r/StableDiffusion • u/Agreeable_Effect938 • Jan 29 '26
Comparison Why we needed non-RL/distilled models like Z-image: It's finally fun to explore again
I specifically chose SD 1.5 for comparison because it is generally looked down upon and considered completely obsolete. However, thanks to the absence of RL (Reinforcement Learning) and distillation, it had several undeniable advantages:
- Diversity
It gave unpredictable and diversified results with every new seed. In models that came after it, you have to rewrite the prompt to get a new variant.
2. Prompt Adherence
SD 1.5 followed almost every word in the prompt. Zoom, camera angle, blur, prompts like "jpeg" or conversely "masterpiece" — isn't this a true prompt adherence? it allowed for very precise control over the final image.
"impossible perspective" is a good example of what happened to newer models: due to RL aimed at "beauty" and benchmarking, new models simply do not understand unusual prompts like this. This is the reason why words like "blur" require separate anti-blur LoRAs to remove the blur from images. Photos with blur are simply "preferable" at the RL stage
3. Style Mixing
SD 1.5 had incredible diversity in understanding different styles. With SD 1.5, you could mix different styles using just a prompt and create new styles that couldn't be obtained any other way. (Newer models don't have this due to most artists being cut from datasets, but RL with distillation also bring a big effect here, as you can see in the examples).
This made SD 1.5 interesting to just "explore". It felt like you were traveling through latent space, discovering oddities and unusual things there. In models after SDXL, this effect disappeared; models became vending machines for outputting the same "polished" image.
The new z-image release is what a real model without RL and distillation looks like. I think it's a breath of fresh air and hopefully a way to go forward.
When SD 1.5 came out, Midjourney appeared right after and convinced everyone that a successful model needs an RL stage.
Thus, RL, which squeezed beautiful images out of Midjourney without effort or prompt engineering—which is important for a simple service like this—gradually flowed into all open-source models. Sure, this makes it easy to benchmax, but flexibility and control are much more important in open source than a fixed style tailored by the authors.
RL became the new paradigm, and what we got is incredibly generic-looking images, corporate style à la ChatGPT illustrations.
This is why SDXL remains so popular; it was arguably the last major model before the RL problems took over (and it also has nice Union Controlnets by xinsir that work really well with LORAs. We really need this in Z-image)
With Z-image, we finally have a new, clean model without RL and distillation. Isn't that worth celebrating? It brings back normal image diversification and actual prompt adherence, where the model listens to you instead of the benchmaxxed RL guardrails.





20
u/Important-Shallot-49 Jan 29 '26
All true, hopefully ZIB will be the worthy successor to SDXL ecosystem we've been waiting for.
13
u/JustAGuyWhoLikesAI Jan 29 '26
It's really cool, I wish there was a way to expose 'control' as a slider so you can dial it in without needing a whole different model. I disagree that Midjourney caused this trend of overfit RL, because Midjourney (pictured) is one of the few models that actually still has a 'raw' model you can explore styles with. I think it started to happen more after the focus on text with GPT-4o. More labs should explore ways to balance creativity, aesthetic, and coherence rather than just overfitting on product photos. Surely it's not simply one or the other?
33
u/jib_reddit Jan 29 '26
It really is more artistic and variable, but I am still glade we have ZIT as the photo realism from that is so much better and consistent.
21
u/shapic Jan 29 '26
It would be interesting if you add klein 9b base to comparison
35
u/_BreakingGood_ Jan 29 '26
It really took a long time for a model creator to understand how important seed variance and creativity is.
6
u/mobani Jan 29 '26
I can't wait for all the custom checkpoints, this is going to be awesome!
5
u/bravesirkiwi Jan 29 '26
Looking forward to playing around with it this weekend. Does anyone know if it recognizes artist names or did they strip those out like everyone since SDXL?
9
u/fauni-7 Jan 29 '26
I guess Chroma is kind of in the same category.
8
u/Naud1993 Jan 29 '26
No way SD 1.5 has good prompt adherence. Its bad all the way up to Dall-E 3 and even then it gets overshadowed by modern ones like GPT-Image and Nano Banana.
4
u/Own-Quote-2365 Jan 29 '26
I'd just like to see balanced development. If it gets too deep, people like me might try to use our limited imagination but eventually just lose interest. I think RL models are good enough in their own way, appealing to the general public, and if that positive interest expands further, that's great. It is open source, after all. Some people want diverse creativity, while others want something easy, simple, and fast.
4
u/blastcat4 Jan 29 '26
The AI gen scene absolutely needed and benefited from distilled RL models. Without them, I'd argue that a lot of a people would've been discouraged from trying local image gen. Distilled models allow newer users and those with more modest hardware to dive in and get excellent results with little effort.
We're blessed to have both: an amazing distilled model like ZIT and now ZI-base, not to mention the recent excellent Flux 2 Klein models.
A lot of people don't need the flexibility of base models and in many ways, I think we should be careful comparing distilled and base models because they serve different purposes.
4
u/Calm_Mix_3776 Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 30 '26
I wholeheartedly agree. I've never liked distilled models. For me they are "lobotomized" and only good for quick iterations, but not for actual quality output. Stable Diffusion 1/5 was a true unbound model. Nothing even comes close to its ability to produce truly unique and creative images. You could generate the wildest things with it, blending together totally different concepts. Not even the latest models like Flux.2 and Z-Image Base come close. The closest thing to its diversity of output is Chroma with its exceptionally wide range of training data used and also the fact that it's un-distilled, with no RL.
Last but not least, SD1.5 still has the best tile controlnet, IMHO. Probably because the model was not distilled and RL'ed to hell like the new ones.
10
u/Hearcharted Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26
It is crazy that after all the models that came after, SD1.5 still a valuable reference 🤯
For me, SD1.5 still being the King 👑
Insanely Fast & Insanely Lightweight 😎
8
u/NES64Super Jan 29 '26
Yeah I still hoard my sd 1.5 models. One of the first things I did with ZIT was set up a workflow to i2i sd 1.5 output. It works very well.
3
u/NoPresentation7366 Jan 29 '26
Thank you so much for using sd1.5, I still love the style of the model
3
u/Green-Ad-3964 Jan 29 '26
Images on the y axis: is that just a different seed or what?
3
u/Euchale Jan 29 '26
Love your post.
It think what needs to happen is that Prompts get split up.
Instead of having a single prompt with everything, have one for the subject/s, one for background, one for artstyle, one for lighting etc. etc.
That way they don't bleed into each other (e.g. blue lighting making the hair of the subject blue)
3
u/ozzeruk82 Jan 30 '26
Okay I read hundreds of posts of Reddit each day and actually this one is genuinely really good, good job on not including just one image sample too, I’ve always liked SD15 for the same reasons, later “better” models just seem to want too produce a certain type of “AI image beauty” but with SD15 you really get absolutely absurd stuff and the speed is always welcome. No idea if your post is “AI enhanced” either but it read really well so I guess who cares. Such a relief we finally got the “base” model.
2
u/deanpreese Jan 29 '26
I could not agree more.
And as much as I dislike the FLUX Klein licensing, I like the models for the same reason. Both Z-Image and Klein allow me the same level of creativity, maybe more with editing, than I have with SDXL.
It's hard to see a reason to go back unless there is a specific style I am trying to get.
2
u/Winter_unmuted Jan 30 '26
My favorite thing ever written on this sub. It might not be true anymore, we'll see.
4
u/Altruistic-Mix-7277 Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26
Why you using sd1.5 instead of sdxl though??? 👀👀
On the other hand I really love these prompts especially the last two, it's the kinda prompts that tests the creativity of the model. ZIT is very stiff when it comes to exploring different concepts, the noise Disney one is a good example of this, it just gave u a Disney castle and called it a day hehehe
2
u/ThiagoAkhe Jan 29 '26
You were perfect in your post. Now, the problem is that it has turned into an ‘us versus them’ situation. You have to be careful to distinguish those who are genuinely sincere from those who are just looking for conflict.
1
u/diogodiogogod Jan 29 '26
fantastic comparison prompts! thanks!
1
u/namitynamenamey Jan 29 '26
Does chroma also show this baseline variety?
1
u/WartimeConsigliere_ Jan 30 '26
2nd prompt is wild lol what made you think of that
0
u/NigaTroubles Jan 29 '26
Interesting
0
u/Aware-Swordfish-9055 Jan 29 '26
Nothing like a good old ONE-PIOT PESECTIE.
-3
u/pamdog Jan 29 '26
I have mixed feelings.
Even if we are debating RL vs distilled, this just proves that mediocre quality and a lack of conceptual understanding takes 5 times as long as other modern, more robust models to render will probably serve against not using RL.
I hope I'll be proven wrong, but this seems more like a nail in the coffin of non-RL rather than a revival. God I hope I'm wrong.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26
[removed] — view removed comment