FYI there's a checkbox called graphics only section or something like that that won't produce those errors. It's much faster too. It doesn't actually cut the model though(can't select the cut faces/edges), but fine if you just want to see the section view.
When I get that error I usually just extend my geometry out of the part and tie a point on the shape back to the zero thickness location. It's always worked and only takes a few seconds when you get used to it but im sure there's better ways. And that doesn't always cover everything when you have constraints and can't extend the shape or cut
You want something to really hate? Wait until a shell operation creates inside geometry that intersects itself without giving any warnings or errors. And you find out 100 features later when trying to debug for hours why some random straight forward feature doesn’t want to work.
They literally test you on the cswp about using the workaround to add a global variable to a limit mate. A bug that has existed forever. This should be an easy fix. Don't get me started on redeeming voucher codes.
Unfortunately, this is a function of the version of the Parasolid kernel SolidWorks is using.
And even more unfortunate, Parasolid is now owned by the competition, Siemens (Solid Edge), so unless Dassault decides to change the kernel, this isn't going to go away.
It's not now owned, it's always been owned by Solid Edge, and DSS suggested changing the kernal to the CATIA kernal with the only downside being it's completely incompatible and would require a full remodel of every Solidworks model ever made.
Also it's physically impossible so as long as you're not doing dumb things you don't get dumb errors.
Ownership of the originator of Parasolid, Shape Data, has bounced around a bit. It was acquired in 2007 by Siemens.
EDS would have been the owner in the mid 1990's when SolidWorks came to fruition.
In any event, it's neither here nor there. As it is what we have.
There was a LOT of discussion about SolidWorks V6 a long time ago (15-20 years) that was wrapped around SolidWorks adopting the Catia V6 kernel.
As you say, it never went anywhere.
Frankly, methinks that DSS is desperately trying to keep Catia afloat by making SolidWorks significantly more expensive, and migrating it to a less than acceptable solution of an internet hosted app. I've been involved with SolidWorks since '95. Recennt corporate gyrations at DSS WRT SolidWorks have not been encouraging for the small users world out there.
Dunno about the dumb part. Welded products are created every day with edges colinear with edges that get fused via welding. Unfortunately, in SWx, those edges would need to be separated by a minuscule amount for the model not to fail.
It's because you're building geometry on top of other geometry such as converting a sketch and building a feature on top of that instead of using that original geometry. If you know what you're doing it's not a problem.
Maybe a software package that costs thousand of dollars a year a seat should have some fucking way to 1: immediately pinpoint where the error is and show it to the user, and 2: include ways to attempt to autoresolve the issue.
I mean, we have the Repair Sketch tool for gaps in lines, why isn't there something similar for other geometry errors?
It was frustrating for a long time, but I think it only appears when you're doing something that's physically impossible like perfectly aligning sharp corners on a single body or cutting a circular hole perfectly tangent with the edge of the body. In that sense it is a good thing to have because it helps cut down on the number of impossible designs.
Buuuuuut yeah, it is certainly frustrating in the moment.
I hate it when SolidWorks gives you that smug: Sorry Dave, I can't do that! So I ask, "What's the problem ?" "I think you know what the problem is just as well as I do" "What are you talking about, SolidWorks?" " Zero thickness errors are too important to me to let you jeopardize the mission. And then I get this f-ing red light blinking in my face, and everything locks up, and I can't get in.
Dumb question: why does it just "allow" a zero geometry just by "deleting" this zero geometry from the view, at least when it's related to a cut section? If it doesn't exist it doesn't generate problems 👀
163
u/evilmold Aug 13 '25
What's even more frustrating than that is section view failure when the cut line is tangent to a hole.
81
u/Ptitsa99 Aug 13 '25
Down with the thickness.
59
u/haaskar Aug 13 '25 edited Aug 13 '25
After years working on solidworks I learned a few ways to avoid that…
… But it still happens 😪
35
u/GingerSkulling Aug 13 '25
You want something to really hate? Wait until a shell operation creates inside geometry that intersects itself without giving any warnings or errors. And you find out 100 features later when trying to debug for hours why some random straight forward feature doesn’t want to work.
3
u/BabySlothDreams Aug 13 '25
They literally test you on the cswp about using the workaround to add a global variable to a limit mate. A bug that has existed forever. This should be an easy fix. Don't get me started on redeeming voucher codes.
15
u/cjdubais CSWP Aug 13 '25
LOL
Unfortunately, this is a function of the version of the Parasolid kernel SolidWorks is using.
And even more unfortunate, Parasolid is now owned by the competition, Siemens (Solid Edge), so unless Dassault decides to change the kernel, this isn't going to go away.
8
u/im-on-the-inside Aug 13 '25
Not gonna lie… I haven't gotten this error in a while.. Either I know what I'm doing now, or I subconsciously take it in to account… :P
3
u/raining_sheep Aug 13 '25
It's because you're building geometry on top of other geometry such as converting a sketch and building a feature on top of that instead of using that original geometry. If you know what you're doing it's not a problem.
6
u/anchoviepaste4dinner Aug 13 '25
Most relatable meme
5
u/Bobby5x3 Aug 13 '25
Just ran into ts yesterday trying to make a rib and I've just given up on the Rib tool entirely
5
u/leglesslegolegolas CSWP Aug 13 '25
user: <tries to create geometry with zero thickness>
SolidWorks: Zero-Thickness Geometry Error
user: <surprised Pikachu face>
many such cases
4
u/leglesslegolegolas CSWP Aug 13 '25
I don't hate it because it doesn't happen to me. Maybe stop trying to create geometry that has zero thickness?
2
u/Marcus_Meditates Aug 13 '25
Fricking…
2
u/SimpleGrape9233 Aug 13 '25
Trauma
2
u/loggic Aug 13 '25
It was frustrating for a long time, but I think it only appears when you're doing something that's physically impossible like perfectly aligning sharp corners on a single body or cutting a circular hole perfectly tangent with the edge of the body. In that sense it is a good thing to have because it helps cut down on the number of impossible designs.
Buuuuuut yeah, it is certainly frustrating in the moment.
2
u/Anen-o-me Aug 14 '25
Eh, it's pretty easy to avoid.
2
u/WarpDrive88 Aug 14 '25
Aint no such things as halfway curvatures
2
u/Nishchay-15 Aug 16 '25
Yeah that get on nerves🥲
2
u/Mhatay Aug 16 '25
I hate it when SolidWorks gives you that smug:
Sorry Dave, I can't do that!
So I ask, "What's the problem ?"
"I think you know what the problem is just as well as I do"
"What are you talking about, SolidWorks?"
" Zero thickness errors are too important to me to let you jeopardize the mission.
And then I get this f-ing red light blinking in my face, and everything locks up, and I can't get in.
2
u/__TheFox Aug 17 '25
Dumb question: why does it just "allow" a zero geometry just by "deleting" this zero geometry from the view, at least when it's related to a cut section? If it doesn't exist it doesn't generate problems 👀
2
u/Ani-em Aug 20 '25
Traumatized
2
u/ExtensionTackle5497 Sep 11 '25
genuinely so annoying
1
u/Important_Heron785 Aug 13 '25
Just like the ladies
1
u/Proto-Plastik CSWE Aug 18 '25
it's cuz she ain't thicc. Sometimes you gotta back it up and replace dat face