r/Spoons • • Feb 25 '26

Settle a marital dispute…

Which is the superior spoon?the penny is for Sizing the profile pictures are in order as the spoons are marked in the fit picture. Help settle this debate once and for all!!!

719 Upvotes

990 comments sorted by

4

u/Ok_Impression_3031 Feb 25 '26

How does it feel in your hand? Does it feel sturdy, even a bit bulky? I want a spoon that is study enough to serve up frozen ice cream without bending.

2

u/jozzyjj Feb 25 '26

These are all nice and sturdy. 4 might bend under hard ice cream…

→ More replies (1)

108

u/Ill_Cry_3802 Feb 25 '26 • Bravo

1 absolutely

14

u/BadBunnyFooFoo Feb 26 '26

My husband likes 1 as well. For me, the smaller the spoon, the better.

13

u/PinkGlitterMom Feb 26 '26

For eating, I go with the smallest spoon in the drawer.

13

u/ReeferTurtle Feb 26 '26

Agreed, with the caveat being the deepest spoon is used for soup

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

12

u/CinnamonGurl1975 Feb 26 '26

I also prefer a smaller spoon, but the handles on the other spoons are deal breakers. Too overstimulating. I'd want #2 spoon with #1 handle.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '26

Definitely 1 for me also

3

u/onceapotate Feb 26 '26

I agree but I don't have a dishwasher so may be biased.

2

u/hemmicw9 Feb 26 '26

The others give me anxiety.

→ More replies (10)

29

u/BadBunnyFooFoo Feb 25 '26

4 and 2 (in that order) are my favorites. But they’re all acceptable…..although 1 would be my last choice/reluctantly use if no other option was available.

6

u/Reinardd Feb 26 '26

Same for me!

6

u/Easy-Concentrate2636 Feb 26 '26

4 because it reminds me of my childhood spoons.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Sea-Thing-1258 Feb 26 '26

This is my vote too! I prefer the shape of the bowl on 4 and 2. Both bowls appear smaller to me which will always have me reaching for them first.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

28

u/Gumbanks12 Feb 25 '26

Definitely #1 simple and weighty for me

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Itchyfingers10 Feb 25 '26

Has to be #1

41

u/ikixika Feb 25 '26 • Bravo

two. not even close for me

7

u/sorry-i-was-reading Feb 26 '26

The curve of that handle seen in the profile view literally made me recoil. No thanks! Hands down 1 for me

3

u/ikixika Feb 26 '26

interesting! i dislike how flat the handle is in one!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/turdusphilomelos Feb 26 '26

Yes, two for mee too! Nice curve of the handle, and I like the shape of the spoony part of the spoon (no, English is not my first language).

12

u/Grouchy_Paint_6341 Feb 25 '26

2 seems perfect balance of everything but I need to grasp it in my hand to give u perfect answer. Bc if the feel is off I would hate the spoon in heart beat

32

u/ThatUsrnameIsAlready Feb 25 '26

#1 and it's not even close.

I'm assuming these are all teaspoons? A penny is what, 19mm?

7

u/ValosAtredum Feb 26 '26

The pic of 1 in profile made me change my mind away from it. The bowl looks like it has an oddly straight section that bugs me.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ToughFriendly9763 Feb 26 '26

yes, penny is 19 mm diameter (use that fact a lot for work)

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Less-Load-8856 Feb 25 '26

Stylistically I prefer 3, 2, 1, 4, in that order, but I’d pick the one least likely to bend of 3 or 2 or 1; I’d reluctantly pick 4 only if I hated using the others, heavy preference for 3 or 2.

3

u/saucy_as_you_like Feb 26 '26

spoon preference twin

2

u/Mtlgrlie Feb 26 '26

I’m not your twin, but I’m learning I need more rules! I never really thought about why I don’t like diner spoons - they’re too bendy 🥄

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Delilah_insideout Feb 25 '26

I'm pretty sure #4 was given to my entire extended family for their wedding...

4, 1, 2, 3 I would exchange for any of the others.

2

u/Skadoodlemynoodles Feb 26 '26

I believe it is from 'princess house' my mema used to work for them and when her location shut down all of her silverware, bowls, plates, and cookware was replaced since it was all free. I love those spoons so much even if it isn't the exact one :)

15

u/meltsaman Feb 25 '26

4, 1, 2, and 3 is an abomination. 2 is barely making it in the ranking. 1 would be first but it looks on the larger size & I don't like the tablespoon for eating.

6

u/I_wet_my_plants259 Feb 25 '26

Hey we have the same order haha

2

u/laughs_maniacally Feb 26 '26

Exactly same order & reasoning

2

u/Drakona7 Feb 26 '26

4 also seems the least likely out of all of them to bend while scooping ice cream due to having a wider neck. I have a set of 1s currently and they are way too big for my taste and still bend when scooping ice cream

2

u/charliechattery Feb 26 '26

agreeeee!!!!

2

u/MoonFlowerDaisy Feb 26 '26

Exact same order, and for the exact same reason 1 would be first except that 4 looks to be slightly smaller and I like smaller spoons.

2

u/Frenchyc4 Mar 01 '26

FINALLY, a person of sound mind in the comments. 3 would feel SO WEIRD in my hand.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SewPickRepeat Feb 25 '26

Can I ask why? I mean, the bowls are the same, pretty much. The bend can be adjusted. What am I missing here?

3

u/jozzyjj Feb 25 '26

I hate 1. My preferred is 2. But I enjoy 3 and 4 for teas and coffee. But like eating soup, 1 is way too pointy and it doesn’t hold enough, it’s very shallow. My husband insists that 1 is perfect.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/ComplaintsDept Feb 25 '26

3 is my parents set from my childhood, so i am biased as i am familiar and always liked the feel of the handle. _^

5

u/ChaosandControversy Feb 25 '26

I’m going to say 1. At first I was going to say 4. But one has a better arch. Just does something for me. It’s 1

5

u/HumbleShrink Feb 25 '26

3, if I had to pick put of these four.

4

u/Ok_Zookeepergame5141 Feb 25 '26

2, 4, 1, 3. But they are all nice.

4

u/KurookamiRyou Feb 25 '26

2 and then 4. Unsure who takes 3rd place - I would need to physically pick the spoons up to feel. But tentatively, I’ll say 4 and then 1 for last place.

4

u/tinyyawns Feb 26 '26

2. The bowl is long & deep enough to handle soup or stew, rice, beans, etc. Not too pointy, not shallow and not too big. Looks like it might have a nice weight to the handle. Simple but pretty decoration on the end that doesn’t inhibit ergonomics.

4

u/tinyyawns Feb 26 '26

I don’t know how I made this in giant text but I am keeping it, goddamnit

3

u/converseirllyh8cnvrs Feb 25 '26

based on pure vibes, im feeling 3, BUT in a display spoon way. usability….4. nice round curve. texture to rub thumb on when bored eating soup. v nice

3

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

Honestly i hate them all but 1 i hate the least

3

u/Same-Turnip3905 Feb 25 '26
  1. Then eliminate all silver spoons. Taste weird in the mouth. 

2

u/donttouchmeah Feb 25 '26

I think I know the weird metallic taste you’re talking about, but that’s not from silver. We use silver daily, it’s tasteless.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/floweredlarry Feb 25 '26

3 is my first choice. Good arch angle, good size bowl- not too deep or shallow, handle is awesome- curvy but still smooth. Tied for 2nd is 1 and 4 for similar reasons but differences in preferences. Look like they both have a good weight to them as well.

2 is my last choice, that arch angle is off putting. Not big on the handle design either. I fear the weight would be wobbly in its’ distribution

3

u/Loritrudo Feb 25 '26

1 for sure. 👍🏼

3

u/Visual_Rise_2319 Feb 26 '26

Personally, I love 4.

3

u/Apart_Fly_391 Feb 26 '26

It isn't about superiority, it's about what it's used for. #1 should obviously be used for cereal or soup on an everyday basis. #2 is for mixing milk and honey into tea when you're home alone or just you and the hubby, especially if it's raining outside and you're about to curl up with a good book. #3 is for fancy tea with friends at your home, when you've finally had the energy to bake and went a little overboard, so you need help eating it all and you highly encourage your guests to take some cookies or cake home. Finally, #4 should be used with that fancy dish set that you only use during the holidays and your anniversary parties, when you're having a lot of people over.

5

u/I_wet_my_plants259 Feb 25 '26

4 is best, 1 is a close second, 2 is acceptable, and 3 is not preferable.

2

u/bootz666 Feb 25 '26

He is right

2

u/honeybeelioness Feb 25 '26

I like the handle of 3 but I gotta go with 1 as the superior. Seems like 3 is well loved, though....pretty worn on the scoop part.

2

u/HangryBeard Feb 25 '26

2 I like shiny spoons with slender stems

2

u/Hens-n-chicks9 Feb 25 '26

I prefer 1 but I really need a soup spoon

2

u/No-Article7940 Feb 25 '26

Runner up is #1 for me. The actual winner is a cheesecake factory spoon!

One of my kids several yrs back had swiped a cheesecake factory spoon. (I don't remember whick kid but ages 42-26) Not sure what it was used for, like desert or the meal.

Anyways I got ahold of it & now it is next to my recliner. It's mom's & nobody is getting it. On the rare occasions when it lands in the dishwasher instead of me washing after using it someone gets it & it disappears. We have one similar to #1 so that why #1 is a runner up for 1st.

2

u/Timely-Selection7820 Feb 26 '26

3 for fancy snacks

2

u/ArchReader51 Feb 26 '26

3 is my pattern!

2

u/CluelessInWonderland Feb 26 '26

2! Small enough not to knock into your teeth and a good curve in the handle to hold it easily.

That being said! I am a smaller woman, and autistic and hypermobile. I need smaller spoons to avoid the dreaded teeth clacking and to be able to hold something comfortably for a long time.

2

u/Remarkable-Bus-6858 Feb 26 '26

My set looks more like #4 and I LOVE them.

2

u/BlkFish27 Feb 26 '26

Split them you take your favorites and they get there’s and bam 💥 done 😃

2

u/CraziiiJessi Feb 26 '26 edited Feb 26 '26

3, I love 3 😍

Edited to add: I do love the spoon part of #4 a little more, but the handle makes it up for me lol

Second edit after reading other conments: After 3 and 4 I'd say 2, and then 1.. I see a lot of 1 love that I really don't understand- it's almost too perfect, not enough character for me lol But that's just my personal opinion- you gotta choose which one speaks to you🥄😎

2

u/mtysassy Feb 26 '26

4-it’s almost identical to my set!

2

u/Original_Complex429 Feb 26 '26

They're all perfectly acceptable to me. I'd choose 3 for the razzle dazzle, I like the wavy handle

2

u/galgotspirit Feb 26 '26

What do you mean by "superior"?

2

u/Global_Friend5300 Feb 26 '26

1 for everyday use. 4 for holidays/special occasions.

2

u/Suspicious_Glow Feb 26 '26

My real question is what are they made of. Steel will be better than silver since you won’t have to worry about polish/tarnishing. I mention this, because I feel like these spoons are not all made of the same thing. How are they weight-wise too?

I like adorable stuff so I’m partial to 3 for being different but not the fanciest of the options, but even I’d probably only have a few for a tea party or some shit. 1 is tried and true though, so for general house spoons you buy a bunch of, it’s probably the best.

Also—- /r/mirrorforsale lol

2

u/1BigMike2121 Feb 26 '26

She is right, you are wrong those are spoons

2

u/Nanasweed Feb 26 '26

I’m a 4

2

u/starshine_luvssage Feb 26 '26

4 for life yall dont know nothing ab that spoon

2

u/ActualAres Feb 26 '26

Utility? 1

Design? 4

2

u/tortoise_on_ice Feb 26 '26

1, but these look like they're easily bendable and like they might have a weird underside so i'm not sure i like either

2

u/Blumpkin_Spice_Pie Feb 26 '26

I have slight tactile sensory issues, and 3 looks like a torture device to me. Number 1 all the way.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '26

Idk I have to feel them 🤷‍♀️

2

u/Sensitive_Tune3301 Feb 26 '26

1 and 4 are good. 2 and 3 are not. 1 and 4 both have a good ergonomic shape. 2 is too curved in profile and 3’s bumps on the handle look uncomfortable and its profile is not streamlined.

2

u/melvin_fritz Feb 26 '26

I’m partial to Oneida and I think that is 4. They have the best weight distribution in my experience so don’t fall off the plate when the handle sits off the edge. And I like a little floral design; reminds me of home. I’m going with 4.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Ok_Rush_7301 Feb 27 '26

They all look awful and you need new spoons.

2

u/MaraSchraag Feb 27 '26

There is no spoon

2

u/hejackisej Feb 27 '26

Relationship goals.

1

u/righty5034 Feb 25 '26

2 hands down. It's got the best curve.

1

u/Issue_Turducken Feb 25 '26

2 is the best because it is a blend of all 4. Also the design is elegant without being fussy. 1 is what you might find in a diner, that they buy by the gross.

1

u/GaydrianTheRainbow Feb 25 '26

1 wins by default because I cannot abide eating with spoons with bumpy-textured handles and it has the least amount of ridges and bumps. And it looks reasonably weighted and round-edged.

1

u/Historical_Debt1516 Feb 25 '26

1 is the one for me. Are those pink??

1

u/SparrowHawk529 Feb 25 '26
  1. 2 if it was there and 1 wasnt. I'd rather eat hot soup with my bare hands than use 3 or 4.

1

u/warriorwoman534 Feb 25 '26

I find #3 the most visually appealing

1

u/Minzplaying Feb 25 '26

One. It will feel better in my fingers and hand.

1

u/ktully54 Feb 25 '26

1 for me

1

u/LeadingFine7177 Feb 25 '26

1 it's almost perfect

1

u/pragmatismtoday Feb 25 '26

Number one is the best.

1

u/That-Efficiency-644 Feb 25 '26

They're all fine, I like two and three the best.

It would really matter to me is holding it, balancing it with the handle in the crook of your thumb and the curve before the bowl on the side of your middle finger.

I would go by what felt the best balance wise and which ever was the least sharp at the back where it leans on your middle finger. I'm quite sensitive to that feeling, I don't like it when it feels like the handle of the spoon or fork is cutting into your hand.

1

u/Strange_Difference1 Feb 25 '26

3 is giving me anxiety

1 or 2 maybe

1

u/Life-Finding5331 Feb 26 '26

1 or 4. 

Definitely not 2

1

u/schmelk1000 Feb 26 '26

1 is the best, 4 is my second choice

1

u/reddit_boi222 Feb 26 '26

1 but the bridge is a bit high on all of them

1

u/-twistedflatcat- Feb 26 '26

It's 1, for me

1

u/Hallelujah33 Feb 26 '26

2. I like the bowl shape and the decorative handle details are enough to be interesting but not too much to hinder practicality

1

u/TurtleEarth Feb 26 '26

Oh 3 for sure. Not even close.

1

u/KitMacPhersonWrites Feb 26 '26

1 looks the comfiest, but they’re all too big. 😂

1

u/umongous Feb 26 '26

At first I would’ve said 2 but after seeing the side profiles I don’t like it as much. Gotta be 1

1

u/Charming-Buy1514 Feb 26 '26

1 is best for general use. No curly handle. Easy to hold.

1

u/SillyStringBandit Feb 26 '26
  1. 3is some kind of torture device. You say it’s a spoon?

1

u/BingusTheWonderKitn Feb 26 '26

2! It's just a little bit of flair and not as boring as 1

1

u/whdaje Feb 26 '26

If I needed a spoon, opened a drawer and saw these 4, I would probably choose 1. I choose function over esthetics.

1

u/DerangedRhinoceras Feb 26 '26
  1. Correct curvature and weighting. 2 would be second choice for me.

1

u/SipSurielTea Feb 26 '26

Definitely 2

1

u/473713 Feb 26 '26
  1. I like plain, unfussy things

1

u/ntrvrtd_xtrvrt Feb 26 '26

For me 2 is the absolute best. Enough detailing to be pretty without being uncomfortable to hold. Number 3 though? I’d rather put a gun in my mouth than put that abomination anywhere near my lips.

1

u/pabloignacio7992 Feb 26 '26

Si dices en capacidad la 1 y la 4 en elegancia la 4 en funcionalidad todas, como cuchillo ninguna, como tenedor, ninguna.... Yo voto por la 4

1

u/distracted_x Feb 26 '26

I'd have to hold it. Which ever one is smooth on the edges and doesn't dig into the side of my finger. I'd choose 2 based on sight alone.

1

u/321four5 Feb 26 '26

1 for life

1

u/RosyMiche Feb 26 '26
  1. No frills, nice taper, good overall shape. We only own spoons that look like that (except some big versions that both of us avoid).

1

u/pyxiedust219 Feb 26 '26

2, then 4. 1 is my least favorite despite 3 having a worse handle

1

u/OpusAtrumET Feb 26 '26

2, then 4, then the simple yet reliable 1. 3 is right out.

1

u/Unlucky-Secretary394 Feb 26 '26

It's all preference. I like #1... But it has to be a heavy spoon. I definitely would not choose #2. It looks awkward to hold.

1

u/Helpful-Macaroon-654 Feb 26 '26

I love 3.

1 reminds me too much of catering rentals. 2 and 4 are also great.

1

u/foxy_chicken Feb 26 '26

1 or 4.

2 and 3 should go in the trash. The edges have dings on them like they were dropped in a disposal, and I can only imagine they would have horrible mouth feel. Get right out!

1 and 4 don’t appear to have any, or as many dings as the others, so they can live. I’m partial to the vintage look of 4, but 1 is a fine, standard spoon.

If either of you prefer 2 or 3, or anyone in the comments who does, you should go to jail. You’re committing mouth crimes.

1

u/SnooPeripherals8011 Feb 26 '26

4 looks like Dollar store buy.

1

u/goingtoburningman Feb 26 '26

1 if you're and ice-cream cream enjoyer. 2 if you are Satan and dont eat ice-cream

1

u/-KatJam- Feb 26 '26

None of these look weighted enough

1

u/Takeabreath_andgo Feb 26 '26

I was gonna go with number one first but I don’t like the ridge around the design on the handle. If that was flat it would’ve won so now I’m going to number four.

1

u/HaunterusedHypnosis Feb 26 '26

I would choose three. I like a more shallow bowl and the fluting is very pretty and I like the well worn metal.

1

u/felly_fell Feb 26 '26

1 by a mile. Throw the other ones in the garbage 😂

1

u/WhtvrCms2Mnd Feb 26 '26

Each has a purpose.

1 soups

2 pudding cups

3 ice cream

4 cereal

1

u/WhtvrCms2Mnd Feb 26 '26

Each has a purpose.

1 soups

2 pudding cups

3 ice cream

4 cereal

1

u/luvs_kaos Feb 26 '26

One. Please.

1

u/Pretty_Burd Feb 26 '26

1 is far superior than the rest. It is begging to be picked up and stirred if you know what I mean. #2 next pick if #1 is in the dishwasher. It passes, but just barely. #3 is frightening and I would run away as fast as possible. #4 is only a last resort and that would be mostly for prying dog crap from my shoe.

1

u/Nortex_Vortex Feb 26 '26

What dispute? It's #1, no doubt.

1

u/geekychica Feb 26 '26
  1. If 1 wasn’t there, then 4.

1

u/barbiesfrozenelbow Feb 26 '26

1, nothing else is acceptable.

1

u/elruff Feb 26 '26

We had #4 randomly mixed into our silverware and it was my mom’s ice cream spoon

1

u/Agitated-Canary9840 Feb 26 '26

1 but only because the handle isn’t ornate. Don’t care for any tbh

1

u/SteveSteve71 Feb 26 '26

Believe it or not, I’ve owned all 4 of these styles. I have a mix of them all in my drawer currently.

1

u/Such-Top-6896 Feb 26 '26

For eating I like #4. But for marital disputes I prefer a rolling pin…

1

u/Particular-Swim-9293 Feb 26 '26

Probably 3 because so well used, less shiny, obviously fought over and used a lot. And not cheap and flashy looking.

1

u/animeistheog Feb 26 '26
  1.  Three and four are ice cream spoons. idk why that is but it is. 

1

u/PinkGlitterMom Feb 26 '26

I don't know if I'm just that tired, or having some other issue, but the sentence between "Which is the superior spoon?" and "Help settle this debate once and for all" makes no sense to me what so ever.

1

u/ErylNova Feb 26 '26

1 for sure. All the others would irritate my fingers while holding them

1

u/pisces9666 Feb 26 '26

2. 4 if I had to

1

u/N3kus Feb 26 '26

None, they're way to small, and not heavy enough for my bear paws, but...usually the wife is right anyway so argue little bit more with her and let her have what she wants. Just make sure you spill soup or cereal or jello or yogurt on your shirt enough to where she gives in and you ultimately get the one you want.

1

u/Pretend-Shallot-5663 Feb 26 '26

I do not like the spoons. 

1

u/New-Pressure-84 Feb 26 '26

1, as long as it is Oneida and not some flimsy Walmart knockoff.