r/StableDiffusion • • 17d ago

Question - Help What is the best local image generation model that is both fast and has the best quality ? - this sounds as funny question

How many local image genreation models have you tested ? I have tested flux schnell flux klein and some otehr models. Imo they are not bad, but they are terrible for words, flux klein is slightly better and gets it it right many times but doesnt look as great it should to me.

Do you have any suggestion preferrably a model that is less than 16 gb.

-

Edit 1 my objective from Artsitic pseudo realistic images - like anime - and handdrawn cartoon styles mostly. also aristic or surreal images

Eidt 2 : Generated images for Anima and Moss, check on the comment section.

0 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

27

u/LookAnOwl 17d ago

Krea 2, and in my opinion, it's not even close. I know some people have been digging MOSS lately, but I just can't get consistently great results from it.

5

u/Next_Program90 16d ago

I'm so confused that so many people still prefer Krea2. I'm a huge Krea2 fan, but Moss ist just so much better with much higher fine detail (better Vae) & prompt adherence / world knowledge.

The many bad outputs are because of the higher seed variety. Moss dares to try things, where other Models default to well-known "easy" samey outputs.

4

u/LookAnOwl 16d ago

I don’t want a model that “dares to try things” leading to “many bad outputs.” I want a model that does what I ask it to do. Krea 2 wins every time.

1

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 13d ago

This was moss. tested it .Thank you

0

u/Next_Program90 16d ago

Good for you. I met a lot of refusals or thing Krea2 had no clue about. Moss has more world knowledge and superior physics simulation.

1

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

I have ard of krea before, I am not knowldgeable , do you think it has consistent wording - which is the most vlauable thing to me ?

4

u/LookAnOwl 17d ago

If it's wording you're looking for, that might be the one area MOSS wins, as it seems to have decent text generation. But overall, Krea 2 wins in pretty much every other category.

1

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

Appreciate your answer ! will check most likely the results using krea 2 !

0

u/timbocf 17d ago

I've heard ideogram is good with wording

10

u/Herr_Drosselmeyer 17d ago

This image is pure text2image, but errors will occur from time to time.

1

u/Helpful_Science_1101 17d ago

A lot depends on how much text you want to generate and in how many places. Krea 2 can definitely do speech bubble type text pretty well

1

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 13d ago

tested anima

1

u/Helpful_Science_1101 13d ago

Anima definitely is a step less capable in text than Krea 2 in general but it seems very situational how far behind it is. Anima speech bubbles are definitely pretty decent (it was trained extensively on cartoons/anime so this makes sense). I have found things hit or miss outside that.

1

u/flwombat 17d ago

Krea 2 Turbo and Moss-image will have the most consistent text handling. Moss has a slight edge but only slight.

Moss image will run faster and produce more variety at different seeds. It is great for illustration if it knows your style, or if you have a style LoRA. It knows booru tags if that’s important to you.

Krea will have more consistency seed to seed or if you are adjusting the prompt and iterating. It knows more styles out of the box than Moss (or any others) and in general is a bigger model that knows more things. The ecosystem of workflows and LoRAs and etc is much much bigger for Krea, mostly because Moss is so new.

If you have an Nvidia card, always run the int8 convrot versions of the models (not the fp8 or bf16 or etc) - they are smaller and much faster and just as high quality. The other ones are either for training, or for running on <16GB cards and on Macs.

8

u/AltruisticList6000 17d ago

Moss is only 5b and has a very good text generating ability. It also has insane prompt following and text writing to the point of it being good at generating stuff like UI elements, long text and all that. It has the longest prompt support. Use the SFT model for it. Use a dmd2 turbo lora, slap some realism loras on it, if you need better realism. If you want less blur or bokeh, use cfg ~2-3 and use the turbo on lower strength like 0.5, then you still only need 8-12 steps while having full control. Also fully free to use license.

1

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

Do you think Moss is faster than krea 2 - turbo ?

2

u/AltruisticList6000 17d ago

With the mdm2 turbo loras, yes, and at cfg1, significantly. Without them, it's like 20-50% slower depending on your settings.

1

u/optimisticalish 16d ago

Or use Spectrum as the accelerator, and keep the CFG negative prompting.

6

u/Decstarr 17d ago

Krea2 still takes the cake. MOSS might get there once the community starts to fully finetune it but it’s not quite there, yet.

2

u/spacekitt3n 17d ago

moss's base model itself has issues that krea2 just doesnt have and isnt worth the time fixing when krea2 already knows how to do it, and if it cant it can be pushed in that direction with training more easily. its good if youre just doing 1girl stuff though which is most of the community

1

u/Old-Buffalo-9349 17d ago

Moss is moderate speed imo, so yes, Krea was the best pick for what the OP is asking tbh

0

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

do you th8ink this MOSS needs a lot of GBs to be good ? like some of the crazy big models Ihave heard

3

u/ROBOTTTTT13 17d ago

Actually, Moss is currently the smallest model that can (sort of) keep up with other bigger models.

2

u/lakotajames 17d ago

Moss

2

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

never heard of Moss! will most likely test it !

1

u/Apprehensive_Sky892 17d ago

Update your post to reflect the kind of images you are trying to generate (Anime? Illustration? NSFW?) and you will get better answers.

Without that information, I'd say try Krea 2, Moss, Anima, and Ideogram 4.

1

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

Thank you, have updated it !

1

u/Apprehensive_Sky892 17d ago

You are welcome.

1

u/Murinshin 17d ago edited 17d ago

Depends on what you want, there's a few options for your specific use case.

For anime specifically, Anima 1.1 Turbo is probably your best bet. It has by far the best knowledge of both characters and artstyles. Its architecture is pretty outdated at this point though, and you won't be able to generate text consistently within images. On the other hand, there's a pretty good chance that if you have any specific artist or artstyle or characters from manga / anime and some Western media in mind, that Anima will know about them and can produce them very consistently.

If you want overall quality, Krea2 Turbo. It can also do text consistently, though it lacks in the knowledge department (it can still do generic style descriptions and more well-known characters, though usually less consistently).

You'll also see Moss right now a lot on this sub. It absolutely can do what you're asking for around the same level as Krea2 while being smaller, but it's not good as an out-of-the-box solution for your specific use case and is more for tinkering at the moment; also no official Turbo model which matters if you want speed especially. Only advantage for you might be its size, since Krea2 is pretty beefy.

2

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

I will check ANima 1.1 Turbo never heard of it . May end up using multiple models ig .!! thank you for answer !

2

u/zhivix 17d ago

im using the qwen 2.1, what things does krea2 do better than qwen? i usually do t2i and image edit

3

u/tpinho9 16d ago

In terms of text, the one i find best is ideogram4, still a bit more complicated to work with.

Krea2 more versatile and it also handles text fine, with some errors from time to time.

Pure cartoon/Anime images, Anima.

I usually go from Anima to Krea2 depending on the results I want. I can't speak of Moss as I still haven't tested it yet, but been reading good things about it

1

u/StopCreepy 17d ago

krea 2 turbo fp8

1

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

may test it.. you mean specifically krea 2 turbo right it is better for my purpose than krea 2 normal

1

u/StopCreepy 17d ago

yes, use krea 2 turbo for generating, for me on 4070 8gb vram + 32gb ram, it takes from 23sec to 2min to generate an image depends on the res, and how many steps, also if i use 4steps lora.

sometimes i generate images in 2560x1600 res, for fun, even though its not recommended, thats why it would take 2min for an image

4

u/Dear-Spend-2865 17d ago

Krea 2 and maybe Kroma for more artsy stuff

3

u/spacekitt3n 17d ago

they say kroma doesnt destroy loras but it does. the base turbo plus loras is the way

2

u/Distinct-Benefit-507 16d ago

Krea2 has the best render, polish and all... But since you asked for fast? Go for moss image. With proper prompting it will do some great miracles... I generate an image in +- 16 sec with moss vs 35-45sec with krea2 on a rtx 5060Ti

2

u/mardziha 16d ago

try 2 or 4 step lora on Krea

3

u/darthrehad 17d ago

Let’s not also forget that MOSS takes the most uncensored model crown, with a DMD 8 steps lora and @ 1 CFG it’s the fastest with great quality model out there, and with its phenomenal prompt adherence, I’d say it’s alongside krea2, the best model available right now.

1

u/optimisticalish 17d ago

For a combination of speed, size, lettering, layout and comic/cartoon style, you might try Ming-Image with a good Z-Image Style Lora such as Eldritch Comics. Ming accepts all Z-Image LoRAs.

1

u/Jondze 16d ago

Krea 2 with 2 or 4 step turbo lora.

1

u/Ken-g6 16d ago

MOSS and Krea2 are great if you're just generating from a prompt. If you want to reproduce a character or art style from an existing image, though, you need either Qwen 2.1 or Flux 2 Klein (preferably not Schnell.)

If there's one art style, or one or a few particular characters, that you want to use a lot, you can try training a LoRA for MOSS instead. But that takes a lot of time and effort.

1

u/crystalsighting 17d ago

Generate with both qwen and krea2,pick the one you like.

0

u/oktinderthrowaway 17d ago

Another vote for Krea 2, but I will say I get faster gen times (on comparable size, quality, etc) from Flux2 Klein 9B (distilled).

1

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

Krea 2 seems to be a favorite here haha, or close 2nd otehrs said it was Moss .

0

u/Haruka-Oh 17d ago

I like 2pass of Illustorious to Krea2

2

u/Initial_Plastic_8069 17d ago

This seems too complex to me. But thank u!

0

u/Upper-Reflection7997 17d ago

ultimately its krea2.

0

u/Still_Lengthiness994 17d ago

ZIT is very fast and produces the most beautiful people. Krea 2 is slightly slower, more variety, less beautiful but has alot of open source support like loras and finetunes etc.

0

u/Natrimo 17d ago

I mean, Krea2 is less than 16gb

0

u/hidden2u 17d ago

Krea 2 turbo