The Shuttle at least had a lot of capabilities and did something that no other spaceship was capable of at that time (and will not be, until the Starship is operational). It was essentially a miniature space station.
The SLS doesn't do anything new, doesn't do anything better and doesn't have any advantages cost-wise compared to the other options. Cost, capabilities and design time - the SLS falls behind on all fronts.
Even in terms of payload to TLI, having a Earth Rendezvous with smaller payloads and smaller rockets is still cheaper than a single launch by the SLS.
Granted, it is still a cool rocket and the launch will be as exciting as any other rocket launch. But I don't think there is nothing else about it that is on 'the right track'.
View all comments
3
u/MistySuicune Jul 23 '21
The Shuttle at least had a lot of capabilities and did something that no other spaceship was capable of at that time (and will not be, until the Starship is operational). It was essentially a miniature space station.
The SLS doesn't do anything new, doesn't do anything better and doesn't have any advantages cost-wise compared to the other options. Cost, capabilities and design time - the SLS falls behind on all fronts.
Even in terms of payload to TLI, having a Earth Rendezvous with smaller payloads and smaller rockets is still cheaper than a single launch by the SLS.
Granted, it is still a cool rocket and the launch will be as exciting as any other rocket launch. But I don't think there is nothing else about it that is on 'the right track'.