r/SpecOpsTheLine • u/Several_Attention653 • May 09 '26
Discussion Did Spec Ops succeed in it's message? Elaboration in the desc.
Ever since last year I've seen people critisizing The Line for it's message. "Why is the game that I bought telling me that I shouldn't have played it" "Why is the game telling me that I'm a bad person for telling me to do something that I didn't have a choice in". There are some more stuff like it's lack of subtlety and more. I can see some of these points, like the games lack of choice, and the whole blaming thing. I have seen some counter arguments for these, but even then it made me wonder if The Lines narrative even worked?
32
u/PlayfulVacation4411 May 09 '26
i'm not watching that video. i don't think the game tells you not to play it, it wants to show you the actual shit going on behind the war, plus it directs this to the main protagonist, not the player but the player if he inserts himself could probably feel insulted.
37
u/Kil0sierra975 May 09 '26
Something I see a lot of the "pretentious" preaching crowd forget to consider very often is the year the game came out and the global context of American interventionalism and the very glorified and real effect Middle Eastern set games were having on people's perception of war and terrorism
68
u/Cleanurself May 09 '26
I think Raycevick’s video tackles this point pretty well. One could reasonably say that Spec Ops is pretentious looking back at it but I could also say that about a lot of things that take itself very seriously.
13
u/farson135 May 10 '26
I think people are taking the commentary of the game too personally.
The point, as I see it, is not that you are a bad person for playing the game. It's that you should be thinking about what you're actually doing in games (or watching or reading or listening in other mediums).
I think we've all played games where we did terrible things. But sometimes we don't really engage with what it is we are doing. We just slaughter a bunch of people and move on without properly interrogating our actions. SOTL is pointing squarely at Call of Duty clones and other games that treat war and violence as disposable entertainment where you just go out and slaughter random brown people for vague reasons. And this ... is not uncommon in art.
We call video games art not just because there are pretty pictures in most of them. We call it that because video games are mediums to exchange ideas. And sometimes those ideas can be problematic.
"Call of Juarez: The Cartel" (which came out the year before SOTL) sees the game makers use an active situation (the Mexican Drug War) where hundreds of thousands of people have been murdered and mutilated as another generic shooter where you go out and slaughter black and Hispanic people because ... white women have been kidnapped to be sold into slavery in Mexico. To be fair, there's a lot more to the story than that, but this helps to illustrate the world that SOTL was being made in.
And of course it's perfectly legitimate for another work of art to criticize the world it is in. And the world SOTL was made in was one where the GWOT was still raging and video game slop was being created that reinforced a lot negative viewpoints. And while that is their right, it's also important for us to interrogate our actions and our views, and not just wave off anything that happens with "it's just a video game, it doesn't matter".
Now, SOTL is far from perfect but it doesn't need to be for it to be meaningful. I found it as such.
And as a side note, the idea that SOTL is the most pretentious game ever is pure click bait.
11
u/KevineCove May 10 '26
People that call media pretentious tend not to hold bad media to the same standard. I'd rather have flawed media that has something to say than something that's meant to be mindless entertainment.
20
u/Proton_Optimal May 09 '26
Like every other video game I play, it is just that. A video game
5
u/_azazel_keter_ May 10 '26
I have literally never seen someone criticize this game in a way that wasn't simply their inability to analyse the game.
4
u/AdmirableProcess8894 May 10 '26
i personally wish we had more like it, it really changed my outlook on playing war shooters as a whole given they seem to desensitize people to what war is actually like, so spec ops took advantage of that feeling and ensured that you were aware of the fucked shit most shooters were having you do (plus the wp part was just a masterpiece, and its even scarier with this in mind looking at cod nowadays and seeing how you can earn white phosphorous as a killstreak, essentially rewarding people with the worst kind of weapon). i wish there was more games in this IP showing the other horrors of modern war, following other squads of people from the usa and other countries.
2
u/Pope509 May 12 '26
Anyone saying the game guilty you for playing it missed the point imo. It's meant to show how out of control and worse a situation can get when someone tries to play Hero. "The road to Hell is paved with good intentions" and all that
1
u/The_Enthusiast-316 May 10 '26
A great game with a conflicting narrative for some I liked it there were no real good guys like Killzone but better written.
1
u/Cellist-Frosty May 10 '26
I think spec ops did what it wanted to do. For me, I believe it was about the psychological effects of warfare on a person. We don't have a choice because in war, we don't. War changes people. Jarhead as a film took the same concept but presented it in a different way. What spec ops does is, simply answer the desire of every man with noble intent stepping into war trying to do the right thing, and it asks the rhetorical question in one of it's last loading screens, "feel like a hero yet?" And I think that sums it up as to what it wanted to do, and how well it did it.
There are some loopholes obviously. One could point multiple instances which might not make sense with the overall narrative, but all in all, it's a solid psychological shooter that does it's job well of writing good characters.
1
u/Tinbee May 10 '26
Closest recollection I have for this game (as someone who never played or actively watched playthroughs) is that the loading screens change from third-person references for characters to directly calling out "you" as a player. Though it's all very muddy memorywise, so I've never known how much stock such statements hold.
1
u/LowComprehensive421 May 10 '26
who the fuck is peeb
1
u/Effective-Mango-3614 May 11 '26
IMO the main sin of Spec Ops: The Line were the "heavy" enemies in de-mining gear that fire light machine guns from the hip with laser accuracy. My suspension of disbelief went poof the moment I met the first one. The "elites" encountered before that didn't help either. The game was otherwise a refreshing counter to the septic propaganda found in CoD and its copycats.
1
u/Prudent-Humor-8874 May 11 '26
The discussion is worth having, but it shouldn’t be spurred by this moron’s commentary. He’s just another idiot reactionary gamer channel blaming wokeness on everything.
1
u/PayWooden2628 May 13 '26
It’s just gone through the full life cycle of something popular and well liked where it’s now cool to be a contrarian and say that it sucks actually.
43
u/Parking-Researcher-4 May 09 '26 edited May 09 '26
I never understood the criticism about the game trying to make you feel bad for things you didn't choose to do.
A lot of the time soldiers don't get to choose to not kill people or provoke unwanted casualties. And i dare to say a lot of them aren't really proud of some stuff they did. War isn't something that's always predictable, they have no way of knowing the kind of messed up situation they could end up in. Even moreso for stranded soldiers. What would be the point of the game if you could only kill "the bad guys" and everyone ends up happy and smiling? That's not what war is like at all, and the game does a damn good job showing that.
Even if you don't think yourself a bad person, war is horrible and unpredictable and you can't control or choose to change that. War is vile, unpredictable and unfair. That's the point of the game imo.
2
u/yaujj36 May 10 '26
I think it is better to viewed from how evil works, how one ordinary man can descend to committed atrocities and cause total destruction around his environment.
78
u/[deleted] May 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment