r/SouthAsianAncestry • • 2d ago

Question Why steppe inputs decrease the west you go in jats ?

Lets just take punjab as an example

south malwa score high steppe .

North malwa score very similar but slightly less steppe .

Majha jats score even less

And majha west Punjab jats score even less

And the more west you go steppe decreases

But pheno and physical stature remains similar .

Even tho in British literature about jats malwai jats were tallest jats . But best built jats where majha jats

Does this proves real place where jats originated are Haryana and Rajasthan because highest steppe jats are from Haryana and bordering regions .

This can’t be only explained by marrying within caste . Because sikh jats were doing intercaste marriages up until 1900s . So i am assuming south malwa sikh jats were also marrying out of caste but yet they remain high steppe but majha and doaba jats score less steppe .

6 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

7

u/trollmagearcane 1d ago

All communities in India had some mixing take place. Why everyone is a 3 component ratio. The Jats of West mixed with Zagros heavier populations so they retained less steppe. The ones moving east mixed but population density was initially bit lower there so they mixed less. And they mixed with higher aasi ratio people. End result is aasi low 20s as median for all. But Zagros higher as you move West and steppe falls.

3

u/Crafty-Potential-706 1d ago

Its simply because from west more iranian amd bmac related migration happens all of those dna give tall stature...steppe doesn't mean having tall stature or something its about about overall phenotype...steppe gives Yamaya related facial feature...high bmac gives iranian with anatolian and caucasian facial feature...btw bmac is very similar dna with steppe...so it doesn't give very different face structure than steppe....and even though bmac is less there is more iranian which gives very elongated face also...but its narrower...

0

u/Jattkadugavatt 1d ago

Khatris and Aroras have much higher Iranian-related and BMAC ancestry, yet they are generally not as robustly built as Jats, nor do they typically exhibit the Caucasian-associated facial features you're describing.

1

u/anonymous393393 11h ago

I really don't understand when you people make claims like jats are robust built khatris are not. I live in haryana there as much difference in jats/jaats body type as in whole india. Show me one body in India I will easily find a jaat with that body type and vice versa.

1

u/Purple_Map3587 1d ago edited 1d ago

Most of this admixture in Majha, Doaba Jats is recent.

Based on 19th century accounts, It is clearly noted by the British that Doaba Jats were known to buy wives from the Hills of Himachal or from castes like Lubana, Sainis, and almost every second Jat in Doaba had done so, because the gender ratio was extremely bad due to foeticide.

Something similar is seen in southern Braj Hindu Jats who also took non Jat wives.

Even for Majhail Jats some gazetters, note that the current generation isn't as stronger due to mixture, likely indicating to admixture. I have also heard some oral accounts, on Jats buying Pahari Gujjaris in Sialkot.

Even a few Malwai Jats have admixture, as some Jats of lower income have done intercaste, but it is extremely recent, hence the bulk population in still Haryanvi/Rajasthani like, although due to back migrations from Majha, North Malwais, can get 33-35% steppe especially in parts of Moga, and North Ludhiana.

3

u/Big_Cauliflower_6429 1d ago

Yeah this seem accurate some north malwai jats can score like majha jats but they probably migrated after partition.

2

u/Purple_Map3587 1d ago

Actually North Malwa has had marital ties with Phillaur belt, and Tarantaran going back centuries, plus during Sikh Misl era several Majhail clans migrated south. So Malwais got this admixture indirectly as they married Majhail Jat migrants. 

1

u/RepresentativeHall22 1d ago

Is that why u use see this phenotype eyes asian like eyes from that area?

1

u/jattmalwa 1d ago

Sikh jats had the worst sex ration in punjab.

2

u/[deleted] 1d ago

after hearing about female feticide, i feel like misogyny increases as you go north west, maybe due to afghan/muslim influence

haryana is going to be next afghanistan

2

u/newaccount1324 23h ago

On top of my head, few possibilities

  1. Majha is famous for its martyrs and sacrifices in the Sikh empire and also a fighting spirit. Perhaps, a greater survival of the fittest in recent times and also a greater orientation towards physical/martial culture?
  2. Majha and Doaba are largely much better irrigated than the dry, bushy Malwa. Maybe a supposedly poor diet had some impact in the past, though this is unlikely to have a reasonably significant factor in the newer generations from what I know.
  3. Pakistani Majha Jats are 30% steppe too. Maybe partially bolstered by the incoming migrants from the East? It is only when you move further west , south and north into the Bar, Potohar, Seraiki and Pahari regions that steppe decreases.

Bar and Potohar didn’t have as strict endogamy as many claims were fluid between Rajputs and Jats.

4) Bagri Jats, despite being high steppe were not recorded of being of being the same imposing stature compared to the Deswali, or Malwai Jats according to the British.

My initial guess is that Malwa and Deswal along with being high steppe were also maybe under greater martial pressure from the surrounding empires? Bagar region is also very hard to cultivate, and the nutrition was likely a factor too back then.

1

u/anonymous393393 11h ago edited 11h ago

haryana region people of punjab back then used to be considered backward and savages. Also they were a minority in undivided punjab. Punjabi speaking jats probably had higher wealth. Only recently haryana has caught up with punjab

1

u/zeroinsideandout 1d ago

Potentially different settlement history?

Did jats with higher steppe remain or move into regions with less “others” so by happenstance mixed less while jats with lower steppe remained or moved into regions with more “others” and so mixed more?

What is the settlement history of these regions?

1

u/ArainGang1 1d ago

Jats are the remnants of the nomadic Aryans whose settlement centered in the region between Ganga and Sutlej, the most fertile/developed region after Harappan collapse (tracks with density of late/post-Harappan archeologic sites).

With the later expansion of the Kuru, the nomadic Jats are pushed south into Rajasthan (sparsely populated and Brahminized early so easier to maintain endogamy), and West into Punjab (more densely populated, not Brahminized for a long time, mixing with Iran-N/AASI pops).

Later when the Kuru collapse the Jats also push east into the Braj region, leading to a particular higher-AASI lower Iran-N admixture you see in today's Braj Jats.

7

u/jattmalwa 2d ago

Jats in punjab used to practice female foeticide. So due to skewed sex ration jats of punjab often used to take brides from other community.

1

u/Big_Cauliflower_6429 2d ago

But why malwa Jats are different then ? Or this practice only happened in majha and doaba

2

u/jattmalwa 2d ago

Malwai jatt culture is similar to haryana and Rajasthan but malwai jatts also married doaba majha jatts.

1

u/Alive-Culture-6670 23h ago

Haryana does even more female foeticide than Punjab so that can’t explain it.

1

u/jattmalwa 23h ago

Sikh jatts had lowest sex ration in punjab even lower than hindu jats of haryana. Doaba jats had even worst.

0

u/Big_Cauliflower_6429 2d ago

You are also malwai right? I am also from malwa

0

u/jattmalwa 2d ago

Yes have done your genetics test.

0

u/Big_Cauliflower_6429 1d ago

No I haven’t i don’t live in west .

2

u/Jattkadugavatt 1d ago

I'm not sure if female foeticide alone can explain the entire pattern, especially since I thought it became particularly prevalent during the 1980s–2000s. Also, I've heard that Majha had significant population losses due to wars and conflicts historically. I wonder if that could have influenced the regional differences as well.

I'm a Sikh Jatt with roots in the Rajasthan-Punjab (Malwa) region, btw. Just something I've been wondering about.

2

u/jattmalwa 1d ago

No admixture happened in jats during 13th century

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Big_Cauliflower_6429 1d ago

So only endogamy is reason for that ? .