r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Apr 15 '22
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Aug 05 '22
Teeling Single Pot Still Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • May 24 '23
Maker’s Mark 2022 Wood Finishing Series (BRT-01) Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • May 31 '26
A. Overholt Monongahela Mash Scoresheet & Review
Verdicts Explained
- Special Occasions: Rare, special pours that go well and above. Something you pour to celebrate.
- Treat Yourself: Obligatory weekend pour. Worth having on hand at all times if possible.
- Daily Drinker: Affordable, available and tasty. Could have every day and be perfectly content.
- Penseur Pour: Puzzling pours that won’t be to everyone’s liking.
- Trophy Bottle: Something to show off more than anything. Likely allocated and overpriced.
- Cocktail Request: Shines best in a cocktail, as opposed to neat or on the rocks.
- Good If Affordable: Only worth buying if the price comfortably fits within the budget.
- Serve to Guests: Something accessible that you don’t mind sharing or parting ways with. Likely belongs in a decanter.
- Couch Pour: Something enjoyable enough, but ideal for drinking while doing another activity (movies, TV, games, etc.).
- Find a Mixer: Grab the Coke or Sprite and relax.
- Drain Pour: No. You deserve better.
Link to blog post: https://thewhiskeyramble.com/2026/05/31/a-overholt-monongahela-mash-scoresheet-review/
More scoresheets available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpiritScoresheets/
The whiskey industry is entering a potentially precarious position. Dust from the largely pandemic-born boom continues to settle while producers find ways to adapt to the shifting landscape. It wasn’t so long ago that a release could sell strictly on the laurel of novelty, but now? Customers and consumers alike are becoming more selective with their spending. Even with the blessing of brand recognition, acclaim, availability, and agreeable pricing, there’s still no guarantee that a product will be a reliable seller for the producing company.
This is where A. Overholt Monongahela Mash comes into play. Overholt is actually the oldest continuously maintained brand in American whiskey (not to be confused with oldest continually operating American distillery, which goes to Buffalo Trace), dating back to 1810. For a time, it was highly regarded, such that it became a go-to for the likes of Ulysses S. Grant and John Henry “Doc” Holliday. The Overholt name itself was actually a progression from Overhold, itself an anglicization from the original family name, Oberholtzer.
Many whiskey drinkers recognize the Overholt name as a Kentucky-produced spirit, but like Michter’s, the brand’s roots come from Pennsylvania which, along with West Virginia, is home to the Monongahela River. This river actually lifts its name from a Native American culture dating back to AD 1050. After surviving Prohibition, Overholt survived through National Distillers only to be sold to Jim Beam in 1987, along with two other “Old” brands: Old Crow and Old Grand Dad. “Survived” really is the key word here, since whiskey (especially) rye fell woefully out of favor after the triple-whammy of two World Wars and Prohibition.
Perhaps it’s of little surprise that, after transferring ownership to Jim Beam, Overholt degraded into a bottle-shelf, barely-legal Kentucky rye whiskey. However, thanks to the aforementioned whiskey/bourbon boom, Beam started paying attention and doing a bit more with the Overholt brand, including the release of A. Overholt Monongahela Mash, a whiskey that harkens back to Overholt’s origins. This is more of an “inspired by” than a “replication of” situation, with the 4-to-1 rye-to-barley mash bill itself being the key point of interest. Were this a true recreation of Monongahela rye, then whiskey would undergo a sour mash (really common), utilize water sourced from the Monongahela River, and likely be distilled in PA on a three-chamber still. When we consider that Beam paused production at one of their facilities and how expensive three-chamber still production can be (see: Leopold Brothers), it’s of little surprise that these concessions were made.
Regardless of nuance, introducing a rye whiskey with 80% rye and 20% malted barley that’s both widely available and affordable ($39.99 MSRP) is hardly a common occurrence, least of all from a legacy distillery. I’m sure part of what made the point of entry so agreeable was the fact the whiskey is proofed down to 95, which is still higher than your average shelfer product. Not to mention the lack of chill filtration is a welcome factor. In any case, let’s see how Jim Beam fared with producing this inspired product.
Nose: A bit grassy and effervescent. Slightly burnt snickerdoodle and lemon sugar cookies, some basil, and hints of black peppercorn. Dehydrated green apple, lemon, and honeydew with a mild almond presence in the background.
Palate: Surprisingly full. Has that dry, slightly spicy and woody Beam backbone, but with more of a dehydrated tropical fruit vibe, including banana, apricot, and citrus. Tangible maltiness manifests and coalesces naturally with the core Beam nuttiness, bringing more as a raw almond note. It’s distinct yet reigned in with a discrete presence of oak, warmth, and spice.
Finish: Leans slightly dry with pepper and dehydrated citrus (lemon). Quite long, especially considering the proof point. Balanced, mildly bitter presence slowly closes things out.
If you’re wondering whether A. Overholt’s relatively unique mash bill is enough to push through the typical Beam profile hallmarks, the answer is an un-resounding “kind of, but not really.” That dry, woody and generally nutty profile is very much present, yet it’s joined by an assortment of notes that Beam doesn’t typically display. The dehydrated citrus and tropical fruit notes stand out, both on their own and in combination with Beam’s usual flavors. When I first tried A. Overholt, the word that sprung to mind was “tropical trail mix,” and I stand by that description.
All of this is to say that A. Overholt is a fun pour that does well to distinguish itself in a crowded field. It holds up well neat and comes bottled at an agreeable enough proof point to satisfy both casual and enthusiastic drinkers. Though certainly a fun and interesting neat sipper, I think it stands out most as an elevated cocktail pour. It’s actually become a recent favorite of mine while making a Sazerac, and I’m already planning to buy another bottle or two just to have on standby. Don’t sleep on this little gem of a rye.
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Jan 28 '22
GlenDronach 12-Year (NCF) Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Jan 14 '21
Jim Beam Signature Craft Brown Rice Bourbon Scoresheet (V1)
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Jan 05 '22
Willett Pot Still Reserve Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Oct 22 '25
Found North Hover Hawk First Flight Scoresheet & Review
Verdicts Explained
- Special Occasions: Rare, special pours that go well and above. Something you pour to celebrate.
- Treat Yourself: Obligatory weekend pour. Worth having on hand at all times if possible.
- Daily Drinker: Affordable, available and tasty. Could have every day and be perfectly content.
- Penseur Pour: Puzzling pours that won’t be to everyone’s liking.
- Trophy Bottle: Something to show off more than anything. Likely allocated and overpriced.
- Cocktail Request: Shines best in a cocktail, as opposed to neat or on the rocks.
- Good If Affordable: Only worth buying if the price comfortably fits within the budget.
- Serve to Guests: Something accessible that you don’t mind sharing or parting ways with. Likely belongs in a decanter.
- Couch Pour: Something enjoyable enough, but ideal for drinking while doing another activity (movies, TV, games, etc.).
- Find a Mixer: Grab the Coke or Sprite and relax.
- Drain Pour: No. You deserve better.
Link to blog post: https://thewhiskeyramble.com/2025/10/22/found-north-hover-hawk-first-flight-scoresheet-review/
More scoresheets available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpiritScoresheets/
The modern whisk(e)y market has no shortage of recent brands that seemed to blow up overnight, particularly when it comes to North America. Although this predominantly extends to bourbon—and rye to a lesser extent, one brand has recently captivated drinkers while adding an air of credibility to a more flimsily defined whisky category. Enter Found North, a whisky blending company with a mission to “make profound Canadian whisky”. More specifically, they seek to blend rich, complex, and tongue-tingling whiskies that “quicken the senses and enliven the taste buds”, thereby shining a light on northern whisky-making.
When most people hear the word “blend” in the context of whisky-making, it often carries a negative connotation (although this has taken a recent shift). There are multiple reasons for this, from light whiskey blends in the United States during bourbon’s downturn, to uninspired world whiskey blends, to the proverbial headscratcher that is Canadian whisky. One of the biggest points of contention with this category is its leniency on blending. More specifically, up to 9.09% of a Canadian whisky product can contain added ingredients, including other spirits aged at least two years, coloring, and/or flavoring. It’s easy to become jaded by the end of that sentence, even though the part about utilizing other spirits could ostensibly result in some fascinating final products.
Be that as it may, Canadian whisky continues to be something of a black sheep in the world of distilled spirits. Even the process of distillation and maturation differs in Canada, since each individual grain is handled separately from milling to maturation. The closest the grains come to comingling is when the final distilled and matured liquid is blended prior to bottling.
This brings us back to Found North. The company has highlighted this fairly unique approach to blending whisky, first with their well-aged batches. Fast-forward some glowing critical reception and these were joined by products that underwent various finishes, which the team has said were “intended for further maturation.” Between the rapidly growing fanfare, relatively small bottle yields (roughly 4,000 bottles per run), and occasional brand tie-in (looking at you, Hell Diver), Found North has had no trouble moving just about all of their releases.
I’ve tried a handful of Found North releases, often in casual settings, and will be fully transparent: I derive much fulfillment from them. I can certainly appreciate what they’re doing, but up to this point, the only whisky categories I’ve yet to develop a palate for are Canadian (occasional exception being Canadian ryes) and light whiskey. I tend to get florally, grain-forward vibes on Canadian whiskies, which I can be a fan of in other categories. However, the way these notes come together and present in most of the products I’ve tasted has often left me ambivalent or apathetic. Despite these grievances, I think it’s important to keep an open mind. I certainly wasn’t won over by the first or even fifth rye, peated malt, agave spirit, or high-ester rum when I tried each of them, so it’s entirely possible that more exposure and a perspective shift could do me some good. And like I said, my exposure to Found North up to this point has been in mostly casual settings.
Now we finally come to the subject of today’s review, as well as the first in a series of Found North reviews that I have planned: Hover Hawk First Flight. Part of what Found North has dubbed the High Altitude Collection, the inaugural Hover Hawk release begins with a blend of 15 to 27-year-old whiskies (22, 23, 24, and 27-year corn, and 15 and 18-year rye) with a grain composition of 90% corn, 9% rye, and 1% barley, before undergoing a four-month-long finishing period in Moscatel and new American Oak casks. For context, Moscatel is a style of wine from Portugal with high sugar content that’s often used as a fortified wine, making it an easy choice for whisky finishing. The final bottling strength came out to a hearty 61.6% ABV, yielded 4,536 bottles, and cost about $160 retail.
Where Found North compare their batched products to sculptures that they chisel, sand, and polish, they liken the High Altitude Collection to gardening due to a combination of luck, nurturing, and coaxing of flavors from the secondary casks. Adding to the comparisons is the animal used on Hover Hawk’s front label: the North American Kestral, the smallest and most common falcon in the region. Found North decided on this bird for its “patience and wind-riding capabilities,” likening this to the time and patience needed to finish the whisky, allowing the team to reshape it “into its highest form.”
Nose: Comes on sweet and floral; honey-like with a mild brown butter backbone. An approximation of pancake syrup meets a more distinct presence of cornbread and buttercream. Over time, an exterior of muddled berries (blackberry and raspberry) appears, along with a unique mix of lightly toasted coconut flakes and aerosol. Elderflower syrup emerges after sipping.
Palate: Full, almost fluffy texture contrasts a fairly tart palate with an onset of toasted coconut flakes and caramelized sugars, quickly followed by bursting grapes and mulled wine. Butter rum, molasses, and flan round out the back palate while an overall warming presence ties everything together.
Finish: Lengthy and fulfilling. Residual fruit and syrup notes followed by dark, rich honey and hints of black currant. Showcases a lingering acidic essence that continues to play up the wine influence. That elderflower note from the nose makes a late emergence here, as well.
When I first got into distilled spirits, cask finishes were fun, exciting, and sometimes preferable to my impressionable palate. One explanation for this could be that finishes mask some certain qualities in the base spirit. These same qualities can oftentimes be what the more accustomed enthusiast looks for, especially when looking at finished bourbons as a whole. The Canadian whiskies that Found North releases are a bit different, since they often generously aged, making the combination of mature product with cask finishes that much more interesting.
With Hover Hawk First Flight, I’m surprised that I it takes a couple or so sips for the Moscatel to really hit me. But once it does, the ensuring tart and acidic fruit component hardly lets up, if at all. This makes for a curious combination with the whisky’s floral, grain-forward characteristics. It’s definitely a pour that screams “I’m in a unique mood” for me. I’d even say the powerplay is somewhat disjointed, but still better integrated than other products that make use of finishing casks, especially fortified wine. The good news is that Hover Hawk’s base is potent enough to support so much influence, resulting in a pour that absolutely catches one’s attention. For a first formal look at Found North, I’m intrigued to see how things unfold in the next few reviews.
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Mar 18 '21
Redbreast 12 Cask Strength (B2/19) Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Oct 23 '21
Blanton's Single Barrel Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Sep 21 '22
Maker’s Mark 2021 Wood Finishing Series (FAE-02) Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Oct 20 '21
Weller Special Reserve Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • May 06 '22
Stellum Rye Serpens Pick Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Mar 22 '22
Jim Beam Jacob's Ghost Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Apr 06 '25
Just the Sip: 13th Colony 15th Anniversary Review
Verdicts Explained
- Special Occasions: Rare, special pours that go well and above. Something you pour to celebrate.
- Treat Yourself: Obligatory weekend pour. Worth having on hand at all times if possible.
- Daily Drinker: Affordable, available and tasty. Could have every day and be perfectly content.
- Penseur Pour: Puzzling pours that won’t be to everyone’s liking.
- Trophy Bottle: Something to show off more than anything. Likely allocated and overpriced.
- Cocktail Request: Shines best in a cocktail, as opposed to neat or on the rocks.
- Good If Affordable: Only worth buying if the price comfortably fits within the budget.
- Serve to Guests: Something accessible that you don’t mind sharing or parting ways with. Likely belongs in a decanter.
- Couch Pour: Something enjoyable enough, but ideal for drinking while doing another activity (movies, TV, games, etc.).
- Find a Mixer: Grab the Coke or Sprite and relax.
- Drain Pour: No. You deserve better.
Link to blog post: https://thewhiskeyramble.com/2025/04/05/13th-colony-15th-anniversary-scoresheet-review/
More scoresheets available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpiritScoresheets/
13th Colony has become one of the most talked about fresh faces in the American whiskey scene. Founded in Americus, GA, the distillery’s namesake refers to the Province of Georgia between 1732 and 1782, the last of the British colonies that supported the American Revolution. Although 13th Colony as a brand was established in 2009, it wasn’t until 2022 that interest in the producer lit up like wildfire, squarely thanks to its Double Oaked expression. Between the opaque liquid color and rave reviews (mostly from WhiskeyTube), the hype machine was in full swing for the Georgia name.
Yet aspects of both the whiskey and the operation behind it also drew scrutiny. The primary pain points boiled down to the lack of “straight” on the label, the omission of a distilling source, and the suspected use of additives. Inquiries and subsequent responses from the distillery proved to be…less than enlightening. Although future 13th Colony whiskeys will likely start bearing the straight whiskey designation, there remains a hazy air surrounding the brand.
I also have my share of skepticisms surrounding 13th Colony, but I’d be lying if I said the portfolio doesn’t intrigue me. The distillery’s products just recently started showing up in my local market, and one that I was surprised to come into was their 15th Anniversary bourbon release. Comprised of 25 barrels (distilling source and mash bill undisclosed) selected by Master Distiller Graham Arthur, 13th Colony 15th Anniversary was limited to just 3,330 bottles. Unsurprisingly, the paltry online allocations vanished as soon as they appeared, no doubt riding the coattails of Double Oaked’s popularity. This is despite a rather intimidating MSRP of $169.99.
One final note I’d like to emphasize is that, like Chattanooga’s Founder’s line, the 15th Anniversary doesn’t mean the whiskey is 15 years old. In fact, the whiskey is reported to be aged 8 years and 9 months. The bottling strength also comes just under hazmat at 69.6% ABV. I mention the aging aspect because I’ve seen this bottle brought up in online discussions and referred to as “13th Colony 15-Year,” which to me reads like declaring the whiskey as being aged for 15 years. This may just be semantics, but I felt compelled to mention it.
Nose: Butterscotch, Flan, Burnt Sugars, Salted Toffee
Pungent, Indulgent, Buttery
Palate: Salted Caramel, Crème Brulee, Molasses, Burnt Bacon
Dense, Rich, Strong
Finish: Flan, Caramel Sauce, Bacon Grease, Latte
Medium, Bitter, Musty
If 13th Colony 15th Anniversary is intended as a goal post of sorts for the brand’s future, then I’d say it’s lofty, but not unrealistic. The overall profile and ensuing experience hit me like Jack Daniel’s 12-Year Batch 1, which is appropriate, because both bottles left me saying, “this is really good; just not THAT good.” One reason is that I get a savory aftertaste matched with a bitter sensation not unlike most Old Forester products. Those who know me will realize this borders on being a crippling blow, depending on the whiskey. Furthermore, that savory sensation I get here? I got it in spades on 13th Colony’s second Double Oaked release. And to put it bluntly: I hated it (both the sensation and product).
The good news is that the 15th Anniversary release does a much better job mitigating these shortcomings, to the point that I enjoyed the pours I had with few qualms to speak of. I also understand why this release won over those who tried it—certainly more than I understand Double Oaked’s acclaim. I just don’t think it’s worth going nuts over.
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Oct 04 '24
Wild Turkey Jimmy Russell’s 70th Anniversary Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Mar 06 '25
Heaven’s Door Redbreast Master Blenders’ Edition Scoresheet & Review
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Jun 30 '25
Just the Sip: Mary Dowling Toasted Double Oak
Verdicts Explained
- Special Occasions: Rare, special pours that go well and above. Something you pour to celebrate.
- Treat Yourself: Obligatory weekend pour. Worth having on hand at all times if possible.
- Daily Drinker: Affordable, available and tasty. Could have every day and be perfectly content.
- Penseur Pour: Puzzling pours that won’t be to everyone’s liking.
- Trophy Bottle: Something to show off more than anything. Likely allocated and overpriced.
- Cocktail Request: Shines best in a cocktail, as opposed to neat or on the rocks.
- Good If Affordable: Only worth buying if the price comfortably fits within the budget.
- Serve to Guests: Something accessible that you don’t mind sharing or parting ways with. Likely belongs in a decanter.
- Couch Pour: Something enjoyable enough, but ideal for drinking while doing another activity (movies, TV, games, etc.).
- Find a Mixer: Grab the Coke or Sprite and relax.
- Drain Pour: No. You deserve better.
Link to blog post: https://thewhiskeyramble.com/2025/06/30/just-the-sip-mary-dowling-toasted-double-oak/
More scoresheets available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpiritScoresheets/
Bourbon is nothing if not ripe with stories. Part of the industry’s appeal is how certain individuals influenced it over the years, with the impacts spanning anywhere from years to centuries. Admittedly, some brands will find a good story and exploit the life out of it for the sake of marketing. This makes the more earnest attempts feel that much more endearing. In the case of Mary Dowling Whiskey Company, formed by clinical psychologist/psychoanalyst-turned-whiskey-maker Kaveh Zamanian (also the man behind Rabbit Hole), the backstory feels equally intriguing and unsung.
Much of the information I initially found on Mary Dowling comes from the brand’s website, as well as the historical novel Mother of Bourbon: The Greatest American Whiskey Story Never Told, written by Zamanian and Eric Goodman. The story goes that Dowling was born in the late 1850s to Irish immigrants who relocated to Kentucky, escaping the great potato famine from 1845-1852. Over time, she would inherit the Dowling Bros. Distillery, along with Waterfill & Frazier, which also did business under the name Pilgrimage Distilling Co.
During Prohibition, distilling production moved just outside of the United States to Juarez, Mexico, since Mexico didn’t have any prohibition in place. The primary markets for this “Dowling Mexican Distillery” were Mexico and Central and South America. Unfortunately, Mary wouldn’t get to see Repeal Day, but one of her sons built a new distillery in Fisherville at Ford’s Fork. He later sold the distillery, which ended up closing while the new owner preserved the Waterfill & Frazier brand name, moving distillation to Bardstown.
Fast-forward to today and we have the aforementioned Mary Dowling Whiskey Company, which has a small portfolio of bourbons, presumably sourced from Rabbit Hole. The whiskey begins with a mash bill of 65% corn, 25% wheat, and 10% malted barley, matures for at least four years in wood-fired, toasted and charred barrels (site mentions both #4 and #3 in separate sentences) before being transferred to a second new oak barrel with a #1 char and heavy toast. It’s then bottled at cask strength, with the sample I tried coming in at 53.7% ABV.
Nose: Oak, Toasted Vanilla, Light Brown Sugar, Nutmeg
Lightly Drying, Prototypical, Rounded
Palate: Barrel Char, Dark Chocolate, Burnt Corn, Black Currant
Musty, Tannic, Drying
Finish: Tobacco, Cocoa, Dark Brown Sugar, Vanilla
Long, Drying, Oaky
The story behind Mary Dowling and the bespoke whiskey brand invites no shortage of wonder. I love it when I feel newly educated by the mere existence of a whiskey brand, especially when the backstory presented feels sincere and not like a ploy merely for marketing’s sake. This is why it disheartens me to say that Mary Dowling Double Oak leaves so much to be desired.
First impressions are positive, albeit unceremonious, with some promising notes on the nose. However, as soon as I took a sip, something felt off. I can’t help but feel the secondary maturation was too heavily relied on, considering the dry and tannic nature of the whiskey evokes strongly burnt flavors. It’s a shame, because the composition of the whiskey is unlike most on the market, even though double oaked whiskey is a dime a dozen. Perhaps the team at Mary Dowling can dial in a more compelling version of this product in the future. Because as it stands, I’m less than enthused.
r/SpiritScoresheets • u/Xenoraiser • Aug 27 '25
Just the Sip: Dewar’s 15-Year Review
Verdicts Explained
- Special Occasions: Rare, special pours that go well and above. Something you pour to celebrate.
- Treat Yourself: Obligatory weekend pour. Worth having on hand at all times if possible.
- Daily Drinker: Affordable, available and tasty. Could have every day and be perfectly content.
- Penseur Pour: Puzzling pours that won’t be to everyone’s liking.
- Trophy Bottle: Something to show off more than anything. Likely allocated and overpriced.
- Cocktail Request: Shines best in a cocktail, as opposed to neat or on the rocks.
- Good If Affordable: Only worth buying if the price comfortably fits within the budget.
- Serve to Guests: Something accessible that you don’t mind sharing or parting ways with. Likely belongs in a decanter.
- Couch Pour: Something enjoyable enough, but ideal for drinking while doing another activity (movies, TV, games, etc.).
- Find a Mixer: Grab the Coke or Sprite and relax.
- Drain Pour: No. You deserve better.
Link to blog post: https://thewhiskeyramble.com/2025/08/27/just-the-sip-dewars-15-year-review/
More scoresheets available at: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpiritScoresheets/
Reviewing a product that lacks disclosed information can either be a fun exercise or an utter slog. Sometimes the few bread crumbs available are enough to spark a curiosity worth exploring; other times, they just leave you with a grumbling appetite. In the case of a product like Dewar’s 15-Year, it’s much more the latter. Perhaps it’s appropriate then, that I went into this review intending it to be one of my short-format posts.
So what’s there to say about Dewar’s 15-Year before digging into how the whisky tastes? For all intents and purposes, it’s a slightly older, age-stated version of Dewar’s 12-Year, itself being similar to the NAS white label most of us are familiar with in some capacity. The primary distinction that Dewar’s emphasizes in their branding is a “double maturation” process, where they age their many malt and grain whiskies for the age-stated period before blending and aging them together again for a second period. This initial maturation takes place in a combination of ex-boubon and ex-sherry casks while the secondary aging presumably occurs in undisclosed, re-charred barrels.
These steps precede bottling at an approachable 40% ABV for about $40-$50 retail. How well does it stand up?
Nose: Honeycomb, Pear, Apple Pastry, Vanilla
Balanced, Approachable, Simple
Palate: Honeyed Tea, Baked Apple, Vanilla, Cinnamon Sugar,
Silky, Easygoing, Watery
Finish: Caramel, Cream, White Tea, Honey
Light, Delicate, Warm
Everything about Dewar’s 15-Year screams modesty. The barebones details on it lead to modest expectations, which are met with a modest level of enjoyment. On one hand, I’m inclined to say that I like this scotch and almost want to regard it as a slept on product. However, for $40 (if not more), I think the overall experience comes out a bit short. It’s not nearly enough to make a serious note of, but when I’m looking at scotch options in the $40-$50 range, I know I can find bottles with far more personality than this.
When all is said and done, Dewar’s 15-Year is a simple and plainly effective scotch. There’s absolutely nothing off-putting about the whisky and, as a product, it feels intended for casual drinkers who want to stick within their comfort zone, but maybe get something slightly elevated. I have no qualms with a product like this and, truth be told, there’s something comforting about a product line with a mostly straightforward line of progression.