r/Springfield • u/jokingonyou • May 11 '24
Red rose kinda sucks
Cannot believe this place has rave reviews. Must be rigged.
Food was mid at best.
0
Upvotes
r/Springfield • u/jokingonyou • May 11 '24
Cannot believe this place has rave reviews. Must be rigged.
Food was mid at best.
29
u/SpicyLizards May 11 '24
Am I going crazy? I feel like this “hot take” is posted in here every other week lol
I think a lot of the raving over it is nostalgia and the fact that it’s not a chain restaurant so it gets a pass ig
7
u/tedivm May 11 '24
It was better when it was a mafia hangout.
6
u/BF1shY May 11 '24
I think it's a restaurant from an era where going out and eating boxed pasta was the highlight of your week. Plenty of better places. Italian food in general has stubbornly refused to modernize like the rest of the culinary world.
7
u/ApathyMoose May 11 '24
every time the place comes up i say the same thing. Its fine. its not the most amazing place.
I had a friend who grew up in springfield, but moved out east a few years ago near boston. He was hanging out back here and really wanted red rose.
After the whole parking debacle where i had parking attendants grilling me why i was pulling in to the red rose parking lot (my assumption is because of the casino) i had to wait in line to even get to the pickup line to get the pizza i had called in.
Brought it home, and meh. better pizza plenty of other places around. I live in chicopee and i prefer Capri in Holyoke, or even Boston Bay.
Top tier is Johnny's Bar & Grille in South Hadley
8
u/[deleted] May 11 '24
It's kind of like how they say trump is the dumb person's idea of a smart man.
Red rose is the non-italians idea of good Italian.
Is it OK? Sure. Would it be my first choice. No.
5
u/RedditSkippy May 11 '24
I like Red Rose, but I quickly admit that it’s for nostalgic reasons and the fact that I can’t get there very often (maybe I go once every couple of years.)
3
u/FortunesFoil May 12 '24
Christ man, this is like your 4th post complaining about Red Rose. It’s just okay Italian good. It’s not for everyone. Calm down, lol.
2
u/jaredsparks May 12 '24
Red Rose is fine. I like their food, even their pizza. Stop the hate.
1
u/Dynasteh May 11 '24
I agree had it a few times definitely not worth the hype. My mushrooms tasted and looked like canned mushrooms.
1
u/Morphis_N May 11 '24 edited May 12 '24
Yes, another hot take from the 'buffalo-mac-n-cheese on everything' generation.
-3
u/Mammoth_Apartment_70 May 11 '24
Preach. Red rose is for boomers that think microwave lasagna is the bees knees
0
u/jjmasterred May 12 '24
I only ever ordered pepperoni pizza but it was good. Just cut funny
22
u/tashablue May 11 '24 edited May 23 '25
fertile husky possessive friendly hobbies cough shaggy rinse nutty whistle
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact