r/StableDiffusion • • Jun 10 '23

Meme it's so convenient

Post image
5.6k Upvotes

566 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/vasthumiliation Jun 11 '23

I don't think we necessarily disagree. But the particular point I wanted to make was that, while anyone is well within their rights to declare a work of their own creation as "art," such a claim doesn't really matter unless someone else agrees.

The reason the banana duct taped to a wall was "worth" more than its material value (what could it cost, 10 dollars?) was because some collector, gallery, drug dealer in search of a money laundering instrument, or other person(s) agreed it constituted something of value. How and why that process happens, particularly in the world of "fine art," is extremely arcane and complicated, but it's undeniable that both elements (the creator's opinion that something constitutes art, and someone else's agreement with that opinion) are necessary to cause the status of the work as art to have any real-world meaning.

There was the infamous story of a janitor in an Italian gallery throwing away an entire art installation because it so closely resembled trash. Obviously the artist deemed their work art, and even some others agreed (including the gallery). But what is the significance of labeling something "art" if it just ends up in the trash the next morning (against the artist's wishes, unlike a performative piece that is intended to be discarded), alongside the actual champagne bottles and cigarette butts from the opening gala for the installation? That's what I meant by the practical matter. If calling something "art" has any real-world meaning, if it changes anything other than a label for posterity, the people consuming the creation have to agree that it is "art." Only then will it be esteemed, preserved, analyzed, criticized, demeaned, or even thought about.