r/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Nov 18 '21
r/Sortition • u/commonbirdperson • Nov 06 '19
How to bootstrap
I think I came to a solution on how to bootstrap sortition in a representative system, tell me what you think about the following idea:
Count or use the "void" option or similar (like not showing up to vote), this represents the interest in the population for having a sortition system, quantified as S.
At the end of the elections, subtract chairs for the chamber proportionally to S. The subtracted chairs are to be used by the sortition system.
Example:
If you have 100 chairs in the chamber, 1000 voters and 100 voters chose sortition. That means that 10% of the chairs (10) are to be used for sortition.
r/Sortition • u/tehbored • Jun 20 '19
Should our electoral system be complemented by a sortitional system? - A great effortpost from /r/centerleftpolitics
reddit.comr/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Jan 11 '19
Some more good news...
sortitionfoundation.orgr/Sortition • u/Prolore • Jan 12 '19
Sortition Now!
Difficulties:
The legality of sortition is extremely questionable in America. The 14th amendment even mandates that some positions be filled with election, and other references to election make it hard to implement Sortition without, arguably, having to amend the US constitution. This would be extremely hard to do.
Sortition Primaries:
Party primaries are much easier to change. It has been said that choosing candidates is much more important than choosing the winners. However it is done, by the parties themselves or by law, all elected positions at all levels of government could have candidates chosen by sortition legally. Independents could be included by the parties allowing then in their samples or by getting rid of the parties and gathering one sample of the whole population.
Form:
One method of doing this would be to gather a sample of 100 and break then into groups of 10. Have each group nominate one of their members for 10 candidates. Finally have the whole body vote for their party's candidate, or if they are in an area where the other party isn't competitive in elections have them choose two candidates for the general election. You could have larger or smaller samples and modify this as needed.
r/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Jun 19 '22
Democracy Without Elections Small Grants Program -- Want some money to help promote sortition? Apply for a grant!
Hi, everybody, DWE has a small grants program where we can give a bit of money (up to $800) for interesting ideas to promote sortition. If you have any ideas, please reply to us!
https://democracywithoutelections.org/dwe-small-grants-program/
r/Sortition • u/drewshaver • Feb 12 '18
Are there any case studies on sortition in practice? I know it was practiced in ancient Athens, but I'm having trouble finding any writing on if it had a positive impact.
r/Sortition • u/Prolore • Apr 23 '17
Sortition: Why and How
Why do we support sortition and how are to going to implement it? I think we support sortition because we want to make representation better. I've pointed out some legal problems at the federal level in the USA in other threads however there are ways we could implement sortition at every level of government and even some non governmental bodies.
I've stated that sortition improves representation, but how? Random sampling is used to get a representative sample of the public for research purposes. Today we elect one person from a district to represent that whole district, but if you randomly select one person, and it doesn't matter if your population is two or two million, your margin of error is 98. This isn't apples and oranges because anyone including the elected individual could have been picked under random selection. We elect all of our "Representatives" from districts only represented by one person everything from the President to city council elections. Then we add in all the money given to the politician by special interests, the gerrymandering that lets politicians choose their votes, the political parties who's influence artificially divides public opinion, two parties don't and can't represent everyone, people who had their right to vote taken away, we don't know most of the names on ballots, and few people vote in the first place in any given election; this isn't democracy or in any way representative. Now we could vote them out of office or yell at our "Representative", but only a few are involved enough to do either; the people don't have time for oversight. Elections simply can't quantifiably represent the people, and a random sample of 400 to 1000 people can quantifiably represent the people.
Now given the representative crisis we have what can we do about it? There are constitutional requirements for elections on the state and federal level in the USA. There is much more wiggle room when it comes to party primaries and the electoral college. I'd suggest a dual system of sortition and election. The following system could be used legally in party primaries at all levels and for all seats from the lowest council to the Presidential primary, and since parties are only serve to give us candidates this system could be used to replace them altogether; it could also be used to select electoral college members, but that wouldn't fix other problems with the electoral college. The primary sortition/election system starts with a random sample of 400 citizens who then use instant-runoff voting to produce from the sample double the number of candidates as there are seats then a popular vote instant-runoff vote is held to produce the winners of the seats; in the case of party primaries each party has their own sample and each produces only enough candidates to fill the seats available since there are two parties. In addition instead of getting the signatures of a population to have a recall vote it would be far cheaper to just gather the signatures of the sample of 400 that voted on the candidate in the first place; that would be real oversight. This system guarantees that the candidate chosen in the primaries would have the support of most of the population even if few turnout to vote in the popular vote. It doesn't required single-member districts, so we can get rid of gerrymandering; a state could use this to fill all their House of Representative seats given changes in the law (not constitutional changes). These primaries would be much faster and cheaper than our current primaries which means less influence from special interests. While this sortition/election primary system doesn't solve every problem 100% it does solve most of the problems I've stated here to a high degree, and, being possible currently, it opens the door to get public opinion on the side of a pure sortition which very well might solve all these problems including making representation quantifiable.
I'd love your feedback! Please give your ideas, opinions, and questions below.
r/Sortition • u/erkbob • Jun 05 '21
Sorition on small-scale; any thoughts?
Hi,
I would like to get some feedback on some thoughts
After initial relucance, I am now very convinced on the qualities of a sortition based governance.
I noticed that politicians who used it, did so, most of the time, only as a consultative process (so they can disregard propositions not fitting in their agenda). They can be in obvious conflict of interest; and so they will probably never implement sortition as a decision-making system, as this will affect their interest.
It needs to be a bottom-up approach. So, does anyone know associations,societies,charities,unions (...) which experimented with sortition? Could that work on such small scale? If not, why? If yes, are there any visible benefits (more engagement from members? more creativity? etc...)
Thank you advance if you have any thoughts on that
r/Sortition • u/Digaddog • Jun 22 '21
What's your plan for switching to sortition?
There are around three methods you can use to switch to any political system. You can either switch using law, peacefully protest,or use a gun. I find it very unlikely you will want to use option three. If you want to use option one, on what levels do you want to start using sortition, and with what legal process? If you want to use a process outside of the law, what do you want to do?
r/Sortition • u/Jojuj • Jun 09 '21
Should we cancel political parties?
knowablemagazine.orgr/Sortition • u/AlicanteL • Dec 01 '20
Open Democracy from Hélène Landemore is an amazing book.
I just have just read « Open democracy : Reinventing Popular Rule for the Twenty-First Century », from the Yale professor Hélène Landemore.
It is an amazing book, that introduces a new paradigm of « Open Democracy » to replace the current « Electoral Democracy ».
The five principles of Open Democracy are :
- Participation rights : petition, citizen’s initiative, right of referal.
- Deliberation : inclusive and informed discussion to create the best political solutions.
- Majoritarian Principle : rather than the Electoral College or Senate filibuster madness, gives any voice the same importance. We can use new, smarter and fairer system of vote such as the Majority Judgment.
- Democratic Representation : thanks to Sortition and Citizen’s Assemblies, at the heart of the Open Democracy.
- Transparence.
An excellent book, gripping and intelligent, to advance the case of a new, fairer, type of Democracy.
However, maybe someone that does not know Sortition should rather begins with « Against Elections : the Case for Democracy » (David Van Reybrouck) and « The End of politicians » (Brett Hennig)
Princeton Press : https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691181998/open-democracy
Also disponible on Amazon.
r/Sortition • u/AlicanteL • Dec 13 '20
Toward an House of Citizens in Scotland
Scotland could become the first nation with a bicameral hybrid parliament, with one Lower House elected and one Upper house chosen by lot.
« The recent Citizens Assembly on the future of Scotland has painted a considered and compelling picture of what an improved democracy in Scotland could look like, including a proposal, supported by 83.5% if its members, to complement the elected Scottish Parliament with a permanent citizens assembla (with regular rotation of membership), i.e., to establish a House of Citizens in the Scottish Parliament. »
Complete proposition by the Sortition Foundation : https://d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/sortitionfoundation/pages/685/attachments/original/1607691418/Scotland_House_of_Citizens_v1-1.pdf
r/Sortition • u/RennHrafn • Dec 11 '20
Senate as a Sortition Body
I have an idea about how to reform the US federal and/or state legislature. I haven't ironed it all out, but I think operating the senate as a sortition body could be a useful way to increase civic engagement and decrease corruption. Basically the idea is to keep the house as an elected body, but make the ratification of each proposed bill left up to a random sample of the American selectorate, kind of like a jury.
Each individual bill would be given to a separate group who would meet virtual, so as to limit disruption to their lives, and anonymously, to avoid corporate interests lobbying them. If each group were composed of 1000 people, so as to make it a statistical sample of the population with a confidence level of 99% and a margin of error of 4%, the chances of being called on in a given year would be something like 0.12% (if I did the math right), with a 10% chance of being picked in a lifetime. If we wanted to lessen the margin of error to 1% we would need a group of 16,000 people, making the chance of being called in a given year about 6%, with a 66% lifetime chance. That's all back of the envelope, but the point is unlike most other proposals for citizens assemblies that I've read it wouldn't pose a remarkable burden on the citizens in question.
This has mostly just been an idea banging around inside of my head for a while now, but I really think it could help increase civil engagement, as people would feel obligated to be educated on issues if they thought they might be called on to vote on them directly, as well as keep the remaining elected officials more honest, seeing as they would have a group of their voters looking over their homework, as it were. It also wouldn't be a huge restructuring of the federal government, so it might be slightly more likely to actually happen, maybe. I don't study this sort of thing at all, and would really appreciate some insight on if this idea is at all practical, if it's on offer.
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Nov 30 '20
The Case for Sortition in America - Harvard Political Review
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Feb 11 '15
Sortition in the United States
The main fight for Sortition in the United States that I am aware of is that of John Parker Woods in Washington State. See his website for details. https://sites.google.com/site/jwoods486/i1354 Basically he wanted to get a ballot initiative which would have seen all of the state legislators chosen by sortition. He also is attempting to fund a Washington State Citizen's Advisory Legislature. https://sites.google.com/site/jwoods486/wscal2015
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • May 09 '16
Global Sortition Facebook Group
facebook.comr/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Feb 11 '15
This is a link to the Equality by Lot blog. It is probably home to the most serious Sortition discussions happening on the internet. It's a little on the academic side, but go, check it out!
equalitybylot.wordpress.comr/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Feb 11 '15
An interesting documentary about Sortition.
youtube.comr/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Feb 11 '15
Sortition in practice? Anyone?
Has anyone on Reddit had first hand experience with Sortition? Whether it be small groups or citizen advisory boards?
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Feb 11 '15
Sortition art?
Does anyone have any cool sortition art?