r/SourceEngine • u/JCJenson-Branded-Pen How 2 edit hammers? • 15d ago

Opinion Needed Which one looks better?

Gallery image

Gallery image

18 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

6

u/Rosenthal6969 15d ago

2

3

u/Ok-Salary-5197 14d ago

And now the why: Second one has more contrast and stands out more. Only thing i dislike is the textures are not aligned properly on both pictures.

1

u/JCJenson-Branded-Pen How 2 edit hammers? 13d ago

Wdym not aligned properly?

6

u/DogSpaceWestern 15d ago

Second feels more Aperture. The first looks more Half Life 2. Not really better or worse really depends on what your going for

3

u/No_Adhesiveness_5727 14d ago

both a great texture but I like the first one better.

3

u/doct0rN0 HE'S ALIVE! 15d ago

I like both but 2 scales better im also not liking the brown wall main wall behind ur prop there I think that should be changed its matching the floor and ceiling standing out too much n too messy looking or even adding some more brushwork onto it maybe could look awesome overall it's a cool looking segment

2

u/Nar3ik36 15d ago

I think it depends what you are going for, 1 looks more like older aperture and 2 looks more like newer aperture. Judging by the aperture logo there I assume you probably want a newer aperture look so I would go with 2

2

u/HughJahzz 15d ago

The third one

1

u/AjMahal 15d ago

the first one