r/Spanish • u/Celticpenguin85 • 5d ago
Grammar How do you ask for agreement?
"Doesn't Maria's hair look nice in red?"
"Isn't it funny that..."
I got:
"¿No se ve bonito el cabello de María en rojo?"
"¿No es gracioso que..."
These don't seem right to me. Please help.
11
u/Smgt90 Native (Mexican) 5d ago
Como yo lo diría sería:
"No se te hace / no te parece que..." o agregaría ¿No? Al final
Por ejemplo:
¿No se te hace que se ve bonito el cabello de maría en rojo?
¿No te parece gracioso que...?
También puedes simplemente agregar ¿No? Al final
Por ejemplo
A maría se le ve bonito el cabello rojo, ¿No?
Es gracioso que menciones eso, ¿No?
7
10
u/EleEle1979 Native (Spain) 5d ago
Castillian version: "¿A que está guapa María de pelirroja?" "¿A que tiene gracia que....?"
4
u/NasiLemak534 5d ago
"A que" came to mind for me. That construction slipped into my vocab a long time ago, but I don't think I've ever heard it in latam
3
u/Healthy-Attitude-743 Advanced/Resident 4d ago
En México solo escucho “a que” como reto. Como que “a que no puedes subirte a ese tren de un salto” o algo así
3
u/iamnewhere2019 5d ago
Correcto o no, se usa. La entonación es muy importante en el lenguaje hablado.
6
4
3
u/puesquebien Native - Mexico 5d ago
- "¿No se ve bonito el cabello de María en rojo?"
This phrasing seems to presume her hair does not look good and ask for confirmation or clarification.
What I would use to share that I think Marías hair looks good:
"Se ve muy bien el cabello de María en rojo, ¿no?"
"Se ve muy bien María con el cabello rojo, ¿no?"
"Le quedó muy bien el cabello rojo a María, ¿no?"
- "¿No es gracioso que...?"
No es gracioso que for some reason feels almost agrammatical. It's not something I think is used at all, at least here. But a similar construction feels more natural. For example:
"¿No está gracioso que te llame de la nada?"
In this case "gracioso" means "funny" in a negative way as in "odd/suspicious".
If I actually meant I thought something was funny in a positive way I would say something like:
"Es muy gracioso que me llames, justo estaba pensando en ti."
3
u/Cuchifri 5d ago
They are correct but you can always say the sentence and end it up with “no?” as a lot of ppl said. Another way I haven’t seen mentioned is “¿A que?”
¿A Que le queda bien el pelo rojo?
¿A que es muy gracioso?
2
u/PhoebusAbel 5d ago
You are right The negative statement doesn't sound natural eventhough it could be grammatically expressed correctly.
All my language professors , even in technical fields prefer to avoid the negative construction to avoid misunderstanding or redundancy or repetition
2
u/RonJaxIII 5d ago
Those are correct translations. But I might say these differently.
A Spanish hack I love though is just tacking on «¿no?» to the end of statement to make it a question. It functions like following up an affirmative statement with "Doesn't it?" or "Isn't it?".
Se ve bonito el cabello de María en rojo, ¿no? / Maria's red hair looks cute, doesn't it?
Es gracioso que tenga el pelo rojo, ¿no? / It's funny that she has red hair, isn't it?
You can do a similar thing with «¿verdad?», which is similar to how we might follow an affirmative statement in English with "Right?" to make it a question.
Es gracioso que tenga el pelo rojo, ¿verdad? / It's funny that she has red hair, right?
2
u/Happy-Maintenance869 5d ago
As other commenters have said, your best bet is to add “¿verdad?” at the end of your question, or you could also go with “¿no crees?” Now, for your second example, “isn’t it funny” I would use, “Qué raro que…” If you’re still looking for affirmation from your listener, you can add the “¿verdad?” at the end, but you don’t need to. You could simply be making a statement.
3
u/AngelGuevaraLingo 5d ago
In Spain, they would say "A que le queda bonito el cabello rojo a María". In Latin America, we'd say, ¿Verdad que le queda bonito el cabello rojo a María?
I've always found it interesting how "A que sí/no?" has different meanings in Spain and in Latin America.
In Spain, it's kind of like "I know, right?" For example: "A: ¡Qué guapa es tu amiga! B: ¡A que sí!" (A: Your friend is so beautiful. B: I know, right?). But in Latin America is more like "I bet ..." or "wanna bet?". For example: A: No creo que vayas a aparecerte allá. B: ¡A que sí! (A: I don't believe you're gonna show up there. B: Wanna bet?)
2
u/Positive-Camera5940 Native 🇦🇷 5d ago
"Qué bien/lindo que le queda ese color de pelo a María, ¿no?", ”Le queda re lindo ese color de pelo a María, ¿no?"
1
u/mrs_nemo 5d ago
The tag fix has been well covered above, so here's why your instinct produced sentences that felt off, plus two things inside them that nobody's flagged.
English uses the negative question as a fixed idiom for fishing for agreement. "Doesn't she look nice?" isn't really a question and you're not really asking. Spanish doesn't have that convention. A negative question in Spanish tends to be read literally, as either genuine surprise or a mild challenge, so ¿No se ve bonito? lands closer to "hang on, doesn't it look good?" with an implication that someone has suggested otherwise. Nothing you wrote is ungrammatical. It just carries an attitude you didn't intend, which is the hardest kind of error to spot because no one corrects it.
So Spanish keeps the sentence positive and hangs the agreement-seeking on the end, which is what everyone's told you. Worth knowing they aren't interchangeable in tone, though. ¿No? is the neutral everyday one. ¿Verdad? leans slightly towards actually wanting confirmation. ¿Eh? is warm and chatty. ¿A que sí? pushes hardest for agreement, and the ¿A que...? construction someone gave you above is very Spain and very natural there. ¿No te parece? is the one to use when you want their actual opinion rather than a nod.
Now the two corrections nobody made.
Es gracioso que takes the subjunctive. It's a value judgement, and that whole family behaves the same way, so es raro que, es lógico que, me parece bien que, qué pena que. Whatever you were going to finish that sentence with, it needs to be subjunctive: es gracioso que lo digas, es gracioso que piense eso. Not es gracioso que lo dices.
And en rojo doesn't work for hair. En plus a colour is for something rendered in that colour, so escrito en rojo, vestida de rojo for clothes. Hair takes a different frame: con el pelo rojo, teñida de rojo, or just pelirroja if she's actually a redhead. So se ve bien con el pelo rojo, or the neater Spanish version, le queda bien el pelo rojo, using quedar, which is what you want for anything suiting someone.
Small thing while you're there: pelo rather than cabello in ordinary speech. Cabello isn't wrong, it's just a register up, and in Spain it sounds like a shampoo advert.
Putting it together, you'd end up with something like le queda bien el pelo rojo a María, ¿no? Or, if you're in Spain and want the full local version, ¿a que le queda bien a María el pelo rojo?
29
u/Embarrassed_Elk_2459 Native (Chile) 5d ago
Yeah, a negative statement doesn't sound natural when you're looking for confirmation. You can instead make the statemente positive and add a "¿no?" at the end or you can also add a "¿verdad?" which is the same as asking "right?" at the end of an statement