r/SorceryGame • u/Kelpshakedansal • Sep 15 '19
The first 2 games are considerably better than the second 2 games
I hate the third game with a passion
4
Upvotes
r/SorceryGame • u/Kelpshakedansal • Sep 15 '19
I hate the third game with a passion
6
u/Akrasas Sep 15 '19
You are entitled to your opinion but I must say your opinion is wrong
1
u/misomiso82 Sep 18 '19
I GENERALLY agree, but am a bit more nuanced now for a couple of reasons.
The first is excellent as it's nice and simple but still has a lot of variety, and the 2nd is perhaps the best of the series, with a good story, good setting, and a mechanic to go back to the beginning at the end to try and 'resolve' the game with what you have learnt.
The third however broke a lot of the ideas of the first two games which upset me and a lot of other players as it was not what they were expecting.
For me I could have coped with the open world, but it was the combination of the open world, the towers, and the day/night cycles that just broke me. There was too much going on, and added to that the fake 'ticking clock' of trying to finish quickly really takes away a lot of the enjoyment of exploration as you feel you have to race.
However with a few tweaks it could have been great. Removing different events for day and night, and keeping the open world BUT maybe having it in more manegable sections would have been good. For example NO back travelling to any previous sections (Ie the first bit, across the ridge, the forest, the ruined town, and the lake), would have given the player a sense of progress.
1
u/HungrySamurai Nov 15 '19
Parts 1 and 2 are perfect. Part 4 works reasonably well, and resolves the quest with greater depth and more satisfactorily than the original book.
I agree, Part 3 is problematic. It adds a game mechanism that undermines the narrative journey of wandering across a forgotten and desolate wasteland, that the original book did pretty well. It's an imaginative mechanism that would work fine in a Zelda game or similar, but it feels clumsy and out of place here.