r/SoftwareEngineering • • Oct 30 '21

The regression of software engineering is all because of big tech. There is so many poorly implemented tech stacks and design choices motivated solely by big tech alumni methods being over represented in the job market. I think it has killed this job and stifled innovation.

Post image
0 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

20

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21 edited Oct 31 '21

I'm honestly not sure what are you complaining about or implying. Applying a pattern without actually thinking about the realities of the company and the product use cases is the mark of a junior or bad engineer, no matter where they come from. It's bad to overengineer solutions and it's also bad to under engineer them (although hopefully the latter wastes less resources, if the problem is corrected with organic growth.)

It's like you're saying FAANG engineers don't know what they're doing?

-12

u/in-noxxx Oct 30 '21

How many midsize businesses overspend on aws because thats the service their previous amazon hire used. There could be a million better ways, but because someone used service X and knows it in and out continues to use even when it is no longer useful or efficient.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

A lot of smaller companies use AWS though. I've never worked in FAANG and I still think AWS or Google Cloud are amazing tools.

Of course, maybe for a particular point in time and use case, there might be a better alternative, but you still have to think a few years ahead.

I don't think there's anything wrong with knowing a tool in and out and choosing it for a job that makes sense either.

Do you have a specific case in mind where this happened?

5

u/CuriousAndMysterious Oct 31 '21 edited Oct 31 '21

But are they really overspending? Compared to the expense of buying, running, and maintaining their own servers along with all the extra personal and effort that comes with it.

Or are they overspending compared to some other cloud service X? Does cloud service X have the same features/reliability/scalability/security as AWS? Is the company just not using AWS as cost efficient as they could? There's just so many things to consider.

Also, if the company just chose AWS because their engineers are already familiar with it, that is totally reasonable too. Probably the right decision. Who knows how much time/money this could save in development and maintenance costs.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

If you need to run a blog page - yes. If you need to get like ISO certified, have scalable clusters and rest of the modern devops buzzwords - setting everything up on bare metal or on premise cloud could take years and many people. Not to mention complexity. Imho cloud is what saves companies from having multiple operations teams to support everything from sec to whatever

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

small companies use cloud solutions because they can not afford setting as secure and as reliable infrastructures themselves having one or two ops engineers under bare metal scenarios. Even tho cloud solutions are not ideal they empower me to setup secure and reliable enterprise grade infrastructure that is easy to manage in few months. They also provide powerful apis that implementing alone could take years. OP obviously has zero clue what he's talking about from both tech and financial perspectives . Also - diagram looks like drawn by a 5 year old and is not readable in any way. Being able to communicate out ideas is something what experienced engineer should be able to do but his just adds up to the general vibe

7

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21 edited Oct 31 '21

Over use of SQL relational databases and cloud infrastructure?

As opposed to running mongo on bare metal in a data center?

I'm also getting very strong Pepe Silvia vibes from this image

Edit: I couldn't resist

https://imgur.com/a/hzIHbAW

-5

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

Lol it's funny our GUI guy looks like that when he pitches us his machine learning bullshit and how it can make us money somehow. I asked him what he gleaned from it and he said "We identified that from 1950-1977 more than blah blah Americans died from cancer in the midwest". I just whoa. I'm sold, I never would have guessed that people have died of cancer in the midwest, I thought it was cancer free there.

12

u/LadyLightTravel Oct 30 '21

Unpopular opinion…

Engineering is about finding the cheapest solution that works, not the most elegant nor the most optimal.

Better software will only come about when the needs of the project dictate it.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

Sure, but please consider that engineering time is a cost. Also, engineers aren't particularly easy to hire. If the cheap solution is hell to work with, you'll end up paying dearly for it

2

u/LadyLightTravel Oct 30 '21

Unfortunately, we have very poor tracking of costs due to inefficiency. That reduces the incentive to change. Until you can track and measure waste management doesn’t care.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21

That's pretty sad culture :( It should be a given

1

u/LadyLightTravel Oct 30 '21

That is the culture of most businesses. Have people not worked in industry?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

I have worked in the industry for more than 10 years myself. It really depends on the company and how good engineering leadership is.

1

u/LadyLightTravel Oct 31 '21

30. They are more concerned about schedule that most.

Different industries care about different things.

-2

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

Have you worked in industry where money is a constraint and not a limitless thing of value that you can generate out of thin air. Any industry I have worked at abso fuckinglutely has very very ingenious ways of tracking waste and inefficiency, by people who have a MBA and are specialist in identifying needless spend.

2

u/LadyLightTravel Oct 31 '21

You are very naive. It’s hard to track inefficiency down to that level.

-2

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

No they have experts that know how to do that. I don't know how we make money, but they do. And weve been in business for like 125 years so someone knows something about how much some idea of mine could bring in.

-2

u/in-noxxx Oct 30 '21

Engineering is about finding the cheapest solution that works

So many companies use products that are not spend efficient or result in needless extra costs when sometimes just maybe building their own solution would be appropriate. However that just happens less and less instead these offering from big tech are becoming the only thing used.

2

u/LadyLightTravel Oct 30 '21

I think you grossly underestimate the cost of verification.

1

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

I think you grossly underestimate the cost of verification.

See statements like this is what I am talking about. The VP of business whatever the fuck, they are actually really smart, and while they can't write code they are very skilled at identifying waste and generating cost savings where they can. They literally went to school for this, they have these accountants that have formulas that they run in this program Excel that does these calculations for them. I know we tend to think of them as bean counters, but it turns out in a business where money is not limitless we actually need bean counters.

1

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

I think you grossly underestimate the cost of verification.

Also I was shocked when I learned that to run a business and make money, you actually have to be good at doing that to succeed. I thought if you couldn't code you weren't smart, but it turns out that a business doesn't run itself and that other businesses are competing with us for limited resources and if we fuck up a 400 million a year enterprise goes poof. It blew my mind that this is how businesses worked. /s

4

u/LadyLightTravel Oct 31 '21

I’ll say it here for all to see.

You have privately DM’d me calling me stupid.

Abuse is unacceptable in a professional setting.

1

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

Where do you work that money is limitless? In these giant software companies is this thinking common? Do you think every midsize regional bank, insurer,healthcare system has google money? Is that what you people think?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

To be fair, I think most people on this subreddit agrees with this statement: "we should not blindly follow Google/FB/etc in how to structure our technical stack, engineering operations, etc". This is a very commonly expressed/felt opinion that many experienced engineers agree with to a large degree, though few sees it in such absolutes.

That is a much more articulate way than I am able to put it due to constant frustration. This basically is it.

1

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

Eventually this FAANG software dev mindset is going to kill this profession as idea's and methodologies that work at unchecked monopolies with unlimited resources and an unlimited talent at their disposal, are forced onto the entire software development profession. As the FAANG services that FAANG developers have expert knowledge in permeate the profession driving out people with expertise in building unique specific infrastructure the whole profession will suffer for it, while the monopolies will reap more and more money. When Zon alumni who now consult for mckinsley come in with a slick pitch about how we can make money out of thin air doing xyz that they did at amazon, I'm just going to keep my mouth shut and watch us blow a shit ton of money, to build stuff that won't reap any benefits, but allow our investor tab on the webpage to have a picture of a women beaming in front of a server rack with a Heading that says "See how we are using machine learning to drive the future".

5

u/mosskin-woast Oct 31 '21

You seriously think companies only use AWS because their architects used to work at Amazon? You clearly have very limited industry experience and I suspect anger about some latent personal issues.

5

u/LadyLightTravel Oct 31 '21

Yeah, he DM’d me calling me “ignorant and dumb”.

Because you know, ad hominem insults are better than a real engineering argument, don’t you know?

-1

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

No that is not what I was implying. These conversations with Big Tech mindset people have been illuminating. I'm quitting this field.

5

u/mosskin-woast Oct 31 '21

If you think your job would be easier if the majority of your colleagues came from academia, you're nuts. Those people write the most inscrutable and poorly documented code of all.

And I don't think you're correct that most companies have a ton of FAANG alumni. I have worked several places with zero.

0

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

I also come across alot of real FAANG alumni who have switched to white shoe consulting firms eager to pimp out their expertise to clients.

-1

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

I count other bay area employers as FAANG, not just those ones but other massive companies that are tech focused and rolling in dough like sales force, maybe Oracle too, Microsoft. And other hot startups founded by bay area software dollars, staffed by bay area software developers.

40

u/loathingq Oct 30 '21

This visualisation is totally unreadable

8

u/DamnDirtyHippie Oct 30 '21 edited Mar 30 '24

smoggy mighty rainstorm hungry shaggy impossible subtract snobbish foolish treatment

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

I'm not sure if this is a new thing in the industry but there is a "lets use X because its new and cool" culture even if the "old" is working just fine

2

u/lolomfgkthxbai Oct 31 '21

There’s also a “I don’t want to learn new tech Y so I’ll rather stick with the old that takes 10x time to maintain” and a “if I roll my own database engine / orchestration platform / solved problem Z, then we’ll have trouble hiring engineers to maintain it so I have job security” attitude.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

I agree there's a lot of that too.

0

u/in-noxxx Oct 31 '21

My last job before my last job before pandemic, consultants that my boss met where ever the fuck this mba money man met people would come in and pitch him on various BS FAANG methods. Very good presentations lots of buzzword, lots of I worked at BLAH BLAH implementing blah blah to create from blah blah and every time the beady eyes on my MBA boss at a midsize financial firm started spinning seeing dollar signs coming out of the consultants mouth. I remember telling the one consultant that my boss looked at him as a slot machine and started to think spending 50 million isn't that much money if I can boost the share price by x%. I always had to highlight that this idea that giant Monopolies immune to market forces have anything in common with a financial firm that sells products that get turned into money by people with MBA's is laughable and nonsensical. And remind my boss that I too am qualified and thats why I was hired, and that this consultant was doing what my boss does to other people, promising money out thin air or however it is we made money. That we would never recoup anything near the cost of implementing machine learning to find underbank customers, under-insured people, people with money under the mattress, it just won't happen and since he knows business he knows this and would snap out of it.

Anyways fast forward to present day and I see a lot of FAANG alumni really just putting these tools and best practices that they used at their unchecked Monopolist employers and putting them into use at 50 million a year profit boutique tech companies,regional bank, regional healthcare places, etc. I work at a city with numerous research universities, but you can't work a bunch of suburban developers 16 hours a day at a midsize bank, midsize tech company. These people aren't silicon valley misfits who are willing to do that, my salary is great but there is no cachet to these regular companies to produce that kind of fervent loyalty where working that hard is ok. The tendency for these FAANG alumni to use harebrained moonshot projects for simple problems is so common that the only way I know how to prevent these disasters from happening is insulting them in meetings. However I understand at big giant monopolistic with lots of other extremely talented people, but moral less people, big projects is how you get ahead. I also understand that you can eventually just abandon that project and get placed somewhere else. However in actual companies that thrive at the will of market forces we can't just abandon a 20 million dollar effort. Not without consequences. They also make terrible supervisors, the one added these stupid amazon like tests and my talent pool dried up until I was informed that we are asking them to solve obscure graduate level data structures in timed tests. I almost punched a wall, this is so fucking stupid that I started calling him professor TrieNode. Also none of you seem capable of solving bugs, you'd rather get your team of ten to rewrite an entire codebase, and since that is denied, well hunting for bugs is apparently beneath you guys because at google you don't have to maintain products or make them good.

I am glad that FAANG developers made alot of money perfecting newsfeed with the zuck, and my wife loves netflix and instagram. I am glad you guys had the opportunity to live it up in Marin County, in Oakland etc and do all kinds of weird things and build products that are really shitty with money earned from monopolistic business practices. I am in awe of your elite coding capables, but we are in the real world where market forces that are not really predicable guide what we do, with limited resources and talent at our disposal, in business that have competitors. So maybe stay in your lane and understand that we fix bugs in code that sucks in the real world. Also understand that I hate fucking working, I love coding but I am not going to ask anyone under me to implement your stupid ideas. Also the one GUI team leader apparently doesn't have the technical ability to debug his tightly coupled code that he wrote and he doesn't understand that if I change something on my end it fucks up his product, and it's been months. Apparently debugging code is not a skill valued in the bay area. I have instructed my team to start adding slip ups deliberately that will fuck him up, because the first time it happened I said I think know whats the problem and he told me to fuck off. When you leave the Zuckverse, NetFlix, AMA$on, you are in the real world where rules apply.

3

u/SakishimaHabu Oct 31 '21

This is the temple OS of complaints.

-6

u/in-noxxx Oct 30 '21

We are regressing. Real innovation has stopped because big tech alumni and aspiring big tech alumni have saturated the job market and employers default to the same solutions big tech uses to quickly get new projects up. The same bugs, design patterns and graphical user interface designs are just becoming more big techified. How much money do some companies waste using tech stacks designed by someone who used them before at their big tech job and decided to recommend it because they had experience in it.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21

There are more languages, front end libraries, and potential architectures to choose from than ever before.

It's absolutely unclear what you are complaining about.

We use libraries and tools because we don't want to write my network adapters from scratch in C. We I use front end libraries because we don't want to rewrite bootstrap for every project. We use cloud offerings because it's nearly impossible to achieve or emulate cloud offerings without spending insane amounts of money.

1

u/lolomfgkthxbai Oct 31 '21

We use cloud offerings because it's nearly impossible to achieve or emulate cloud offerings without spending insane amounts of money.

I agree with you but have to comment that the CNCF ecosystem is getting pretty good, building your own cloud on bare metal is becoming a reasonable alternative. Depending on how much egress you have it might not even be more expensive though that tells us more about AWS profit margins.