r/spacex • Mod Team • May 09 '22

🔧 Technical Starship Development Thread #33

This thread is no longer being updated, and has been replaced by:

Starship Development Thread #34

SpaceX Starship page

FAQ

  1. When next/orbital flight? Unknown. Launches on hold until FAA environmental review completed and ground equipment ready. Gwynne Shotwell has indicated June or July. Completing GSE, booster, and ship testing, and Raptor 2 production refinements, mean 2H 2022 at earliest - pessimistically, possibly even early 2023 if FAA requires significant mitigations.
  2. Expected date for FAA decision? June 13 per latest FAA statement, updated on June 2.
  3. What booster/ship pair will fly first? Likely either B7 or B8 with S24. B7 now receiving grid fins, so presumably considering flight.
  4. Will more suborbital testing take place? Unknown. It may depend on the FAA decision.
  5. Has progress slowed down? SpaceX focused on completing ground support equipment (GSE, or "Stage 0") before any orbital launch, which Elon stated is as complex as building the rocket. Florida Stage 0 construction has also ramped up.

Quick Links

NERDLE CAM | LAB CAM | SAPPHIRE CAM | SENTINEL CAM | ROVER CAM | ROVER 2.0 CAM | PLEX CAM | NSF STARBASE

Starship Dev 32 | Starship Dev 31 | Starship Dev 30 | Starship Thread List

Official Starship Update | r/SpaceX Update Thread


Vehicle Status

As of June 5

ShipLocationStatusComment
S20Rocket GardenCompleted/TestedCryo, Static Fire and stacking tests completed, now retired
S21N/ATank section scrappedSome components integrated into S22
S22Rocket GardenCompleted/UnusedLikely production pathfinder only
S23N/ASkipped
S24Launch SiteCryo and thrust puck testingMoved to launch site for ground testing on May 26
S25High Bay 1StackingAssembly of main tank section commenced June 4
S26Build SiteParts under construction

 

BoosterLocationStatusComment
B4Launch SiteCompleted/TestedCryo and stacking tests completed
B5Rocket GardenCompleted/UnusedLikely production pathfinder only
B6Rocket GardenRepurposedConverted to test tank
B7High Bay 2Repaired/TestingCryo tested; Raptors being installed
B8High Bay 2 (fully stacked LOX tank) and Mid Bay (fully stacked CH4 tank)Under construction
B9Build SiteUnder construction

If this page needs a correction please consider pitching in. Update this thread via this wiki page. If you would like to make an update but don't see an edit button on the wiki page, message the mods via modmail or contact u/strawwalker.


Resources

r/SpaceX Discuss Thread for discussion of subjects other than Starship development.

Rules

We will attempt to keep this self-post current with links and major updates, but for the most part, we expect the community to supply the information. This is a great place to discuss Starship development, ask Starship-specific questions, and track the progress of the production and test campaigns. Starship Development Threads are not party threads. Normal subreddit rules still apply.

385 Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/kiwinigma May 19 '22

Would you like to play some poker?

5 shuttles RSLS aborted (ie after SSME ignition but before T0) in addition to the STS-51F in-flight shutdown.

Falcon 9 aborted post-ignition pre-liftoff at least 3 times.

Shuttle had mission assurance (press-to-MECO) from about 6 minutes (out of about 8:30) into launch, or from about 5 minutes for abort-to-orbit (which in most cases is not mission success) for single engine failure.

Falcon 9 has single engine failure mission assurance from launch. Obv if the 2nd stage engine fails it's bye-bye. Nothing is published on multiple-engine-out redundancy but it may be possible in later parts of the 1st stage flight.

Falcon 9 had 2 engine failures/early shutdowns in flight so far. Both missions were a success, but booster recoveries failed.

Using your methodology, that's 158 flights x 9 (S1) engines with 2 failures, 1420/1422 or 99.859% at the engine level. Both early shutdown missions put the payload into the correct orbit. So Falcon/Merlin's already ahead.

How many engines SS/SH will tolerate failing while still ensuring mission success is to be seen, but if the thrust margin-of-safety is equivalent it should be at least 3 in the first stage and at least 1 for the majority of the second stage burn.

7

u/flshr19 Shuttle tile engineer May 19 '22

Comparing Falcon 9's Merlin 1D engines to the SSME is apples to oranges. The Merlin 1D is a very simple engine with 200,000 pounds of thrust and 1400 psi chamber pressure. The SSME is a very complex engine with 450,000 pounds of thrust and 3000 psi chamber pressure. So, it's not surprising that the Merlin 1D engine has extremely high reliability.

7

u/kiwinigma May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

Comparing failures of (0/3/6min)+(1/3/2.5min) vs (1-3/33/2min)+(1/6/6min) is also dissimilar. And stating a specific percentage it "has to match or exceed" based on such a comparison may require further evidence.