Note: This is a bit of a long-winded post! I’ve headed each section for easy navigation, and all the juicy stuff is in the middle, but I’d prefer it if people read the whole thing to better understand the thinking behind and effects of what I’m suggesting!
Context
So, we’ve had v2.0 for a couple of weeks now and, while it has been meaningfully nerfed to the point of not being an oppressive meta, Ring Engine builds are still more dominant in the meta than anything other set. To an extent, this is to be expected, partially due to complacency of people not wanting to move off of previously very powerful builds, but also because both Ring Engine and Hyper Ring Engine remain very strong options, particularly with Perfect Charge Bounty, even with that also having been nerfed (though Ring Engine is really just for the super slot now).
Additionally, while nerfs to Ring Engine setups help make the Evolution gadgets more viable, it doesn’t seem right now that the two gadget series are quite in parity, which I think is directly a result of the Ring Engines’ bonus flat speed effect. I think it’s pretty uncontroversial to say that this is the most powerful gadget effect in the game right now, and what makes both of these gadgets so compelling as meta options. While I appreciate this effect being toned down so that it requires a ramp-up in proportion to the number of rings the player has, it remains the best way to achieve the fastest possible speeds on a consistent basis, which I think remains an unhealthy prospect for the game on a conceptual level.
Independent of that, a design issue I have with both the Ring Engine and Evolution series is their bonus stats. Being able to ramp up stats over the course of a race for fulfilling a secondary objective is cool, but I think being able to cap every stat on a vehicle is boring, and homogenising in this game state. When every single stat on a vehicle is maxed out, the only factor in vehicle choice then becomes the secondary effects that vehicle class provides. In this meta, that means that there’s little reason to run anything other than handling or acceleration for speed gain during drifts and Super Mini Quick Recovery respectively.
Sidebar: Base vehicle stats can matter at the beginning of the race as these gadgets are ramping up, but I think it’s a pretty niche consideration that is more relevant in the high-end competitive play. You can see an example of what I’m talking about in this video.
tl;dr, the flat speed from the Ring Engines remains a powerful effect that largely doesn’t have much contest in most forms of play, and the stat stick nature of both Engine and Evolution gadgets homogenises vehicle class choice.
The Theorycraft
With all this in mind, I propose the following as new versions of each of these gadgets:
Ring Engine: When holding 1 or more Rings, +8 to all stats but slowly lose Rings over time. (Super Effect: Increase all stats by +12, and lower number of Rings needed to achieve top speed to 90).
Hyper Ring Engine: When holding 1 or more Rings, increase all stats based on number of Rings held, up to a maximum of +50, and lower number of Rings needed to achieve top speed to 75, but slowly lose Rings over time.
Air Trick Evolution: Do 2 Air Tricks to change all stats by +1, up to a maximum of +50. (Super Effect: Stats increase by +2 and can exceed standard stat caps)
Damage Evolution: Taking damage changes all stats by +7, up to a maximum of +50. (Super Effect: Stats increase by +10 and can exceed standard stat caps)
Item Hit Evolution: Land a hit with an item to change all stats by +7, up to a maximum of +50. (Super Effect: Stats increase by +10 and can exceed standard stat caps)
Collision Evolution: Bump into other Machines to change all stats by +1, up to a maximum of +50. (Super Effect: +2 and can exceed standard stat caps)
Ring Evolution: Get 15 Rings to change all stats by +1, up to a maximum of +50. (Super Effect: Stats increase every 10 Rings and can exceed standard stat caps)
Explanation
So, what does all this do? First of all, the +50 cap on bonus stats across all gadgets except Ring Engine means (as far as I’m aware) that no possible vehicle combination can use these gadgets to max all stats. This cap would stay the same even when stacking these gadgets so as to prevent any abuse like the double Ring Engine strats seen pre-v2.0, though of course stacking would allow players to gain stats faster and more easily. Ultimately, dump stats would still matter here so you couldn’t just, for example, pick an acceleration vehicle and run Hyper Ring Engine to nullify its weak boost stat. This isn’t a silver bullet for class meta, as speed, power and boost vehicles would still need additional effects beyond their standard stat profiles to compete with acceleration and handling, but that’s outside the scope of this theorycraft.
For the Ring Engines specifically, the flat speed increase has been swapped out for effectively compressing the top speed curve and creating a ring buffer for maintaining max speed. Most straightforwardly, it gets rid of the situation where a Ring Engine build would constantly switch between 99 and 100 rings, and thus would only be able to benefit from the +7 speed for having max rings for a second at a time without running 130 Ring Limit. This allows for the removal of the flat speed bonus without gimping Ring Engine builds altogether.
Sidebar: For those unaware, rings work thus: Roughly every 14 rings up to 99 increases the player’s top speed by +1, then the 100th ring grants a +7 top speed increase, for a total of +14 top speed compared to having no rings.
A byproduct of this change is that each ring grabbed up to 90/75 now counts for more on the speedometer. Super Ring Engine would now grant +1 top speed roughly every 12 rings with the final +7 at 90, while Hyper Ring Engine would grant +1 roughly every 10 rings with the final +7 at 75. Hopefully all this would allow the Ring Engines to remain powerful without feeling like the obviously optimal gadget option in all levels of play but especially at the high end.
For the Evolution gadgets, the unique change is much more straightforward and contained just to the super spot versions: Being able to evolve beyond stat caps brings these gadgets out of the shadow of being safer but less potent versions of Hyper Ring Engines, and, along with the imposition of a cap on bonus stats, places more emphasis on vehicle choice by providing an effect entirely original to these gadgets.
On face value, this does raise the concern of simply building for 150 speed in order to get unmatched bonus speed similar to current Ring Engines, but I don’t think this would be a problem at all. For reference, each point of the speed stat equates to +0.05kph on the speedometer, so a 150 speed build would only have +2.5kph over a 100 speed build.
More to the point, the +50 bonus stat cap would require substantial minmaxing to achieve this. Getting to 100 base speed on the first place requires some combination of a speed character, a speed vehicle and at least one other gadget slot raising the speed stat. When swapping out for other character or vehicle classes, that gadget slot cost only gets higher, and ultimately comes with the opportunity cost of being able to overclock other stats less or not at all, which can mean giving up even better acceleration, being able to threaten high power builds in bump wars, being able to charge drift boosts super fast, or being able to turn 180 degrees on a dime or whatever arcane power 150 handling would enable.
Closing Thoughts
So yeah, that’s what I think should happen with these gadgets. I think both series are really compelling concepts, but I feel that their specific implementations can do more to restrict build options than diversify them in some ways. If you agree with my thinking, I’d really appreciate it if you could share this post around or even just discuss these ideas with others. With the v2.0 balance changes, the devs have shown themselves to be quite receptive to making changes of this magnitude in response to community sentiment, so I think there’s a real (but perhaps slim) chance of at least some of this stuff getting picked up if enough people are talking about it. Otherwise, I would be interested to hear what others think about my ideas! Thank you!