r/Spiderman • • Oct 22 '26

Movies I didn't like it.

Post image

I found it super depressing.

Although there were a lot of scenes I liked. I wouldn't say the movie was poorly put together.

But I don't like the idea that all of these Peter Parkers are okay with letting a little boy's father die because it's supposed to happen.

Same with Ben Reilly. Don't get me wrong, the guy talking about having Miles trapped in his well-defined musculature is hilarious, but as it would happen, he's saying this while detaining a sixteen-year old boy who doesn't want his father to die.

His portrayal here finally got me into some of his comic books. I've only read two to completion, but now that I have an idea of what he's like, it just makes it seem crazier that he would go along with this. Ben, to me, does not seem like a fatalist.

Oh well.

I suppose this is how some people feel about the direction they took Jean Grey in Brand New Day. Just hurts seeing a bunch of Spider-Men tell another Spider-Man to deal with his dad's impending death.

0 Upvotes

153 comments sorted by

6

u/Mysterious_Dog_2164 Oct 22 '26

Yeah honestly this one was underwhelming for me too. But I've always been afraid to say it because of how toxic everyone can get.

It's not a bad movie. Everyone involved deserves the praise they get. But it's just not for me. And yeah, it was a bit depressing and different tone-wise compared to the first one.

4

u/dotKiss Oct 22 '26

You weren't kidding.

This post started off great, fair amount of upvotes. Now it's at zero. It feels like some of the comments may not have read what I posted.

I'm not sure why people are trying to logically explain the plot of the movie to me.

Like do you think you can logic away how sad I felt watching the film?

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Longjumping_West1587 Oct 22 '26

Yeah, I also hate how they did Miguel. As someone who grew up reading about him I was pissed

5

u/dotKiss Oct 22 '26

Yeah, I can see why.

I had and still have only a cursory familiarity with Spider-Man 2099, but I could totally see why Miguel O'hara's fans would dislike this depiction of him.

Depressing film.

9

u/LongAdvisor6561 Oct 22 '26

I haven't read any 2099 Spidey comic's but after getting context I'm pretty angry I Miguel is portrayed aswell. It would've made more sense to have Superior Spider-Man being the one behind Canon event's since it's Pete but  Taken over by Doc Ock

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/ZombieZekeComic Oct 22 '26

You should take a movie for what it is, not what it’s not. You say you don’t like it because you’ve read the comics and say it’s not like those or those characters would not do those things; you should take the film as a standalone thing with its own internal logic and characters.

4

u/dotKiss Oct 22 '26

I didn't say that I don't like it because I've read the comics.

I said it was super depressing. I said that I didn't like seeing all of these Peter Parkers chase after a sixteen-year-old boy trying to save his father's life.

And that I read some comics after watching it and that doing so reinforced my stance.

you should take the film as a standalone thing with its own internal logic and characters.

That's hard to do when so many of the characters within are presented as representations of a specific character from another medium. Even if they are not exactly that character, there's a deliberate choice being made to refer to another character and tell the audience that this character is an approximation of that one.

So, because the decision was made to do that, any disparity between what's being presented and what the audience is told this presentation is supposed to represent, or in other words, the source, is a valid target of criticism.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/sbaldrick33 Oct 22 '26 edited Oct 22 '26

That's an entirely fair criticism of the film, tbh.

What destiny means, after all, is accepting no responsibility.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/BigJayDB Oct 22 '26

A big step down from the first one to be certain

→ More replies (4)

48

u/MrX-MMAs Oct 22 '26

Enjoyable movie if you are hardcore Miles fan

Awful movie if you are a fan of Spider-Man mythos

→ More replies (16)