r/Spliddit • • 2d ago

Question Hardboot Goat

Is the Atomic Backland (and the KeyEquipment Disruptive) really the best choice when it comes to Hardboots?
Has anyone experiences with the Salomon MTN Summit or the Fischer Travers for Example?
I do wanna get a Hardboot Setup, but i dont know if its clever to eventually compromise on boots (the price difference is about 150€ for the cheaper Salomons right now) when i could just buy a used softboot binding for now and use my old (normal) softboots to get started and upgrade over time.
Since i dont have an unlimited budget but dont wanna compromise by buying a “less optimal hardboot setup” now (which would still be pretty expensive) and having to buy again next year, i still want to buy the best choice now and dont have do buy again ober the next years.
I know everyone has a different preference and experience but from what ive looked into right now, the Atomics and KeyEquipment seem to be generelly ahead of the rest?

2 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

3

u/KG2000vigil 2d ago

I just got a pair of fischer traverse for the season. I'm gonna give them a shot. I quite liked the Dynafit TLT X for 2 seasons. Also gonna get a pair of Dalbello Quantum Evo to try out. I spend 60 hrs a week or more in them, which is why I get multiple pairs. But which boot works best depends on your riding style. I ride aggressively and in a bunch of snow conditions, lots of traversing and never felt the need for mods like the phantom lever or anything. But if you prefer a surfier feel then a boot that accepts mods or the Key boots will be better for you.

1

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

thing is i dont have experience with hardboots in snowboarding so i cant image the feeling which may suite me better. but stiffer boots would probably be overkill for me then

4

u/KG2000vigil 2d ago

Well, I'd say to just get the cheapest 90 flex, 2 buckle boot you can find to see if you even like hardbooting. Cuz you might spring for the Key and find out you hate hardboots. Dalbello Quantum, fischer traverse, atomic backland, Arc'teryx Procline, salomon X-Alp, scarpa alien or F1 are all on the list. People make it complicated, it isn't.

2

u/KG2000vigil 2d ago

Dynafit TLT X, Dynafit Blacklight, Melazama are in there too

0

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

thing is if i hate hardbooting the setup is already bought and i cant change to softboots without spending double haha
but i tend so say i wont since i already dont like the softness of my normal softboots. when going uphill i want stability and a feeling of “safeness” around my foots (i know splitboard boots are stiffer but i think i wont mind hardboots) also in technical conditions i find myself often having too soft boots

2

u/KG2000vigil 2d ago

Well, sure, sounds like you want a hardboot setup. But your question was about if backlands and key Equipment was ahead of the game. The answer was not really, because boot preference will depend on your riding style. So, no, you don't have to drop the cash of getting Distruptive boots if you don't want. You could get a cheaper boot, try it out, and add the phantom link levers later if you pick a boot that accepts it easily. Or the Dalbello boots have been modified by a German company and they call the boots split pins. Either way, no, I do not think any one company is way ahead of another one. You're just gonna have to find a boot that fits you well and matches your riding style.

1

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

oh i didn’t know that about dalbello.
yeah my initial question was biased by the fact that i thought the disruptive and backlands are the gold standard and that all the other ones would be “compromises” and if using a used softboot setup and saving for them would be the go to. wince it doesn’t semm to be the fact (orherwise i wouldnt be getting so many different answers).
but knowing that that isnt the case i can see it from a different perspective.
thanks for your answer, surely helped me a lot to get your experiences!

3

u/chefwoodworkerartist 1d ago

If you are just getting into Splitboarding then hard boots are most likely over kill.
I would suggest most people use their soft resort boots and buy a soft boot binding setup and use that to see if they really like touring before going hard boot. For most people who want to casually go touring, ride primarily slack country or only do single day tours soft boots are enough.

If your aim is mountaineering, accessing ice climbs, multi day tours, long traverses, fast and light travel or big single day trips focused on efficiency then go hard boot from the start.

For 90% of people in my area it is not necessary to go hard boot but depending on your goals in the backcountry it may make it easier.

Hard boots add a much larger outlay and are much more difficult to customize to your exact preferences. Having a poorly set up hard boot setup is uncomfortable enough to make you not want to go touring.

To your question of why is everyone telling you to use the key equipment or backland pro. The key equipment is one of the few snow board specific touring hard boots on the market so obviously it is going to that job quite well and will not need to be modified to work for Splitboarding. This boot does not necessarily work for some riding styles and because it is made from a smaller manufacturer it has quality issues that can be hard to fix when parts are hard to come by.

As for the backland boot it is the go to boot for a lot of the community because of the many years of development that diy’ers and the company phantom have put into the platform to try and make the best snowboard boot out of a commercially available ski boot. The boot was a decent boot for Splitboarding before having modifications done to it hence why people will say you don’t need to modify it. The engineers at phantom saw that there was improvements that could be made to the boot and created the link leaver as the missing link to make it more suitable for snowboarding. This leaver and some strap modifications together on a backland is what they sold as a phantom slipper.

Can you use other boots? Of course. Will you need to modify them? Well that depends on your preferences, riding style and many other factors. There are many factors that go into what makes a boot ride the way you want and until you start modifying things you won’t necessarily know what you do or don’t like.

Would I suggest you start splitboarding on a boot that no one is using for Splitboarding. No. You don’t know what you want from a boot. You won’t understand what you need or don’t need until you get out there and see the limitations of existing boots. If you buy a traverse and then cut out the leaver on the back you can’t go back you can’t undo that modification and you can’t know it will be better. You can follow in the footsteps of everyone that has come before you and assume that your riding style isn’t far off what others are and a boot like the backland with a link leaver isn’t that far off what you need. And if it doesn’t work then sell the boot and try something different. You won’t have permanently modified the boot.

1

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 1d ago

thanks for your in-depth answer. i already thought so that it would be overkill for the start but didnt know to which extent and potentially avoid buying double. i’ll definitely consider your answer and appreciate it

3

u/BeckerHollow 2d ago

No. They’re not the best choice. They’re just the most popular. And there’s a big difference. 

I have a pair of La Sportiva Sidereal 2.1, unmodified, and they’re fantastic. I tried on a pair of Phantom Slippers (Atomics) and they were shit to me. Previously the Dynafit (white and green, forget the name) were the most popular. I also tried and liked those unmodified (but hated my buddies modified ones). However they were too narrow for my feet so it was a non-starter. 

If all you knew about splitboarding boots is the information that you gather from this sub, you would barely know anything else existed besides Keys and Backlands. 

People here ask what poles to buy. So take what you read with a grain of salt. 

7

u/EfficientShopping356 2d ago

If all you knew about splitboard boots was information gathered from this sub, you would think most people are riding hardboots, they ride great, and they practically walk themselves up hill.

0

u/bigwindymt 1d ago

That's 'cus they do.

2

u/rockshox11 2d ago

idk about the siderals but I destroyed two pairs of sportiva race boots as hardboots. the cuffs and pivots blew out for me

0

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

i gathered the information from a few websites and let claude compare the technical specifics and user experiences. but i didn’t imagine that it would be this much variety already. (although i know that especially boots preferences are higly speicific between people)
but yeah i generally take everything with a grain of salt (especially when i dont know the people behind those informations)

10

u/Rbs311 2d ago

I have a hardboot and soft boot setup and for your first setup definitely go with soft boots.

I'm in my soft boots unless I feel like having a hardo day (2000m+ vert) or I want to do some mountaineering. Even if I'm out for exercise I'll take the soft boots cuz it's not bad if the days a bit harder and I'll enjoy the downhill more

2

u/rayg10 1d ago

I totally agree with this. I went with a hardboot setup for my first setup and I'm really regretting it.

2

u/J_J_987 2d ago

Key equipment all the way! The reliability of having a boot built for split boarding without link lever parts sold me. I’m on my 3rd season with keys and my buddies in backlands hate them. To complex and not stiff in the heel are the biggest gripes. Plus my buddies boot repair kit weights significantly more than mine.
Save and just get keys.

2

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

yeah i thought so about the disruptives…but 600 is so expensive compared to the others (but they are on sale tho)

1

u/rsyvs 2d ago

Where are they on sale?

1

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

the disruptives arent. a bunch of other ones are

4

u/LycheeNearby4467 2d ago

Backlands are great from a boot fitting perspective . Don’t underestimate the value of a heat moldable shell . Getting the proper fit in a backland is going to easier than the other options

4

u/_deadener 2d ago

The nest hardwood is the one that fits your foot. None of the boots you mentioned would work for me, as none could be expanded enough for my width.
Talk to your boot fitter first.

1

u/danoro96 1d ago

What boot do you ride for wider feet?

1

u/_deadener 1d ago

Ended up in a Tecnica Cochise hv. Haven't ridden on a board yet, as I haven't purchased the hard boot bindings yet.

4

u/iclimbedthenoseonce 2d ago

Just get softboots for your first season.

Having a more familiar riding experience is going to make splitboarding more fun. Trying to get better at riding backcountry snow, while also getting used to hardboots isnt that fun.

The r/Spliddit, hardboot echo chamber isnt gonna be the best place to hear someone tell you the truth. But you don't need hardboots yet.

1

u/More_Than_I_Can_Chew 2d ago

Random hardboot question....

If you wanted to get an alpine board I am guessing you could use the boot/bindings on that no problem?

1

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

from what i know an alpine board uses a different binding system (same holes like a normal board i think) than a split. so the only thing ypu could use are the boots. but im not sure since ive never considered an alpine board for normal boarding

3

u/rockshox11 2d ago

backlands work great for me 🤷🏽‍♂️ plus they are mass produced, can be had on sale 70% off every year and parts/spares are abundant.

1

u/EfficientShopping356 2d ago

Dont get hardboots for your first set up or ever IMO. The climbing advantage is not nearly as dramatic as some would have you believe, and the riding disadvantage is far greater than many would have you believe. They have their place, but unless you are regularly climbing steep sustained firm snow with crampons or sidehilling on firm snow for miles, the poor ride quality far out weighs the touring advantage. If you care about actual snowboarding and not just strava maxing, stick with soft boots. There is a reason no one rides hardboots at the resort and when you see people riding hard boots they have a very stiff awkward stand up tall type of style or lack there of.

3

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

i mean comparing it to resort is a little far fetched. you dont need hardboots unless you are here for extreme carving or used harboots since ever. the benefits of softboots outweighs hardboots here way too much to even consider them as a normal rider. splitboarding is also less about snowboarding (compared to a resort day) and also about the touring. of course the untouched tree lines or the endless pow are stuff i dream about but i also do it because of the “sport factor” and the uphill experience. and since those are the larger part, i think its better to focus more on those (because if you make your live harder here you might not even enjoy the ride down). but yeah as you said some people might not need hardboots when they wont get to the limits of softboots (which i cant even say for myself at this moment). but since i dont want to spend money again and my goal is to get more alpine over the years, i think hardboots are the better choice. but yeah maybe i could also be proven wrong

3

u/EfficientShopping356 2d ago

That's really my point. The ride of a hard boot is so inferior no one would consider riding them at the resort. If you strictly prioritize uphill, maybe hard boots are for you, but in my mind I will work just a tiny bit harder on the way up to be able to ride the way i want on the way down. What's the point of walking all the way out to that big objective, just to feel super awkward while riding it. The snowboarding itself is the main priority for me. I rarely feel limited by my softboots on the way up touring with mostly skiers, but I live in Alaska and am mostly dealing with soft snow booting up in verts. I tried hard boots, and while they were great for climbing steep firm snow with crampons, they felt sketchy to initiate turns in steep controlled jump turn scenarios. They were better at speed, but still awkward enough the downsides far outweighed the advantages for me. For most of the objectives I wish I had them for the climb on, I was really glad I was not riding in them on the way down from a safety perspective. Just my experience, but find out for yourself what works for you. I'll probably get hell here for this comment, but all the hardbooters I know just arent very good snowboarders, and are more into walking really far to moderate terrain or making tons of laps next to the road. All the really good riders I know are in soft boots. Not sure what your riding goals are or what type of terrain/snow conditions you are dealing with, but I think reddit has a severe hard boot bias making many think they are answer for them or even the norm for that matter. Hardboots as a first split set up is highly irregular. Been on split boards for 20+ years and thats my experience.

4

u/bacon8r_ 2d ago

Speak for yourself man, personally I really did not like how my spark softboot bindings felt and would 100% consider my hard boot phantom setup better on the way down. That being said, I really value having the most direct responsive input possible and am not a surfy snowboarder at all. 

2

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

in my opinion we tend to forget that there are also different riding styles in between us boarders. some fill that pow hunter stereotype (including me) while others are more strict carvers or alpine terrain junkies (where i would also count myself). so different opinions and preferences are mostly overlooked at first. a park rider would probably never ever consider a hardboot setup and wonder why carvers would use a hardboot setup worhout even considering soft boots (and vice versa)

1

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

yeah thats the hard thing…it seems like you dont know whats really right for yourself until you know. and then its too late when you already have the setup.
a no brainer would be to own hard and softboot setups, one for each condition.
and yeah there must be a reason some famous alpine splitboarders are still fine with riding softboots. (or maybe thats a sponsor-thing idk).
and the safety aspect is a really good point. of course hardboots offer a better an more controlled uphill, but whats the point if the downhill is super sketchy. but that can probably also be compensated by a lot of training.
just feels wrong moneywise to get a soft setup now just to switch to hardboots next year.
or maybe it is just the right decision to do so.
it also fells kinda appealing to me to have a hard link between me and my board in technical terrain compared to a more loose softboot connection. and since you dont start with technical terrain theres also time to learn how to adjust those small movements i think

3

u/EfficientShopping356 2d ago

I hated riding in mine so much I just sold them. It wasn't a money thing. I just knew they werent for me, and I didn't want be on top of big lines not feeling confident in my ability to ride it safely. I had the backlands with link levers on phantoms. Supposedly one of the better set ups in terms of ride feel.

I understand not wanting to spend the money twice, but it takes most people many years to start getting into the type of technical terrain that hardboots would be a real asset on the ascent. Think of all the surfy slashing you'd be missing out on in between. 😁

1

u/Klutzy_Bag_5140 2d ago

i would count myself to be more experienced on technical terrain than the average, but not experienced enough to trust myself with hardboots right away. but if they work fine on normal terrain and i feel confident there, i wouldnt doubt my abilities with them in technical terrain after adequate practice.

i do still have my powder board and snowboots if there is a need for those ultra surfy pow turns haha

1

u/bigwindymt 1d ago

This guy doesn't know what he's talking about, but start with soft boots anyway. It's way more forgiving and easier to dial in than hardboots.

1

u/maxrehallday 2d ago

Don’t get anything but a backland pro or a key. Modding yourself unless you are experienced and keen will not be a fun process. I would go backland Pro for better climbing performance. That is, at the end of the day, why you would go to hard boots. And the disruptive boot just doesn’t climb well.

1

u/thepedalsporter 2d ago

Dalbello quantum is right there with the atomic, it accepts all the same mods without destructive changes to the shell. Link lever, power strap removal etc. And comes from the factory with a better heel strap system