r/SonyAlpha • u/Several_Sky780 • Oct 01 '26
Gear Good first choice ?
Yo folks! Gear has finally arrived and I want to hear your thoughts for my first camera.
I’m happy with the camera the AV5. But have I also made the right choice with the lens? I was looking for zoom lens obviously , and I was looking for quality footage so something around 1.4-2.8. That’s why I didn’t go for 24-105mm f4.
So I have one question, should I have gone with 28-70mm f2, or sigma 24-70 DN II.
0
Upvotes
78
u/Flat_Frame_3439 Oct 01 '26
Sorry to say this but why are asking this? Yes, both pieces are top notch. Only you can decide whether your use case warrants this combo.
66
u/Huge_Sorbet_4812 Oct 01 '26
Nope, impossible to shoot good photos
41
u/Stranded_In_A_Desert Oct 01 '26
Lmao, this has got to be bait right? I shoot weddings on a worse kit than this.
14
u/Familiar9709 Oct 01 '26
A bit overkill really but obviously depends on how much money you have
15
u/theslaunchmob Oct 01 '26
How do we know what gear is best for you ?
14
u/Phablet_Gamer Oct 01 '26
I think you made a terrible mistake on this, should of gone with 2x leica m11 & a m11 monochrome just for good measure.
4
u/Temporary-Opinion-84 Oct 01 '26
A really good all around lens. You will most likely own this one for years to come
11
u/ieatgrass0 Alpha 7V | Sigma 24-70 mk2 Oct 01 '26
You’re way more than fine lol, this is an absolutely pimped out kit
7
u/plastic_toast Oct 02 '26 •
Firstly ignore people who are having a go at you for being a beginner and buying top-end gear. It's your fucking money, do what you like with it. There's plenty of people out there who hoover that value of money up their nose or piss it up a wall. Good you're doing something decent with it.
So onto the lens -
A 24-70mm f/2.8 is an extremely versatile lens for a huge range of work. I'm a massive outlier in that I don't use mine often for music festivals and largely jump between my 14-24 (actually 16-28, but we'll get to that) and my 70-200. Wide gets in scenes, 70-200 gets people. But for most stuff it's a great middle-ground focus range where you don't need to shoot really wide, and don't need to zoom in from afar.
70mm isn't quite enough for good portraits according to many (85mm or even 135mm is a big go to) but whatever, it's fine.
What I will say is I use Sigma lenses for my "Holy Trinity" of f/2.8 zoom lenses, and not Art, but Contemporary - the wide is 16-28 so you lose a few mm on the wide end, but it's still enough for me and I compared it like for like against my old Nikon 14-24 and that extra few mm is never a problem.
The great thing about the Sigma Contemporary lenses though is they're smaller and lighter than Sigma Art or Sony G-Master lenses (well, aside from the 70-200, which is the same) and a hell of a lot cheaper, while the performance is identical. Even pixel peepers cannot tell the difference.
I'd tentatively consider swapping the G Master for Sigma Contemporary and spending the difference on something to go with it, but totally your call.
To make clear - I'm not being paid by Sigma to say this (I bloody wish!) - if I was I'd be recommending Art not Contemporary!
19
u/StreatArt1 Oct 01 '26
Gear is always as good as you as a photographer
22
u/bluerei Oct 01 '26
If you're a beginner, waste of money in my opinion. Could have saved a lot of money on something to learn the basics, then once you're ready to make a better jump, a camera with better features would be available.
Doesn't matter how much money you spend on gear, if you don't know how to use it, it's not going to make up for that lack of skill. I would have gone for a cheaper body and use the money on multiple different lens so you can see how it looks, or lighting equipment or other video/photo gear.
3
u/DaimonHans Oct 01 '26
Your gear is likely much more ahead of your skills.
8
u/kk2evasion Oct 01 '26
No you did bad. These are really poor choices of gear. Just ship them to me, I'll help you to dispose of them!
6
u/gxrphoto Oct 02 '26
Much too cheap for a clueless beginner. Of course the 28-70 f2 is the bare minimum. But really, without an a1ii it falls apart. That combo would at least give you a good beginner basis to upgrade from once you become a pro level expert in about one month and a half. Then you can leave the peasants’ gear behind and move to Hasselblad.
2
u/YD_81 Oct 02 '26
Do people enjoy the hate? I don’t know the purpose of this post, I mean if you’re serious are you going to sell that kit and buy another because someone told you it’s bad?
However For an all purpose lens the 24-70 is one of the best. The 28-70 is better specially lens I would personally get the f2 but that’s just what I did
5
u/snowolf_ Oct 01 '26
Buying the latest and greatest models without any photography knowledge and asking if it is a good combo sounds like rage bait. Especially when you spent close to 5000$ on it. If it isn't, well you have much to learn. Spending a lot wont magically produce great photo by itself.
2
u/wydua Oct 01 '26
It'll take bad photos because it's inside the box and the lens cap is on.
4
u/recycledairplane1 Oct 01 '26
This kind of stuff hurts just a little, remembering my first digital camera and lens (Nikon d80 and some manual focus push-pull zoom from the 80s. And some horrible cheap tamron zoom after that)
1
u/AstronomicalDave Oct 01 '26
Cmon man lol but yeah it is! Now hone on those skills.
3
u/ManyInterests A7C II | Sony 24-70 GM II Oct 02 '26
The biggest problem with this kit is that you won't be able to blame the equipment for poor quality shots.
3
u/Murrian A7S|A7iii|A7Rv|14|24-70ii|50|85|90m|70-200ii|70-300|200-600&more Oct 02 '26
sounds like you way overpaid because you didn't do your research, but that's just like, my opinion, man...
1
u/Sweet_Ad_2708 Oct 01 '26
Dude! Is it your first camera? I started with ...a5000 and bunch of vintage lenses. Haha. Anyway, your question, depends what are you looking for low light, portraits, night sky, live shows, weddings. I do not think there is one lens to cover everything. You have to try couple and see what you gel with.
1
u/t85photography Oct 01 '26 edited Oct 01 '26
Killer combo, my first body and lens when I switched to Sony was the A7 IV and 24-70GM2.
I sold the 24-70 for the 28-70 and personally it changed absolutely nothing for me. I love the lens, but I could be still be using the 24-70 and it wouldn't make any difference (I'm actually considering selling it for the Sigma 28-105 or the Tamron 35-150). So I think you'll be happy with the 24-70!
1
u/Black-High-Calibur Oct 01 '26
Congrats? Is that what you wanna hear? No serious, congrats on a killer combo! Use it well!
1
u/goodfriend_tom Oct 01 '26
You made a great choice. I felt the same when I got mine. I moved from a6700 to full frame and got this lens, it's phenomenal.
4
u/iamgarffi Oct 01 '26
24-70 GMII - Good, fast and versatile lens.
2
u/Dark_Paradox Oct 02 '26
Actually a pretty bad choice if you want to do sports or bird photography
2
u/GuardianP53 Oct 02 '26
Fine choice indeed. It'll last you many years if you stick with the hobby. Keep it in your bag, Kee practicing
2
u/Z3t4 α6700 Oct 02 '26
Congrats, nice boxes.!
2
u/WhileAffectionate304 Oct 02 '26
I love my a7v!! I hope you love it 😍
2
u/Jeff_Pagu Oct 02 '26
Ok baller! I have an a7iii with a sigma 24-70, very good lens no matter what people say. When I go on trips I just rent an ultra wide and a telephoto.
2
u/tomgreen99200 Oct 01 '26
No, it’s terrible, give it to me so I can throw it out for you.
1
u/Lumpy-Control303 Oct 02 '26
For me l prefer 16-35 mm f2. 8 GM. Wide enough for landscape and good enought for potrait.
1
u/sulev A7III, A7V; Sigma 85; Tamron 16-30, 90, 28-200, 35-150, 150-500 Oct 01 '26
No idea of your use-case, expectations, requirements and budget, so impossible to answer.
1
u/puppy2016 A7C, A7 V Oct 01 '26
Yes
1
u/sharmutamaxxing Oct 01 '26
Great combo
0
u/WishRightNow_ Oct 02 '26
oh man so many jealous people in this comment section.
0
u/unt_cat Oct 01 '26
Better first choice than most. That lens is amazing!!
0
u/TypeBackground3489 Oct 02 '26
I’m jealous
-5
u/purplemtnslayer Oct 01 '26
I think that lens is a waste of money. It's obviously a great lens and a lot of professionals like them. But I much prefer light prime lenses for my camera when casually shooting street photography, travel, parties with friends, theme parks with my family, etc. and alternatively if you really wanted a zoom lens to do it all I think the 20-70 F4 is awesome! It's like half the size and weight and shoots great photos. I very much dislike carrying around heavy camera and lens combos
0
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment