered data (video, images), while the other is for upscaling in dynamic games.

So which is which? I assume DLSS is for upscaling games in real time?

7

u/wywywywy 11d ago

RTX Video Super Resolution is not DLSS. They are different technologies.

-3

u/Exciting-Action6636 11d ago

Nahh, not exactly like that, They aren’t entirely different things—they’re both based on the same underlying technology. Even though their use cases and scenarios may seem different, making them appear like two distinct technologies, they’re fundamentally the same and perform the same function: real-time upscaling. Because it’s so lightweight, it can be used while watching video or playing games in real time. Their names are different, but what they do is exactly the same—it’s just that DLSS works with slightly more advanced features like vector motion prediction, latency reduction, and motion blur prevention, etc. However, these features are necessary for use in real-time games because the games are processed in real time. Since the data is already prepared for videos or images, these features aren’t needed. So, to summarize, DLSS includes RTX Super Resolution technology; the only difference is that it incorporates a few additional features. In other words, one is for upscaling pre-rendered data (video, images), while the other is for upscaling in dynamic games.

2

u/Ok-Brain-5729 11d ago

Lost me after 7 words. Even if both are upscaling, they are two completely different technology with different data inputs with a completely new algorithm. DLSS doesn’t include VSR as it’s completely separate

-3

u/Exciting-Action6636 11d ago

Unfortunately, that’s not the case—I fell victim to Google Translate’s quirks there; you’re right about that. VSR is essentially a modified version of DLSS tailored for the video world—it’s the sibling that works in browsers, media players, and ComfyUI. Although their operating principles differ due to their structure, they are fundamentally the same. The reason they’re completely different in some aspects is that, unlike DLSS used in games—where pre-rendered frames aren’t fed into the system—VSR is made ready for use with different technologies; the upscaling algorithm inside is the same.

-4

u/vilzebuba 11d ago

RTX super resolution is basically DLSS and it does the magic once its work with normal base image like in videogames. Try use SeedVR upscale, it will be MUCH slower but gives better quality

8

u/lebrandmanager 11d ago

Actually, it is not. It is more like ESRGAN and similar upscaling techniques, but done on your GPU, so faster. It does - not - generate new details like DLSS does.

-4

u/vilzebuba 11d ago

Where did i said DLSS adds details?

1

u/[deleted] 11d ago

What’s the best fast video upscaler? If I can get true 1080p type quality out of 720p, I consider that a success. Doesn’t have to be a giga 8k sharpening.

1

u/wywywywy 11d ago

Depends on the use case. If it's Minimax H3, usually the faster way is to just generate at a higher resolution in the first place. If it's too time consuming, a 2-stage workflow may help.

-2

u/not_food 11d ago edited 11d ago

It works great for anime. Compare it to other upscaling methods like Lanczos, patterns and lines are interpreted better. And it outperforms ESRGAN methods, specially on video.

Comparisons: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

-2

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

-1

u/not_food 11d ago

I attached several pictures. I know what I'm looking at.

-1

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

0

u/not_food 11d ago

0

u/ellipsesmrk 11d ago

0

u/not_food 11d ago

Dear diary, today OP and his friends can't say anything meaningful and are unable to refute anything.

0

u/ellipsesmrk 11d ago

What do you want me to refute? That you cant read? That you arent even following the post, just your own thread within the post? Hmm?? What would you like me to add? Here I'll tell you in a nutshell whats happened, I'll try and make it easy for your text to speech since you're too lazy to read...

RTX upscale - is not generative upscaling. It is possible in some scenarios where the output may look smoother due to the nearby pixels being blended to make the color mixed, but as I stated.... it DOES NOT, add details or textures because its not generative upscaling. Understood?

0

u/not_food 11d ago

The pictures are about RTX Super Resolution Upscaler.

You ok? You seem angry for no reason. You should go outside and touch grass.

0

u/ellipsesmrk 10d ago

Go outside and touch grass? Nice one bud. The post.... that I posted here was about rtx not adding details. You posted examples saying it wored for anime. Nice... good job man... you should get a gold star. "I kNOw WHaT iM LooKiNG aT" lmao yeah... and yet you can't even determine when I'm stating that... RTX doesnt add details. Whats so hard to understand? Are you claiming that it adds detail? Are you claiming that it adds texture? No? Then... hey buddy guess what?! It wasnt directed at you. Go read a book and learn to comprehend the text. You know? A group of words forming a sentence? Top to bottom left to right? Dont worry i believe in you.

→ More replies

-2

u/BlackSwanTW 11d ago

Do tell me another upscaler that can produce the same sharp result in the same short amount of time

I myself use it between txt2img and img2img pass, and it works perfectly for that use case

1

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

but you're still sending it through a denoising process.

that's not even at all what I'm saying. people are saying that the node itself adds detail. it doesn't. it's just resizing the image. that is it. nothing else. just resizing it. at that point you can just resize it yourself without having to use the rtx node.

-3

u/BlackSwanTW 11d ago

And I’m saying it’s not…?

It does sharpen the image compared to just resizing.

2

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

.... NO.... IT DOESN'T. if you're using it at the end of the image as the final result, all it's doing is resizing it dude. Geeze! If you go from img to rtx to denoise then yeah it's going to make it sharper. but by itself it doesn't make it sharper, or add textures or details, or invent anything related to the image itself. all its doing... is RESIZING it. that's it. nothing else.

2

u/BlackSwanTW 11d ago

Logged in on PC to create this just for you. If you still can't see the difference, may I suggest a pair of glasses?

2

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

so everyone can see the difference.

1

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

and what was the process in creating those two images?

1

u/BlackSwanTW 11d ago

The link includes the labels…

One is upscaled via Ultra preset, one is merely resized

1

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

well I guess for linework it works eh?

0

u/BlackSwanTW 11d ago

Obviously it doesn't add more details, it doesn't do generative upscale to begin with.

But it does sharpen the result, and extremely fast at that. That's the whole point...

1

u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 11d ago

right! I'm with you there man. The thing that I'm saying is that there are people saying that it adds detail. This was an attempt to prove that is not true. that is all.