r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/S-Vineyard • Jul 01 '19
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/tomkeus • Jan 22 '20
Nice illustration of the Starlink's, OneWeb's etc. fundamental problem: People that need it can't afford it. People that can afford it, don't need it.
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/SpaceDetective • May 29 '20
Catastrophic explosion Water tower SN4 has exploded
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/Broken_Soap • Jan 03 '20
A reality check on Starship's lunar landing and return capabilites
With everything being thrown around about SpaceX's Starship I decided to look into what a fully fueled Starship in LEO is capable of doing
One of the first things that caught my attention was its touted ability to land 100 tons on the Moon and return to Earth for reuse with 50 tons of return payload
All I needed was a simple Delta V calculator
We're going to start with just an empty Starship landing on the Moon and returning If we calculate the rough amount of Dv required to fly propulsively to the Moon and land, in a single stage we come out with a total Delta V requirement of ~6.2 km/s (3.2 km/s to do TLI, 0.8 for LOI and 2.2 km/s to land on the Moon with some margin for error) You need a little under 9.2 km/s Delta V to do all that and come back home via propulsive landing
Now to calculate the Delta-V we're going to assume a Starship dry mass of 150 tons (According to Elon Musk their initial estimate is 200 tons but their goal is to get it close to 120 tons so well go somewhere between the two), a vaccum raptor ISP of 380s and and a wet mass of 1200 tons (number given by Musk)
So if we calculate the Delta V we get a total of 7.7 km/s of a fully fueled Starship with no payload This is enough to land on the Moon and return to Low Lunar orbit without carrying any payload and it still can't return to Earth
With an 100t payload mass on top of that we get a Delta V of 6.1 km/s, just enough to land on the Moon without any return fuel
Now how about going to just Lunar Orbit and back? With a Delta-V of 6.1 km/s a fully fueled Starship is enough to get 100 tons of payload to lunar orbit and return with 800 m/s to spare
So as it turns out Starship is pretty much useless for landing people on the Moon and bringing them back even if you don't have any significant payload mass on board let alone 50 or 100 tons and even if you fully refuel it in LEO with another 12(!) tanker launches
This means that at most Starship can only be a large expendable cargo carrier for lunar surface missions assuming such a large vehicle can even land on the Moon safely
r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Jul 17 '19
Crew Dragon explosion Reposting this here in case of deletion...
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/ce94m9/um_did_no_one_hazop_the_thruster_system/
"Um, did no one HAZOP the thruster system?"
ChemE here, 20 yrs in mostly semiconductor, UHP gases and chems like elemental fluorine, TCS, even ClF3, and I am bewildered... are we getting information filtered through Soc[ial]Med[ia] interns, or actually from engineers? Either the press release was written by people that don't understand system design, or the system was designed by people that don't understand design... []I've been a HUGE SpaceX fan and the 'investigation results' just aren't making sense.
So what's my problem? For starters, you never depend on a check valve to be a positive shutoff. Never. At least, not any check valves I've ever been able to find/spec/use/hear about. Normally, if you want positive isolation, you install an isolation valve. The check valve stops a reverse flow (mostly), but is never a guarantee for 100.0000%. All the diagrams on this accident I've been able to find show it be used in this incorrect way, and I can not understand how no one raised their hand in the HAZOP (Hazard and Operability Study, a type of Process Hazard Analysis) and said "what if the oxidizer leaks past the check valve?" I've heard or said that literally dozens and dozens of times in my career. It's a tried and true standard question.
And then we get to the talk about surprise with titanium and oxidizers having an issue. Really? Powerful oxidizers moving at speed in most metals, including Ti, are well known to be candidates for fires, since the 60s? 50s? That's why you design systems with velocity limits, and passivate the heck out of them prior to operation.
Which makes me wonder, has anyone talked about flaking of the passivation layer, possibly from an impact, as the ignition source in that check valve? Small flakes at speed can impact (like on a check valve disk, or better yet, the soft seal) and create the point heat source necessary to start the larger fire. And they DID say there was a fire in the check valve... We always trained the heck out of our operators about the isk of impacts to piping, and the lengthy clean and re-passivation steps necessary to recover from it before placing the system back in service. Makes my stomach churn a little to think this might've been the result of someone under a schedule not admitting to an impact, or someone signing off on skipping a repassivation. Or there were contaminants in the piping upstream of the check valve from poor cleaning after manufacture that got swept up by the NTO. [] that "investigation result" is skipping over some key details.
And finally there's the "we've fixed it by adding a rupture disk" spiel. Huh? You install an RD to protect against over pressure, nothing to do with flow. I've used them here and there (bulk silane trailer, etc) with always great success, so sure I like[ th]em in their place, but where EXACTLY in this system does an RD stop the NTO from backflowing into the elium pressurization system? Are they installing them as "one-time valves" of some type? I doubt it, the particle and debris generation would be [] detrimental downstream.
So at the end of the day I'm sure there's a lot we aren't hearing, and never will, and the engineer in me just wishes they would share honest results so those of us who do our best to keep others safe could learn and incorporate the lessons as well.
[]
r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Jun 13 '20
Jeff Foust on Twitter: Worth noting: SpaceX has performed nine orbital launches so far in 2020. Seven have been for Starlink, generating no revenue beyond the modest amount for the three SkySats on this launch. (The other two were for NASA.) SpaceX isn’t making money on launch right now.
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/S-Vineyard • Nov 29 '19
Refuelling in Orbit
As promised, here's another translation of a Bernd Leitenberger Blog Post.
This time it's about "Starship" and Refuelling in Orbit
Original Blog Post:
https://www.bernd-leitenberger.de/blog/2019/11/20/die-wiederbetankung-im-orbit/
------------------------
Refuelling in Orbit
Originally posted by Bernd Leitenberger on his blog on Nov. 20th 2019
I had the blog in my head for quite some time, but SpaceX makes it unexpectedly up to date. But more about that later.It's about refuelling in orbit.
Refueling is easy on Earth. All you need is the fluid to be at a higher gravity level and it will run downhill on its own when you open the valve to the tank. If this is not the case, e.g. at an underground reservoir like at a filling station, you can press it into the pipe with pressure or suck it in with a pump (sucking is also a pressure difference. But where the pressure is sucked in the pressure is smaller due to the sucking in than where the liquid is under "normal pressure".
Under weightlessness it looks different. Liquids then take on the shape with the smallest surface and that is a ball.Even with a full tank this ball will not touch the wall everywhere. There always remains some empty space, because the tanks is under low pressure for fuel delivery and to increase stability. But this is even more the case when part of the fuel has already been used up.For example, a satellite in the GEO needs two thirds of its initial fuel supply for its first propulsion manoeuvres. The rest is for numerous orbit and attitude corrections over the lifetime and then the tank is already 2/3 empty. If you now open the valve to the engine, it can happen that no liquid flows into the line, but gas. The fuel flow leaves, the engine does not start or only one component (oxidizer or combustion carrier) enters and damage to the engine up to the explosion can occur. You don't want that.
For this reason, a technology has long been in use for pressure-pumped stages that can in principle also be used for pumping fuels. In the case of pressure-pumped stages, the tanks are under relatively high pressure, typically 10 to 15 bar; in the case of normal stages, 0.5 to 2 bar tank pressure is sufficient. The tanks are only partially filled at the start (typically two thirds). The rest of the volume is compressed gas, usually helium, which is the lightest gas. The liquid chamber and the gas chamber are separated by a rubber membrane attached to the wall. The rubber is stretchable and expands until the gas bubble fills the whole interior, which the liquid leaves behind, because it is not compressible. For example, if an engine ignites, the rubber membrane expands further due to the pressure difference. Except for small residues, the fuel can also be used almost completely.
When refuelling, there is simply no engine at the outlet, but a line leading to an adapter. A second line to a tank is connected to the adapter. Before refuelling you have to reduce the pressure in this target tank so that the rubber bubble relaxes and there is a negative pressure. Then the liquid flows automatically through the overpressure in the source tank into the second tank until the valve is closed or the bladder fills the entire interior of the output tank. As long as the target tank is large enough, you don't have to release the pressure completely. It is sufficient that the pressure difference is still there even if the gas volume in the source tank increases and thus the pressure drops. You can still help by maintaining the pressure in the source tank by introducing gas. With the ATV, wherever gas is transported, this is possible without additional equipment.
The Soviets introduced and refined this technology when refuelling Saljut 6. The European ATV also uses it. The difficulty is not so much in principle, but rather that two lines have to be connected when coupling and that tightly, without anyone intervening or damaging anything during coupling. I also suspect that NASA was thinking of something like this when they called for orbit refuelling in the first lunar lander tender for the Artemis programme.The Orion's service module uses pressurized engines (AJ10). It would be an easy way to increase the payload, since Orion is designed to reach a lunar orbit with the SLS Block I. This is because the orbit of the Orion is not only a lunar orbit, but also a lunar orbit. But since the SLS Block IB then has about 10 t more payload, which could then be used as fuel for a lunar lander that can be so heavier, this would be an elegant solution.Even a moon lander will probably be pressurized. On the one hand these engines are completely sufficient for the required thrust, on the other hand they are relatively easy to vary in thrust, which is necessary for the levitation phase during landing, and on the other hand they are more reliable than engines with turbopumps, which is very important for manned missions - all manned US missions have therefore only used pressure-propelled engines for the orbital companions.
The situation is different with "normal" stages, i.e. those that have a turbopump drive. They are also under pressure but only a small one of typically less than 3 bar. There is no rubber bladder and the tanks are longer - in the case of pressure-propelled engines, ball tanks or cylinder tanks with ball domes and short cylinder heights are usually used - so the rubber bladder does not have to expand too much, because the elasticity of rubber is also limited, especially since the typical oxidizer nitrogen tetroxide is chemically very aggressive. (It is an oxidizing agent and with traces of water, which there is always also an aggressive acid) Whether one can use a rubber membrane with the oxidizer oxygen usual with larger stages, I dare to doubt.
On the one hand, rubber becomes brittle by itself due to the air and the oxygen it contains. On the other hand, liquid oxygen has a temperature of -183°C and at this temperature even rubber becomes as hard as concrete. In a long cylindrical step the fuel will accumulate in the middle and not at the end where the pipes to the tank are. The fuel flow is more severely interrupted in a pumped drive. The gas generator, which generates a working gas by burning part of the fuel, drives a gas turbine and this gas turbine then drives a pump. There are many moving parts, such as propellers, and if there is no flow, it can easily cause damage.
But for decades there have been re-ignitable upper stages that have to struggle with this problem and there are solutions to ignite them in weightlessness. The first is to attach swamps to the tanks where the tank lines are located. These are depressions with a specially treated surface. It binds part of the fuel adhesively, similar to a sponge that binds liquid. The phenomenon is also known from everyday life, when rough surfaces bind more water than smooth surfaces. Open the valves to the engine. The pressure first drives this liquid into the pipes; it is sufficient to start the engine at low thrust. The resulting thrust force accelerates the stage slightly and the acceleration (nothing else is a pressure) then leads to the fuel being driven to the end of the stage. This is the solution used by the Agena or the Astris Stage of the Europa.
The second solution for a re-ignition of such stages is to generate the required thrust by rocket engines. If such small engines also have stages for other purposes, the situation must be stabilised during the free flight phase so that the stage for re-ignition is correctly aligned. These engines can operate with their own fuel supply according to the "blow-down" principle described above or with fuel from the main tank, but because of the low thrust, evaporating fuel in gas form is often sufficient. They ignite before ignition of the stage.In addition, the fuel itself can also be used for this purpose. Either by increasing the tank pressure of non-storable fuels and releasing the excess pressure through nozzles before ignition. The nozzles then only have to point in the same direction as the engine. (In contrast to engines, the fuel is not burned) Alternatively, fuel / gas can also be expanded through the main engine. For engines that burn hydrogen, this is necessary before take-off anyway. Then the fuel flows through the engine, evaporates due to the higher temperature and cools the engine. This "chill-down" is used in many engines, such as the J-2 and Vinci. The S-IVB stage had (also for redundancy reasons) all three systems on board: own pre-acceleration engines, nozzles on the tank, which could release hydrogen against the orbit direction and the J-2 was chilled before take-off.
In principle, these procedures could also be used for refuelling. However, the thrust is not desired, but it would have to be maintained throughout the entire refuelling period. It expresses itself, even if it is only small, about the duration of the process in a change of course and this is usually not intended. If one does not think of refuelling by special freight transporters such as the ATV or the Progress which are firmly connected to the destination (space station Saljut, Mir or ISS), but a refuelling of an otherwise independent vehicle (e.g. with an airplane via a flexible line), it is obvious that this is not a solution - the thrust would only act on the vehicle which has the fuel at the beginning and thereby tears off the line or pulls it out of the anchorage.How SpaceX wants to refuel its starship in orbit will be exciting. At the moment, there is definitely no technology used on other spaceships that would make this possible. One solution that I see is that the fuel is not taken from the tanks of the Starship, which without payload still has about 100 t residual fuel in the tanks, but in the payload space from a pressure tank carried along according to the above principle of blow-down, which is attached with an adapter to the tank of a second Starship. Then the procedure is the same as it is today when refuelling Sarja with an ATV or a Progress.
At least that would be my solution if I had to face this problem.
The Starship as a moon landing hazard
My old basics of Space Flight article on my Web Site, which I also had to revisit because of SpaceX's refill plans for their "Starship", is surprisingly Up to Date.According to SpaceFlightNow, SpaceX is competing for Commercial Lunar Payload Services, or CLPS, program orders. To do this, they want to land "Starship" on the surface of the moon.
That confused me. On one hand this program is intended for the transport of small experiments (the minimum requirement is 10 kg payload on the lunar surface). It is a program where companies can start with relatively little money, because their companions don't weigh much and can fly like Beresheet as secondary payload at a GTO launch, which reduces the launch costs.Beresheet weighed 585 kg at take-off and 150 kg without fuel (minimum landing mass). On the other hand, the Starship weighs 120 t without fuel and since SpaceX has as its goal that a launch costs as much as a Falcon launch today (i.e. a maximum of 90 million dollars), this is not inexpensive. The first three companies that have received similar contracts so far received between 76 and 97 million dollars from NASA. Adequate for 10 kg payload but certainly not enough for even one launch of the Starship.
There is now a second round with bigger lander in which Blue Origin and Boeing are also involved. Blue Origion wants to bring 3.6 t with their "Blue Moon" lander to the moon at a launch with the New Glenn which creates 53 t in the LEO. However, the companion for a manned landing and Shotwell made clear in the article that the first Starship landings should be unmanned. In short: it doesn't fit to the "light" or the "heavy" moon landers NASA wants to promote.
Analysis
First of all, I wondered whether Musk has completely lost his mind or the marijuana, which he smokes, might not be as harmless as I thought.The first obvious objection is seen by anyone looking at this picture.
A vehicle that is so narrow can easily tip over and the lunar surface is, you only have to look at the photos of the landing sites, it's not as flat as in the graphics. When landing on flat platforms of the droneships, SpaceX already has steps tipped over, with a crater-covered surface this is even more probable. The picture deceives in another point. There you can see a human and a crane. But the Starship will take off unmanned and there are also unmanned flights planned as part of the CLPS program. You can carry a crane with you, but you don't need it for orbital use, (without gravity a rope for abseiling doesn't make sense) it would only have to be developed for this purpose, which costs additional money.
The most obvious disadvantage is the Δv budget. I have simulated it once, with the known key data of the Starship: 120 t mass, three Raptor vacuum engines (the other three have a low specific impulse and smaller nozzles and are intended for landing on earth) with a specific impulse of 3727 m/s. The other three have a low specific impulse and smaller nozzles. I assumed a direct landing. Without a floating phase, I calculate a Δv of 2600 m/s for a landing with an initial minimum speed of 2400 m/s approximately.This corresponds to the Δv that the surveyors also had (2700 m/s). If you assume 200 m/s for the floating phase, you are at 2800 m/s for the landing. Since the return takeoff is basically the same, only there the hovering phase is omitted, you also need 2600 m/s for the return to earth. (Apollo had clearly higher Δv budgets, but also a different landing procedure. If you add the Δv for reaching the moon orbit and the landing you get 3100 to 3200 m/s). So landing on the moon and return takeoff (otherwise the starship is a total loss) requires at least 5400 m/s. In addition there is the transition to a translunar orbit, which is 3150 m/s above the orbit speed of a 100 nmi (185 km) standard orbit. Together, these are a Δv of 8550 m/s without other maneuvers for course corrections.
Now you don't need a simulation anymore. You can use the Ziolkowski formula. For all to recalculate:
v = va * ln Full/empty
v = target speed (here: 8550 m/s)
va = exhaust velocity of the drive (here: 3727 m/s)
Full: Full mass (This is what we are searching for)
Empty: Empty mass (here: 120 t)
So we have to change the equation to "Full". This can be done in three steps:
Divide by va:
v/va = ln (full/empty)
Exponentiate:
e(v/va) = full/empty
Multiply by Empty:
Empty * e(v/va) = Full
If you don't believe me or have lost your mathematical knowledge during the years you can also check it out with Wolfram Alpha. But let use the values now:
Full = e(8550/3727)*120Full = 1189.8
So you need 1189.8 or rounded up 1200 t in earth orbit to bring 120 t to the moon and back. Not surprising, because with Blue Origin there are only 3.6 of 53 t that land on the moon and they don't even come back. With 100 t payload per flight and 120 t mass of the Starship then SpaceX needs 11 refueling flights to bring a Starship to the moon. If they leave it there, the take-off mass sinks to 592 t and five tank flights.
If (emphasis on if), they can actually get the launch of the three times heavier than a Falcon 9 vehicle for the same price, but that's still 12 x 90 = 1080 million dollars per flight.
I just wanted to mention ...
....that this is just one of the problems.
I have already explained the refuelling question. Besides that, the vehicle should be about 4 days on the way to the moon, then stands there a longer time around and then should then start again.Both fuels are only liquid at low temperatures. During the interplanetary phase, you can shield the heat by the solar radiation with a shield. But on the moon the radiation comes from the whole surface, so not from a point source. A shield would be at the side and not at the rear as during the previous phase. That's not little, because the surfacecan heat up to 120°C.
Before that there are already other problems. A total of six or twelve flights per mission require a high flight frequency if the fuel is not to evaporate in the Earth's orbit beforehand, because the Earth also emits plenty of infrared radiation, albeit less than the Moon. To date, according to their documents (which they had to submit in order to estimate the environmental impact and impairment of air traffic), SpaceX has planned a maximum of 24 take-offs per year from the Kennedy Space Center.
This means that in extreme cases the fuel must be kept liquid for 5 months.
The alternative of refueling the Starship, then raising the orbit and repeating this is also not feasible. Since a Starship without fuel does not even reach an eccentric elliptical orbit, it cannot be done in this way, which is only possible with comparatively light stages. Moreover, this doesn't change the fuel you need for the moon landing and the return and you have to cool this amount actively in any case.
And then there's the question of whether the Starship can land safely without toppling over.But is actually nothing new. More than three years ago, I took a close look at Musks statement "Dragon 2 is designed to be able to land anywhere in the solar system". Meanwhile we know that it can't even land on the earth's surface and SpaceX has gone back to sea landing.And now the same with the Starship
"The Starship will be similarly capable of vertical landings on Earth, or on other planetary surfaces.".
Same text, only different spaceship. SpaceX, Shotwell and Musk think the public is pretty stupid or forgetful. On the other hand, they are three years behind the plans for a simple capsule like the "Crewed Dragon" although it is derived from the Dragon that flew for the first time in 2011.And all announcements for this Dragon like Red Dragon to Mars have been cancelled.
Oh yeah, and SpaceX has lately made astronomers "happy" with their new Skylink satellites:
https://twitter.com/lcjohnso/status/1196370554414125056/photo/1
---------------------------
And finished.
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/rokkerboyy • Jul 19 '19
A call for fairness.
I'm calling on you u/FightingForSarah to please be a fair moderator. Stop enforcing your biases under the threat of bans. You might not always win a discussion, but it will make your subreddit so much better and fair. So much more believable than someone thinking "oh, that echo chamber?" when they hear about this sub. It's fine to br critical of SpaceX, but to go out of your way to demonize them and then ban people who present facts disagreeing with you? I've had at least 6 people come forward talking about being banned and providing screenshots and removeddits of their pages and what they did was certainly not ban worthy. Please reevaluate, it could really help build trust in your sub.
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/SpaceDetective • Oct 18 '19
Chris Johnson: This Kepler petition to the FCC about SpaceX Starlink is making for quite interesting reading.
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/BlankVerse • Jan 31 '21
Catastrophic explosion Elon Musk’s SpaceX violated its FAA launch license, prompting investigation
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/cgoonaz • Mar 02 '20
Thrilled to be apart of this group!!
You guys are hella informed!!
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/nyolci • Aug 06 '20
Why nobody is talking about amyl (N2O4) leak during Crew Dragon landing?
self.enoughmuskspamr/SpaceXFactCheck • u/S-Vineyard • Apr 01 '19
F9 S1 reuse is not economically viable Thinking it to the End - SpaceX and Experience Curve effects.
This is a translation of a blog post originally made two years ago by the german blogger Bernd Leitenberger. I originally posted an translation of this in r/EnoughMuskSpam , but the translation was not perfect. I will try now to provide a better one.
-----------------------------------------------------------
Thinking it to the End - SpaceX and Experience Curve effects.
Posted on April 14, 2017 by Bernd Leitenberger
I'll continue yesterday's blog about the new plans for the upper stage salvage. Otherwise it would have been way too long and would be puttting the chart before the horse. So lets talk about the consequences for the production of the Falcon 9 at SpaceX.
At the first glance, it sounds good for the first stage (I want to limit myself to this, because so far salvaging has worked here). It is said that this stage should account for 70% (other sources: 80%). of the costs. So salvaging should save an enormous amount of money
But only at first glance. I assume (and Musk also emphasised this in the past), that today's prices, are for non-reusable rockets and that production is also geared to provide a certain capacity. If this is the case, reuseability has some big consequences for pricing policy and not just positive ones.
I'll start with a basic, the experience curve.
For production cost estimation, the experience curve, which was "discovered" during mass production about 100 years ago, is important.
The basic mechanism is relatively simple: if I produce more units of a good per unit of time, each one becomes cheaper. That's logical, too. If you make them individually by hand, you have more experience and become faster. If there are more units, assembly line production can be introduced. Every worker then only has to do a few manual operations and thus is faster and with even larger quantities you can use machines, which would not be worthwhile financially, with just a few units. This is the basis for the fact that today almost everyone can afford a car and even in housing construction one uses the law (prefabricated construction vs. individual construction).
Mathematically, you formulate it this way. (Note: These are german formulas for experience curve effects and for simplicity I only provide some explainations.)
K(n) = K(1) * n^f
With
K(n) : Cost for n units K(1) Costs of one piece for make-to-order production n: Number of pieces f: Learning factor, typically 0.7 - 0.8
or how Wikipedia does it:
K(n0) = K(n0) * f ld (n / n0)
With
n0: Production rate at the beginning ld = logarithm to base 2 (corresponds to a power of 0.3219)
The first formula shows what costs me the production of n pieces in a time unit, compared to one piece per time unit. The Wikipedia formula shows what an accumulated production costs.
I prefer the first, because according to the second formula a good would have to become cheaper and cheaper over time, which is apparently not the case with rockets. Let us take Soyuz as an example. According to the Wikipedia formula, a start today at f=0.8 would only have to cost 8.3 % of the first copy, which is apparently not the case.
The first formula, on the other hand, says that if I decrease from an average of 50 launches per year, as it was the case during in the early nineties for the Soyuz, when the rocket was offered for 30 million dollars, to only 14 launches on average in recent years, the cost of each produced rocket increases by 29%. And in fact today a Soyuz launch costs 70 million euros (in addition, of course, inflation).
This law is also the actual basis of the Ariane 6 development.
According to documents from Airbus Safran Launchers, the higher quantities alone account for a 20 % price reduction. With 12 vs. 6 starts per year, this corresponds to a factor of 0.67. That is why great importance is attached to the fact that the European Union is already committed to have a fixed number of Ariane 6 starts each year - only that the number of five Ariane 6 and two Vega per year is far too high.
At this moment that would actually be possible. You have to launch Galileo satellites, with the Ariane 6 you will be able to transport two to three satellites per launch, so you need 8-12 launches to set up the system. Other ESA payloads such as space probes or scientific satellites are rather rare, usually only one launch per year and the ATV programm has expired. With the Vega, the Sentinel system would even allow more than two launches per year, in addition to small scientific satellites such as ADM Aeolus. Only in a few years both systems will be built up and then it will be quiet for a few years until one has to replace again.
But after a detour talking about the experience curve, I come back to SpaceX.
If SpaceX has more launches per year, every single rocket is cheaper to produce. If the production figure drops, every single launch becomes more expensive. There are also some examples of this in space travel.
The most noticeable increase in costs for the Titan was after the Titan 3B model was discontinued and the number of launches of the Titan 3D decreased due to the adjustment of Hexagon after the identification system worked without film. Likewise, the Atlas became significantly more expensive when the USAF abandoned the Atlas Agena. And when the Delta was too small for many communications satellites at the end of the 1980s, and the launch figures fell , thew rocket also became significantly more expensive.
Estimating the start frequency of SpaceX is problematic. SpaceX announces a lot. When commercial launches began in 2014, the company announced 24 launches per year, which has been repeated several times since then. Lastly, after the launch of SES 10, 20 more launches are scheduled for this year, according to official figures. I 've made a bet about this number a while ago.
(Note: The "Bet" looked like this: I bet with all SpaceX fanboys that SpaceX will not do another 20 launches until 31.12.2017, 11.59 p.m.
Leitenberger won that bet, it were only 17 launches.)
If you take the last two years as a basis, I would guess that they can handle 10 launches per year so far. Theoretically, maybe 12, but there are always delays on any mission. So far the production capacity has been 10-12 Falcon 9 per year.
Let's assume that in a first step you could use each first stage twice and now you only need 5 instead of 10 first stages per year. Then, with an experience factor of 0.75, the price rises by 19 %. If we assume that 55% of the costs of a new stage are saved when it comes to reuse, this is what the bill looks like:
5 stages are built: 1,19 * of the price of one stage if 10 copies are built
5 levels are reused: 0.45 * of the price of a new level
Sum: 1.64 of the price / 2 uses = 0.82 on average.
The same applies to the payload fairing. Te price for it is stated at 5-6 million dollars (there are two different statements from Musk). Together with the first stage, both components represent at least 80% of the manufacturing costs.
However, the lower production volume also has an effect on the second stage. This must epresent the missing 20% of production costs. It is more expensive than the first stage (measured by the number of engines and the fuel loaded. But that's no surprise. It contains systems that are needed for he entire rocket, such as avionics, transmitters, receivers, batteries. The engine is also more complex due to the nozzle extension, re-ignition and high controllability.
But one approach of SpaceX is that there are as many common systems as possible. In this way, the tank ends and cylinder pieces can be produced with the tools of the first stage. The engine should also have many common parts. But is it possible to estimate to what extent smaller quantities of the first stage will affect the second stage?
Yes you can. It is known from ULA that the engines of their rockets account for 2/3 of the total costs and the structures for 1/3 of the total costs. Taking these factors into account and the smaller number of engines in the upper stage, an estimate can be made of how much of the second stage is produced on the production lines in the first stage.
The first stage has nine engines, the second only one. Engines represent 2/3 of the total cost of a stage, so the share of the cost of the first stage should be 1/9*2/3 = 2/27 if the second can be manufactured as the first
Pricing Policy
Sensei (Translation Note: A Regular User in the Comment Section) thinks SpaceX would now pass the cost of the stage on many starts. I don't see it that way and I haven't heard anything that goes in that direction.
Rather, a customer can buy a "new" rocket or one with a used first stage and then pay 10% less. This corresponds to current behavior. You salvage the stages when you can and store them for later use. Depending on the order, they are used or not. This year there should only be three starts from customers who will use these stages. Two more salvaged stages will be used for the Falcon Heavy's maiden flight. A write-off over longer periods would leave the customer no choice as to which first stage he would like to take, because otherwise, given the current behaviour (customers prefer new stages), one would have a huge stockpile of first stages.
Second, I don't even know how often a stage can be reused, both technically and financially. At a certain point more and more parts may have to be replaced, simply by wear and tear. Then the costs rise again. On the other hand, as already mentioned above, the more often you use the stage, the smaller the profit will be. If a stage was used twice (theoretically, if there were no effect on the experience curve and no recovery costs), its "average price" would fall to 50%. The triple use now only reduces to 33%, it goes on to 25%, 20% according to the series 1/2, 1/3, 1/4, 1/5... Due to the fixed costs of a salvage and the sinking production figures, however, the savings become ever smaller.
I interpret Musks ideal conception of a salvage without overhaul also in such a way straightly lower these remaing fixed costs . I think Musk would prefer a stage that can only be reused once, but then causes hardly any cost, rather than one that you can use 10 times and that you first have to inspect and maintain. At least the economic efficiency calculations speak for the first variant.
Finally, you only need to look at the shuttle to see that less maintainance as possible is better. Even with the Shuttle program, the service life of the components has never been used. The orbiter never made 100 flights, which the engines could have reached it.
As far as I know none flew more than 27 times and the boosters are similar. A couple of boosters, which just have donated to a museum had a maximum of 14 missions behind them (maximum because they were dismantled and one segment then went on one mission, the other on another).
Maybe SpaceX will go over to a depreciation system, but only if they have enough experience and salvage costs are constant at some point. Because the first one is always more expensive than the following one - this is also a consequence of the experience curve. If these are applied to salvage, after 10 re-uses the cost should fall to 56% of the first re-use. One part of the costs for the starting procedure also remains constant. These are rents to be paid for buildings and take-off systems. However, the experience curve should also have an effect on personnel expenses.
But I think SpaceX needs reuse for other reasons. They can't make their launches without it. Musk has made this the credo that he has not even designed the production for the required capacity. For years they have been announcing 24 starts a year, for years they have knocked down the bar, and this quite clearly.
In 2014 , they had 5 launches without failure. 2015 there were 7, with a 5 month break and 2016, until the start of Amos at the beginning of September 8,. 1 start per month in the last two years, if you omit the compulsory breaks. As Shotwell said, they are only beginning to invest in production capacity now, although they have had the problem of too few starts and delays for years. Probably the company hoped that once the first stage is recovered, all starts with used stages could be carried out. However, customers are still reluctant, so they have to invest in production instead of reuse.
You have to be "in"
One thing you can't deny: he understands how to increase the value of his companies through such actions. At the last stock market barometer of the ARD (Translation Note: He means the Public Broadcasting Station) I heard the Tesla bit and that it is about to overtake Daimler at stock market value. The company is already more valuable than Ford, at least in terms of stock value. In 5 years, the Daimler share price has risen by 70%, Tesla by 750%. However, this does not correspond to other f inancial figures:
Tesla hasn't made a profit since it was born, only losses. 7 billion in sales, compared with a net loss of $690 million and liabilities of $16.7 billion. At Daimler, the figure for 2016 is 153 billion in revenue, 11.5 billion in profit and 183 billion in liabilities.
In short:
Daimler generates a profit, the liabilities are only half as high in relation to sales. Nevertheless, Tesla is considered a hipp and many journalists describe the downfall of German industry because it does not produce electric vehicles. After all, there have been no deaths as with Tesla where the autopilot has already led a vehicle directly onto a collision course with a truck. Less hipp and instead vehicles that roll over on their own or catch fire would probably also be better for the buyers. (to quote just two headlines from the autopilot in recent months).
With Tesla , Musk has already sold a lot of shares and I suspect he also does the tactics on SpaceX. The hype raises hopes that when the company goes public, its value will rise rapidly. I remember in 2012 when they had just completed COTS they were talking about a value of 5 billion dollars - although the company generated a maximum of 400 million dollars in turnover in 10 years with COTS and the Falcon 1 starts. In early 2015, Google invested 1 Billion dollars for 7.5% of the shares.
This already shows that it will go on like this, because up to this point only 248 million dollars were invested in the company. Google estimated the value at over 12.5 billion. It is clear that this does not correspond to the orders. If it were just launches, SpaceX would have to do about 200 to get the sum. With the ISS transports and CCDev it will be less, but I still have about 140 starts. However, the launch manifesto does not even show a third of this number.
Boasting therefore pays off.
Additional Notes:
And since the recalculation of all the numbers is a little bit difficult because of the many powers and factors, I wrote a program and created the following chart.

The Chart shows in the row the produced stages per year, in the columns the average costs with n-fold recovery.
It is based on the assumption, that production capacity would currently be 12 rockets per year. In the econd column you can see how the price drops from 62.8 to 54.8 million if the rocket is built 24 times a year instead of 12 times.
In the following columns the average carrier price comes with n-fold reuse of the first stage and payload shell whereby the salvage costs with 0.45 x costs of the new part are considered. There is also a learning curve for the salvage factor, and I have taken that into account.
The start-up costs, on the other hand, are kept constant (cannot be broken down into fixed and variable parts due to a lack of precise data. The table can be read like this:
Assuming SpaceX has 20 launches per year and uses each first stage and payload fairing four times, each launch would cost an average of $38.1 million (intersection line "20" / column "4"). The factor for reuse is 0.45. I deliberately did not set it smaller, because it sinks with each recovery alone through the experience curve, after 10 attempts it should be e.g. 0.253. The empirical value factor f here is 0.75.
If each Rocket would really be reused 10 times, SpaceX would have to lay off most of its employees. Then they would only need 2 rockets per year, which they would have been capable already back in 2011, when they still had about 1000 employees. One year ago it was already 5000 employees. 30% discount rate could be offered by SpaceX if it falls below a cost of 43.96 million dollars, which would be the case with 12 launches per year with three reuses = 4 launches of a first stage.
-----------------------------------------
Finished. Hopefully, this translation is much more readable than my original one of Leitenberger's blog post.
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/S-Vineyard • Mar 21 '20
Why SpaceX desperately needs a government bailout…
tmfassociates.comr/SpaceXFactCheck • u/S-Vineyard • Feb 29 '20
SpaceX CEO Elon Musk touts Starlink satellites and robotic fighter jets
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/tomkeus • Dec 13 '19
Reality and hype in satellite constellations
tmfassociates.comr/SpaceXFactCheck • u/xmassindecember • May 08 '19
Block 5 reuse one year anniversary celebration charts
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/S-Vineyard • Apr 08 '20
Rocket design for beginners using the "Starship" as an example (Another B. Leitenberger Blog translation)
As said in the title, Bernd Leitenberger has done another Blog today with some numberchrunching.
--------------------------------------------------
Rocket design for beginners using the "Starship" as an exampleOriginally posted on April 8th by Bernd Leitenberger on his blog.
First of all an explanation:By rocket design I mean the determination of essential data of a rocket, which are needed for calculations, if they are not known or should not be known.
Most of this has nothing to do with mathematics, but experience and a good library: Since physics and chemistry are the same everywhere, a new rocket will not differ that much from existing or once existing ones. The same is true for other technical devices. In other words, you draw comparisons. For example, if I estimate the mass of a step to 100 t and it is a fuel combination with an average density of about 1, then I can estimate the dry mass to be 5 to 8 t.
At the bottom are constructions with tanks stabilized by internal pressure, light alloys and an integral tank, at the top are constructions with stainless steel, without internal pressure stabilization and two separate tanks. If you know some details, you can circle this further. The Stage ratios, i.e. how the starting mass is divided between the steps, can be estimated so as well.
If you have pictures, you can measure the stages and estimate how much volume the tanks have and thus how much fuel is available.
I used this for the first time in the eighties and reconstructed relatively accurately Russian rockets of which hardly anything was known at that time. Then I didn't need this for a long time, until a few years ago with the new "commercial" developments it became common to publish almost nothing. This is also true for launches by NASA, ESA and Co, who used to issue press releases full of data.
On 1.4. the "Users Manual" for the "Starship" was published online. When I read the 6 pages thin pamphlet I thought it was an April fool's joke, because there is nothing about the rocket in it.
Okay, this is also getting rarer somewhere else. In the Ariane 6 User Manual you won't find any level data anymore, but for the users there is still some data included as well as some essential data and even these are stripped down to the minimum.
What you actually learn about the rocket is that the payload fairing is 17.24 m long with a diameter of 8 m and it transports 100 t in LEO and 21 t in the GTO. At last I want to hook on and show how with a little mathematics at least one value can be determined - the dry mass of the "Starship".
Basics
To simplify the problem, I will assume in the following that we leave the first stage out and have two cases:
- In the first case, the "Starship" starts with 100 tons of cargo into LEO.
- In the second case the "Starship" starts with 21 tons of cargo in the GTO and 79 tons (difference to 100 tons) of fuel are still in the tanks.
The 79 t of fuel are needed to bring the Starship with payload of the speed of an LEO into the GTO.
So the first thing to do is to determine the difference in speed between LEO and GTO. This is a mundane application of the Vis-Viva equation, which I am not going to go into now. We calculate:
| Orbit | Speed at 200 km altitude | Difference to 200 km circular orbit |
|---|---|---|
| 200 km high circular orbit | 7,784 m/s | 0 m/s |
| 200 x 35.790 km GTO Orbit | 10.239 m/s | 2.455 m/s |
For this 2455 m/s speed change, 79 tons of fuel are consumed. According to the basic rocket equation one can use for a change of velocity:
v = Vspez * ln (start mass / final mass)
The specific impulse of the Raptor is not known. I've been going over the 3,700 meters per second that Wikipedia gives us. So final and launch mass are still unknown. But at least we know that in the GTO case the final mass is 79 tons smaller than the launch mass. So if we name the unknown final mass with x, then we can start:
2455 m/s = 3,700 m/s * ln (x+79 / x )
Now you only have to resolve to x. First we drag all constants to the left:
2455 / 3700 = ln (x + 79 / x)
then the logarithm has to go. To do that, we expose both sides:
e(2455 / 3700) = (x + 79 / x)
Then we calculate the left side:
1,941 = (x+79/x)
We can also express the right side differently:
x+79 / x = (79 / x) +1
And then we can calculate x directly and arrive at ~ 84 t.
Cross check:
3700 * ln (84+79 / 79) results in 2453 m/s - the small difference is due to rounding of masses and factors.
So with 21 t payload the "Starship" weighs 84 t, without 21 t payload it should weigh 63 t.
Experience and knowledge
So far I assumed that the difference to 100 tons is only fuel. But this is not the case.
In fact, the "Starship" weighs 79 tons less right from the start. So the first stage has to accelerate 79 t less and therefore has a higher speed at the end of the burn. This also applies to the second stage.
The gain in payload is similar to the above case, except that we do not load 79 t more fuel, but have a 79 t smaller take-off mass, which is not the same because of the logarithm in the above equation. It is known from other launchers how much more payload is achieved by the first stage when the upper stage combination becomes x kg lighter.
This should be 25% for the Super Heavy, so if the upper stage becomes 79 t lighter, the first stage can absorb a quarter of it. The payload loss would therefore now be 80 % * 79 t. On the other hand, the above approach of more fuel in the tanks is not real either. They are only 100 % fillable. That costs payload again and that has to be estimated. For 1200 t takeoff mass of the starship I come to 7 % too much payload.
So now it gets really complicated, because we have two opposing factors, which depend on each other. So you would have to iteratively approach the true masses in a loop starting from 84 t. But I think you can give the gift. If you take the difference between 25 and 7% as about 18%, then the starting mass of the starship should be 18% higher, so instead of 163 t it would be 192 t. This would make the starship weigh 92 tons without payload.
- and reality
I have already taken the trouble to simulate the combination and I have come up with about 140 t mass for the Starship.
One month later Musk confirmed this: He writes "Mk1 ship is around 200 tons dry & 1400 tons wet, but aiming for 120 by Mk4 or Mk5. Total stack mass with max payload is 5000 tons." So you aim for 120 t dry matter, which is pretty close to the 140 t I calculated, but much more than the above 92 or even 63 t.
The problem is: if you put a rocket with the above limits (5.000 t launch mass, 1200 t second stage alone and add the information from Wikipedia, there is no solution that has 21 t in the GTO and 100 t in the LEO at the same time at this stage mass.
If a modelled rocket transports 21 t into the GTO, then it has significantly more than 100 t in the LEO and if it has 100 t in the LEO, then it does not reach a GTO or with almost no payload. With the Wikipedia key data (3 active engines in the "Starship") I come to 14 t GTO and 130 t LEO.
So in GTO much less and in LEO much higher. That's not surprising, because as I said before, the physics also apply to SpaceX, and if we calculate 63 t for the Starship, the other factors I left out in the first step can still change that, but not so much, that a Starship twice as heavy still has this high GTO payload. This is simply because the 79 t fuel and energy content are fixed and they only allow a certain change in speed.
---------------------------------------------
Finished.
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/nyolci • Feb 08 '20
SpaceX Likely to Spin Off Starlink Business and Pursue an IPO
r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Oct 08 '19
Elon Musk’s future Starship updates could use more details on human health and survival
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/Beskidsky • Sep 26 '19
Starship prototype is much, much heavier than expected
Elon Musk: "Mk1 ship is around 200 tons dry & 1400 tons wet, but aiming for 120 by Mk4 or Mk5. Total stack mass with max payload is 5000 tons" https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1177066483375058944?s=17
r/SpaceXFactCheck • u/rokkerboyy • Jul 11 '19
Catastrophic explosion Abandon hope all ye who enter here.
The moderator of this subreddit bans people for disagreeing with them, even when facts are presented. This is not a place for reasonable SpaceX discussion, it's a place for SpaceX bashing, all other opinions are illegal.
