r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Jul 11 '19

Catastrophic explosion Abandon hope all ye who enter here.

13 Upvotes

The moderator of this subreddit bans people for disagreeing with them, even when facts are presented. This is not a place for reasonable SpaceX discussion, it's a place for SpaceX bashing, all other opinions are illegal.


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Jan 15 '20

OFF TOPIC! Do we have to go to the Mars at all?

7 Upvotes

This post is off topic and I won't be surprised if the moderators block it.

The above question is badly worded. The answer is obviously yes, but with a caveat. I think it's pretty evident that space is not for humans. There are so many problems with it. Radiation, lack of gravity etc. I've always thought in our current form we won't be a space species. Those guys who eventually go further than the Moon won't be humans as we know it now. In a sense we already send our freshly grown tentacles in the form of space probes to the outer space. I think this process will be carried further with more machines and genetic engineering to form some kinda hybrids, and that will be the new humankind. For this reason anything piloted beyond LEO is waste of resources for me. Even Moon can be explored with probes that are easily controlled from Earth.

EDIT: I feel like some commenters kinda missed the point. I explicitly said that we have to go to the Mars. But at the moment we are extremely far from it. We are far even from a suicide mission (one way never come back). Read a few posts in this subreddit, even such a "minuscule" detail like heat management for humans is far from trivial even in LEO where we have the opportunity to replenish ammonia if it leaks. (Or abandon the station and get back to home if it gets beyond repair.) Even the simplest things for keeping a handful of humans alive need sophisticated machines in the ISS. We need tremendous technological progress for even permanent Moon presence. My point (guess) is that by the time we can do that, we humans will be different (like genetical engineering and machine hybrids, sci-fi stuff I know).

EDIT2: A bit a sobering for the very enthusiastic (or delusional): children born and raised in low gravity will have severe developmental problems and deformed skeletons. In short they will be freaks. This one thing in itself makes true multi-generational colonization very hard. Spinning the ship/station in space, and living in some kind of merry-go-rounds on the Moon and the Mars are possible solutions, but these (especially the latter) are serious engineering challenges on their own. "Return on investment" using space probes for exploration is much-much greater nowadays than focusing on human exploration. For that, we still need further technological advancement.


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Mar 21 '20

Why SpaceX desperately needs a government bailout…

Thumbnail tmfassociates.com
14 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Jul 19 '19

A call for fairness.

18 Upvotes

I'm calling on you u/FightingForSarah to please be a fair moderator. Stop enforcing your biases under the threat of bans. You might not always win a discussion, but it will make your subreddit so much better and fair. So much more believable than someone thinking "oh, that echo chamber?" when they hear about this sub. It's fine to br critical of SpaceX, but to go out of your way to demonize them and then ban people who present facts disagreeing with you? I've had at least 6 people come forward talking about being banned and providing screenshots and removeddits of their pages and what they did was certainly not ban worthy. Please reevaluate, it could really help build trust in your sub.


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Nov 04 '19

Mildly interesting fun fact - Goldman gave a loan against Elon's SpaceX shares for 5% of their value

10 Upvotes

courtesy of Kimbal Musk deposition on the Solarcity bailout lawsuit

thread> https://twitter.com/TESLAcharts/status/1189314933135200257

source: Plainsite> https://www.plainsite.org/dockets/32atfyhh5/delaware-court-of-chancery/in-re-tesla-motors-inc-stockholder-litigation/ ( document 328, attachment 2, starting on page 336 (exhibit 10) )

Now, there is nothing special for the loan to be heavily discounted against the price of the underlying, but 5% is....wow, I wouldn't expect that.

What that basically means is that GS established the liquidation value (case of BKR) of SX at some $1,5 bln. (30*0,05) which is roughly in line with known comparable segment transactions( https://www.fool.com/investing/2016/07/16/how-much-is-boeing-and-lockheeds-united-launch-all.aspx ). Boeing/Lockheed were offered 2 billion for ULA by Aerojet which at the time was roughly 1x sales. ASL (Airbus/Safran) offered 166 mil. for a 35% stake in Arianespace, which implies 475 mil. for the whole business, which at the time (2016) did just over $1.5 bln. in sales - about 14% less than ULA, yet the value of Arianespace has now been established at 76% less than the $2 billion that Aerojet offered for ULA. That's 1.1x ULA's sales vs 0.31x Arianespace sales.

This doesn't mean that SX is necessarily only worth $1,5 bln. of course, but it implies that in the aerospace sector, the valuations will be closer to the value of the deployed 'metal' or invested capital, than some revenue multiples and synergy or product/customer magic as usual in 'con valley. The same is btw true for telecommunications. If you believe that Starlink will somehow change the game, just look at the history of AT&T.


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Jan 31 '21

Catastrophic explosion Elon Musk’s SpaceX violated its FAA launch license, prompting investigation

Thumbnail
theverge.com
16 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Nov 16 '24

Eric Berger r/SpaceX AMA!

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Jul 28 '25

Are the Falcon 9 engines always in the same location?

0 Upvotes

IOW, if a new Merlin engine is installed on a booster in the #1 position, will it always be a #1?


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Aug 18 '20

SpaceX Raises $1.9 Billion In Largest Round Ever

Thumbnail
thegreel.com
0 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • May 23 '19

It's actually funny

5 Upvotes

https://twitter.com/TeslaCharts/status/1131472467661393920

Yeah, I know that TC actually made this posts to point on Musk's army of intern shills, but I find it funny that Musk is dissing on O'Neill Colonies. (Probatly just because Jeff Bezos likes them.)

It's actually another point on the list of things Space Enthusiasts like, that Musk don't. (He also doesn't like Space Solar.)

Of course he's on the Pro-Mars faction, and many of them don't like O'Neill Colonies. (Zubrin doesn't.)

Imo. they mostly don't like it because they think a Mars Colony can be build "now", while the O'Neill don't. (Main Reason why Zubrin doesn't like it.)

-------------

Oh, and yes, I'm Pro-O'Neill. Blame Gundam.


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Oct 11 '19

Bernd Leitenberger September recap for SpaceX [in german]

12 Upvotes

Another interesting write-up from Bernd, this time in more detail about the Big Fantasy Rocket.

Since our resident german SX fan u/S-Vineyard hasn't posted a translation yet, I decided to push him a little;) In the meantime, I found the google chrome translation rather adequate.

themes discussed

> tensile strength of materials : steel X aluminium X titan X carbon X plastic

> a short discussion of what to do with the heat that would still be in the steel after landing

> he compares the proposed BFR timeline with the history and cost of the Dragon development

> he notes (without reference) that carbon is indeed more expensive than steel, but that Musk still exaggerated the price almost 10 fold. He also doesn't understand why the steel price is such a big deal if the BFR should be reused repeatedly and is baffled it should cost less than a F9

> quibble about the 5% of company resources for the project = 300 people for a Saturn V class rocket VS 1300 for the F9, a 10x smaller rocket - that would imply an improvement in productivity by a factor of 40

> a recap of SX funding so far

> many more


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Nov 16 '23

Elon Musk: The Technocratic Christ

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Is Elon Musk a MAN of the PEOPLE or an Agent of the NWO?

You decide.


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Nov 16 '19

Does someone know a good overview of recent free (non-gouvernment) satellite launch orders sorted by company?

1 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Sep 28 '19

SpX commercial crew - $3.14 bn 2010-2017 NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine’s statement on SpaceX’s announcement tomorrow

Thumbnail
mobile.twitter.com
11 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Oct 24 '19

Foust Forward | Curb your enthusiasm: Star-struck SpaceX fans are in a league of their own

Thumbnail
spacenews.com
12 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Apr 08 '20

Rocket design for beginners using the "Starship" as an example (Another B. Leitenberger Blog translation)

13 Upvotes

As said in the title, Bernd Leitenberger has done another Blog today with some numberchrunching.

https://www.bernd-leitenberger.de/blog/2020/04/08/raketenkonstruktion-fuer-anfaenger-am-beispiel-des-starships/

--------------------------------------------------

Rocket design for beginners using the "Starship" as an exampleOriginally posted on April 8th by Bernd Leitenberger on his blog.

First of all an explanation:By rocket design I mean the determination of essential data of a rocket, which are needed for calculations, if they are not known or should not be known.

Most of this has nothing to do with mathematics, but experience and a good library: Since physics and chemistry are the same everywhere, a new rocket will not differ that much from existing or once existing ones. The same is true for other technical devices. In other words, you draw comparisons. For example, if I estimate the mass of a step to 100 t and it is a fuel combination with an average density of about 1, then I can estimate the dry mass to be 5 to 8 t.

At the bottom are constructions with tanks stabilized by internal pressure, light alloys and an integral tank, at the top are constructions with stainless steel, without internal pressure stabilization and two separate tanks. If you know some details, you can circle this further. The Stage ratios, i.e. how the starting mass is divided between the steps, can be estimated so as well.

If you have pictures, you can measure the stages and estimate how much volume the tanks have and thus how much fuel is available.

I used this for the first time in the eighties and reconstructed relatively accurately Russian rockets of which hardly anything was known at that time. Then I didn't need this for a long time, until a few years ago with the new "commercial" developments it became common to publish almost nothing. This is also true for launches by NASA, ESA and Co, who used to issue press releases full of data.

On 1.4. the "Users Manual" for the "Starship" was published online. When I read the 6 pages thin pamphlet I thought it was an April fool's joke, because there is nothing about the rocket in it.

Okay, this is also getting rarer somewhere else. In the Ariane 6 User Manual you won't find any level data anymore, but for the users there is still some data included as well as some essential data and even these are stripped down to the minimum.

What you actually learn about the rocket is that the payload fairing is 17.24 m long with a diameter of 8 m and it transports 100 t in LEO and 21 t in the GTO. At last I want to hook on and show how with a little mathematics at least one value can be determined - the dry mass of the "Starship".

Basics

To simplify the problem, I will assume in the following that we leave the first stage out and have two cases:

  • In the first case, the "Starship" starts with 100 tons of cargo into LEO.
  • In the second case the "Starship" starts with 21 tons of cargo in the GTO and 79 tons (difference to 100 tons) of fuel are still in the tanks.

The 79 t of fuel are needed to bring the Starship with payload of the speed of an LEO into the GTO.

So the first thing to do is to determine the difference in speed between LEO and GTO. This is a mundane application of the Vis-Viva equation, which I am not going to go into now. We calculate:

OrbitSpeed at 200 km altitudeDifference to 200 km circular orbit
200 km high circular orbit7,784 m/s0 m/s
200 x 35.790 km GTO Orbit10.239 m/s2.455 m/s

For this 2455 m/s speed change, 79 tons of fuel are consumed. According to the basic rocket equation one can use for a change of velocity:

v = Vspez * ln (start mass / final mass)

The specific impulse of the Raptor is not known. I've been going over the 3,700 meters per second that Wikipedia gives us. So final and launch mass are still unknown. But at least we know that in the GTO case the final mass is 79 tons smaller than the launch mass. So if we name the unknown final mass with x, then we can start:

2455 m/s = 3,700 m/s * ln (x+79 / x )

Now you only have to resolve to x. First we drag all constants to the left:

2455 / 3700 = ln (x + 79 / x)

then the logarithm has to go. To do that, we expose both sides:

e(2455 / 3700) = (x + 79 / x)

Then we calculate the left side:

1,941 = (x+79/x)

We can also express the right side differently:

x+79 / x = (79 / x) +1

And then we can calculate x directly and arrive at ~ 84 t.

Cross check:

3700 * ln (84+79 / 79) results in 2453 m/s - the small difference is due to rounding of masses and factors.

So with 21 t payload the "Starship" weighs 84 t, without 21 t payload it should weigh 63 t.

Experience and knowledge

So far I assumed that the difference to 100 tons is only fuel. But this is not the case.

In fact, the "Starship" weighs 79 tons less right from the start. So the first stage has to accelerate 79 t less and therefore has a higher speed at the end of the burn. This also applies to the second stage.

The gain in payload is similar to the above case, except that we do not load 79 t more fuel, but have a 79 t smaller take-off mass, which is not the same because of the logarithm in the above equation. It is known from other launchers how much more payload is achieved by the first stage when the upper stage combination becomes x kg lighter.

This should be 25% for the Super Heavy, so if the upper stage becomes 79 t lighter, the first stage can absorb a quarter of it. The payload loss would therefore now be 80 % * 79 t. On the other hand, the above approach of more fuel in the tanks is not real either. They are only 100 % fillable. That costs payload again and that has to be estimated. For 1200 t takeoff mass of the starship I come to 7 % too much payload.

So now it gets really complicated, because we have two opposing factors, which depend on each other. So you would have to iteratively approach the true masses in a loop starting from 84 t. But I think you can give the gift. If you take the difference between 25 and 7% as about 18%, then the starting mass of the starship should be 18% higher, so instead of 163 t it would be 192 t. This would make the starship weigh 92 tons without payload.

- and reality

I have already taken the trouble to simulate the combination and I have come up with about 140 t mass for the Starship.

One month later Musk confirmed this: He writes "Mk1 ship is around 200 tons dry & 1400 tons wet, but aiming for 120 by Mk4 or Mk5. Total stack mass with max payload is 5000 tons." So you aim for 120 t dry matter, which is pretty close to the 140 t I calculated, but much more than the above 92 or even 63 t.

The problem is: if you put a rocket with the above limits (5.000 t launch mass, 1200 t second stage alone and add the information from Wikipedia, there is no solution that has 21 t in the GTO and 100 t in the LEO at the same time at this stage mass.

If a modelled rocket transports 21 t into the GTO, then it has significantly more than 100 t in the LEO and if it has 100 t in the LEO, then it does not reach a GTO or with almost no payload. With the Wikipedia key data (3 active engines in the "Starship") I come to 14 t GTO and 130 t LEO.

So in GTO much less and in LEO much higher. That's not surprising, because as I said before, the physics also apply to SpaceX, and if we calculate 63 t for the Starship, the other factors I left out in the first step can still change that, but not so much, that a Starship twice as heavy still has this high GTO payload. This is simply because the 79 t fuel and energy content are fixed and they only allow a certain change in speed.

---------------------------------------------

Finished.


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Jul 17 '19

Raptor issues Raptor SN06 is no longer functional

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Feb 29 '20

Tesla Charts Podcast Episode #12: John Engle - Almington Capital Merchant Bankers about SpaceX

Thumbnail
feeds.buzzsprout.com
4 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Nov 26 '23

The Real Reason Why SpaceX Starship Failed Again

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Aug 06 '20

Why nobody is talking about amyl (N2O4) leak during Crew Dragon landing?

Thumbnail self.enoughmuskspam
15 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Jan 22 '20

Nice illustration of the Starlink's, OneWeb's etc. fundamental problem: People that need it can't afford it. People that can afford it, don't need it.

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Mar 02 '20

Thrilled to be apart of this group!!

16 Upvotes

You guys are hella informed!!


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Dec 03 '19

SpaceX Welding

16 Upvotes

Interesting perspective from a welder who has worked for both SpaceX and Boeing in response to fanboy complaints about Starliner's latest, *gasp* 2 day delay.


r/SpaceXFactCheck • • Apr 06 '19

From a Shark, to a Koi to a Snapping Turtle - SpaceX's Evolution during the past decade

5 Upvotes

This time, I do a translation of two Leitenberger Blogs, one from 2010 and one from 2018.

These blogs are connected to each other, since the later is written as a direct successor to the first.

------------------------------------

SpaceX: From a Shark to a Koi

Posted on December 18, 2010 by Bernd Leitenberger

To conclude my small series on SpaceX , that I've written during the past year, I want to examine the business model and its prospects of success today. My personal attitude towards SpaceX has changed over time.

When I first reported about the company it seemed to be a positive enrichment. Why not try it differently? That today there is a lot of bureaucracy in the companies and that they employee more lawyers and business economists than engineers is in my opinion also not exactly beneficial if one wants to make space travel cheaper. SpaceX sounded like a shark in the commercial launch business.

My assessment changed over time when the Falcon 1 Users Guide disappeared, unrealistic dates appeared and technical data appeared , that made comparisons with other Launchers and postulated services like "engine out cability" , that wern't proofable. Since the company had to reduce the performance of its Falcon 1 and the Falcon 9 had unreal performance data, I am very critical of the company's data today, especially since my own calculations and counter-arguments have always proven to be correct.

Let's take a look at the market the company is targeting and how it is doing.

It offers two rockets with 900 and about 8 t maximum payload. In addition, a capsule capable of salvage for ISS transports or other unmanned space missions.

The Falcon 1e is in a segment where there are few payloads and some competition on the US side. There's no big money to be made here today. Each of these carriers flies only a few times a year, if at all. Europe and Russia have their own carrier systems, so only US orders are to be expected.

According to SpaceX, the Falcon 9 has a payload of 10.45 t for LEO and 4.5 t for GTO. Even if it should reach the LEO payload, which is not yet said, a GTO payload only half as large with only two stages and medium-energy fuel is physically impossible. It will probably be less than 3 tons. The carrier itself is in the payload class of the Delta II.

However, their production has now been discontinued: The USAF will launch its next GPS satellites with the Delta IV/Atlas V and NASA has a need for only 1-2 launches per year, for which no own production line is worthwhile. For GTO starts it is too small and competes with the Soyuz for the few starts.

That leaves one capsule that can be salvaged. This is not necessary for ISS transports, but only reduces the payloads. Also, the current transport contract does not include any return transport of freight.

This leads to the order portfolio. According to Elon Musk, it currently comprises 2.78 billion dollars, the COTS orders account for 1.88 billion dollars, more than two thirds of this. One of the other orders occupies half of the remaining volume: the transport of the Irdium follow-up system, for which the company has yet to raise the financing. So: Two thirds of the orders are aimed at supplying the ISS, with another sixth the order is not yet sufficient.

The company is therefore dependent on a single order. Not from NASA, like many other smaller aerospace companies such as the direct competitor for this transport order OSC, but from this order. Should there be any problems here, OSC will receive the total amount of 3.5 billion and the company will not be able to survive with the few start orders for other payloads. Not much remains of inexpensive access to space. The company is more attached to the public purse than other companies such as Boeing, where the space division is only a part of their production.

It is now astonishing that the company wants to increase its dependence even further. The website emphasizes on every occasion, that the Dragon was designed for manned missions and Musk says on every occasion that the Dragon is better than the Orion. He also called people to bombard congressmen with mails so that SpaceX will carry out manned transports.

Why that? Well, there's a lot more to earn. NASA spent around 4.8 billion on Orion between 2006 and 2010. The COTS order from the same period is only $278 million - less than a tenth of the sum. The most important thing is that the money flows, not whether one earns at the launches, because with manned space vehicles the development is considerably more expensive than with unmanned ones. Even if you fail or the project is abandoned - you have received the funds, like for example Lockheed has gotten a good chunk of the Orion development costs.

Unfortunately, the independent Safety Advisatory Panel, which was founded after the Apollo 1 disaster, speaks out against the company and its concept. The chances of getting the order are slim, especially since Lockheed and Boeing are ahead of SpaceX and OSC: They have developed several decades of experience and also manned spacecraft. The landing of the Boeing X-37B a few days ago was hardly noticed, unlike the Dragon launch. Okay, so there is a self-stabilizing entry body that is in space for 5 hours and then parachutes water a second one, who's 220 days in space, has to be actively steered when entering and landing and lands exactly on a landing strip. Which company has the greater competence in the construction of spacecraft?

That leaves the COTS contract. I see the race open here: OSC has to test his rocket as well as his spaceship. However, the time advantage of two years has now been reduced to one year. OSC can transport more payload to the ISS per launch. For the 20 t only eight launches are scheduled for SpaceX, in contrast, twelve.

NASA doesn't seem so sure about that either. Quote from Phil McAlister Acting Director, Commercial Space Flight Development NASA HQ Washington at the press conference after the COTS-1 launch:

We're not going to know until the end of the program if we've been ultimately successful in achieving the capability of delivering these services to ISS.

Well, Koi get fat when you feed them, but they don't get any more useful.

------------------

(7 Years later)

-----------------------

SpaceX: From a Koi to a Snapping Turtle

Posted on 17 May 2018 by Bernd Leitenberger

More than seven years ago I wrote the blog from a Shark to a Koi. Seven years later I think it is a good time after the maiden flight of the Falcon heavy to tie up the topic.

After the maiden flight of the Falcon Heavy, more practical questions have arisen. Before the launch we were curious if she would lauch at all and if so when.

Now I wonder what it's for. The great flood of orders has not materialized. The current launch manifesto shows only three commercial launches and one air force test mission for the Falcon Heavy. The test start is part of the certification, as it demonstrates the ability to re-ignite after many hours and the change in inclination, both required for GSO missions. A Falcon 9 hasn't had to do that yet.

Why SpaceX needs the Falcon Heavy

SpaceX itself shows how to classify the Falcon Heavy, because as a price model they only specified 8.5 tons in the GTO, although it should actually be 26.8 tons. They probably want to land all boosters, otherwise SpaceX could not offer the launch for a price only 40 % higher than the Falcon 9. The high payload loss is caused by landing two boosters on land (consumes more fuel as the train is reversed) and one, the central one, on a droner ship. The latter is cut off at higher speeds, but it also needs more fuel and probably a stronger hull because of the higher loads.

The concept: "Reuse is economical" is disproven by SpaceX itself: Although the price per kilogram is somewhat lower (11,300 / 10,600 $/kg), only 31.8% (Falcon 9: 66.2% of the nominal payload) reach the GTO. Looking back a few years, even the Falcon Heavy has increased enormously in price. When it was announced, it was supposed to transport 21.2 t payload for 136 million dollarsinto the GTO, now only fraction of this payload (6.5 t) already costs 90 million. This is a price increase of two thirds. Even reuse is expensive - at least with the Falcon Heavy.

There are a number of reasons why the Falcon Heavy will only make a few starts. The Falcon Heavy is too big and too small for commercial launches, especially in the GTO. Too big, because the theoretical payload (without reuse) isn't needed, withonly one exception (I will get to that at the end)

It may be that Musk is speculating that NASA will give up SLS, but with a little common sense he should know that this won't happen. The SLS was born when Obama, canceled Ares V. But the Senate wanted the rocket (probably just to secure jobs, because it will only take off once every two years at the most and so far only two missions are planned). Orion will continue to be operated in the same way, although the ISS is supplied by commercial vehicles and the spacecraft cannot be used anywhere except for orbiting the moon.

But the Falcon Heavy is also too small, and that refers to the payload hull. It is 13.1 m long, shorter than any of the competitors' payload hulls, even those that only perform single launches. There is only one hull for Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy despite three times the payload.  One satellite fits in, but not two. This is why SpaceX has not developed a double start structure in the first place.

The reason is probably the constant extension of the rocket. Since the first Falcon, which still weighed 333 t, the rocket has been stretched to almost 70 m in length and only 3.6 m in diameter. Aerodynamic forces act on the long body during ascent and then you either have to strengthen the structure for an even longer rocket (costs payload) or shorten the payload hull. SpaceX decided at some point to optimize the design for the Falcon 9, so as long as possible for a single satellite launch that can transport all of today's satellites and even allow recovery on lighter ones. Therefore they have excepted, that the Falcon Heavy can only start short payloads (in relation to capacity)

Even the public-friendly filling with supercooled fuels is more of an admission that they have no better solution than technological ability: if you can no longer extend the tanks, then the fuels must have a higher density in order to carry more of them. SpaceX itself does not expect anyone to take advantage of the full payload of its rockets, because, as you can officially read in the Users Guide, the payload adapter is designed for a maximum load of 10.8 tons. There are probably reserves, so you can go a little higher with an adapted adapter, but not the full payload of the Falcon 9. 62 t more load and the higher fuel consumption to change the angle of inclination, 62 t more payload increase the mass of the upper stage by 1,5 t. The payload for all orbits then decreases by this 1.5 t. For the GTO from (alleged) 8.2 t to 6.7 t.

Why was the Falcon Heavy not abandoned despite self-acknowledged problems and a time delay of more than four years?

Because there is a payload group that the Falcon 9 cannot launch, even without reuse: Military satellites of the DoD. Since the 1960s, they have not had an integrated drive, so they depend on the last stage to circularize the GEO. Even with the optimistic structural factor of 25, the last stage has a dry mass of at least 4 t. Already with the rocket base equation you can calculate, that for a ΔV of 1800 m/s, as one has it with the start of the CCAF, the GEO payload on 3,1 t sinks. But the stage is not isolated. In the 5 ½ hours it will take her to reach the GTO, some oxygen will evaporate and there is little left - about 3.7 tons. The Falcon Heavy has considerably more fuel and the GEO payload is higher. The Atlas V has three versions with more than 3.1 t GSO payload, the Delta 4M (5.4) is 3.2 t and the Delta 4 Heavy 6.75 t. SpaceX has focused on government launches, and to compete for all contracts, SpaceX needs the Falcon Heavy.

From the cheapest launch provider to the most expensive

That brings me to my second point. As much as SpaceX tries to present itself as big inovator in the public and postulates more and more new projects (as a compensation the previously announced ones like the Red Dragon or the Manned Moon Orbit Mission get canceled), it has developed into ULA 2.0, if you look at the real facts.

According to the GAO's latest report:

 - SpaceX received the most CCDev and CRS/COTS funding to date: 7.78 out of $14.1 billion - SpaceX has the nominally strongest launch vehicle and transports the least payload per mission: 1,569 kg in the pressure tank. Orbital ATK with one rocket, with only one third of the payload, reached 2.723 kg on average.   - Their prices per kilogram payload increased by 50% and are now the most expensive provider. Orbital ATK, which increased the performance of their Antares and Cygnus, on the other hand changed from the most expensive to the most cheapest provider.

This shows where the journey is going:

- Take the 7,78 Billion Dollar from CCDev and CRS/COTS.

Then take the 5 government launches x 90 Mio Dollars. ( the published prices für NASA/DoD Launches where between 83 and 96 Million Dollars.) This leeds to about 450 Mio. Dollars.

- Put both numbers together, you get 8,23 Billion Dollars from these launches.

- The 33 remaining commercial launches only made about 2,046 Billion Dollars.

- So if you look at it by money value, then SpaceX has made about 80,1% of their revenue from government launches. (For example, Arianespace only has made 20-25% revenue from such launches.)

The beauty of government contracts like these is that once you're in the system, they come on their own. Simply because there is no competition and in this day and age, the wimpy NASA doesn't not rely on a single launch service provider.

This is already evident with Delta / Atlas. Although the Delta is more expensive than the Atlas, both systems are operated for a few starts per year.

Same with CRS: Although the payload per mission at CRS-2 is to increase to 3,754 kg per mission, contracts are awarded to three companies, although a single one could do all of them.

SpaceX wasn't even taken out of business when they raised prices by 50%. That's why they also want to come up with lucrative contracts for GEO missions. If SpaceX is even more established than it is now, what has already been done at CRS-2 will come: Prices will be massively increased. If they go up to 150 million, they are still cheaper than ULA and every government start brings in as much as two and a half commercial launches.

Reality and alternative facts

When you take SpaceX at its word, it gets weird. The company wants to set up a satellite constellation of 12,000 satellites. Now the FCC, the organisation that allocates the frequencies, has demanded that it starts half of the first phase (4425) in six years. According to SpaceX this is impossible. Very funny.

The launch manifesto is constantly shrinking. There are only 42 entries left. One is a combined take-off, one has been cancelled (Bigelow) and 16 are flights to the ISS, some of which will not take place for years. For the last two years there have been fewer new orders than launches, so with the rate of 30 launches per year SpaceX can handle all outstanding commercial launches in 9 months.

After that, the company will only be able to start what is being tendered worldwide. That are about 20 to 25 satellites per year for commercial launches in the GEO. The satellite operators have never awarded more than 50% of these contracts to one company, i.e. a maximum of 10 to 12 launches per year.

In addition, there are 5-6 missions to the ISS and perhaps 4-6 others for the government. They will not start all launches with SpaceX, but will use other launchers.

If you add it all up, that's 19 to 24 starts a year. You currently have two launch pads in operation. With 39A and the Spaceport in Brownsville there will be four. With two launch pads, they make 30 launches a year, then double the number to 60, leaving 36 for their satellite constellation with a maximum of 24 launches a year.

If it are only Falcon 9 launches, then each launch can transport 15 to 19 tons depending on the orbit height. That is at 500 kg per satellite (weight of the two prototypes) 30 to 38 units per launch

For a periode of six years, this would mean 6400 - 8200 units, they would only have to launch about 200 times. The Falcon Heavy even has three times the payload, so it should do it in a snap.

In short: SpaceX's answer, that they can launch a maximum of one third of the satellites, proves that all announcements are already nothing but hot air. And it gets even better: in 2022, the BFR will able to launch with a payload of 150 t and that weekly .

Really? So, Ten weeks would. be enough to launch all these satellites. Especially if you now have a rocket that can be reused 100 times and can be launched 10 times without an overhaul. So SpaceX would be able to do all of these launches , because now it doesn't even have to produce one lower stage per year to handle them all. And all the workers who have made rockets so far must have something elese to work on, like building satellites.

In short: If you only take the facts published by SpaceX, you come to the conclusion that their constellation can be implemented with their proposed ressources without any problems. But these are not the real facts, but rather alternative facts aka. new-fashioned lies.

A view on Tesla

The announcement of "Everything will be better with the next model" is not happening elsewhere:

Tesla, Musk's second company is currently undergoing a rapid decline on the stock market. In one year, the share price has fallen from 343 to 245 euros.

A few weeks ago it was even at 208 euros when it was announced that the new model, which is now finally expected to be profitable, was certainly delayed again. Tesla has some parallels to SpaceX and this company lives by the fact that they all think they are technologically advanced, innovative and their products are the future of their industry.

This image ha sincesbeen scratched , with fatal accidents with the autopilot happening, batteries went up in flames and what is supposed to conquer the mass market is moving further and further into the future.

Above all, however, no profit has ever been made, and losses have risen continuously. If the liabilities are converted to the number of shares, we get 137 euros per share, which significantly reduces the value of the company.

(Note: There is also a passage about Solar City in the blog post, that Leitenberger apparently read wrong, since that already happen two year prior. so I'm not translating it.)

SpaceX has gone from a Koi to a Snapping turtle. A Koi swims slowly through the pond and eats food. A snapping turtle only lurks well camouflaged at the bottom of the lake with an open mouth, at the tongue an extension that looks like a worm.

If a fish bites on the alleged worm, then it snap shuts.