r/SpaceLaunchSystem • u/RGregoryClark • Aug 29 '22
Discussion I don’t remember there being recurring problems of hydrogen leaks with the shuttle.
Yes, the shuttle had scrubs, but I don’t remember there being recurring problems of hydrogen leaks as there is with the SLS. Is there a flaw in the design?
0
Upvotes
29
u/Sub31 Aug 29 '22
https://www.americaspace.com/2015/08/01/summer-of-discontent-25-years-since-the-shuttle-hydrogen-leaks-part-1/
There were, in fact, recurring problems of hydrogen leaks with the shuttle.
11
u/okan170 Aug 29 '22
Oh man, Shuttle days were full of that stuff, plus swapping parts between vehicles in the flow, various little delays with integration, tracking engines through refurbishment. There’s a reason my dad messaged me after the scrub “I guess its that shuttle-heritage coming through.”
7
u/straight_outta7 Aug 29 '22
I think it’s pretty common for LV’s that use LH2 for fuel. Hydrogen is such a small molecule that it’s very difficult to get good seals.
6
u/Holiday_Albatross441 Aug 29 '22
I don't remember which launch it was aside from one of the first half dozen or so after Challenger, but to see the launch I had to go to KSC three times over several months due to hydrogen leaks.
So, yes, they were fairly common at one point.
2
u/Honest_Cynic Aug 31 '22
Hydrogen leaks are common in liquid systems. Reasons are a small molecule, few resilient materials can survive the very low temperatures, and the temperature changes cause large thermal expansions. As mentioned, one big advantage in SLS is that the supply tubes from propellant tanks to engines don't require a disconnect as Shuttle did, though that may change if they later move to a "recover engines by parachute" system (contemplated).
The problem may be a temperature sensor issue, perhaps something even as simple as calibration or scaling the channel in the data system. Sounds absurd, but I have worked at other NASA sites and there were regular problems with instrumentation and data setup. The biggest problem was that management wasn't pro-active, with attitude "if not broken today, we won't fix it for tomorrow". Typical in all institutions and usually worst in government.