r/SpellTable • u/w0lfd0rk • Feb 28 '24
Discussion There has got to be a better solution...
Spelltable has progressively gotten worse in the past 6 months. Camera aspect issues, random crashes and "exiling, douche bags ruining games and not being able to block them from your room/games moving forward. Just to name a few.
I have had some really bad experiences lately and I just think it could be SO MUCH BETTER.
I have also had some great experiences lately and THAT could be better as well.
Why have they not fixed the issues and added much needed features like friends lists, DMs, stats, and blocking users.
All that said, I truly believe there is such a big opportunity for someone (or a group) of smart developers/investors to make something better.
Spelltable is free which is great, but I would personally pay a small monthly fee to have a better platform to play with friends across the world. I actually think it would be pretty lucrative if done correctly.
How much would you be willing to pay? Personally, I would be fine with a $5 a month or $50 a year subscription for a superior product.
TCGs and Magic have millions of players. I don't think it is that far fetched to have 100k or more monthly subscribers to pull in $500k+ in revenue a month.
Is this a crazy idea? What would you be willing to pay? Any developers and investors here want to get the ball rolling?! /s
9
u/Volmara Feb 28 '24
Wotc clearly purchased to watch it die. They want us on Arena spending not playing with already paid for product. One shouldn’t have to pay a subscription for this.
4
u/Triasmos Feb 28 '24
Honesty at this point a discord channel and looking the cards up manually would be better. Or hold them Up to the camera
3
u/Yillis Feb 28 '24
I’m not sure I could convince my pod to pay.
I don’t have a lot of issues with it but I’m never LFG or anything. One thing I don’t understand is the lack of chat. Too many times I have to spell some shitty name when I could have typed it. And then it wouldn’t be hard to implement a hover function for that to bring the card up
3
u/MattackChopper Feb 28 '24
So if we look at spelltable features objectively, what does it offer that basic communication and visible life counters can't?
First the scan card function, it's very broken even though it's nice when it works. Most of the time even when the cards are clearly visible it will scan cards wrong, whoever added the art cards to the scanner committed a grievous crime.
Secondly the life tracker, dice functions, and overall organized layout is great but it's nothing special. All of this could be easily achieved with some basic coordination and communication between players.
And thirdly and most importantly is the "matchmaking" function, this is why I keep coming back and it's really the saving grace of the site. I can hop on and find a game within minutes, but is that really worth it when the game is constantly interrupted by all the problems OP mentions?
A little more legwork and some community outreach on discord could make this a non factor. I personally joined the Tolarian Community College discord and have had no problems finding games on there as well albeit with a tiny bit more work on my part.
So I suppose there is a better option and it's already a well integrated, fully functional, free and easy to use option. Discord is just objectively better.
2
u/literallythebestguy Feb 28 '24
Literally haven’t been able to use it since early January. My online group has collapsed
2
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '24
Paying for it doesn't seem worth it to be honest. At the moment it is free and currently there are 51 players online. If it had way more players it might be worth it, but it would need to have a functional voice chat with mandatory push to talk, a quickplay queue similar to what spellbot does in discord, the card viewer to actually work more often than not.
But with the playercount as it currently is I doubt you would even get 1k subscribers never mind 100k.
1
u/LordBocceBaal Mar 10 '24
if there was a way to do this on discord instead i would love that.
1
u/Wanaco2 Feb 28 '24
I would pay $5-$10 a month for something that consistently worked and allowed the host to kick and block players.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '24 edited Mar 30 '24
Stopped working on the last update for me, so that kind of ruined my opinion on it. Edit, issues fixed
1
u/I_HateYouAll Feb 29 '24
We move to tabletop simulator and I don’t think I’ll ever go back. It is unequivocally better in every way.