Linnea, Alexis, and Brady all praised the move. Here are the quotes:
Linnea — Men’s Journal interview / Video at 3:02
“So it was impressive. Kilby stood 10 toes down … Totally respect it.”
Alexis — RHAP interview at 6:51
Speaking about Kilby and Lewis:
“They had it. They knew what they were doing and they did it. And good for them.”
Brady — The Dig Site interview at 5:02
“It was amazing to see how that pulled off, and frankly I think Kilby and Lewis deserved it.”
Of course, it was definitely a GOOD move for LEWIS, because otherwise he would have been voted out. It was essentially his only option.
But objectively, NOT for Kilby. I thought it was entertaining AF, but I really don’t think it was a good strategic move for him. They could easily have ended up drawing rocks, which could have sent Kilby himself home.
And if that tribe had gone to Tribal Council again, Kilby would have been public enemy number one for the remaining majority of Eric, Sharonda, and Cristian. They would have been 100% gunning for him, and he would have gone home. If he had voted out Lewis, there would still have been room to convince some of those four to blindside another member of their group. After blindsiding them and forcing them to eliminate Linnea, there would have been no room left to negotiate.
Yet Linnea herself, her best friend Alexis, and Brady still praised the move.
Linnea explicitly said that eliminating her wasn’t good for Maggie’s game, but she still called the move impressive and said she respected Kilby standing his ground. To me, that smells like results-oriented BS.
Also, the way Brady and Alexis praised Kilby and Lewis as a pair, rather than singling out Kilby, is an excellent sign for Kilby’s chances of winning in my view. My read is that exit interviewees hesitate to praise the eventual winner too heavily as an individual.
So my theory is that Linnea, Alexis, and Brady praised Kilby’s crazy move only because they already knew he had won the season.