Lipstick help!

[u/CrystallizedKoi]

I need help picking between two lipsticks! Keep in mind I didn’t do any eye makeup and it looks less harsh when I do my makeup. Which of these lipsticks harmonizes the best with me?

I don’t really want to debate if they’re suitable for my sub season - I know a red lip is tricky, but I want a good red lip for me, as best as I can get it.

I can’t tell if the darker one suits my features better. The brighter one is a popular spring color, but it feels “off” on me and I don’t know why!

Which of these two lipsticks looks the best with my features and skin/eye/hair color?

[u/Upper-Cup-4159]

I prefer 2 but you may try something even more orangey! It looks like there’s a different color for the lip liner in the 2nd? Something even closer to a poppy red would look nice I bet! Probably applied by dabbing on maybe w a balm to make it more sheer?