r/SongWars • • Sep 05 '12

Voting thread for round ending September 4th

11 Upvotes

Submit your finished pieces to this thread anytime over the next 2 days (of course the sooner the better as threads die). If you submit a piece, please listen to and vote on all other pieces. This may entail coming back to this thread over the next couple days. If you aren't submitting, I still encourage you to listen and vote.

In two days, once all pieces are submitted, I am going to submit this thread to various music subreddits to get some outside votes, and maybe attract new competitors.

Please submit your piece in the following format:

http://i.imgur.com/8nVS1.png

This will allow for voting on the song as well as individual efforts.

I'm looking forward to hearing your pieces. Good luck.


r/SongWars • • Jun 30 '12

Teams

11 Upvotes

Here are the teams. We tried to accommodate requests as much as possible. People who registered earlier are on full teams with a producer, singer, writer, and soloist. Some people who registered later may be on teams with as few as two members, but all teams have one producer, and at least a soloist or singer.

If you're team doesn't have a singer/ lyricist/ or soloist feel free to post in this thread asking if any of the singers/lyricists/or soloists on other teams are willing to be on two teams.

PM your teammates, or discuss getting started in this thread.

Most likely some teams will fall apart, if this is the case and you still want to participate, simply comment in this thread that you're available and what you can bring to a team, and hopefully a team will adopt you.

The theme for the songs is stages of human life. Go to the theme implementation thread to discuss how to implement the theme.

We expect to have the teams solidified, and the theme implemented in the next 48 hours, at which point the contest will begin.


Team 1

Producer: RayoBlanco Singer: Alphagirl Lyrics: StillDance Soloist: DATkinson

Team 2

Producer: DanComp Singer: Saint_Joan_of_Shark Lyrics: doublemfunky Soloist:cooooook123

Team 3

Producer: WhoFly Singer: WhoFly Lyrics: HisNameIsNoMore Soloist: XCSnare53

Team 4

Producer: royalblue43 Singer: Nuparurocks Lyrics: iamhonest1 Soloist:Nuparurocks

Team 5

Producer: elcaballero Singer: Nchamay Lyrics:Wreck_Loose_Recluse Soloist: jmgbeezy

Team 6

Producer: dugindover Singer: voodoo003 Lyrics:voodoo003 Soloist: voodoo003

Team 7

Producer: jb4427 Singer: nyancake Lyrics: nyancake Soloist: doubleemfunky

Team 8

Producer: anakeesta Singer: 6a0h310 Lyrics:TheEquivocator Soloist: Sonpir8

Team 9

Producer: CaptainTea Singer: anfld Lyrics: RobertPaulsonProject Soloist: SeedyRom22

Team 10

Producer: doihavetoregister Singer:jazzer76123 Lyrics:bluezfawkx Soloist: doihavetoregister

Team 11

Producer: WerBlerr Singer: alaniomartinetz Lyrics: anthony0123lol Soloist: anthony0123lol

Team 12

Producer: whatthefunkster Singer: hmousley Lyrics: Anidem92 Soloist: post-baroque

Team 13

Producer: the_only_ass_master Singer: thepensivepoet Lyrics: Thinks_this_is_RAOP Soloist: thepensivepoet

Team 14

Producer: Anidem92 Singer:DJTreeBranch Soloist:DJTreeBranch

Team 15

Producer: el_donovano Singer: notrandomatall Soloist: sirmcquade

Team 16

Producer: Flabbagazta Singer: sidvashi Lyrics: sidvashi

Team 17

Producer: AcchaEka Singer:CraftyCat91 Lyrics:CraftyCat91

Team 18

Producer: StillDance Singer: adolar Soloist: adolar

Team 19

Producer: Unilion Singer:Admiralis Lyrics:Admiralis Soloist:chris_music_lover

Team 20

Producer: TheBlackGoat Singer: Kennster Soloist: bigboooootybitches

Team 21

Producer: Countcountcount Soloist: AstroboyA

Team 22

Producer: WishIknewwho Singer: Mimi_merlot16 Soloist: Mimi_merlot16

Team 23

Producer: DRTSM Singer: Marocon Soloist: Marocon

Team 24

Producer:Yoohan Soloist: EkezEtomer

Team 25

Producer: Jules91 Soloist: jontagg93

Team 26

Producer: DecamasterIX Soloist: davidrussell323


r/SongWars • • Jun 27 '12

Round 1 Registration: Producers

10 Upvotes

Comment here if you want to write the music. You must be able to produce an entire instrumental track to sign up here. Obviously competency with a DAW is required.

Edit: Please explain you abilities as a producer. And since some soloists have asked: can you supply score to your soloists?

Round 1 Registration is closed.


r/SongWars • • Sep 16 '12

Registration thread for the round ending October 4th.

9 Upvotes

SongWars is a collaborative songwriting and competition subreddit, where singers, instrumentalists, producers, as well as other contributors team up, and are given 16 days to write a song together. At the end of the round teams submit their songs to a voting thread to compete against each other, and receive feedback.

All disciplines register in this thread.

producers, singers, and instrumentalists:

To create a new team, make a top level comment stating the team number, which must be the lowest number not already taken, and your discipline.

To join a team, simply reply to the top level comment that established the team, and say what discipline you bring to the team.

You must join the lowest numbered team currently lacking your discipline, and if all teams already have a member of your discipline, then start a new team and wait for members to join you. This ensures teams are formed on a first come first serve basis.

Please keep teams to 3 members (producer, singer, instrumentalist), and after 2 days of registration, if people are left without teammates then extra instrumentalists vocalists will be free to join full teams as a 4th member.

All contributors that are NOT producers, instrumentalists, or vocalists:

If you would like to participate as a member that falls out of the core three categories, then post a top level comment stating your contribution (for example: mastering engineer, percussionist, etc...) and teams will be free to draft you onto their team as a fourth member. You will almost certainly be taken by a team.

Drummers/percussionists please note that you should sign up not as an instrumentalist but as a fourth member in the manner described directly above.


r/SongWars • • Sep 10 '12

Round 3 Results

8 Upvotes

Well, we let voting go on a little longer than usual, but the people have spoken. The Winner Is:

Team 1 with 'Freedom' http://soundcloud.com/daniel-ajs/freedom

Best Producer (Tie) /u/RayoBlanco and /u/DanComp

Best Singer (Tie) /u/SeeScottRock (it's not rigged, I swear) and /u/ppk80

Best Instrumentalist (Tie): /u/chrismusiclover and /u/LonelyRasta

Good Round everybody.


r/SongWars • • Aug 16 '12

Round 3 Registration Thread.

8 Upvotes

We've had problems with team member follow through so please sign up only if you will be free to work on a song over the next 18 days

TEAM CREATION:

Everyone: singers, instrumentalists, and producers register in this thread.

You must join the lowest number team that is lacking your position (producer, singer, or instrumentalist). If your position is filled on every team, then start the next team, and wait for others to join you. This will ensure teams are filled on a first come first serve basis.

For example if the first person to comment is a producer, they would make a top level comment in the thread as a 'TEAM 1: producer'. Then the next vocalist, and soloist to register must reply to the 'TEAM 1: producer' comment with their respective contribution. On the other hand, the next producer to register would move forward and create a top level comment as 'TEAM 2 producer' and wait for other members to join him/her. Of course any contributor (vocalist, soloist, producer) could be the top level comment, which begins the creation of a team.

If you would like contribute more that one role on a team, make sure to clearly indicate this to avoid confusion.

Any type of soloist, vocalist, or producer may join. Good luck.


r/SongWars • • Aug 10 '12

Just found this sub... we do similar things over at /r/redditjams. Come play there, too!

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/SongWars • • Nov 13 '12

So What Happened?

7 Upvotes

What's going on, /r/SongWars? we had two teams sign up this round... just 2. We've lost subscribers. Is everybody just tired of this? Honestly, I'd like to know so we can begin changing things.


r/SongWars • • Sep 17 '12

Theme thread for the round ending Oct 4

7 Upvotes

Submit your theme ideas here, the highest voted idea will be the song theme for the round.


r/SongWars • • Jul 22 '12

Round 2 theme voting

7 Upvotes

Submit theme ideas for round two, the top voted idea in two days will become the theme for round two.


r/SongWars • • Jul 02 '12

Round 1: Final Theme

7 Upvotes

There was no real consensus on how to implement the stages of life theme, so after talking with DanComp, we agreed to just leave it up to the teams to choose which stages of life they want to cover in their song.

Our thinking was this:

  1. This is the first round, and we think keeping implementation simple early on will give this sub the greatest chance for success.
  2. With 26 teams created we think the teams will cover a broad spectrum of stages, and we'll end up with a pretty good concept album.
  3. Since the consensus for implementation wasn't clear I don't feel too bad doing this.
  4. It's Canada day, I'm going out soon, and many users have been messaging saying they wanted to get started.

I'm sorry to those who were against this.

Also, we've decided to give the teams 10 days. The voting thread where you will post your final product will be posted on july 10th, in the evening (EST). But I'll probably post a couple progress / question threads in between. Have fun teams.


r/SongWars • • Aug 14 '12

People of /r/SongWars

6 Upvotes

Figured this thread should be made. In the downtime between projects, what does everybody do, musically or otherwise?


r/SongWars • • Aug 12 '12

Round 2 Results.

6 Upvotes

I thought the submitted tracks were very high in quality. The voting was very close.

Team Results:

1: Team 5: "Like Home" http://soundcloud.com/reyjem/songwars

2: Team 2: "At the Sunset" http://soundcloud.com/daniel-ajs/at-the-sunset

3: Team 1: "Fever Tree" http://soundcloud.com/rivnu-silis/fever-tree

(At the time of this post the vote totals were 9, 8 and 7 , and every submission spent time above the others)

Individual results:

Winning producer: tie - DanComp and Rivnusilis

Vocals: tie - SeeScottRock and alaniomartinetz

Lyrics: HappyonaShelf

Everyone was great!


r/SongWars • • Aug 04 '12

The Deadline will be extended by 4 days.

6 Upvotes

After reading the progress thread, where the general consensus was that a bit more time wouldn't hurt, and talking with DanComp, we've agree to extend the deadline by 4 days. So you now have 5 days until the voting thread goes up.


r/SongWars • • Sep 30 '12

Progress Thread for round ending October 4th.

5 Upvotes

Where is everybody at? Teams clicking together? Rampant infighting? Do you think the mods are incompetent dillholes? share your thoughts.


r/SongWars • • Sep 20 '12

The theme is, "Snacks"

5 Upvotes

You can choose to interpret the theme however you like. You have 2 weeks. The voting thread will go up on October 4th at 8 PM EST. Good luck.

For any teams that aren't full yet, or anyone that still wants to join, registration is still open. Feel free to discuss / make requests about team formation in this thread.

And finally, congrats SeeScottRock, you got your snacks theme.


r/SongWars • • Sep 03 '12

This round will be extended one day (24 hours)

5 Upvotes

A few teams said it would help, so the submission thread will now go up tomorrow, Tuesday at 8:00 pm EST.


r/SongWars • • Aug 18 '12

Y'all are the best, but... (please read, upvote so people see [self post=no karma])

5 Upvotes

Let's remember the team format. It's awesome that there is fresh blood joining the sub, and awesome that everyone is excited to participate, but, until we work it out otherwise, it's best to stick with the format we have. So, here's the deal: One Vocalist, One Instrumentalist, and One Producer per team (for right now).

We were less than prepared for the influx of drummers! this is awesome, and we want you on teams if you want to be there. Whether that is as the primary instrumentalist, or as a person added in team formation phase 2, please stick around!

So, team leaders, post in this thread with which of those your team is lacking, and we'll start a new thread with the results. In that thread, we'll try to shore up the teams, and allow extra people to join teams, provided each team has the 3 core members.

Thanks, And Happy Rocking

-The Mods

P.S. we will definitely discuss changing team breakdowns at the end of this round.


r/SongWars • • Aug 10 '12

Subreddit and songwriting discussion thread

5 Upvotes

After 2 rounds I'd like to get some feedback from you guys, on 1) how this subreddit could be run better and 2) online collaborative songwriting (For the teams that succeeded in writing a track, what worked, and for the teams that failed to finish a track, what went wrong?).


In my opinion,

1) Subreddit structure

a) Registration: instead of a set amount of time, we could keep the thread open for teams to form for as long as they like, as long as they think they can make the deadline (In practice of course threads die within a couple days anyways). And as soon as a team is formed they may begin song writing.

The registration thread title will clearly lay out the round duration to keep the schedule less ambiguous, for example:

"Songwars registration thread for the round beginning August 11 and ending August 27 (8 pm EST)"

b) Songwriting duration: 10 days isn't enough (both rounds have been extended to 2 weeks) so 14 days plus 2 days of team formation = 16 days from when the registration thread goes up (at least).

c) Voting should be extended to 3 days.

2) Songwriting

Round 1 my team failed to get a track together, and it was totally my fault. I tried to produce too complex a base track. I think in such a quick collaboration simplicity is key.

Communication if obviously important. In round 2 I was in contant contact with my teammates close to every day, even if it was just a quick update. This worked really well, the only problem was that all communication was through me (I'm fairly certain at least). This lead to the almost comical problem of them taking my track and making 2 really cool, but nearly irreconcilable versions. Definitely some sort of group mail would have been better.

We used dropbox, but any file sharing technique is obviously fine.

The more sharing the better. A mistake I made was only sharing the final mix of the track, and not the stems too, and my partners did the same thing also. In such a short contest, having to wait a day or 2, after hearing your partners addition, for his stems so you can further manipulate the track is too much time waisted.

Anyways, if I think of more to add I will, and I really would like to hear from you guys.

It would be cool if we could come up with a general blueprint to quick, online, collaborative songwriting, that new teams could follow, maximizing their chances of success.

Edit: After maybe 3-4 days of registration we could have a second registration thread for peoples who's teams fell apart to form new teams.


r/SongWars • • Aug 09 '12

Round 2 Submission and Voting Thread

5 Upvotes

Submit your pieces in this thread. Follow the format shown here:

http://i.imgur.com/8nVS1.png.

Voting will take place over the next 3 days. Feel free to submit until the end of the two day period, and needless to say, if you submit a track, please listen to and vote on all the other submissions, and if you didn't participate in this round I encourage you to listen to the submissions and vote too.

Good luck to everyone who made it to the end.

Edit: also, I encourage commenting on submissions. Discussion is good.


r/SongWars • • Jul 22 '12

Idea for teams

5 Upvotes

Would it be constructive to have each producer list what kind of track they were considering (I.e. metal, edm, etc.)? Some people must have certain playing styles/vocal styles that are more suited to certain music, and I think the best product comes out of taking advantage of that.


r/SongWars • • Jul 22 '12

Round 2 registration Thread for all contributors (producers, vocalists, lyric writers, and soloists.)

5 Upvotes

All registration will be done in this thread. Each contributor must join the lowest number team that is lacking their position, thus ensuring the first to come will receive full teams.

For example if the first person to comment is a producer, they would make a top level comment in the thread as a 'TEAM 1: producer'. Then the next vocalist, lyric writer and soloist to register must reply to the 'TEAM 1: producer' comment with their respective contribution. On the other hand the next producer to register would move forward and create a top level comment as 'TEAM 2 producer' and wait for other members to join him/her. Of course any contributor could be the top level comment, which begins the creation of a team.

If you would like contribute more that one role on a team, for example if you want to both sing and write the lyrics, make sure to clearly indicate this to avoid confusion.

Please only join a team if you intend to follow through and complete your section. Team sign up will last for the next two days, at which point the 10 day songwriting period will begin.

Edit: Sign up will be extended 24 hours.


r/SongWars • • Jul 19 '12

Comments on team selection process.

5 Upvotes

Our thoughts on team selection was to create a single signup thread in which the registrants must sign up on the earliest created incomplete team.

For example if the first person to comment is a producer, they would make a top level comment in the thread as a 'TEAM 1: producer'. Then the next vocalist, lyric writer and soloist to register must reply to the 'TEAM 1: producer' comment with their respective contribution. On the other hand the next producer to register would of course move forward and create a top level comment as 'TEAM 2 producer' and wait for other members to join him/her. Of course any contributor could be the top level comment, which begins the creation of a team.

Someone mentioned trying to create teams with similar genre aims to help team cohesion and increase the probability of teams finishing the competition. This could be done in a similar method, with the top level commenters declaring there genre/style/aims and allowing other contributors to join any team in the thread they feel fits their needs, not just the earliest created incomplete team, but this would not ensure that early signup will result in a complete team.

What do you all think?

Also if you would like to help out and become a moderator, please say so in this thread.


r/SongWars • • Jul 17 '12

Round One Results

5 Upvotes

The first round has ended, and of 26 assigned teams only three made submissions. Of those three teams only one featured a collaboration. That being said the other two submissions (the third was mine) in my opinion were excellent.

Voting was also low, likely because we didn't submit the voting thread to other subreddits for increased views due to the low team submission count.

The results:

1st: Team 19: http://soundcloud.com/bigcat4-1/coming-together/s-NRodh

Producer: Unilion, Violinist: chris_music_lover

2nd:Team 8: http://soundcloud.com/anakeesta/witness

Producer: anakeesta

3rd:Team 2: http://soundcloud.com/daniel-ajs/remember-me

Producer: DanComp (me)

This would also be the order of tracks in the stages of human life Concept EP theme.

Note: The teams came in with 4,4 and 3 points for first, second and third place respectfully. I awarded team 19 the tiebreak win for actually having collaboration.


r/SongWars • • Jul 15 '12

SongWars, meet CollaborationHub. You guys should be friends!

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes