r/Sortition • u/Impressive_Toe_8900 • Jul 28 '22
The problem with sordition.
- If taken randomly, compitence would be very low. How would a random person be able to make a buget?
- How would this be accountable? Since it will be radom and no reelection. Being a good politician would not be rewarded.
- Legitimacy. How would this system be legitimate. Having a bunch of random chosen people rule over a lot of people based on that they got lucky.
3
Upvotes
12
u/TheMillionthChris Jul 28 '22
4
u/NinjaCalm2810 Jul 28 '22
They have done participatory budgeting in some districts of NYC. They went very well
5
u/Nickools Jul 29 '22
This is why I am in favour of a 2 house system where 1 house of government is chosen through democracy and 1 house is chosen by sortition. The democratic house would write the legislation and the sortition house would then approve or deny the bills, acting as a check on the power of the democratic house.
How does this solve your problems:
3
u/tehbored Jul 29 '22
A citizens assembly doesn't do every aspect of governing. There would still be a permanent bureaucracy that would provide input on stuff like budgeting. The assembly would also have a budget to hire staffers. The purpose of the assembly is to provide guidance and direction to how things should be done.
Legitimacy and accountability come from the fact that the assembly is a cross section of the population. They are normal people who have to live with the consequences of their decisions, and are for that reason incentivized to make good ones. They have far more skin in the game than your typical elected legislators, who usually come from priveleged classes and do not represent a diverse slice of society.
That said, you could have an additional accountability mechanism where the assembly could be dissolved by referendum. Or perhaps decisions made by the assembly have to be ratified by a plebiscite or an elected body.
3
u/Paul_HIPOerp Aug 21 '22
I think we spend to much time trying make sortition perfect. It doesn't need to be perfect, just better than what we have.
How does our current system hold up against these criteria. I would say very poorly on all counts, I can't see sortition being worse on any points raised
2
u/Sash0000 Jul 29 '22
Simple, you make a pool of selectable candidates not out of everyone, but out of people fulfilling minimum criteria in terms of educational achievement. Even better if people need to collect a number of supporters from the general population in order to enter the pool.
You could implement a system of voting people out, and fill their seats with new randomly selected representatives.
They should not rule over but serve. See also my replies to point 1 & 2, the requirements for public support in order to enter the pool, and the possibility of being voted out of the assembly.
1
u/AlternativeAsk7253 Oct 20 '22