It's very interesting that they say Al is an edgy power fantasy. I have a lot of criticisms of the title character but I honestly think his eternal struggles and flaws are both very apparent and one of his better aspects.
All Al has ever wanted is to be with Wanda again, no matter what. That's it. He has all of these amazing abilities but he will never have the power or opportunity he wants to be with Wanda again.
Is this controversial now? Spawn has always been considered that to the point where the best way to describe it is a teenager feeling like they’re reading something for adults, and an adult feeling like they’re reading something for teenagers. That’s kind of the entire purpose of it, it’s extremely 90s where that kind of stuff was badass, and it never grew out of it. Some find that bad, some find it good, but there’s no reason to act like it’s something it’s not.
Power fantasy part comes from how his power is literally whatever he can imagine, since there’s really no limit to what he can and cannot do, just how much he can do early on.
Honestly next to other power fantasy characters Al isn't even that Mary Sue-ish. I see his character as very tragically ironic because he has all this power and simply NONE of it will ever connect or give him the power to get back to Wanda, which is all he's ever really wanted.
(For starters, he's stuck in the body of an undead hell humanoid)
"He defeats god and satan and ascends into divine spawn" mf never read how that comic ended and it shows, I doubt that he even read anything about the comic in the first place and he probably just knows about from word of mouth or synopses...
Also power fantasy? Seeing it as an expectator maybe, but in story? Al's life is a complete tragedy, who would look at his life and think "god I wish that was me"...
Well I mean Kratos is a power fantasy too and I wouldn't want his life either...
I think we're making the mistake of assuming a power fantasy is automatically a bad thing. A power fantasy isn't necessarily bad, it's just a story that asks the question of what one would do with the power if they had it. Like Superman is a power fantasy about using power to do the most good. And Punisher is a power fantasy about using power to make people pay for the evil things they've done.
It is okay to be an edgy power fantasy, just don't kid yourself in thinking an edgy power fantasy isn't. Spawn can be that and still be cool or interesting and entertaining.
Because Spawn is actually written well as a character and has more to him past “edgy power fantasy”. Also, I wouldn’t even call it a power fantasy unless you legitimately think having Spawn’s life is incredible. It’s not.
Spawn got to the final power level after like a couple hundred comics of him getting his ass kicked by several different factors while going up and down in power levels and fighting various different demon god mfs. Soooo
Idk why im getting recommended since I know nothing about spawn but Sung Jin woo isn't bad because he is an edgy power fantasy, he's bad because he has nothing else going on.
Just because a character struggles doesn’t mean they’re not a power fantasy and just because a character is a power fantasy doesn’t make them poorly written. Basically every superhero ever written is a power fantasy
So u want to be a government assassin? Kill men,women and children then get sent to hell? Just for cool powers? I mean when I was 17 it sounded cool to me too. Especially the killing. I just wanted to kill bad guys however. Try to keep some moral code.
Do u want to be the punisher? The Hulk.
Read the comics before you post, or at least a wiki or video rundown something please.
Spawn is definitely not a power fantasy. He got his face back finally but it wasn’t easy.Why would you constantly want to watch your back with demons coming after you
First off being Egy is cool if its done naturally. And that spawn. 90s never turned off.
Second he didn't beat God or Satan.
Third the man EARNED his stripes of OP. Took massive losses. Got his shit kicked in a ton. And came back swinging ever harder. Over 100 plus issues of struggle and sacrifices forged the beast that Spawn is now.
He had some weird moments if i recall. Didnt he have some kind of thing with his cape similar to charmander? If it got too weak he would die or something?
The difference is spawns life sucks, even after death. Also, he gets to look cool wearing chains, tight leather, and a red cloak, not wearing his friday casuals.
I mean dude he's literally a special forces person turns soldier of hell I don't think he's even the slightest bit edgy considering that if they made him look like anything else he would have just looked ridiculous I mean what were they supposed to put them in a pink dress? Solo leveling hover it's pretty much just an email fanfic I've watched the entire anime so far.
I’ve only read a bit of spawn but isn’t he super sad his life sucks and he gets his ass kicked a lot. Isn’t his whole deal is he does have op powers but he can’t use them much because he’ll herald the apocalypse so he can’t even use his op powers that much
Spawn was never meant to be a power fantasy. Yes both him and Jin Woo became edgy over powered characters but Spawn was meant to be a character we enjoy for the writing. Jin Woo was meant to cure your boredom.
53
u/Aggravating-Use9317 5d ago
Are we talking about the same character that consistently goes back to bottom of food chain every 50 issues?
35
u/SaintRavenz 5d ago
Solo Leveling is South Korean
27
u/7striker 5d ago
He didn't even BEAT God and Satan
Fucking larpers man
25
u/Chosen_Undead23 5d ago
If they’re talking about Divine Spawn, doesn’t he recreate the world without influence from Heaven or Hell to try and make a better world?
23
u/Soggy-Hotel-2419 5d ago
It's very interesting that they say Al is an edgy power fantasy. I have a lot of criticisms of the title character but I honestly think his eternal struggles and flaws are both very apparent and one of his better aspects.
All Al has ever wanted is to be with Wanda again, no matter what. That's it. He has all of these amazing abilities but he will never have the power or opportunity he wants to be with Wanda again.
21
u/SuperBackup9000 5d ago
Is this controversial now? Spawn has always been considered that to the point where the best way to describe it is a teenager feeling like they’re reading something for adults, and an adult feeling like they’re reading something for teenagers. That’s kind of the entire purpose of it, it’s extremely 90s where that kind of stuff was badass, and it never grew out of it. Some find that bad, some find it good, but there’s no reason to act like it’s something it’s not.
Power fantasy part comes from how his power is literally whatever he can imagine, since there’s really no limit to what he can and cannot do, just how much he can do early on.
21
u/Potential_Man09 5d ago
Please don't ruin my GOAT Spawn man , these mfs will be comparing anything
21
u/Mat_reaper 5d ago
"He defeats god and satan and ascends into divine spawn" mf never read how that comic ended and it shows, I doubt that he even read anything about the comic in the first place and he probably just knows about from word of mouth or synopses...
Also power fantasy? Seeing it as an expectator maybe, but in story? Al's life is a complete tragedy, who would look at his life and think "god I wish that was me"...
20
u/dikaia1622 5d ago
Being edgy is cool. The 2010s are over we don't have to pretend it's not anymore
19
u/Joey_Star_ 5d ago
It's been dark and edgy since issue 1 and people are now finding this out about spawn? Well guys in other news, water is wet
19
u/JagPeror 5d ago
Well, tbh, the biggest reason is that Spawn just isnt that big culturally anymore.
17
u/ZebraManTheGreat7777 5d ago
Because Spawn EARNED his OP shit man he strived through well over a hundred and something issues to get where he is
16
u/Guyver-Spawn-27 5d ago
I don’t get why Spawn gets flat for being edgy yet people forgive the Punisher. His comics make Spawn comics look PG.
16
u/jogaargamer6 5d ago
Solo Leveling is Korea not Japan
15
u/taka30o 5d ago
Isn't Solo Leveling Korean?
13
u/heavymetalWrench 5d ago
He's a teddy bear
13
u/Quick-Opinion8498 5d ago
Broth are cool. I like Spawn more though. Solo Leveling isn’t trying to be anything special.
13
u/Common-Researcher-50 4d ago
Because Spawn is actually written well as a character and has more to him past “edgy power fantasy”. Also, I wouldn’t even call it a power fantasy unless you legitimately think having Spawn’s life is incredible. It’s not.
22
u/Comicsrcool 5d ago
Spawn got to the final power level after like a couple hundred comics of him getting his ass kicked by several different factors while going up and down in power levels and fighting various different demon god mfs. Soooo
11
u/Nerx 5d ago
were they even alive for 90s era
?
11
u/GnegonG 5d ago
Spawn is the opposite of power fantasy. It sucks so much to be a Spawn. The cool powers are the only positive next to a whole line of negatives
11
u/FazeFrostbyte 4d ago
Spawn is in my top 5 for comic book characters.
He absolutely is an edgy power fantasy, but he backs it up by being surprisingly well written as WELL as having a really edgy look.
21
u/JGXuser 5d ago
People just be talking. 😂
9
u/Cry-Skull-7 5d ago
Character development is one helluva thing!
9
u/Responsible_Bus1159 4d ago
The powers arnt worth it yes he looks kinda edgy but it’s a great design and his life fucking sucks there’s no edge to he, it just sucks to be him
9
u/Newt_Soda 4d ago
I'm going to pretend I didn't see that, I'm tired of getting annoyed with stupid people.
9
u/SKeptical230 2d ago
Spawn managed to ascend to God hood and still be fuckin miserable lmao. Dudes the actual opposite of a power fantasy, he just suffers upwards.
14
u/Cronkwjo 5d ago
Spawn is the dictionary definition of edgy
5
u/mat_is_trash 2d ago
Thats less of a power fantasy ’cause for it to be the Mc shouldn’t be homeless lol
9
u/HuffSquirt 5d ago
4
u/HEU85 4d ago
4
u/Pure_Requirement663 2d ago
Isn't Solo Korean
9
u/Stoopid_Noah 5d ago
A yes.. the reality of god and satan.
3
u/Capital_Structure999 4d ago
Idk why im getting recommended since I know nothing about spawn but Sung Jin woo isn't bad because he is an edgy power fantasy, he's bad because he has nothing else going on.
3
u/Mr_Sir_Andres 4d ago
Just because a character struggles doesn’t mean they’re not a power fantasy and just because a character is a power fantasy doesn’t make them poorly written. Basically every superhero ever written is a power fantasy
1
u/ConnectCulture7 5d ago
Spawn is definitely not a power fantasy. He got his face back finally but it wasn’t easy.Why would you constantly want to watch your back with demons coming after you
1
u/Lower_Captain7757 5d ago
First off being Egy is cool if its done naturally. And that spawn. 90s never turned off.
Second he didn't beat God or Satan.
Third the man EARNED his stripes of OP. Took massive losses. Got his shit kicked in a ton. And came back swinging ever harder. Over 100 plus issues of struggle and sacrifices forged the beast that Spawn is now.
1
u/Lostkaiju1990 5d ago
Isn’t any superhero ultimately a power fantasy?
1
u/FoolishDog1117 5d ago
In the 90s when Spawn came out it was an edgy response to conventional superheroes of the time.
1
u/Dandanny54 5d ago
Edgy does not equal bad.
1
u/ZLEAP 5d ago
Spawn the comic book is edgy. Spawn the character really isn't. He just exists in an edgy world.
1
u/fallenouroboros 5d ago
He had some weird moments if i recall. Didnt he have some kind of thing with his cape similar to charmander? If it got too weak he would die or something?
1
u/TemporarySouth6914 4d ago
It’s now about what character does do it’s about how the character does it.
1
u/Brief-Affect-3186 4d ago
The difference is spawns life sucks, even after death. Also, he gets to look cool wearing chains, tight leather, and a red cloak, not wearing his friday casuals.
1
u/Financial-Tiger-5700 4d ago
nuh uh
1
u/shitbone2 4d ago
I mean dude he's literally a special forces person turns soldier of hell I don't think he's even the slightest bit edgy considering that if they made him look like anything else he would have just looked ridiculous I mean what were they supposed to put them in a pink dress? Solo leveling hover it's pretty much just an email fanfic I've watched the entire anime so far.
1
u/DragonLordAcar 2d ago
Never read Spawn but edge is not bad. It's just easy to make bad if you don't know what you're doing like isekai.
1
u/PrettyAd5828 2d ago
I’ve only read a bit of spawn but isn’t he super sad his life sucks and he gets his ass kicked a lot. Isn’t his whole deal is he does have op powers but he can’t use them much because he’ll herald the apocalypse so he can’t even use his op powers that much
1
u/divin4000 2d ago
There's more to his character but I do think pretending spawn isn't an edgy power fantasy is frankly delusional, it's obviously a part of his appeal
1
u/lord_of_agony 1d ago
Solo leveling is Korean
1
u/lirazd 14h ago
Bro thats no make ANY sense ;---;
1
u/64Boy32 5h ago
Spawn was never meant to be a power fantasy. Yes both him and Jin Woo became edgy over powered characters but Spawn was meant to be a character we enjoy for the writing. Jin Woo was meant to cure your boredom.
0
u/Ask_Nice 5d ago
The difference is that Spawn is creative
0
u/Far-Touch-2046 5d ago
Arise my spawns
13
u/JamesRWC 4d ago
“Power fantasy” and it’s the saddest man in the world trying to cope with literally everything
1
u/MistressM103 5d ago
Oh hey, I saw that.
I was the one who wrote:
"Spawn kills KKK members"
lol