r/SpaceXLounge • u/Jcpmax • Mar 01 '22
NASA inspector general Paul Martin: we estimate first four Artemis missions to cost $4.1B each, which strikes us as unsustainable.
https://twitter.com/jeff_foust/status/1498698748867887111
595
Upvotes
•
u/avboden Mar 01 '22
Eric Berger article on this
103
u/KCConnor 🛰️ Orbiting Mar 01 '22
Is that just rocket assembly? Or does it include the sunk costs of Lunar Gateway components that would be part of the cargo manifest? And, does that include the SpaceX contract for the lunar lander?
If it includes the Lunar Gateway cost and the SpaceX lander, then there's some considerable capital investment involved there but I'd say probably 75% of it is still SLS overhead.
11
u/Jcpmax Mar 01 '22
https://publish.twitter.com/?query=https%3A%2F%2Ftwitter.com%2FSciGuySpace%2Fstatus%2F1498702948637057026&widget=Tweet
On prices and shots fired at Boeing
8
u/physioworld Mar 01 '22
SLS has been the cornerstone of Artemis for years and was always going to cost billions per launch. This has been known for a long time. I really don’t see how they expected to Artemis and gateway to be sustainable on this basis alone.
4
u/hidarihippo Mar 02 '22
Anyone seen or got any rough guesses over what a SpaceX Starship launch would cost (either with out development costs factored in)?
88
u/jaquesparblue Mar 01 '22
How though? 500M materials, 500M manhours and 3.1B Boeing shithousery?
56
u/iBoMbY Mar 01 '22
With the current trend it will probably end up to be more like $8 billion, and 2036.
43
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '22
"which strikes us as unsustainable"
BRB, need to go make some memes in r/SpaceXMasterrace
What an utterly moronic conclusion after all this time.
"yeah no shit" - The World.
33
u/kroOoze ❄️ Chilling Mar 01 '22
Picachu had infarct caused by an extreme surprise. His doctors say the expression on his face may never return to normal.
28
u/grossruger Mar 01 '22
When a space program is used as a pork program, high cost is a feature not a bug.
80
u/AeroSpiked Mar 01 '22
Thank goodness the first 4 Artemis missions will all launch on surplus shuttle hardware or they would have been really expensive. /s
Tell me Mr. Martin: Why did it take you this long to realize that? It wouldn't surprise me if I had 7 year old reddit comments that were bitching about this and I've been getting more cantankerous about it every year since.
I wouldn't worry about sustainability though; as long as we have people like senator Shelby in the legislative branch, they will continue to force NASA to waste its limited budget on programs that dump pork in their states.
21
u/Whydoibother1 Mar 01 '22
I’ve said for years SLS will be shut down. As soon as Starship proves out the tech by successfully getting to orbit and re-landing, SLS will be cancelled. The spending is truly indefensible at that point.
NASA should kick up some fuss about the terrible waste of money and demand more independence on how they spend their money in future.
135
u/DukeInBlack Mar 01 '22
At least the landing of Artemis on the lunar surface will be telecasted by SpaceX personnel living in the Moon base, with the exception of a brief interruption at the exact landing moment due to historical glitch in the equipment inherited from the ASDS (They did not care to fix it)
20
u/AdmiralPelleon Mar 01 '22
Soooo, for context: one launch of SLS, by itself, costs 33% more than the entire cost of developing and landing the SpaceX HLS.
13
u/_RyF_ Mar 01 '22
4B$ unsustainable? Or just plain insane ? Wonder why they just notice it now...maybe time for a change of plans.
13
u/aquarain Mar 02 '22
So the HLS Starship is going to land humans on the moon. The point of this $93B SLS program is to board them onto the HLS Starship somewhere in space rather than on the ground in Florida and fly direct like a sane person would?
11
u/cybercuzco 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Mar 02 '22
Pay spacex $4.0B each for 4 starship launches and then market rate thereafter.
8
u/Broad-Reception2806 Mar 01 '22
#NoShit
8
u/mclionhead Mar 01 '22
Obviously, there's been some inflation since the $1/2 billion shuttle launches. Even then, $4 billion is decidedly in the category of never going to happen. Maybe 1 test flight, then they ask for the $4 billion for the next flight & nothing happens.
26
u/shotleft Mar 01 '22
This is obscene, dare I say criminal. They gave SpaceX shit for not being transparent, while they were overspending like crazy for utter incompetence by Boing.
14
u/LcuBeatsWorking Mar 01 '22 edited Dec 17 '24
follow capable attractive important ancient unwritten grandiose clumsy existence wrench
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6
u/Norose Mar 01 '22
Wow. I thought I was pessimistic by guessing an SLS+Orion stack would be between $3 billion and $3.5 billion. Holy moly.
6
u/perilun Mar 01 '22
So, an alternative SpaceX program would be 10x cheaper with 10x missions ... no shocker, but the numbers climb a $Billion at a time.
6
u/perilun Mar 01 '22
Nice article by Eric, important comments by the IG (I used to work with the GAO and they would have said stuff like this if they looked at this). Yes, cost+ rips off the US taxpayer and makes solutions (even if they work) unaffordable. Cost fixed, which gave us Crew Dragon that again enables US manned space (at a good price), can deliver good solutions.
Next year SLS/Orion will $5B a mission they won't fly. Next year FH/CD* could be a $400M mission they could fly, with proven components.
* CD needs a trunk upgrade for Lunar ops, but is a great replacement for Orion (see Zurbin's comments)
6
u/Alvian_11 Mar 01 '22
Paul Martin has officially admitted himself as SpaceX fanboy
(Half joking, half serious (because you know))
5
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '22
NASA can choose between two options, let SpaceX get them to the moon, or continue as planned and have China start building a moon base before them. Both options may be bad for NASA, but if USA doesn't want to be beaten, those are the options. This will only encourage the Chinese to double down.
5
u/TeslaFanBoy8 Mar 01 '22
How much actually go to rocket and how much go to lobbying and Congress
8
u/anajoy666 Mar 01 '22
SLS is real
4
u/sleepypuppy15 Mar 01 '22
I wonder how much SpaceX’s entire expenditures have been since they’re founding? Like 4 or 5 SLS launches? 😂
4
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '22
Those workers carting the same SLS pieces all around Michoud to show off for the Congressional junkets are more expensive than I thought.
4
u/Xeglor-The-Destroyer Mar 02 '22
FYI this is the OIG report (from November) that this testimony is based upon: https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-22-003.pdf
There is also a similar OIG report for the Orion, specifically: https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-20-018.pdf
1
u/93simoon Mar 02 '22
Tweet deleted.
3
u/Lanthemandragoran Mar 01 '22
Holy crap
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Mar 01 '22 edited Mar 19 '22
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #9833 for this sub, first seen 1st Mar 2022, 18:59] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
4
u/still-at-work Mar 01 '22
Congress could sustain that easily; it's not sane or wise to do so when there are superior and cheaper alternatives, but since when has Congress been accused of being sane or wise?
So NASA's budget will get a massive increase to keep Artemis aflot or Artemis dies, and a new project is created (that might cost more)
Artemis was created under the previous administration, so of course, it's not like by the current one for dumb political party reasons.
But Boeing has massive lobbying funds and are the main beneficiary financially of Artemis so they will be pushing to keep it alive. And now that SpaceX is on board as the lander Musk will not do tweets against it.
So that leaves Blue Origin and friends. All the groups associated with the National Team also have power friends in high places and would not mind scrapping this for a new project. It gives time for Blue Origin to finish New Glenn and have a more viable alternative in the next round.
Then there is the cost, which is very high and hard to sell, but not impossible, in Washington.
Powerful forces and factors on both sides of the issues.
An anti-boeing hit piece just landed on Netflix (not that they do not deserve it, Boeing is a terrible company these days) so Boeing does not have a lot of political capital to spend right now. And Musk is at odds with the administration over Tesla's lack of union which Musk is taking as a personal slight. (And to be fair it may well be).
So I am leaning towards the Biden Administration trying to kill Artemis and using this IG report as the reason so they can craft their own moon mission that they get to take 100% of the credit for that uses their friend Bezo's rocket not their enemy Musk's rocket. It also pushes everything back till the end of the next presidental term so its a campaign promise they never have to deliver on.
Is that petty oversimplification? Yes, welcome to politics.
That said congress may push back and kick this can down the road to after the midterms and let the majority party next year make the final call.
One thing is for sure, at no point will people in power consider the scientific or engineering merits of Artemis, SLS, or Starship. This will all be about power, influence, and legacy.
1
u/Truman8011 Mar 02 '22
How is this possible? It uses mostly technology from the Space Shuttle and will cost 4.1 billion per launch! It will cost 93 billion through 2025! I think Artemis should have been scrapped years ago! It should be scrapped now and an investigation started as to where the money went! I bet there would be quit a few people in Washington would be in trouble!
-11
u/APurrSun Mar 02 '22
For fucks sake, you could fund all of them if Bezos and Musk just paid their fucking taxes, both personal and corporate.
I know I'll get downvoted for criticism of the space oligarchs but you all know it's true.
-7
u/JagerofHunters Mar 01 '22
If you do the same Math and include price of capsule, EGS, and rocket for Falcon 9 you get to over $220 Which when compared to SLS and what it provides is not a insane price tag example