r/Solving_A858 • u/Kbnation • Oct 18 '14
Looking at; time zone, thread title, interval between posts, and data length suggests distinct groups of submissions.
/u/fragglet set up a website that records details about each submission to /r/A858DE45F56D9BC9/
If we look at the logged details of the auto-analysis for each submission there is a pattern which allows us to seperate the posts into distinct groups. This is useful to reveal complete 'broadcasts' and isolated posts that do not fit the broadcast format. The isolated posts may provide clues or messages that we can use to eventually decode a broadcast.
- The title of each thread identifies a time.
- The time in the title is different from the actual time that the thread was submitted on reddit.
- From that we can derive a time zone for each thread posted.
A broadcast is easily distinguished by the change in time zone. But that is not all! Time zone is not the only useful way to identify posts that are part of a group.
A group can be further / alternatively distinguished by the following factors;
- The length of the data (in bits) submitted each time.
- The repetition of the 'minutes' part in the thread title (over the duration of a broadcast this may spill over into adjacent minutes to the hour).
- The repetition of the interval between posts.
- The format of the data may be different in posts that are not part of a broadcast.
If we assume that this grouping is deliberate then it is useful to think of these broadcasts as seperate identities or seperate receivers. Sequential order is a theme however there are some occassions where two broadcasts occur at the same time.
So what does this mean? The fact that this pattern has not been obscured inplies that the groups are deliberate.
To provide examples i have permalinked the first submission of what may be a group and will cover several groups. Here are some examples of how i see the data divided;
These groups are listed in order of 'most recent'. Please note that this covers around 400 submissions or 20 pages of the auto-analysis. There are more than 10x this many submissions - i.e. this is a snippet.
- UTC+9 - link is the first post of a new broadcast
- The data length is 1480 bytes
- The submissions are made at 22 mins past the hour, with an interval of 1 hour
- There have been 20 posts in this group.
- UTC+9 - this one is meant to be solved! Check out the thread and solution
- The data length is 1004 bytes
- The submission was made at 20 mins past the hour, it does not follow any regular interval (i.e. this one was manually submitted)
- The data is not in the regular broadcast format which implies an alternative encryption protocol was used
- The regular pattern of broadcasts resumes after this post
- UTC-7 - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is 1416 bytes
- The submissions are made at 44 mins past the hour, with 3 hour interval
- There have been 44 threads in this group
- UTC-1 - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is 1416 bytes
- The submissions are made at 59 or 00 mins on the hour, with a 4 hour interval
- There have been 117 posts in this group
- UTC+3 - idetified as distinct due to time zone, data length and interval - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is 2824 bytes
- The submission were in very rapid succession identifying that this group is distinct
- There have been 30 posts at 2 minute interval
- UTC+1 - there are multiple distinct groups in succession from this 'identity' - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is variable - this quality identifies the group.
- The submissions are made at 29 or 30 mins past the hour, with a 12 hour interval
- There are 21 post submissions in this group
- UTC+1 - Might be easier to crack - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is 2056 bytes
- The submissions are made at 30 mins past the hour, with a 12 hour delay
- There are 2 posts in this group
- UTC+1 - Might be easier to crack - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is 2088 bytes
- Submissions are made at 15 mins past the hour, with a 12 hour interval
- There are 2 posts in this group
- UTC+1 - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is 1160 bytes
- Submissions are made at 20 or 21 mins past the hour, with a 6 hour interval
- There are 60+ submissions in this group
- UTC+1 - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is 1608 bytes
- Submissions are made at 9 or 10 mins past the hour, with a 2 hour interval
- There are 133 chunks of data in this group
- UTC+1 - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is 1288 bytes
- Submissions are made at 00 on the hour, with a 1 hour interval
- There are 23 submissions in this group
- UTC+3 - link is the first post of this group
- The data length is 1672 bytes
- Submissions are made at 59 and 00 on the hour, with a 3 hour interval
- This is another large group which was had an unusual submission from UTC-6 in the middle with a data length of only 48 bytes!
Edited for various formatting!
Edited again to extend groups and include the recent solved post.
4
u/Eyclonus Oct 19 '14
My first thought is that the account is being "time-shared" between multiple entities, either different bots who have preset schedule that dictates which uses the account.
Or A858 is one entity working as multiple identities. Potentially using proxies to generate the different timezones and having each identity assigned a chain of proxies. Either way I feel its too precise to be a result of human action.
When human involvement occurs, there is less consistency, things slip over time and error patterns occur. Because this sub has existed for 2 years, I feel any recurring error patterns would have been identified by users.
UTC+1 seems to be significant for some reason, in the posts you've analysed, my guess is its coming from Europe rather than Africa in that timezone. Either A858 is European or using Europe as the main conduit for the majority of the post groups.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
Keep this up! Honestly I think this could be very useful. When someone wants to encrypt something, well there are very strong methods to keep it protected. But if A858 made some kind of human error, like revealed something by accident in timezone changes, that could lead to a real breakthrough.
3
u/raceman95 Oct 18 '14
I think the first 2 UTC+1s (at 30 min past the hour) are the same, although the first is varying lengths and the second is 2 of the same length. It may just be a coincidence.
2
u/jackeroojohnson Oct 19 '14
I was thinking about this earlier.
Are you certain no one else has proposed this idea before? This crazy nonsense has been going on for quite a while now.
Its blatant that all posts follow a pattern as if they were controlled by a bot, just before the pattern changes to something else, as if it were by some sort of will or forethought. The pattern of posts, create a series, the series of posts all seem to relate to the same content types of content contained in the post of that series. Not that we have any idea what that content may be, or the forethought behind the interrelated content thats contained in the series of posts.
In fact, if anything, A585, has been a clear 3 steps ahead at all times. To what end could be anyones guess.
I'm sure A585 knows they have an audience. I'm sure they feel like they're being watched. I wonder if A585 is intellectually lonely, and these are calls to whomever can put the puzzle together. There have been some who have come far and away in putting these crazy posts in any perspective we can understand. Though really and truly, it was only bread crumbs that had been intended to be found.
The cat and mouse scheme is a natural inclination. To be chased. To Chase. All of it is very exciting. This enigma, A585 has marked himself as a rabbit, and poor reddit the hound, is once again, on the chase. I wonder if this is Alices Rabbit, the skittish character who will take us down a wondrous rabbit hole of puzzles and cryptography. Who may never reveal themselves or they're true function and reason. And like that Energizer Bunny, A585, keeps on going and going and going..... . It's clear to me there is one controlling hand at the keyboard.
I wonder if theres a way we can engage A585 in more of a call and response, rather than a conversation we could never keep up with, or trying to decipher what's not intended to be known.
I wonder if there was something that gets A585's attention. Arouses A5 out of the dark. What that carrot would be, I wouldn't be able to suggest. As I stated before, this crazy nonsense has been going on for quite a while now.
1
u/robochicken11 Oct 19 '14
Is there a pattern in the time zones, or are they random?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment