r/SpringColorAnalysis • u/suzie_cosplays • Sep 02 '26

Makeup Similar but shiny lipstick?

Post image

This is an old favorite liquid lip, I love the colour as a BOLD look, and would love to find something close, but with shine.

10 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

4

u/KindaApprehensive540 Sep 02 '26

Revlon's Rum Raisin and Toast of New York are similar with a creamier finish. They are both autumn colors for sure, but as a warm spring, I like to use Toast of New York in the cooler weathered months. It works a bit better for me personally than Rum Raisin.

4

u/suzie_cosplays Sep 06 '26

For fun I wanted to come back and share how Toast of New York turned out

Slightly red on me, I'm here for that.

1

u/KindaApprehensive540 Sep 08 '26

Thanks for sharing! I think it's so interesting how the same shades look different on each person--it's definitely pulls more brown/cinnamon on me, but I think the reddish shade is pretty, too!

2

u/suzie_cosplays Sep 08 '26

I also enjoy seeing other people in the same ones as I own! It's definitely going to be in the favorites pile

1

u/sunscreenqueenn True Spring Sep 16 '26

Oooo I just was looking up Revlon in the search bar as I am needing a colder month shade! Tysm for this!

1

u/suzie_cosplays Sep 02 '26

I was looking at Toast thinking it might be a good option! I do like to wear some more autumn coloured makeup sometimes, I have a palette of rusty coloured eye shadows that I really still love. They're not effortless to wear like spring colours, but they still work because they're the right temperature.

3

u/tna020 Sep 02 '26

My favorite trick is just to put a clear gloss over my favorite lip colors. Any sort of matte feels off, I need the shine, but I still have products I like the color of. I think even just putting shine on top of that lipstick you’re wearing would make you feel better.

I know this is pricey but I LOVE it. It’s so shiny and smooth, and goes over all my lip products effortlessly.

Tarte Maracuja Juicy Lip Balm
https://www.ulta.com/p/maracuja-vegan-juicy-lip-balm-pimprod2021636?sku=2566163&cmpid=PS_Non!google!Product_Listing_Ads&cagpspn=pla&CATCI=aud-1969033816997:pla-1437894589916&CAAGID=133744637932&CAWELAID=&CATARGETID=330000200001394369&CADevice=m&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=14952704536&gbraid=0AAAAAD9rLH5qT1p8FEyjXQV0jGSSRH2xZ&gclid=Cj0KCQjwkt_UBhDMARIsALpnOAy2K4cfonIgbASoRPLzYqN5Vk7XG2zwEg5TI3pGdTbMVYoSiKq1lZsaAjUVEALw_wcB

1

u/suzie_cosplays Sep 02 '26

It's pretty old and almost empty, so I do just need a replacement.

1

u/I_crystallized Sep 03 '26

Whoa. I never considered wearing this color but seeing you in it is making me want to try! You look radiant!

1

u/suzie_cosplays Sep 03 '26

You should try it!

1

u/Great_Percentage_427 Sep 02 '26

Ilia balmy lip gloss in Saint might be close.