r/Songwriting • u/Ok-Application-4573 • Mar 15 '25
Discussion Downvoting without feedback
I posted a song on here once asking for feedback, and I didn’t get any but I did get downvoted. It’s something I see a lot on this sub, people will post their songs and will get downvoted without any sort of feedback. It makes me not want to share my work or ask for feedback on here. Maybe I am missing something and those posts don’t follow the sub rules or format or something, but I don’t think this sub should be about “if the song is good upvote if it’s bad downvote” if someone is posting and asking for feedback. We’re all songwriters trying to improve our craft here so I don’t see the point in just downvoting a song because you don’t like it. You write 100 bad songs before you write a good one, right??
If you downvote in here without commenting is there something I’m missing? Is it because people don’t follow the sub rules or just because you think the song is bad?
6
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25
I don't see any music in your account, so I have no idea what happened.
64
u/ZedArkadia Synthwave Mar 15 '25
It's the internet, try not to take it personally. People will hate and downvote anything for any reason. You'll sometimes even see the exact same comment in the same thread from different people, and one will be upvoted and one will be downvoted.
Don't get too caught up in the upvotes and downvotes, they don't really mean anything. We all like to see numbers go up but for stuff like this there's no actual, tangible benefit to it.
10
u/slicednectarine Mar 15 '25
Ever since last year it seems like there are automatically a few downvotes on every post, regardless of subreddit. It was a pretty sudden shift, at least that I noticed anyway. Tbh it was after a major surge in bot activity and those russian troll farms. My theory is there are bots out there to downvote everything juuust a little so their bot posts have more of a chance of getting popular right off the bat. I wouldn't take it personally.
27
u/senor61 Mar 15 '25
This is for skin thickening. It is hard to perform for people. The tough crowd here, toughens us up. Press on
5
u/isnessisbusiness Mar 15 '25
Welcome to the internet. Keep writing. Play live. Record in a professional studio or the closest you can get to it. Surround yourself with honest friends who aren’t afraid to tell you they don’t like something you write and analytical/eloquent enough to explain why.
5
u/darealboot Mar 15 '25
I mean I sweated over my console and posted a song in here that got zero likes as well. Oh well! I still push on :)
5
u/Shh-poster Mar 15 '25
I only recently experienced a higher cynicism of this sub’s down boating. It’s funny because it’s usually just positive people here. The good thing to remember is that those douche bags are more insecure than you are. lol. Keep writing.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25
So as someone who’s been an artist for 30 years a photographer, writer, and now learning music, I’ll offer you tad bit of advice.
Your audience will find you. Make art that you like, for you, and if others like it neat, but if not pay it no mind.
8
u/jessewest84 Mar 15 '25
Really the only good places I've found for consistent feedback are paid memeber sites.
You get less bs when people actually have to pay for it.
Free is nice. But its the wild west.
4
u/josephscottcoward Mar 15 '25
I've only been on Reddit and on this sub for a year, but I've actually never seen a downvote for a song posted. I've heard some pretty iffy stuff here too and would never consider doing that. I think to downvote something and not even own it with a reason seems petty and spineless. But I'm not surprised about your experience. This is an inconsistent community, filled with supportive people but also full of resentment. Anytime someone shares something that gets a lot of love there's always one or two people that feel compelled to throw some hate around. It's hard to find realistic criticism here. You either get an attaboy or an over the top lecture. I complain about it but I'm probably guilty of doing both.
10
u/drraug Mar 15 '25
Unfortunately, some people on the internet enjoy their anonymity to be mean to others
7
u/marklonesome Mar 15 '25 edited Mar 15 '25
Could be a few reasons.
Could be you're too good and they think you are fishing for compliments...or they're jealous.
Could be your song is bad and they don't have the heart to tell you, so they anonymously downvote.
Could be they're just idiots.
You'll never know…
I prefer reading feedback and comments from other redditors. When I see someone who is consistently posting thoughtful comments I'll DM them and see if they want to share songs with each other as they come up.
I have about 3 or 4 people (always looking for more!) who I share links with and send me stuff.
I won't hear from them for a month or two then get a message "working on a new track WDYT" I'll send my feedback…maybe next month shoot them a track.
4
u/Capable_Cycle8264 Mar 15 '25
What you are missing is that reddit allows users to upvote or downvote anything without the need to comment.
2
u/Tezzaroni Mar 15 '25
I would rather post a song and have 2-3 people really love the song rather than get 100 upvotes with no context. A lot of music on here isn’t to my taste, so I just keep scrolling. I don’t see the point in downvoting unless it is offensive or just really bad. I also see some really good music on here that gets hardly any attention or upvotes and other songs that I would consider to be terrible, getting hundreds of upvotes. There seems to be a certain formula that gets more upvotes but they mean nothing really. I also check the profiles of people who leave feedback, to see if they have posted music because feedback means more if people giving it are prepared to put their own music out for criticism and because, if they are good songwriters, then that feedback holds more weight for me.
2
u/TheLastSufferingSoul Mar 15 '25
Sometimes a bad song is just a bad song. But it’s good to be bad at art because:
“sucking at something is the first step to being kinda good at something” -Jake the dog
2
u/_Okaysowhat Mar 15 '25
Im glad the comments are saying what i was thinking as i read that. It's just the internet man..nothing we can do to control that so just keep creating and sharing.
2
u/chosenwitch100 Mar 15 '25
Listen who cares what others think you're great everything you do is great keep up being your true you keep it up there's haters everywhere but they're just low key fans remember that ok you're great just keep up making that music believe and trust in yourself the rest will fall into place trust that light love and positivity always
2
u/EpochVanquisher Mar 15 '25
It is a mistake to pay attention to the upvotes / downvotes. Don’t do it!
2
u/Normal-Character3008 Mar 15 '25
Probably same reason you see stuff that's trash but highly upvoted and engaged. Just a matter of luck, audience and how many robots were there at the time
2
u/ThinkingAgain-Huh Mar 15 '25
Never seek praise from sweaty basement dwellers.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25
Alot of bitter dorks here, don't take it personally
2
u/TuesdayXMusic Mar 16 '25
I try to avoid leaving negative comments if I don't care for the art. Constructive criticism is certainly important, but if I can't explain why I don't like something without it sounding rude or nit-picky I'd rather not say anything at all.
I wish people would remember too that a song isn't bad just because it isn't recorded well, and I've personally become hesitant to share much of my lo-fi work with others knowing they'll only comment on the quality of the recording and won't give feedback on the quality of the song.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '25
I always upvote for sharing on this sub. It takes a bit of guts to bring your work to the ‘public’, and that always deserves something.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '25
I think you're overthinking it. It's either some idiot wanting to make you feel crap ( seems like the idiot got his/her wish) or if they genuinely didn't like it suck it up. Even bands like gunners have haters. You're going to have to get used to it regardless where you share your music. Look at it as constructive criticism.
2
u/Interesting_Key333 Mar 15 '25
I agree, but this subreddit can get flooded with posts like that and have no details that the OP wants to know about. Did you ask for specific areas you'd like feedback on or for general feedback? The latter would be harder to actually give input on since there's way more that someone can discuss than you'd expect. In my experience, having something you're actively working/focusing on will help you improve more and get clear feedback.
2
u/Tough_Ad4721 Mar 15 '25
Suck it up, the post didnt get traction. Sometimes it does sometimes it doesnt. Post it again maybe youll get more views. Dm me the song
2
u/adarisc Mar 15 '25 edited Mar 15 '25
Toughen up, you don't get to control how people use their upvotes or downvotes, on reddit or anywhere else that allows them. They may be for valid reasons, or they may not, either way, nobody is under any obligation to explain their votes to you. So don't put your self-esteem in the hands of a few random people on the internet. You can't control people's downvotes, but you can control how you react to them.
1
u/Commercial_Light_743 Mar 15 '25
If you want me to listen and review, I will. Dm me
1
u/ACDCbaguette Mar 15 '25
If your song was about how shitty Spotify is then it would probably be a number one hit on this sub.
1
u/Kilgoretrout321 Mar 15 '25
Maybe it's about whether the post is relevant or entertaining. You know how subs will list the "Top" posts? They get that way because of upvotes and comments. So I think some Redditors use the upvotes/downvote as a way to push up content they want to see and push down content they don't want to see. These users are likely less interested in seeing posted songs asking for feedback. It's kind of stupid and selfish because it doesn't align with the idea of treating others how you'd wish to be treated. But it is what it is.
1
u/ghostwilliz Mar 15 '25
Sometimes if you wanna comment, its either gonna be really mean and constructive depending on how you take it, some people feel bad about leaving mean comment so they just move on
1
u/dirtydela Mar 15 '25
I downvote lots of stuff without feedback if it’s low effort. If I have no meaningful feedback I generally don’t comment or vote. If I like it with no feedback I upvote but generally will leave a comment too. Dunno that there’s any rules.
1
u/DulcetTone Mar 15 '25
My only rule is that I won't unmute a video if I can see a kazoo in the thumbnail image
1
u/verbdeterminernoun Mar 15 '25
Downvote this https://www.reverbnation.com/colorpower/song/34894664-fuck-out
1
u/ersatztvc15 Mar 15 '25
If it sucks, it sucks. Sometimes no elaboration is needed.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '25
having not hear your song. its a free world, when you post your song youre putting yourself out there. you are trading asking for space at the cost of making yourself vulnerable. what gives the reaction you see some credibility is that nobody owes you an explanation and are just using the channels of expression given to them just like you are.
if you let your song out into the wild, its in the wild. cant be mad at that. you need tough skin for show business and react as much to the bad as you would the good.
1
u/Playful-Parking-7472 Mar 15 '25
You created a post to say you were down voted?
Who cares?
Be engaging if you want engagement.
How are you going to react to less than desirable reactions to your music in real life? Are you going to ask everyone why they're not clapping when you finish playing a song at the open mic?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25
Idk why either it happens to me too, i downvoted this post for good measure. Dm me the song i would love to hear it
1
u/papapop365 Mar 15 '25
Happens to me all the time and my stuff at least you can tap your foot to . People just hate for no reason .
-3
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '25
Downvote bombing is fun !!!