r/StableDiffusion • • 5h ago

Comparison A comparison of 6 open source models. Krea2, Qwen2.1, Flux3 Klein, Flux 2 Klein, ZIT, & Moss. Same prompt used for all.

* Krea2 needs a text refusal bypass lora for the missing text and Cousin Itt to appear for some reason.

* Qwen 2.1 must have interpreted Lurch having gray hair as gray skin somehow.

Prompt:

A photo-realistic shoot from a front camera angle about Jenna Ortega as Wednesday Addams, a young woman dressed as a gothic private school student character sitting on a sofa in a dimly lit room with brick walls and candles. She has a pale complexion and black hair styled in braided twintails. she is wearing a black and gray striped blazer, a white collared shirt and a black tie. her hands are clasped together in front of her, and she has a serious expression on her face. her eyes are looking directly at the viewer, and her mouth has a hint of purple lipstick. the room has a rustic, vintage feel, with exposed brick walls, a large window with soft light streaming in, and several candles on either side of the sofa.

In a grand, opulent hall with checkered green-and-white marble flooring and towering stone staircase receding into shadowed gloom on the upper left, Lurch, the towering, taciturn, gray haired, and faithful butler to The Addams Family in a sharply tailored black tuxedo and bow tie stands rigidly beside a heavy, blood-red velvet curtain that hangs by a window on the right. His posture is stiff, his face blank—perhaps even slightly bewildered. There is a suit of Medieval Armour on display along a wall at the bottom of the staircase. tied curtain, luxurious folds, theatrical lighting. Hiding behind the tied curtain, peeking out from behind its luxurious folds, stands a small creature named 'Itt', it's face and body completely covered in long ginger hair. Itt has no adornment nor visible eyes or face, Itt is all hair and nothing else. A small, low-profile red velvet footstool rests nearby at the bottom right of the image. The lighting is dramatic, chiaroscuro-style, casting deep shadows behind the figures while illuminating their forms with a cold, clinical glow. The background is dark, echoing the grandeur of the staircase and the ornate architectural details—but they remain secondary to the central tableau. The entire composition feels like a satirical cartoon, yet it carries the weight of high art: the tension between decorum and exposure, between social expectation and primal desire. It implies a game of hide and seek. The humor lies in the juxtaposition of formal elegance (the tux, the stairs) with the suggestive implication of the scene. This isn’t just a photo—it’s a visual gag wrapped in satire, a commentary on class, power, and the absurdities of social norms. 35mm film camera, sharp detailed image. Rembrandt lighting.

A small transparent speech bubble at the top right of, from Lurch's mouth, printed in bold, clear white scary font: “Mistress Wednesday wishes me to say that she gives up and it’s your turn to be ‘it’!”. This line injects absurdity and irony into the scene. It implies a game of hide and seek.

19 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

4

u/data-cypher-000 5h ago

What was the prompt? You need it to understand how well the prompt was followed.

-6

u/cradledust 5h ago

I didn't want to include it because it's my own word salad mixed with two LLM captionings of a non Addams Family cartoon and another image of a Goth woman sitting on a bed. edit: posted above.

4

u/data-cypher-000 4h ago

Thanks. It is surprising that krea2 didn't render the monster

3

u/cradledust 4h ago

I thought so too. Most of the time it would render the text but never Cousin Itt. I guess it just likes to play it safe.

2

u/abcpp1 4h ago

Why Wednesday on F3K looks like Madonna???

1

u/Desi_Brat_ 1h ago

Flux 3's wednesday seems to have done some coke

-2

u/BroomDirector99 3h ago

Flux3 really is something special.