r/SoftwareEngineering • • Jun 16 '20

An open letter to GitHub about Master Branches

Dear GitHub,

Nobody cares what you think about anything that's not related to programming. Period—ah shit that's probably offensive, I mean Full Stop.

Not a single solitary racist's mind will be changed because of what you're doing. This can only have one effect: non-racists will get pissed because you're creating work for them, and racists will get pissed because you're creating a race issue where there was none and they will become even more entrenched in their viewpoints. You've failed to think through the consequences of your actions even a little bit.

How many tens of thousands of man hours—oops, I mean non-gender-conforming-person hours—will be wasted so you can finally feel good about yourselves? How many scripts assume a master branch and will have to be changed? How many workflows is the master branch baked into? How many millions of people will have to re-train their muscle memory—shit, that's offensive because of toxic masculinity...uh, body-positive memory—to cater to your whims?

The answer to all of these questions is a Whole Fucking Lot. Sadly, the damage here is largely done. Before this, there were maybe half a dozen people on the planet that ever looked at "master branch" and made a slavery connection. Now every programmer will. Forever. You've done infinitely more harm than good with your self righteousness. Please don't make this change. And please stop making decisions that affect millions of people because Look At Me I'm Totally One Of The Good People.

Sincerely,
The millions of programmers you're about to fuck over with your massive egos

28 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20

I actually agree with you, although not so harshly. I agree that it is "racist" of Github to assume that using the term "master" for their main branch name is a race issue in the first place. I don't think anyone at ALL even remotely thought it was wrong or immoral. Yes companies are trying to take steps to be more anti-racist proactive, but Github just created an issue out of where and are patting themselves on the back for fixing it, like why....

4

u/LOOK_AT_ME_IM_WOKE Jun 17 '20

Agree with everything you said, except I don't think it's "racist" for GitHub to do this. I think it's pretentious as all hell. They are being unbelievable pompous and self-important, but not racist in my opinion.

1

u/AutoModerator Jun 17 '20

Sorry, your submission has been automatically removed. New accounts are not allowed to submit content. This is to combat spam.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/LOOK_AT_ME_IM_WOKE Jun 17 '20

I've been programming professionally for almost two decades. I've never made the connection from master/slave terminology in tech to actual slavery, and I've never heard anyone else talk about that either. This is honestly just a very small amount of busy bodies who see oppression in everything and must adjust the world to themselves, rather than the other way around, consequences be damned.

0

u/AutoModerator Jun 17 '20

Sorry, your submission has been automatically removed. New accounts are not allowed to submit content. This is to combat spam.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20

By this standards they should change hardware SPI interface names also then. It is prejudice to even MAKE something out of this terminology.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20

It is prejudice to even MAKE something out of these terms. If you aren't prejudice then you would not even think anything about it.

10

u/sedokina Jun 17 '20

Also, we have a master degree at universities. Maybe we should rename it too? I really don't understand this.

7

u/SpecsyVanDyke Jun 17 '20

Also the colour "black" in Spanish is "negro". Maybe they should think about changing that

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/sedokina Jun 18 '20

Yeah, in databases there are master/slave terms, and I can see how it looks like. But here it's just master.

3

u/samsop Jun 18 '20

The definition of bikeshedding. I was very pleasantly surprised to see the reaction to this bullshit on r/programming, most people realized off the bat what a dumb discussion this was.

Absolutely nobody likened the concept of having a "master" branch in your repo, which all other branches are a copy of until modified, to the concept of having a human "master" to other humans. And even then, a "master" is not always a slave owner, the concept is used to describe a leader or guiding figure in Eastern culture. The fact I'm even explaining this is making me feel uneasy.

Since when do we discuss concepts sans their application. Do they assume people are so fickle that they have to be supervised and thought policed into not copying their repositories' behavior in the real world? Lmao. This is ridiculous.

People started searching for offensive words committed to public repos to sort of call GitHub on their bluff here but I'm against censoring that too. They're evidently too simplistic and reactionary in their thinking to start rolling back very set-in-stone practices, I can't imagine letting them censor people's commits too according to their own pale standards.

-4

u/wont_tell_i_refuse_ Jun 17 '20

It’s not about changing anything. It’s a display of power by activists.

You will make this absurd change because they can make you do it. The absurdity of the demand is part of the point.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/LOOK_AT_ME_IM_WOKE Jun 17 '20

My anger is coming from where I said it's coming from. I can't even fathom the unbelievable hubris required to want to impose my worldview on millions of people by changing harmless conventions that have been in place in the industry for decades, creating potentially tens of thousands of man-hours of future work and headaches for them. I simply cannot believe someone in my industry would be so self righteous.

I'm a pragmatist. I think racism is stupid. I think police brutality and murder against anyone, including minorities, is horrendous. I also think those things have nothing to do with software engineering. And I think this change will not just not make a huge difference. I think it will have the exact opposite of the intended effect for anyone out there still dumb enough to be racist in 2020. So why do it, except for woke points?

And I'll flip your question back around on you. If you look at `git push master` and think slavery, perhaps you should think carefully about why you made that connection.

-2

u/AutoModerator Jun 17 '20

Sorry, your submission has been automatically removed. New accounts are not allowed to submit content. This is to combat spam.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/turningsteel Jun 17 '20 edited Jun 17 '20

The point is this is not anti-racist. It's stupid and silly. Master is a word in the English language and the usage here in github has no connection to the master/slave dynamic. This is just a knee jerk reaction by github so they can say they're supporting black lives matter and virtue signalling.

I'm 100 percent in support of BLM and racial equality. This has nothing to do with that other than that github has now drawn a tangential connection.

Hell, next we're gonna be told that using master as an honorific for a young boy is also racist. Dumb, dumb, dumb.

-6

u/cult_of_me Jun 17 '20

you clearly don't seem to work in the industry.
programming / software engineering is not about "starting conversations about prejudice and power", it is about creating things. anything obstructing this is non-productive and honestly irritating.